Talk:Robinson Crusoe economy/GA1

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

The classical economists' illustration involving Robinson Crusoe was a small mention on the Robinson Crusoe page and I believe it is commendable how the article has maintained its notability, cited relevant references including press, and avoided excessive jargon, all in all achieving the intended purpose of explaining what is a simple illustration in economics. The main contributor to the page has created and uploaded multiple graphs under free license, formatted the article well and used clear and concise language. I have been watching this article for a quite a while now and making minor edits on it but I have no attachment to the same. The author may want to expand on the references, explaining more about each reference link, maybe also reconsider the inclusion of Robinson Crusoe Economy in the economics systems sidebar (I think as it's merit is limited to being a popular example, à la prisoner's dilemma) however I would like to leave that to other editors to decide. I would definitely pass this article as a good article, hoping the contributions do not end here. Purplesky91 (talk) 19:24, 20 September 2011 (UTC)