Uğur Mumcu

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Uğur Mumcu
Ugur Mumcu Cumhuriyet 24cu01.jpg
Born (1942-08-22)22 August 1942
Kırşehir
Died 24 January 1993(1993-01-24) (aged 50)
Ankara
Notable credit(s) editorial opinion columnist and investigative journalist in Cumhuriyet

Uğur Mumcu (pronounced [uɰuɾ ˈmumdʒu]; 22 August 1942 – 24 January 1993)[1] was a Turkish investigative journalist for the leading daily Cumhuriyet. He was assassinated by a bomb placed in his car outside his home.[1]

Biography[edit]

Uğur Mumcu was born the third of four siblings in Kırşehir. He went to school in Ankara and in 1961 attended School of Law at Ankara University.[1] Graduating in 1965 he initially began his career practicing law.In 1969 he ended his legal career to return to his alma mater; working as a teaching assistant until 1972.

He started to write during university, first in the magazine Yön and then in several other leftist periodicals. Between 1968 and 1970, he wrote articles on politics for the newspapers Akşam, Cumhuriyet and Milliyet.[citation needed]

Arrested shortly after the 1971 military coup, he was tortured. Later, Mumcu wrote that his torturers had told him: "We are the Counter-Guerrilla. Even the President of the Republic cannot touch us."[2]

In 1974, Uğur Mumcu started a career as a columnist,[1] with the periodical Yeni Ortam and from 1975 on, in the dailyCumhuriyet, which he continued until his death.

Research[edit]

Uğur Mumcu published books on current and historical political issues of Turkey. He was investigating the Kurdistan Workers' Party's ties with the National Intelligence Organization (MİT) at the time of his assassination.[3][4][5]

Shortly before his death, Mumcu was investigating how 100,000 firearms owned by the Turkish Armed Forces had ended up in the possession of Jalal Talabani, one of the Kurdish leaders of northern Iraq and, as of 2008, president of Iraq. Twenty-five days after the death of Mumcu, General Eşref Bitlis, who had been investigating the same issue, died in a plane crash, believed to be due to sabotage.[4] In his 8 January Cumhuriyet article, titled Ültimatom, Mumcu emphatically stated that he would soon reveal in a new book the ties between Kurdish nationalists and some intelligence organizations (i.e., Abdullah Öcalan and the National Intelligence Organization).[6]

According to his son, Özgür, Mumcu had an appointment with retired prosecutor Baki Tuğ on 27 January to learn more about Abdullah Öcalan's suspected ties with the MİT (the state was officially fighting his militant organization, the PKK).[7] Öcalan was detained on 31 March 1972 while studying political sciences at the University of Ankara. Per clause 16/1 of the Martial Law (№ 1402), he was sentenced to three months in jail for participating in a boycott. He was released on 24 October 1972 after the National Intelligence Organization forwarded a message to the prosecutor handling the case, Tuğ, that one of the suspects was one of their agents. Tuğ later said that he could not remember whether the agent was Öcalan, or one of the other suspects.[8]

Assassination[edit]

On the morning of 24 January 1993, Mumcu left his home and was killed by a C-4 plastic bomb as he started his car, a Renault 12, license numbered 06 YR 245.[8]

There are numerous hypotheses over who was responsible for his murder. Given the various links (at organizational and personal level) between the Turkish deep state and Turkish armed forces, Counter-Guerrilla, Kurdish forces and the CIA and Mossad, the hypotheses are not necessarily mutually exclusive, especially as Mumcu was investigating some of these links.

Deep state hypothesis[edit]

One hypothesis is that he was killed to protect state secrets regarding the PKK.[9] PKK supreme council member Mustafa Karasu alleged that Mumcu was killed by the state in order to prevent his publicizing the fact that the PKK was aware it had been infiltrated by the MİT. The mole was Öcalan's pilot, Necati. Karasu alleges that they became aware of his MİT identity in May 1997, and misinformed him.[10]

The deep state might have contracted the killing out to JITEM (see below).

