Today We Live
|Today We Live|
Theatrical release poster
|Directed by||Howard Hawks|
|Produced by||Howard Hawks|
|Written by||William Faulkner (dialogue)|
|Based on||Turn About
by William Faulkner
|Cinematography||Oliver T. Marsh
Elmer Dyer (aerial photography)
|Edited by||Edward Curtiss|
|Running time||113 minutes|
Based on the story Turnabout by William Faulkner, which appeared in the Saturday Evening Post on March 5, 1932, the film is about two officers during World War I, who compete for the same beautiful young woman. Faulkner provided dialogue for the film, making it the only film version of his work that Faulkner co-wrote.
Joan Crawford's character was added to the film to include a love interest. She met her future husband Franchot Tone on the set of the film. They married two years later.
During World War I, Diana "Ann" Boyce-Smith (Joan Crawford) is an English girl living on her father's estate in Kent. The estate is bought by a wealthy American, Richard Bogard (Gary Cooper), who seeks to move into his new property. Right as Bogard arrives, Ann and the house's servants find out that her father has been killed in action, but Ann projects calm and brave graciousness and moves to the guest cottage without complaint. Bogard finds her strength attractive and quickly falls in love with her.
Meanwhile, her brother Lt. Ronnie Boyce-Smith (Franchot Tone) and Lt. Claude Hope (Robert Young) are both British Naval officers going off to fight in the war. Ann believes she is love with Claude, and consents to marry him. However, she soon realizes she is in true love when meeting Bogard. Though Bogard originally proclaimed his neutrality and indifference to the war, he soon joins as a fighter pilot. Ann goes to London, and though Claude is unaware of Diana's true feelings for Bogard, Ann admits her feelings for Bogard to Ronnie. Ronnie advises her to tell Claude the truth, but Ann is intent on keeping her marriage pledge. Then Ronnie shows an announcement in the paper informing her that Bogard was reported dead during a training accident.
However, there had been a mistake, and Bogard comes back unharmed. Though she is happy to see him, she disappears soon after he arrives. Bogard comes across a drunken Claude in a bar and takes him home—a home he shares with Ann. Bogard becomes jealous, and a rivalry for Ann develops between Bogard and Claude. Claude agrees to accompany Bogard on an air fight, and Bogard is surprised by Claude's expert shooting. Bogard takes a turn at Claude's shift on a boat, and Claude is blinded when hand-launching a torpedo against a German battleship.
Ann learns of Claude's blindness and says a final goodbye to Bogard, but he realizes Diana and Bogard's true feelings for one another. Diana feels it is her duty to care for Claude, and when an aerial suicide mission comes up, all three men participate, with the outcome being that both Claude and Ronnie die in action, although their boat successfully makes a torpedo run. Their sacrifice allows Bogard to survive, and although Diana is sad to lose both Ronnie and Claude, she and Bogard are reunited.
As appearing in Today We Live (main roles and screen credits identified):
- Joan Crawford as Diana "Ann" Boyce
- Gary Cooper as Lieutenant Richard Bogard
- Robert Young as Lieutenant Claude Hope
- Franchot Tone as Lieutenant Ronnie Boyce-Smith
- Roscoe Karns as "Mac" McGinnis
- Louise Closser Hale as Applegate
- Rollo Lloyd as Major
- Hilda Vaughn as Eleanor
- Eily Malyon as The maid
With the working titles, "We Live Again" and "Turn About", Howard Hawks purchased an option on Faulkner's short story, "Turnabout" of men in combat as a star vehicle for Phillips Holmes, Charles "Buddy" Rogers, and later, Clark Gable. Faulkner took only five days to write the film himself, but when Irving Thalberg, the vice-president of MGM studios at the time, insisted that Crawford be written into the script as she was contractually committed to a $500,000 salary, working or not, the first of many rewrites began.[N 1] Faulkner created the role of Ann, who was involved in a love triangle. Hawks hated the studio interference in what he considered would have been a "man's picture", but found working with Crawford was pleasant. Although touted as a classic screen pairing, Today We Live was the only time Joan Crawford and Gary Cooper performed together. MGM marketed the film as a romance with the trailer focusing on the two stars, gushing on screen with the taglines, "The fiery head-strong personality of exquisite Joan Crawford" and "The calm strength, the eager romantic nature of handsome Gary Cooper."
Once Crawford was signed, an effort to go for a similar star name led to Cooper coming on board, on loan from Paramount two weeks after the projected date of principal photography, although some sources indicate that Cooper, Robert Young and Franchot Tone were Hawk's first choices. Press releases had touted that Crawford had insisted on Cooper as her co-star. Cooper was in a slight decline with two other "mediocre" films in release, and when the opportunity to work with Hawks came, it also aligned him with the mercurial Crawford, albeit in what he later would regard as a "misguided project".[N 2] A series of rewrites with both Faulkner and other screenwriters along with the cutting of key opening scenes led to a confusing jumble of versions, as the original screen time of 135 minutes of a preview print indicates.
