Talk:Flag of Somalia
|WikiProject Heraldry and vexillology||(Rated B-class)|
|WikiProject Somalia||(Rated B-class, Top-importance)|
Designer of flag
Can i just say that the Somali flag designer is until now, disputable. There is no credible source that dates back to the 50s when it was made that mentions who actually made it. For instance, several somali sources state that Islow Omar (who was a politician at the time) designed the flag whilst one questional german source states mohamed liban. The best thing would be to dissacotiate any names with the flag on its wiki page as i've tried to edit it. — Preceding unsigned comment added by Abshir1000 (talk • contribs) 23:29, 6 February 2011 (UTC)
- Who created the flag of Somalia is most certainly not disputed: Mohammed Awale Liban did (c.f. ). He was personally selected by the Somali labour trade union to do so . That Somali-language article you linked to () is also unverifiable, and a Google search of "Islow Omar" turns up a handful of hits for some fellow in Norway . Middayexpress (talk) 23:29, 7 February 2011 (UTC)
The creation of the Flag was designated to the Consiglio Teretoriale, the UN terretorial council which was headed by Aden Abdullah Osman, later to become Somalia's president, not the trade union since their existence began in 1955. Like i said, find me a source that dates back to the 50s or even 60s when the flag was designed that notes Mohamed Liban. Also, he was not a scholar, if you search his name on Google books, he use to work as a scribe in the Presidents residence.
To add to that, how could it be the case that the Flag's blue background was in support of the U.N. considering that the U.N. were the same group who returned the Italians back to Somalia in 1950, an action greatly opposed by the SYL, the leading power who take credit for the Flag and unity.
What do you mean the source in unverifiable? Just because you cannot understand it you think its not verified? The source is by Mohamed Ingriisi, a credited writer from Belgium who has a page somewhere in Wikipedia, the portion about the flag mentions Islow Omar as the individual who composed the colours and suggested the star in response to the claims of Awale Liban. He was a politician of the past and very few Somali writers remember his case.
I have noticed you seem to accept any source as long as it reads english, a policy that promotes ignorance and degrades Wikipedia. When you learn to differentiate truth from deception, only then will you become reliable and accurate. — Preceding unsigned comment added by Abshir1000 (talk • contribs) 21:21, 9 February 2011 (UTC)
- Please settle down and remember to be civil. Wikipedia has a specific policy referred to as WP:VER wherein one must actually be able to verify the stated claims. This has to do with the simple fact that this is English Wikipedia, not Somali Wikipedia. That Somali-language article  you keep adding simply cannot be verified:
"Because this is the English Wikipedia, English-language sources are preferred over non-English ones, provided that English sources of equal quality and relevance are available. When quoting a source in a different language, provide both the original-language text and an English translation in the text or a footnote. Translations published by reliable sources are preferred over translations by Wikipedians, but translations by Wikipedians are preferred over machine translations. When citing such a source without quoting it, the original and its translation should be provided if requested by other editors: this can be added to a footnote or the talk page."
- Wikipedia also does not require sources to be period-specific to be usable (refer to WP:RS). They just have to be reliable, and I've already linked you to two separate sources that explicitly identify Mohammed Awale Liban as the creator of that flag (c.f ). Again, not one English source mentions this "Islow Omar" fellow . Now that I've had a chance to think about it, I also recognize the name of that author of the Somali language article, one "Maxamed Xaaji (Ingiriis)". As you correctly indicate, he used to have an article on Wikipedia, but it was deleted because he apparently wrote it himself (contact User:Gyrofrog for the details). In other words, the author has a presence on Wikipedia. I sincerely hope that person isn't you because that would make this whole affair not just one of unverifiable sourcing, but also of conflict of interest. With that said, I have removed that Somali language article. If you wish to re-add the "Islow Omar" allusions, you'll first have to try and find a quality English language source (or a professional translation into English) that does so, although I very much doubt anyone other than M.A. Liban designed the flag. Best regards, Middayexpress (talk) 23:20, 9 February 2011 (UTC)
Im not suprised at your ignorance. The Somali Flag is one of the single most spoken about treasuries of the Somali republic and you think a source by a Spanish female writer (what does a Spaniard know about Somalia? She clearly derived her statement from the equally innacurate German source that doesnt even know that the trade unions were formed after the flag) is enough to dismiss everything. In many Somali radio shows and gatherings, the history of the flag never involved Awale Liban because outside your ignorant circle of knowledge, its widely known the flag is disputed and a comitee had designated it. Anyway, i will soon file a complaint at Wiki's racist policy of only allowing English sources. — Preceding unsigned comment added by Abshir1000 (talk • contribs) 00:34, 10 February 2011 (UTC)
- Using terms like "your ignorance" constitutes a personal attack as I have already indicated at User talk:Abshir1000. Middayexpress is correct regarding Wikipedia's policies and guidelines. I can understand why this would be frustrating, although you are free to try and convince other Wikipedians to change these policies and guidelines. For what it's worth, I believe the author mentioned earlier is Mohamed Haji (Ingiriis). The article was indeed deleted (via WP:PROD), but WP:COI was just one of its issues (and, by itself, is not a criterion for deletion - as I recall). -- Gyrofrog (talk) 17:30, 10 February 2011 (UTC)
Forgive my ignorance, but I noticed that the flag of Somalia pictured on the CIA World Factbook (https://www.cia.gov/cia/publications/factbook/flags/so-lgflag.gif) is of a different shade of blue than the one depicted here... does anyone know which shade is the right shade? --The Listener 21:41, 13 February 2007 (UTC)
Both designs are correct, though the Wikipedia one is slightly more close to the original official version. The official Somali design is light blue, officially azure, which the Wikipedia one is. The CIA one is a faded light blue. What distinguishes the flags is the slightly faded part. Soomaali (Aug. 23/07) —The preceding signed but undated comment was added at 11:43, August 23, 2007 (UTC).
Bonnie Blue, Vietnam & Belgian Congo flags
I recently tried to add the flag of the Belgian Congo/Congo Free state to the see also category as it is quite similar (though obviously not identical to) the Somali flag. It's not really a big deal whether or not its on the page, but I just wanted to point out that I am aware its not the same flag. Cheers, Otto1943 (talk) 23:41, 4 September 2014 (UTC)
- Yeah, it's similar in design but not identical, much like the flag of Vietnam. On the other hand, the Bonnie Blue Flag is identical in all respects except for its darker blue background. Ultimately, despite varying degrees of similarities, all of these foreign flags are of course unrelated to the flag of Somalia/Somali flag (an ethnic flag). Regards, Middayexpress (talk) 14:48, 5 September 2014 (UTC)