The Tigers have made 10 NCAA tournaments. In 1991, they recorded their first victory, defeating Virginia, 14–13. That season, they went on to also defeat Princeton and Maryland, before falling to North Carolina in the championship game, 18–13. In the 2001 edition of the tournament, Towson reached the semifinals, defeating Duke and Maryland, before losing to Princeton, 11–12. Their most recent tournament appearance came in 2013, where they lost 16–6 to Ohio State.