|This article is/was the subject of an educational assignment in 2014 S. Further details are available on the course page.|
|This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the Cumberland Gap article.|
|This article is of interest to the following WikiProjects:|
|It is requested that a map or maps be included in this article to improve its quality.
Wikipedians in Appalachia may be able to help!
March 13, 2006
The "Geological Features" section covers the crater details well but needs some work. For example this section:
"The 12-mile long Cumberland Gap consists of four geologic features: (1) the Yellow Creek valley, (2) the natural gap in the Cumberland Mountain ridge, (3) the eroded gap in the Pine Mountain and (4) the 3-mile diameter impact crater in which Middlesboro, Kentucky is located."
The Gap is not twelve miles long. The passage across the mountains from the Gap to the Cumberland River ford at Pineville is about 12 miles.
The Cumberland Gap is a geologic feature unto itself, a gap in Cumberland Mountain that is perhaps a mile long but maybe much shorter depending on how you measure such things. The features of the passage are the Gap in Cumberland Mountain, the impact crater, a part of the Yellow Creek valley, a low pass over the Log Mountains, the gap in Pine Mountain and the Cumberland River.
Much of what is known as the Yellow Creek valley is contained within the impact crater. Yellow Creek flows to the Cumberland River but even the earliest travelers, including Dr. Thomas Walker, left Yellow Creek and cross directly north over the Log Mountains to the gap at Pineville.
Gap Cave should probably be mentioned somewhere. I can add that in the future.
The Gap is just EAST of the Tri-State Marker but that might be subject to interpretation.
Obviously I have a great deal of interest in Cumberland Gap and want the article to be as close as possible to being correct.
" The Cumberland Gap was discovered by Captain Samuel Stalnaker who met Dr Thomas Walker in 1748. Dr. Thomas Walker, a Virginia physician and explorer is credited with discovering the Gap, however, his personal journal entries indicate otherwise."
I grew up in the area and I've never heard of Captain Samuel Stalnaker. Does he have a Wiki entry? Where can we find out about this person?
Also, I agree with everything Mr Crockett stated above. All of which are things I've stated here before but no one seems to care enough to fix.
- We're going to need a more solid source other than this obscure paper. I'm not finding anything outside of Stalnaker family websites. This may fall under WP:FRINGE. Bms4880 (talk) 17:17, 24 July 2012 (UTC)
As critical as the Cumberland Gap was to the history of American migration west, a map is really necessary that shows the Gap and its relation to passage through the mountains.--Parkwells 18:06, 18 October 2007 (UTC)
- Good suggestion. I inserted a map that was already here, but at a thumbnail scale... The article needs more text in order to accommodate all of the images. --Orlady 18:18, 18 October 2007 (UTC)
Cumbrland Gap in popular culture
I recall Lonnie Donegan recording Cumberland Gap, and I still have it on 78 somewhere (and on mp3) - might it predate the quoted skiffle group? Lonnie's recording was very popular in our house in UK —Preceding unsigned comment added by Jpedley (talk • contribs) 20:38, 31 October 2008 (UTC)
- I think this is interesting information but seems to be like "trivia" because it isn't verifiable or properly sourced, see WP:IPC. These tidbits of info would probably serve better on pages specifically for each topic with a hyperlink to Cumberland Gap since they are more pop culture material where this article is about geography and places. So if no one has any strong opposition I suggest removing it. Brendan.Hunstad (talk) 18:15, 29 July 2014 (UTC)
Hello! I'm a student at Ohio University and planning on doing some edits to this article and would like anyone involved to be aware. Right now I am thinking about bringing this article current and increase its grading to be more useful to the community. I'm starting the editing in my sandbox if you would like to take a look and I am open for all suggestions and feedback.Brendan.Hunstad (talk) 18:38, 29 July 2014 (UTC)