|This article is of interest to the following WikiProjects:|
Why is there no mention of Jimmy Yancey in this article? I'm researching a project on this genre and its piano beginnings, and Yancey is often reffered to as "the father of boogie woogie". Though he may be not as famous as some of the artists talked about on this page, he should be written in. Thoughts?
- If you have verifiable information about Jimmy Yancey, and can provide a link(s), or a reference(s) for that information, figure out a way to work it into the article. P.S. New subjects should be added at the bottom of the Discussion page. I'll move this there myself if you or someone else doesn't do it in a few days. Steve Pastor 21:17, 7 March 2007 (UTC)
I love listening to music (including boogie woogie) but don't have any skills to analyze the musical structure of what I'm hearing. So, with a little help from those of you who have those skills, I would love to know the following. John Lee Hooker's "Boogie Chillun" can be called boogie woogie? Stylistically, musically, structurally, or in whatever way? If yes, could you explain for me what the distinctively boogie woogie elements of "Boogie Chillun" are? I think Hooker's music is known for its use of one-chord tone. Does this aspect of his music have anything to do with the boogie woogie style per se? --Oichiro 03:22, 11 Mar 2005 (UTC)
- Boogie Woogie doesn't have to use 12 bar blues, it can be based upon one bar blues, or upon something other than blues altogether. It usually is based upon level rather than chords though. Boogie chillun is played on guitar, not piano however. This makes it Boogie, not boogie-woogie.--22.214.171.124 17:46, 15 November 2007 (UTC)
Name of article
I propose moving this article back to "Boogie woogie" from the current title of "Boogie woogie (music)" Once this move is made, "Boogie woogie (dance) would be linked as a disambiguation at the top of the page. Comments? -- Infrogmation 07:01, 25 Apr 2005 (UTC)
- I'm inclined to think the dance form of the boogie-woogie is well-known enough that the disambiguation page at boogie-woogie is justified and that this page should remain at boogie-woogie (music). —Lowellian (talk) 01:05, Apr 26, 2005 (UTC)
slaves built the national railway system?
I see this came from another article, but I can't accept this without further documentation. Slaves were freed during the American Civil war. The West was still a frontier in the 1860s, and most of our "national railroad system" was certainly not built by then. Please come back with something to substantiate this statement. Steve Pastor 23:29, 18 December 2006 (UTC)
google railroad 1860 miles to get to this url  No question that the majority of our railroad system was built after 1860, which is just a few years before slavery was ended in the U.S.. Besides, boogie woogie didn't emerge until the early 1900's over half a century after slavery was abolished. Who are the critics who think otherwise? Steve Pastor 20:51, 19 December 2006 (UTC)
If you follow the link provided for this slave/railroad statement, you will see text from a real book that contradicts this statement, and agrees with the Robert Palmer information. Steve Pastor 16:06, 20 December 2006 (UTC)
Roll em Pete
"Roll 'Em, Pete" is now considered one of the first rock and roll records. ??? Actually, if you read the listed link, you will find that it is listed under the Hot Swing section. Anyone care to rebut?Steve Pastor 16:26, 20 December 2006 (UTC)
- In the late 1940s & early '50s popular American music was undergoing many changes, and many new styles and combinations of old styles were developing. It's not unusual to see a single song, or performer, or album, or record label, classified in several different ways. Much musical classification has little or nothing to do with the music, and everything to do with commerce. (E.g., "R&B", which is really a racial marketing category, and has practically nothing to do nowadays with actual Rhythm & Blues music.) Much of it has more to do with academic theory and theoretical categories than with what the actual performers and their fans thought about the music. Pete Johnson is usually described as a boogie-woogie pianist. His most famous vocalist, Big Joe Turner, is usually described as a blues artist. Their music may be described with pretty much equal accuracy as rhythm & blues, hot, hot swing, jump, early rock & roll, jive, blues, barrelhouse, or boogie-woogie (and probably some other terms that I'm forgetting).
gosh, not a lot of traffic here!
Claim of first Recording 1919 disputed
It is claimed that Source 5 (BOOGIE WOOGIE: Its Origin, Subsequent History, and Continuing Development -- by John Tennison (A.K.A. Nonjohn) -- Updated November 3, 2010.) verifies the first sound recordings of boogie woogie occurred in 1919. However, the author's own website: http://boogiewoogie.com/index.php/history/30_-_the_earliest_sound_recordings_containing_boogie_woogie_bass_figures/ says the following:
- The Rocks” by George & Hersal Thomas (recorded February, 1923) and “The Fives,” (performed by Joseph Samuel’s Tampa Blue Jazz Band) and also written by George & Hersal Thomas (and also recorded February, 1923) are the earliest sound recordings of which I am aware that contain Boogie Woogie bass figures. Moreover, Fletcher Henderson’s recording of “Chime Blues” on Black Swan Records was recorded at a similar time (circa March,1923) and also contains a Boogie Woogie bass figure.
In particular, the website goes on to affirm:
- Thus, the February 1923 recordings of “The Rocks” and “The Fives” should be regarded as a 1st-place tie for the earliest sound recording containing a Boogie Woogie bass figure.
This clearly pushes the first recording back from 1919 to 1923. At the very least, there is an ambiguity here, and either a different source is required, or the text needs to be amended to acknowledge these contradictions. --TonyFleet (talk) 15:39, 16 July 2011 (UTC)
you should mention how Beethoven's piano sonata no.32 was the first work with boogie woogie elements. this is well known. see the wiki page of the no 32 piano sonata of Beethoven for details.
Why does the "typical boogie-woogie bassline' not match the "regular bass figure" shown previously in the article? I know there are variations but this isn't made clear and could be (is) confusing for people new to the subject. 126.96.36.199 (talk) 17:24, 27 June 2013 (UTC)
Somewhere among all the foolishness about "mbuki-mvuki" and other African terms, there really should be some discussion of the homegrown term "wooly booger", meaning pudendum muliebris. Given the sexual origins of at least the names of so many other genres and terms in African-American music (jazz, rag-time, rock & roll, groove, etc.), that one seems pretty plausible to me as the origin of "boogie-woogie". I know I've seen that theory advanced in a book somewhere, but don't have time to track it down.