The Goat and the Vine

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
An illustration of the fable by Harrison Weir, 1869

The Goat and the Vine is counted as one of Aesop's Fables and is numbered 374 in the Perry Index. There is also a West Asian variant.

The fable and its versions[edit]

When a goat starts eating a vine's leaves and shoots, the vine retorts that it will still have enough juice left to produce grapes, the wine from which will be poured over it when the goat is sacrificed. The earliest record of the fable is in an epigram by Leonidas of Tarentum, who lived in the area of southern Italy colonised by Greeks in the 3rd century BCE.[1] Later Greek references come from Western Asia, including another epigram by Evenus of Ascalon containing simply the vine's retort[2] and the prose collection of fables by Aphthonius of Antioch.[3] Still later, the Neo-Latin poet Pantaleon Candidus included it in his collection of 150 fables.[4] The tale only began to appear in English collections of Aesop's fables in the 19th century.

Meanwhile an alternative version of the fable had been appearing in various recensions of the story of Ahiqar since the first century CE. In the Arabic version a gazelle nibbles a madder plant, which threatens that it will be used to tan the goat's hide when the animal is killed and skinned. Madder or other tanning agents make a similar threat in the Syriac, Armenian and Slavonic versions of the story,[5] but the goat or deer involved answers that, while this may happen in the future, for the present it needs to satisfy its hunger.

References[edit]

  1. ^ Greek Anthology, III.99
  2. ^ Greek Anthology III.75
  3. ^ Aesopica site
  4. ^ Centum et Quinquaginta Fabulae carminibus explicatae, Frankfurt 1604, poem 94
  5. ^ The story of Ahikar, London 1898

External links[edit]

19–20th century illustrations from books