The Countess Cathleen
Editions and revisions
The play was first published in 1892 in The Countess Kathleen and Various Legends and Lyrics (the spelling was changed to "Cathleen" in all future editions). Its text underwent many changes until the final version performed in 1911 and published in 1912 ("a complete revision to make it suitable for performance at the Abbey Theatre" and "all but a new play," according to Yeats). The variorum editor, Russell K. Alspach, remarks, "The revision for the second printing, Poems (1895), was so drastic that intelligible collation was virtually impossible." The tendency of Yeats's changes between 1892 and 1911 has been summarized as a move "decidedly away from an almost farcical realism and tentatively toward the austere, suggestive mode of the dance plays."
The play is set ahistorically in Ireland during a famine. The idealistic Countess of the title sells her soul to the devil so that she can save her tenants from starvation and from damnation for having sold their own souls. After her death, she is redeemed as her motives were altruistic and ascends to Heaven.
Yeats based the play on a purported Irish legend, "The Countess Cathleen O'Shea", which had been printed in an Anglo-Irish newspaper in 1867. When he later attempted to trace its origins, the story appeared to have been adapted into English from a French story, "Les marchands d'âmes", whose protagonist was named "comtesse Ketty O'Connor". This original French version appeared in the anthology, Les matinées de Timothée Trimm, by Léo Lespès without further provenance.
The first performance at the Abbey Theatre, in the much-changed final version, took place on December 14, 1911.
Influence on Joyce
Oona's chanted song from Act II, "Who will go drive with Fergus now?" (removed from the 1911 version) made a deep impression on a seventeen-year-old James Joyce in Anna Mather's 1899 performance. Richard Ellmann reports that Joyce "set the poem to music and praised it as the best lyric in the world." According to Stanislaus Joyce, James sang the song at his dying brother George's request in 1902, to this chant of his own composition. In the opening episode of Ulysses, Buck Mulligan chants the song and Stephen Dedalus works several variations on it ("parodically," but "not simply...parody").
Joyce also has Stephen Dedalus recall Cathleen's dying words ("Bend down your faces, Oona and Aleel...") in A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man.
The play provoked controversy over the blasphemous attitudes it apparently supported from F. H. O'Donnell and other critics including Maurice Joy and Christian Ponder. Critic Susan Cannon Harris argued in her book Gender and Modern Irish Drama (2002) that these objections are based more on the depiction of the usurpation of the 'male' space of martyr by a female figure than on any perceived insult to Catholicism.
The play is also seen as anti-English: "The anti-English tendency underlying the play is evident, the merchant-demons being the English landlords."
- Jeffares, W. B. Yeats, man and poet, p. 283
- The variorum edition of the plays of W.B. Yeats, New York: Macmillan, p. xii
- David Richman, Passionate action: Yeats's mastery of drama, Cranbury, N.J.: Associated University Presses, p. 164; Richman considers the 1892 play the "cluttered" work of "an apprentice dramatist...groping toward assurance as a stage symbolist."
- David R. Clark, The Collected Works of W.B. Yeats: The plays, p. 728
- Clark, op. cit., p. 675
- P.J. Mathews, "Stirring up Disloyalty: The Boer War, the Irish Literary Theatre and the Emergence of a New Separatism," Irish University Review 33 (2003), pp. 99-116, p. 99.
- Ronald Schuchard, The last minstrels: Yeats and the revival of the bardic arts, Oxford, 2008 pp. 290f.
- Schuchard, pp. 36-37
- Debora Sherman, Who Goes with Fergus?: The Transfiguration of Yeats in Ulysses
- F. Sefton Delmer, English literature from Beowulf to T.S. Eliot: for the use of schools, universities, and private students, p. 193