Iran hypothesis[edit]

His assassination was initially pinned on Iran.[6][11] According to this hypothesis, Iran's SAVAMA employed the virtually unknown Islamic Movement Organisation (Turkish: İslami Hareket Örgütü) to carry out the assassination. Mehmet Ali Şeker, Mehmet Zeki Yıldırım, and Ayhan Usta were taken into custody. However, it was revealed that the police had falsified the date of their capture.[12] The İstanbul police had been conducting an operation targeting Islamist organizations, just before the attack. Its intelligence chief, Hanefi Avcı, said that the attackers left no trace of their affiliation. Rather, they seemed to have been well trained—by a state.[13]

During the course of the investigation, voluminous documents relating SAVAMA to the Kurdish Hezbollah were found. In addition, the Ankara police detained three suspects who were found to have stayed at a hotel in Ankara before the attack: Yusuf Karakuş, Abdülhamit Çelik, and Mehmet Şahin. Karakuş said that two Iranian spies were involved in the bombing: Muhammed Reza and Muhsin Karger Azad.[14] Çelik, a.k.a. "Abdullah Gürgen", said he reported to Muhsin Karger Azad.[15] Azad was ostensibly a consulate employee, but secretly an alleged Gladio member.[16][17] Azad left Turkey after he was "named and shamed" in the newspapers along with other diplomats alleged to be spies.[18]

Former Interior Minister Hasan Fehmi Güneş said that there was no doubt in his mind as to SAVAMA's involvement.[19]

The alleged motivation for the Iran hypothesis is that Iran's leaders saw secularism as inimical to Islam, and Mumcu had to be killed because he was an outspoken promoter of it.[20] However, others dispute the Iran hypothesis as the assassination coincided with a state visit from Iran to negotiate the passage of a natural gas pipeline from Iran, which was then subject to an embargo by the United States.[21] Tensions flared after the assassination, and the $25 billion pipeline deal fell through.[6]

CIA hypothesis[edit]

In an earlier investigation, Mumcu had been on the CIA's trail. Working on the Mehmet Ali Ağca case, he was the first to discover the connection between the Turkish mafia and the Turkish extreme right.[22] In his Cumhuriyet column, Mumcu named Ruzi Nazar — who was a Turkoman born near Tashkent who had deserted the Red Army to join the Nazis during World War II in order to fight on the Eastern Front for the creation of a Turkistan. Nazar is father of Sylvia Nasar, a German-born American journalist, known for her biography of John Forbes Nash, A Beautiful Mind. — as the CIA's liaison with the far-right Grey Wolves.[23] The CIA's Turkey station chief, Paul Henze, and an American reporter accosted Mumcu to convince him to write that the Pope's assassin worked for Soviets or the Bulgarians, but Mumcu said he would simply follow the information trail. Henze left with an ominous "If you do that, you might find a nice surprise in store", according to his wife, Guldal.[24][25]

JITEM hypothesis[edit]

Abdülkadir Aygan, a JITEM informant from PKK, said that the assassination was carried out by JITEM operatives including Cem Ersever at the behest of General Veli Küçük, who is currently being tried for allegedly being a high-ranking member of the Ergenekon network.[26] Aygan said that he and Aytekin Özen had a briefcase of about 20 kg of C-4 (explosive), obtained from a Vietnam veteran, and that they had used some of it to assassinate the President of the Diyarbakir Bar, Mustafa Özer. The unnamed American soldier had allegedly given the explosives to the Regional Emergency Governorate (Turkish: Olağanüstü Hal Bölge Valiliği) in 1991 or 1992.[27]

A confidential forensic report, dated 29 January 1993, was prepared by the chief of the Criminal Police Laboratory, Muhittin Kaya. It wrote that the plastic explosive weighed approximately 2.5 kg and contained RDX, as used in C-4s. However, it contradicted itself in explaining its origin, saying Czechoslovakia in the body, and the United States in the appendix.[8]

MOSSAD hypothesis[edit]

Uğur Mumcu's brother, Ceyhan Mumcu, finds the evidence for the JITEM/Ergenekon allegations weak. He suspects Israel's involvement since it supported Barzani and Talabani in the Gulf War.[28] Israel's ambassador to Turkey had repeatedly requested to have lunch with Uğur, the only journalist to write about the dealings. Uğur agreed on condition that he be allowed to bring a witness. The ambassador rejected the offer, and Mumcu died shortly thereafter.[6]

