The Story of the Latter-day Saints
Dust jacket used on both printings of the first edition.
|Author||James B. Allen and Glen M. Leonard|
|Subject||The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints|
|Publisher||Deseret Book in collaboration with the LDS Church's Historical Dept.|
|Media type||Print (Hardcover)|
|Followed by||1992 2nd edition|
The authors summarized the tone of their work by identifying four recurring themes that emerged throughout The Story of the Latter-day Saints:
- The Latter-day Saints were primarily religiously motivated.
- The church was always influenced by its environment, to some degree.
- The church started small and American, but would grow into an international organization.
- The church has been flexible with some issues, yet committed to certain central teachings.
Although seen as well-written and comprehensive, the book was intended for a Latter-day Saint audience, because it detailed minutiae like organizational changes, but didn't focus on issues of interest to new readers on Mormonism. Unlike most earlier Mormon histories, this book focused on casting the church in a broader context, addressed controversial historical issues, and covered the events of the twentieth century.
The following list of the book's chapters also describe its historical scope:
- The Religious Setting for the Restoration
- The Restoration Commences, 1820-1831
- Unfolding Latter-day Zion, 1831-1836
- The Saints Move On, 1836-1839
- Building the City Beautiful, 1839-1842
- Difficult Days: Nauvoo, 1842-1845
- Exodus to a New Zion, 1846-1850
- Establishing an Ensign, 1851-1856
- In the National Spotlight, 1856-1863
- Challenges and Cooperatives, 1864-1872
- Close of a Career, 1872-1877
- A Turbulent Decade, 1877-1887
- The End of an Era, 1887-1896
- A Time of Transition, 1897-1907
- Consolidating for Growth, 1908-1918
- Change and Continuity in the Postwar Decade, 1919-1930
- The Church and the Great Depression, 1930-1938
- The Church in World War II, 1939-1950
- Foundations for Expansion, 1951-1959
- Correlating the Worldwide Church, 1960-1973
- "Lengthening Our Stride," 1973-1976
In the 1992 second edition, the last chapter was changed to "Toward a Universal Church, 1974-1990".
For over 50 years, Joseph Fielding Smith's Essentials in Church History was issued as a popular single-volume history of the LDS Church. After Smith's death in 1972, LDS Church and Deseret Book officials asked the church's Historical Department to write a new single-volume history to replace Essentials in Church History and cover more recent events, while using new sources available in the Church Archives. With the First Presidency's approval, the department assigned the project to James B. Allen, an Assistant Church Historian, and Glen M. Leonard, a Senior Historical Associate. The Story of the Latter-day Saints was published in 1976, the one-hundredth anniversary of Joseph Fielding Smith's birth.
The book took a non-partisan, factually-sound approach to LDS Church history and was the first time the entire history of Mormonism was professionally surveyed in one book. It was also one of the first institutionally-sponsored publications to deal frankly with many controversial issues such as the complexities of Nauvoo, and the church's political, economic, social and doctrinal developments. As professional historians, the authors cast their subject in its historic context, with connections made to larger Restoration and American movements. The product revealed the challenges and progress of the new Mormon history in confronting controversy and reevaluating setting and tone.
Anticipating high demand, Deseret Book prepared a very large first printing of 35,000. It sold quickly with 10,000 copies in the first month, including 5,000 to the LDS Church's Public Communications department to place in U.S. libraries. Nearly 20,000 copies sold in the first year and the entire original printing was sold out within three years.
The book was initially received favorably. It was called a "significant" and "pathbreaking" history of Mormonism. Historian Richard Poll recommended it "to every serious student of Mormonism and every library interested in history, religion or Americana." Its extensive bibliography was also respected and seen as noteworthy.
The book was commended for its modern scholarship and dispassionate tone, while representing a faithful LDS perspective. One review noted the authors' "remarkable blend of the scholarly approach and the religious story… They do not feel constrained to bear testimony, and yet they demonstrate an empathy toward Mormonism that could only emanate from devoted members. It is a pleasant balance."
However, this balance risked displeasing both religious and academic readers. Believers in the divinity of all church actions disliked seeing events cast against the influences in their historical setting. History purists wanted discussion of more issues and problems, and felt significant events and details were missing in this concentration of all Mormon history. Allen and Leonard's history was praised and criticized by both Mormon and non-Mormon readers.
In 1976, some members of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles had concerns that the book wasn't faith-promoting. When they approached quorum president Ezra Taft Benson, he requested a thorough reading by his executive assistant. This produced a critique that asserted the book wasn't spiritual enough to be a "true" LDS history and that the Historical Department's activities should be controlled.
In a speech, Benson publicly worried the book may spiritually harm young church members. He condemned the portrayal of the Word of Wisdom health code and Joseph Smith's visions as being influenced by parallel movements in American history. Benson warned that the terms "experimental systems," "communal life," "primitivists," and "prophet alleged," were offensive and did not promote faith in the church. He advised against purchasing work by "liberal sources," because it would "help sustain their cause."
In a meeting with the First Presidency and Church Historian Leonard J. Arrington, Benson and Apostle Mark E. Petersen argued the book was faith-damaging and should have presented more prophetic evidences. Arrington defended it, but agreed to allow future department manuscripts to be reviewed by an Apostle before publication, even though they already passed through a reading committee of accomplished historians.
