Talk:Call and response
|WikiProject African diaspora||(Rated Stub-class, Low-importance)|
- Haven't you seen evangelists lately? "Pray lord!"--"Haleluia!". No music. The notion is wider than music. Mikkalai 18:35, 24 Sep 2004 (UTC)
- The article should be rewritten. E.g., in music it was also known to ancient Greeks (antiphony) I guess, in their religin as well. It is a common human cultural phenomenon, not restricted to Afro. Mikkalai 18:35, 24 Sep 2004 (UTC)
Agreeing with Mikkalai, it is a wider phenomenon. Watching a TV special on the 2004 Indian Ocean earthquake, they were reviewing how the traditional natives of some islands (Andaman or Nicobar ?) were able to escape the tidal waves using old knowledge. A westerner knowledgeable in their language was interviewing a native for the special. Most of what was said was said by the islander. However, after _every_ utterance, the westerner would interject the equivalent of "uhuh". So the exchange was something like:
- "So the land and the sea always fight over the line between them" "uhuh" "They fight and the people wait for them to finish" "uhuh" "And so we saw the sea go out" "uhuh" "And so we ran far inland" "uhuh" "And we waited for the land and sea to agree" "uhuh" "this is what our stories told us" "uhuh" "And so we were safe" "uhuh"
This so struck me as call and response. In some cultures to show that you are listening you must punctuate the other person's speech with your own, 'yep', 'yes', 'uhuh', 'gotcha'. It is as natural as breathing between speaking. Can I hear an 'amen'?
Examples of call and resposnse, anyone?
- Cab Calloway was a master caller, I must say! Youtube search for "Minnie the Moocher." "Hi-de-i-de-i-de-IIIIII" "ho-de-o-de-OHHHHH" "boo-pa-doo-doo-boo-ba-pi-pwn-qurrrrrrrrip!" each phrase copied as best as possible by his band. I don't know Wiki styles on spelling things like scat, though. 22.214.171.124 (talk) 18:24, 27 July 2009 (UTC)
Removed a couple of links which are just ... not linked. LupusCanis
Contemporary Egyptian workers 'call and response'
I'm watching planet green's' story about Hapshepsut with Zahi Hawass, and the Egyptian workers who are digging for evidence of Hatshepsut are doing a 'call and response' as they work. Fascinating. 6/26/2011. — Preceding unsigned comment added by 126.96.36.199 (talk) 01:08, 27 June 2011 (UTC)
Can I get a 'what'? What!
The article includes the following description, which excels at obfuscation:
'...with movement in a counterclockwise circle (the direction the sun moves south of the equator)...' . The number of problems packed into so few words is noteworthy and would be impressive if it had been intentional. - Circles are not clockwise or counterclockwise.... movement is. - The sun does not 'move south of the equator'. It is of course the rotation of the Earth giving us a perception. - It still does not make it clear what is being described... the motion of the sun would appear clockwise if looking south at the sun's apparent motion 'south of the equator' and counterclockwise looking north at the sun's apparent motion 'south of the equator. 188.8.131.52 (talk) 03:10, 30 October 2013 (UTC)BGriffin