Ceyhan Mumcu said his suspicions were supported by evidence uncovered in the Ergenekon investigation.[29] A report seized from retired General Veli Küçük, dated 2 February 1993 and purportedly emanating from the MİT, says that the CIA and Israel's OADNA were involved.[30]

Personal life[edit]

Uğur Mumcu was survived by his wife Güldal, and their children Özgür and Özge Mumcu. Güldal Mumcu and her children established the Uğur Mumcu Investigative Journalism Foundation (um:ag, Turkish: Uğur Mumcu Araştırmacı Gazetecilik Vakfı) in October 1994.[1] Güldal Mumcu is currently a member and the deputy speaker of the Turkish parliament.

Bibliography[edit]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ a b c d e About um:ag
  2. ^ Lucy Komisar, Turkey's terrorists: a CIA legacy lives on, The Progressive, April 1997.
  3. ^ Aydin, Zulfikar Ali (27 July 2008). "PKK-MİT ilişkisini yazamadan öldürüldü". Sabah (in Turkish). Retrieved 19 December 2008. 
  4. ^ a b Ergenekon linked to Mumcu murder, Today's Zaman, 5 August 2008
  5. ^ Duzel, Nese (29 May 2006). "Mumcu, Apo'nun devletteki bağlantısını buldu". Radikal (in Turkish). Retrieved 18 December 2008. It was reported by press that Mumucu was killed due to his discovery of the relation between MIT and Abdullah Ocalan.  |chapter= ignored (help)
  6. ^ a b c d Mumcu: "Yakında yayımlanacak bir kitabımda, Kürt milliyetçileri ile istihbarat örgütleri arasındaki ilişkilere ışık tutacak çok ilginç belgeler açıklayacağım!" Quoted in Kumbasar, İsrafil K (2006-05-26). "Uğur Mumcu, kendisini dört kez çağıran İsrail Sefiri ile ne konuştu?". Yeni Çağ (in Turkish). Archived from the original on 2006-05-26. 
  7. ^ Alpman, Nazım (24 January 1999). "Babam bir şeylere ulaşmıştı". Milliyet (in Turkish). 
  8. ^ a b c İşleyen, Ercüment (1999-01-24). "Artık konuşun". Milliyet (in Turkish). O tür bir olay hatırlıyorum. Ancak Apo'yla mı ilgiliydi, başka bir mensupla mı ilgili onu çözemedik. Sayın Mumcu'ya da söylediğim şuydu: Bana böyle birşey gelmişti. Onunla ilgili mi değil mi bende resmi yazı olacak, dedim. O yazıyı ararken o olay oldu. Gelen yazı `dokunmayın' mealinde değil `bizim mensubumuzdur' şeklindeydi. Aradığım belge oydu. Belgede bir şahıs ismi var. MİT hesabına çalışan bir sanığın ismi. O belgeyi arıyorum. Onu bulursak Mumcu'nun aradığı düğüm çözülecek. 
  9. ^ "28 Şubat'la ilgili iddialar var". Sabah (in Turkish). 27 July 2008. Retrieved 19 December 2008. Oğuztan, Mumcu'nun yanı sıra Jandarma Genel Komutanı Orgeneral Eşref Bitlis ve JİTEM Komutanı emekli binbaşı Ahmet Cem Ersever'in devlet sırrının ortaya çıkmaması için öldürüldüklerini iddia etti. 
  10. ^ Ergenc, Erdinç (30 July 2008). "MİT ajanının sızdığını PKK'lılar da kabul etti". Sabah (in Turkish). Retrieved 28 December 2008. 