After obtaining General Douglas MacArthur's help in reserving March Field in California, individual aerial sequences were shot although footage from Howard Hughes' Hell's Angels (1930) including the bomber mission, the "dogfight" sequence complete with the head-on collision of two aircraft, was merged into the final production print. Principal photography in both Culver City studio and location sites began in mid-December 1932 and wrapped in February 1933. After looking at rushes of the young actors that were integral to the background of the film, it was evident that their British accents were completely unconvincing and Hawks resorted to excising their scenes altogether and entering a new rewrite, focusing more heavily on Crawford's character, with no better results. The upper-class dialogue that once was considered "snappy" now appeared to be "Hemingwayesque" and combined with the ludicrous period outfits worn by the cast, especially Crawford's outlandish gowns, made it difficult for cast members to not consider the entire exercise a farce.[N 3]
Although well received in a preview, Today We Live was a very different film in its final release form, and was almost universally panned, with Variety having a litany of complaints: "... the film was 20 minutes too long. Crawford was unconvincing, Hawks used too much aerial footage from 'Hell's Angels' (1930), the "Gowns by Adrian" were extreme and annoying, and the story was superficial ... " Mordant Hall in his review for The New York Times, was less strident, but noted the film was "at times vague and cumbersome. It possesses, however, the spark of sincerity, and its lack of clarity might be ascribed either to Howard Hawks's direction or to the script contributed by Edith Fitzgerald and Dwight Taylor, for there are sequences that are far too lengthy and others that would be considerably improved by more detail." A modern assessment was similarly damming, "... the melodrama is more clinging than the mud of the Marne."
According to MGM records the film earned $590,000 in the US and Canada and $445,000 elsewhere resulting in a loss of $23,000.
- Thalberg interfered with Today We Live as "the studio simply had to put her (Crawford) to work or lose money." A further complication was that Tallulah Bankhead, the original star, had balked at the role.
- Crawford fretted that not only was she forced into the film but it required her to master a British accent which she felt was not altogether successful. Reviewers called it "dreadful".
- Actors such as Cooper, wore their own 1933 styled clothing in complete contrast to what was to be a World War I setting. The enormous collar worn by Crawford "stuck in everybody's eye." 
- The Eddie Mannix Ledger, Los Angeles: Margaret Herrick Library, Center for Motion Picture Study.
- "Today We Live (1933)." The New York Times. Retrieved: September 18, 2012.
- Phillips 2001, pp. 13–16.
- Quirk and Schoell 2002, p. 69.
- Thompson 2010, p. 40.
- Chandler 2009, p. 116.
- Brett 2008, p. 78.
- "Today we live trailer." on YouTube Retrieved: September 18, 2012.
- Swindell 1980, p. 157.
- Meyer 1998, p. 92
- Chandler 2009, p. 135.
- Brett 2008, p. 79.
- "Notes: Today We Live." Turner Classic Movies. Retrieved: September 18, 2012.
- McCarthy 2000, p. 184.
- McCarthy 2000, pp. 184-185.
- McCarthy 2000, p. 185.
- LoBianco, Lorraine. "Articles: Today We Live." Turner Classic Movies. Retrieved: September 18, 2012.
- Hall, Mourdant. "Today We Live (1933), Joan Crawford and Gary Cooper in the first picture derived from a story by William Faulkner." The New York Times, April 15, 1933. Retrieved: September 18, 2012.
- Evans 2000, p. 185.
- Bret, David. Joan Crawford: Hollywood Martyr. New York: Da Capo Press, 2008. ISBN 978-0-30681-624-6.
- Chandler, Charlotte. Not the Girl Next Door: Joan Crawford: a Personal Biography. New York: Pocket Books, 2009. ISBN 978-1-84739-229-9.
- Evans, Alun. Brassey's Guide to War Films. Dulles, Virginia: Potomac Books, 2000. ISBN 1-57488-263-5.
- McCarthy, Todd. Howard Hawks: The Grey Fox of Hollywood'. Grove Press, 2000, First edition 1997. ISBN 978-080213-740-1.
- Meyer, Jeffrey. Gary Cooper: American Hero. New York: William Morrow, 1998. ISBN 978-0-688-15494-3.
- Phillips, Gene D. Fiction, Film, and Faulkner: The Art of Adaptation. Knoxville, Tennessee: University of Tennessee Press, 2001. ISBN 978-1-57233-166-2.
- Quirk, Lawrence J. and William Schoell. Joan Crawford: The Essential Biography. Lexington, Kentucky: The University Press of Kentucky, 2002. ISBN 978-0-81312-254-0.
- Swindell, Larry. The Last Hero: A Biography of Gary Cooper. New York: Doubleday, 1980. ISBN 0-385-14316-8.
- Thompson, Davis. Gary Cooper (Great Stars). New York: Faber & Faber, 2010. ISBN 978-0-8654-7932-6.
- Today We Live at the Internet Movie Database
- Today We Live at the TCM Movie Database
- Today We Live at AllMovie