Talk:Tolerance analysis

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
WikiProject Engineering  
WikiProject icon This article is within the scope of WikiProject Engineering, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of engineering on Wikipedia. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join the discussion and see a list of open tasks.
 ???  This article has not yet received a rating on the project's quality scale.
 ???  This article has not yet received a rating on the project's importance scale.
 

-- Comments by AZCoder : This page needs to be modified according to following comments I am a new user on wikipedia so I don't know how to change the webpage. I am posting my comments here. Please discuss and update the page

I don't think tolerance stacks is tolerance analysis. Tolerance stack is one method of performing tolerance analysis. The way it is described on this page, it appears as if tolerance stack is same as tolerance charts. The two references cited are both for tolerance charts.

Tolerance Analysis can be conducted by various methods a) Tolerance Charts (Basically one-dimensional analysis) b) Simulations (Monte Carlo and others) c) Parametric or linerized (1D, 2D) tolerance Analysis d) Academic Research math models for tolerance analysis (Offset zones, Variational Surface, Kinematic, Vector Spaces, Variational Surfaces, Degree of Freedom, TTRS, T-Maps, GapSpace, Clearance Space, etc)

review papers for such methods and tolerance research are:

Shah J.J., Ameta G., Shen Z., and Davidson J.K., "Navigating the Tolerance Analysis Maze", Computer Aided Design and Applications, Vol 4(5), 2007, pp705-719.

Pasupathy T.M.K, Morse E.P., Wilhelm R.G., "A Survey of Mathematical Methods for the construction of geometric tolerance zones", Journal of Computing and Information Science in Engineering, Vol 3, 2003, pp. 64-75.

Hong Y. S. and Chang T.-C., “A comprehensive review of tolerancing research”, International Journal of Production Research, Vol. 40(11), 2002, 2425-2459.

Shen, Z., Ameta, G., Shah, J. J. and Davidson, J. K., 2005, "A Comparative Study of Tolerance Analysis Methods", ASME Transactions, Journal of Computing & Information Science in Engineering, v5(3), September 2005, pp247-256.

See my comment below. Mollynet (talk) 20:13, 24 September 2010 (UTC)

Naming the Page[edit]

This page and any discussions on Wikipedia about this subject should be titled "Tolerance Analysis." "Tolerance Analysis" is the general term for all activities related to the study of accumulated variation in mechanical parts and assemblies, and may even be expanded into other types of systems, such as electrical systems.

The issue at hand is this:

"Tolerance Stack" is actually a slang term, jargon usage, and a shortened version of "Tolerance Stackup" or "Tolerance Stack-up." Tolerance Analysis includes all types of studies used to predict or comprehend accumulated variation.

"Tolerance Charts" is a slang-jargon term, naming the analytical process after the form used to compile the information used in the analysis. This is inappropriate. Although you may find references to the term "Tolerance Charts" in certain literature, it is not the best term to describe the subject or the activity.

As a comparison, "Stress Analysis" is the term used in industry and academia to describe the analytical methods used to calculate the stresses that may occur in mechanical parts and assemblies. "Tolerance Analysis" is of a parallel structure, and like Stress Analysis, describes the general activity being performed.

I strongly suggest that this article should not be changed to "Tolerance Charts." The title of this article should be "Tolerance Analysis."

Thank you.

Bryan R. Fischer Author, "Mechanical Tolerance Stackup and Analysis" 2004.

This article needs some work. Either the article needs to be renamed to tolerance analysis or a separate article needs to be created at tolerance analysis and the topics split. Wizard191 (talk) 23:14, 27 May 2009 (UTC)
Agreed. As of this posting, there is a Tolerance Analysis article, albeit very short and incomplete. As a start, how do we migrate the information in this article to the Tolerance Analysis article, then create a redirect from this page to the Tolerance Analysis article? Mollynet (talk) 20:13, 24 September 2010 (UTC)
Done. Wizard191 (talk) 21:12, 24 September 2010 (UTC)