  11. ^ Kumbasar, İsrafil K (25 May 2006). "Uğur Mumcu’nun bombalanmasına neden olan yazı". Yeni Çağ (in Turkish). Archived from the original on 26 May 2006. CIA ve MOSSAD’ın Türkiye ile İran arasında uyuşmazlık çıkarabilmek için ülkemizde birtakım cinayetler işleteceği, sorumluğunu İran üzerine atmaya çalışacağı yaygın bir söylentidir. Bu söylenti, istihbarat kaynaklarına dayandığını söyleyen bir yuttaşımız tarafından bana da bildirildi. Bu senaryoyu daha önce de yaşadık. Uğur’un ölümüne neden olan yazıyı okumanızı ve sonraki gelişmeleri yeniden incelemenizi tavsiye ediyorum. 
  12. ^ Ekşi, Oktay (27 December 2008). "Mumcu cinayeti aydınlanırken". Hürriyet (in Turkish). Retrieved 27 December 2008. 
  13. ^ Akyol, Fuat (22 January 2000). "Hangı Hızbullah?". Aksiyon Dergisi (in Turkish) (Feza Gazetecilik A.Ş.) 268. Retrieved 5 November 2008. İslami Hareket Örgütü üyeleri çok profesyoneldi. Örgüt görevlisinden çok devletçe eğitilmiş kişiler görünümündeydiler. Kendilerine İslami Hareket denildiğinde bunu kabul ettiler ve ‘Siz söylediniz, biz kabul ettik’ dediler. İslami Hareket diye bir bildiri, dergi, afiş ve benzeri örgüt simge ve uzuvları yoktu. Bu bir örgüt değil gruptu, ancak kimin adına çalıştığı belirlenmeden grup söndü. [dead link]
  14. ^ "Mumcu zanlıları itirafa başladı". NTV-MSNBC (in Turkish). 10 May 2000. Retrieved 27 December 2008. 
  15. ^ Zelyut, Rıza (5 December 2008). "Muhsin Karger Azad". Güneş (in Turkish). Retrieved 27 December 2008. 
  16. ^ Ocak, Serkan (29 December 2008). "Oğuztan: Eymür, Tuncay Güney’e emir veriyordu". Radikal. Retrieved 27 December 2008. Güney, İran Konsolosluğu siyasi işler müsteşarı Muhsin Karger’le tanışıp dostluk kurduğunu ve doğrudan Mehmet Eymür’e bilgi ve fotoğraflar aktardığını, Karger’in İran’da MOD adıyla anılan gladyo mensubu olduğunu bizzat şahsıma anlatmıştır.  |chapter= ignored (help)
  17. ^ "19. DOGU PERINÇEK". TBMM Susurluk Komisyonu Raporu (in Turkish). 26 December 1996. Retrieved 17 December 2008. Ugur MUMCU'nun öldürülmesinde Iran'in MOD adli yeralti kurulusunun önemli rolü bulundugunu, MOD'u ABD'nin büyük ölçüde kontrol ettigini, eroin isine girdigini ve içinde Sah döneminden kalma SAVAK ajanlarinin çalistigini, Lazim ESMAELI ve Asgar SIMITKOV'u öldüren Iranlilarin da bu örgütten olduklarini, Iran Disisleri Bakani Mumcu suikastinden sonra Türkiye'ye geldiginde konunun sorulmasi üzerine 'Biz, 25 milyar dolari kapsayan bir dogalgaz ve petrol anlasmasi yapmak için Türkiye'ye geliyoruz, tam geldigimizden bir gün önce böyle bir suikast yapip Türkiye ile iliskilerimizi berhava etmenin hangi mantiga sigdigini açiklamak lazim' dedigini ve kendilerinin de bunun dogru oldugu kanisinda olduklarini, burada Iran'in bir çikari olmadigini, ABD'nin raporlarinda 'Kemalizmin modasi geçti, Türkiye'ye ilimli Islam gerekli, Türkiye'nin kimligi ilimli Islam olmali' dendigini, bizim kültürel kimligimizi Amerika'nin belirledigini ve bunun da 'Ilimli Islam' oldugunu, bu sebeple Amerika'nin, Kemalizmin bugünkü temsilcileri ve savunuculari olan Ugur MUMCU, Bahriye ÜÇOK ve Muammer AKSOY'u öldürterek Kemalizmi savunanlara gözdagi operasyonu yürüttügünü,… 
  18. ^ Bakacak, Mustafa (10 May 2000). "‘Ajanım’ dedi bıraktılar". Milliyet (in Turkish). Retrieved 27 December 2008. 
