The terrorists have won
| This article relies on references to primary sources or sources affiliated with the subject, rather than references from independent authors and third-party publications. Please add citations from reliable sources. (February 2011) |
"...the terrorists have won", or "...then the terrorists win" are rhetorical phrases which were widely used in the United States in the wake of the September 11 attacks. The phrase takes the form of "that if we pursue some particular course of action, why then, the terrorists have won" (as explained by Jeff Greenfield of CNN). In November 2001, the Los Angeles Times reported:[2]
- A database search for the phrase, "If we [blank], then the terrorists have won," turned up hundreds of hits in U.S. newspapers and magazines.
The expression had been used before 2001. In 1995, an editorial about the response to the Oklahoma City bombing in the Ocala Star-Banner, of Ocala, Florida concluded: "Our response to terrorism should be carefully measured. If our First Amendment rights suffer as a result of the awful domestic terrorist attack in Oklahoma City the terrorists have indeed, won.”[3] At the same time, an editorial in the Victoria Advocate of Victoria, Texas said: "If Americans begin to yield their own freedoms at home, the terrorists have won."[4]
In the months after the September 11 attacks, the expression was often used. One of the most famous instances was on November 4, 2001 by Ellen DeGeneres, who was hosting the Emmy Awards, which had been postponed twice that year for worries that a showy celebration would seem inappropriate in the wake of the attacks. To lighten the mood, she quipped: "We're told to go on living our lives as usual, because to do otherwise is to let the terrorists win, and really, what would upset the Taliban more than a gay woman wearing a suit in front of a room full of Jews?" [5]
In December 2001, humorist Steve Symanovich commented on the overuse of the expression, writing in the Washington Business Journal:[6]
- In recent months I had heard about any number of things that would allow the terrorists to win. Early on, I learned that if America plays fast and loose with the Bill of Rights, the terrorists will have won. I couldn't agree more, but that was just the start. Later, I found out that if we stop working/shopping/eating out, the terrorists will have won. I took the message to heart. I'm not opposed to work; I don't mind shopping; and, although I'm on a diet, I can still eat out and order light. But there was more. Finally, I ran into this headline: "If you don't read this article, the terrorists will have won."
[edit] References
- ^ INTOLERANCE, Lawrence Wright, September 20, 2010, The New Yorker.
- ^ A Phrase That Turns Routine Acts Into Acts of War, Los Angeles Times, November 7, 2001
- ^ Hasty laws are not the answer, Ocala Star-Banner, April 27, 1995
- ^ Don’t yield our freedoms, The Victoria Advocate, May 8, 1995
- ^ The Guardian profile: Ellen DeGeneres, The Guardian, February 23, 2007
- ^ If you don’t read this the terrorists have won, Washington Business Journal, December 24, 2001