|This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the Chief Joseph article.|
|This article is of interest to the following WikiProjects:|
|This article has an assessment summary page.|
|A fact from this article was featured on Wikipedia's Main Page in the On this day... section on October 5, 2004, October 5, 2005, October 5, 2006, October 5, 2007, October 5, 2008, October 5, 2009, and October 5, 2010.|
- 1 Contradiction
- 2 Same Event Mentioned Twice?
- 3 Eighteen billion Indians?
- 4 Is "band" appropriate?
- 5 This is informational.
- 6 Reverting a large addition to the article
- 7 Savings Bonds
- 8 Gold Rush Mentioned in Background Section
- 9 PEOPLE NEED TO SIGN MORE ON THIS PAGE!
- 10 Surrender quotation
- 11 other people's names
- 12 Beal's book
After a five-day siege only 30 miles from the Canadian border, he surrendered
Chief Joseph formally surrendered on 5 October 1877 in the Bear Paw mountains of Montana, 40 miles south of Canada (near Havre, Montana).
Those two lines are clearly contradictory, but they're both in the article, so which is right?
- Here's the coordinates of the Bear Paw Battlefield where Chief Joseph surrendered: 48° 22' 38" N 109° 12' 35" W. I'm sure there's a way to figure out what the distance to the Canadian border is, but it'll need to be someone who is more concerned with an answer. -- RobLa 04:45, 11 Oct 2004 (UTC)
- they could have moved 10 mile before signing the treaty after all he did want to find his missing people. so moving a 10 miles away to sign the treatry makes it no longer contradictory. -- User:Drachenkonig 00:04, February 10, 2005
Same Event Mentioned Twice?
"In 1877, after the cavalry threatened to attack, Chief Joseph and other leaders began the journey to the reservation. On a night that Chief Joseph was away from camp, a young Nez Perce man and his friends, avenging the killing of his father, attacked and killed a white settler."
"But, in a reversal of policy in 1877...As they began their journey to Idaho, Chief Joseph learned that three young Nez Perce men, enraged at the loss of their homeland, had massacred a band of white settlers."
Eighteen billion Indians?
"With 2,000 U.S. soldiers in pursuit, Chief Joseph led 18,642,916,000 Nez Perce toward freedom at the Canadian border."
- Always check the page history for vandalism when questions like this arise. Katr67 21:02, 21 March 2007 (UTC)
Is "band" appropriate?
The American Heritage Dictionary defines "band" also as "a group of people", yet in common use (apart from musicians) it is used for outlaws mostly. Is it proper to call Indian warriors "bands"? Are groups of indigenous people invaded by settlers "bands"? Is a Native American Indian glad to read this here, or maybe even in History books (if it is also used there too -I am not familiar)? Hoverfish 06:41, 5 October 2006 (UTC)
- I know that in Canada the term has (had?) meaning, certainly no suggestion of illegal activity. See : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Nations "A First Nation is a legally undefined term that came into common usage in the 1980s to replace the term "Indian band". Elder Sol Sanderson says that he coined the term in the early 1980s. A band is defined as "a body of Indians for whose collective use and benefit lands have been set apart or money is held by the Canadian Crown, or declared to be a band for the purposes of the Indian Act" . There are currently over 600 First Nations governments or bands in Canada. Roughly half of these are located in the provinces of Ontario and British Columbia." --mgaved 10:40, 5 October 2006 (UTC)
Thank you, very enlightening the First Nations article (warbands redirects to "warrior society", which hasn't been created yet). Another help was Band societies, where I will link the first mention of band in the article to. It may be usefull to more readers not familiar with this use of the term. Hoverfish 17:16, 5 October 2006 (UTC)
This is informational.
This is informational about chief Joeseph, don't you think? Thomasreay 00:05, 3 May 2007 (UTC)
Reverting a large addition to the article
By this edit, an anon added a big chunk of text at the end of the article, making no attempt to integrate it. I suspected a copyvio, but, at least according to one website, it's from a 1918 book that's now in the public domain. I haven't reviewed it line-by-line to see what, if anything, might be worth incorporating in the article in proper faashion. JamesMLane t c 16:53, 21 May 2008 (UTC)
Gold Rush Mentioned in Background Section
Which gold rush was it? A small one in the Washington/Oregon area that doesn't have any particular name? I was just curious why no one mentioned it, as seemed to be the cause of the U.S. government's desire for re-negotiation of the 1855 reservation treaty. Vervaine (talk) 19:37, 21 February 2009 (UTC)
PEOPLE NEED TO SIGN MORE ON THIS PAGE!
- Well... you could say
- THERE'S NO BUSINESS LIKE WIKIPEDIA BUSINESS
- LIKE NO BUSINESS I KNOW
- EVERYTHING ABOUT IT IS APPEALING
- EVERYTHING THE TRAFFIC WILL ALLOW
- NO WHERE CAN YOU GET THAT HAPPY FEELING...TA DA
- You could say that, just like Ethel Merman.
The popular legend deflated, however, when the original pencil draft of the report was revealed to show the handwriting of the later poet and lawyer Lieutenant Charles Erskine Scott Wood, who claimed to have taken down the great chief's words on the spot. In the margin it read, "Here insert Joseph's reply to the demand for surrender."
It's not clear to me how the second sentence necessarily negates the historicity of the "I will fight no more forever" quotation. Does this sentence mean that Wood made it up? Or that it was his later recollection of Chief Joseph's statement? (Could he possbily have written it on another piece of paper at the time?) To what extent are we saying that the sad, noble words attributed to Chief Joseph are apocryphal?
other people's names
Hello, do you know: What does Heyoon Yoyikt mean? Is Jean-Louise Sound of Running Feet? How to write Sound of Running Feet in the native language? IsaacDragonBlack (talk) 15:57, 20 September 2013 (UTC)
It's very odd that Merrill Beal's respected account, I Will Fight No More Forever: Chief Joseph and the Nez Perce War (University of Washington Press, 2000), is not cited among sources. Added to books & films section. Sca (talk) 15:04, 31 December 2014 (UTC)