  19. ^ Kilic, Ecevit; Emec, Ali Selim (25–31 January 2007). "Kafatasçı cinayetlerde Özel Harp Dairesi'nin rolü tartışılsın". Yeni Aktüel (in Turkish) 81. Retrieved 2008-12-22. Evet. İran istihbarat örgütünü kastediyorum... planlamanın nereden yapıldığı konusunda kafamda bir tereddüt yok. 
  20. ^ Zelyut, Rıza (12 May 2000). "Muhsin Karger Azad'ı tanımıştım". Akşam (in Turkish). Retrieved 28 December 2008. İran, Uğur Mumcu'yu öldürtmüş olabilir mi? Olabilir...Çünkü, bu ülkenin temel çalışmasını 'İslam devrimini ihraç etmek' oluşturuyor. Hatırlayacaksınız. 1997 yılında, İran'ın en üst düzey ayetullahları ile konuşmuş ve bunu da yayımlamıştım. İranlı ayetullahlar, Türkiye'yi Amerikan güdümünde dinsiz bir memleket gibi görüyor. [dead link]
  21. ^ Söylemez, Haşim (11 August 2008). "Eşref Bitlis ile Cem Ersever'i aynı ekip öldürdü". Aksiyon (in Turkish) 714 (Feza Gazetecilik A.Ş.). Archived from the original on 22 August 2008. Retrieved 23 December 2008. Mumcu’nun İran istihbaratının yardımıyla öldürülmüş olması mantıklı değil. 
  22. ^ Saéz, Jesús López (2005). "8. PAPAL ATTEMPT, STATE´s SECRET". The Day of Reckoning. Meral Ediciones. ISBN 84-933979-2-X. Retrieved 16 October 2008. 
  23. ^ Keskingören, Tuğrul (31 May 2008). "Ruzi Nazar ile Röportaj". Açık İstihbarat (in Turkish). Retrieved 16 October 2008. Tabi Turkiye'de Uğur Mumcu gibi yazarlar bu olayi bizim uzerimize yikmaya calistilar ve benim hakkimda Cumhuriyet gazetesinde haber yaptilar. 
  24. ^ Kirikkanat, Mine G (25 January 1999). "Gerçeğin çaresizliği". Radikal (in Turkish). Retrieved 16 October 2008. Uğur Mumcu'nun Mehmet Ali Ağca dosyası üzerinde çalıştığı günlerde kapı çalınmış, içeri kapı komşuluğuna gelir gibi Paul Henze girmişti. Henze, deneyimli gazeteciye, Ağca'nın Rus ya da Bulgar ajanı olduğunu yazmasını önerdi. Mumcu, CIA'nın önerisini: 'Ben bulduğum gerçekleri yazarım, söyleneni değil,' diye geri çevirince, Henze'nin yanıtı Uğur Mumcu'ya bir süre sonra öldürüleceğini ihtar eder gibiydi: 'Eğer böyle yaparsanız, sizi güzel sürprizler bekler!' 
  25. ^ Bortaçina, Azer (24 January 1999). "Namus borcu ödenmedi". Milliyet (in Turkish). Retrieved 16 October 2008. 
  26. ^ "Charges reveal killer face of suspects". Today's Zaman. 26 July 2008. Retrieved 5 November 2008. 
  27. ^ Unlu, Ferhat (25 August 2008). "Mumcu'yu öldüren C-4 ABD'li eski askerden". Sabah (in Turkish). Retrieved 27 August 2008. Ersever'in valizinde yaklaşık 20 kilo C-4 olduğunu gözlerimle gördüm. Bu patlayıcıları 1991 ya da 92'de Vietnam gazisi bir Amerikalı adam Olağanüstü Hal Bölge Valiliği'ne vermişti. Ersever de patlayıcıları oradan aldı. [dead link]
  28. ^ "MİT belgesi gerçek, kardeşimi İsrail öldürdü". Zaman (in Turkish). 12 August 2008. Retrieved 27 August 2008. 
  29. ^ On pages 826 and 827 of the Ergenekon indictment (Turkish)
  30. ^ "Uğur Mumcu'yu İsrail suikast timi öldürdü". Yeni Şafak (in Turkish). ANKA. 26 July 2008. Retrieved 13 October 2008. 

Further reading[edit]