While other church leaders agreed that the book was too "secular," several continued to support it, including Howard W. Hunter and LDS Church President Spencer W. Kimball. Kimball felt it was a great work and was unhappy with "unchristian" treatment of James B. Allen by some religion faculty at Brigham Young University (BYU) who were upset by it. Kimball thought Allen had performed honorably in this approved assignment, and "that Benson and Petersen did not have the authority or the right to interfere with the sale of the book." However, such support remained private, to preserve the public unity of the Apostles.
Despite its quick sell-out, The Story of the Latter-day Saints was not reprinted for years, and some doubted it would ever be. It was rumored to be uncitable in publications by Deseret Book and the Church Educational System.
The book fueled growing suspicion and disfavor with the Historical Department's activities, which lead to the History Division's turning point. Plans were canceled for a 16 volume comprehensive history series in honor of the church's sesquicentennial. Division staff were downsized, bureaucratized and eventually transferred to BYU, where they could publish under academic rather than ecclesiastical sponsorship.
Eventually, a second printing was approved for 1986. Later, Allen and Leonard prepared a revised and updated manuscript, which was published as a second edition in 1992. After the controversy dissipated, the book was still seen as an influential and notable accomplishment in its field. It is appreciated as respectful and faithful in its approach and "a model example of the new Mormon history… It remains the best one-volume treatment of the Mormon past and the place where the beginning student of LDS history should turn first." Curt Bench, a dealer in fine and rare Mormon books, listed it as one of the 50 most important Mormon books.
The following are published reviews of The Story of the Latter-day Saints
- Drayton, John N. (Fall 1976). Sunstone 1 (4): 86–88
- Ellsworth, S. George (Winter 1977). BYU Studies 17 (2): 241–46
- Paul, Rodman W. (July 1977). Western Historical Quarterly 8: 351–53
- Lythgoe, Dennis L. (Autumn 1977). Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought 10 (4): 134–37
- MacKinnon, William P. (Autumn 1977). Arizona and the West 19: 272–74
- Foster, Lawrence (September 1977). Church History 46: 403–04
- Hansen, Klaus J. (Winter 1978). Utah Historical Quarterly 46 (1): 82–86
- Peterson, Charles S. (Winter 1978). Idaho Yesterdays 21 (4): 31–32
- Cannon, Donald Q. (1993). BYU Studies 33 (3): 618–23
- Bennett, Richard E. (Spring 1994). Journal of Mormon History 20 (1): 153–56
- (Arrington 1998, pp. 142)
- Allen, James B.; Glen M. Leonard (1976), "Preface", The Story of the Latter-day Saints, Salt Lake City: Deseret Book
- Arrington, Leonard J.; Davis Bitton (1980), "Introduction", The Mormon Experience: A History of the Latter-day Saints, New York: Vintage Books, pp. xii
- Allen, James B. (2000), "Historians and Historical Writing", in Arnold K. Garr, Donald Q. Cannon, Richard O. Cowan, Encyclopedia of Latter-day Saint History, Salt Lake City: Deseret Book, p. 498
- Allen, James B.; Glen M. Leonard (1992), Story of the Latter-day Saints (2nd ed.), Salt Lake City: Deseret Book Company
- Arrington, Leonard J. (1976), "Foreword", in James B. Allen and Glen M. Leonard, The Story of the Latter-day Saints, Salt Lake City: Deseret Book, pp. vii–viii
- Poll, Richard D. (Summer 1979), "State-of-the-Art Mormon History", Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought 12 (2): 124–126, retrieved 2008-10-20
- Flake, Chad J. (Spring 1977), "Mormon Bibliography, 1976", BYU Studies 17 (3): 361–372, retrieved 2008-10-20
- Poll, Richard D. (1978), "Nauvoo and the New Mormon History: A Bibliographical Survey", Journal of Mormon History 5: 110, retrieved 2008-10-20
- Foster, Lawrence (Summer 1984), "Career Apostates: Reflections on the Works of Jerald and Sandra Tanner", Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought 17 (2): 45, retrieved 2008-10-20
- (Arrington 1998, pp. 143)
- Lythgoe, Dennis L. (Autumn 1977), "Artful Analysis of Mormonism", Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought 10 (4): 135, retrieved 2008-10-20
- (Arrington 1998, pp. 145)
- Bergera, Gary James; Priddis, Ronald (1985). "Chapter 2: Integrating Religion & Academics". Brigham Young University: A House of Faith. Salt Lake City: Signature Books. ISBN 0-941214-34-6. OCLC 12963965.
- Anderson, Devery S. (Summer 2000), "A History of Dialogue, Part Two: Struggle Toward Maturity, 1971-1982", Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought 33 (2): 66–7, retrieved 2008-10-20
- (Arrington 1998, pp. 147)
- (Arrington 1998, pp. 148)
- (Arrington 1998, pp. 150)
- Anderson, Lavina Fielding (Spring 1993), "The LDS Intellectual Community and Church Leadership: A Contemporary Chronology", Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought 26 (1): 10, 61, retrieved 2008-10-20
- Hansen, Klaus J. (1984), "Jan Shipps and the Mormon Tradition", Journal of Mormon History 11: 143, retrieved 2008-10-20
- (Walker, Whittaker & Allen 2001, pp. 67)
- (Walker, Whittaker & Allen 2001, pp. 66)
- Bench, Curt (October 1990), "Fifty Important Mormon Books" (PDF), Sunstone (79): 56, retrieved 2009-07-23