United (2011 film)
Titlescreen, featuring the Manchester United home changing rooms.
|Directed by||James Strong|
|Produced by||Julia Stannard|
|Written by||Chris Chibnall|
|Music by||Clint Mansell|
|Original channel||BBC Two / BBC HD|
|Running time||90 minutes|
United is a British television film directed by James Strong and written by Chris Chibnall. It is based on the true story of Manchester United's "Busby Babes" and the aftermath of the 1958 Munich air disaster, with the film's events taking place between August 1956 and May 1958. In particular, the film focuses on the experiences of assistant manager Jimmy Murphy, played by David Tennant, and Bobby Charlton, played by Jack O'Connell.
Largely filmed around the North East of England, the film was first broadcast on 24 April 2011 on BBC Two and BBC HD, but is being sold internationally as a theatrical picture by Content Media Corp. The series gained a 14.3% rating in its time slot and was generally well received by television critics.
The drama primarily focuses on the relationship between assistant manager Jimmy Murphy and the young player Bobby Charlton. The film begins in the autumn of 1956 as Murphy gives Charlton his first chance to play a match with Manchester United's first team, nicknamed the "Busby Babes" due to their unique pedigree as an almost entirely club-nurtured team of players, with the exception of a few slightly older players who have been purchased from other clubs.
The other players to come through the ranks and who feature greatly in the film include centre-half Mark Jones, left-half Duncan Edwards and right-half Eddie Colman. A rare signing is then made when Busby signs Northern Irish goalkeeper Harry Gregg in late 1957.
Meanwhile, manager Matt Busby has persuaded Football League administrator Alan Hardaker to allow his team to play in the European Cup with the proviso that they are back in time for each scheduled fixture. They first compete for this title in the 1956-57 campaign after winning the league title, and are able to compete in the cup again the following season after retaining their domestic title.
The team sees success both at home and abroad. However, on the return flight from a European Cup match in Belgrade, their aeroplane crashes attempting to take off after refuelling in Munich, and seven of the club's players (including Mark Jones and Eddie Colman) are killed. Harry Gregg is instrumental in saving survivors from the wreckage of the plane, while Bobby Charlton suffers minor injuries, but Duncan Edwards and Matt Busby are seriously injured.
Charlton is allowed to leave the hospital and return to England within a week, but Edwards and Busby remain in a critical condition at this stage. Jimmy Murphy was not on the plane when it crashed due to his duties with the Welsh national side, but flies out as soon as he can in order to visit his injured colleagues in hospital and travel home with Charlton.
Two weeks after the crash, Duncan Edwards dies in hospital, heaping fresh devastation on Bobby Charlton, who is ready to give up football until he has a visit from Jimmy Murphy and is soon playing for United again.
Against the odds, Murphy vows to present a team to play their next home game and, ultimately, the 1958 FA Cup Final, taking charge of the first team until the following season as Busby recovers from his injuries.
- David Tennant as Jimmy Murphy
- Jack O'Connell as Bobby Charlton
- Sam Claflin as Duncan Edwards
- Dougray Scott as Matt Busby
- Dean Andrews as Bert Whalley
- Kate Ashfield as Alma George
- David Calder as Harold Hardman
- Neil Dudgeon as Alan Hardaker
- Tim Healy as Tommy Skinner
- Melanie Hill as Cissie Charlton
- Philip Hill-Pearson as Eddie Colman
- Thomas Howes as Mark Jones
- Ben Peel as Harry Gregg
- Brogan West as David Pegg
The film was produced by World Productions with a budget of £2 million ($3.2 million). In writing his script, Chris Chibnall drew on first-hand interviews with the survivors and their families. It was shot in November and December 2010 in the north of England including the Tyneside Cinema, Tynemouth Metro Station, Newcastle Civic Centre and the Assembly Rooms. Brunton Park in Carlisle doubled for the inside of Old Trafford in the 1950s. The shoot took four six-day weeks of filming and was hindered by heavy snowfall in December; one extra day cost the production £30,000 because the project was not insured against inclement weather conditions.
In recreating the crash, it was felt it would be appropriate to see events unfold through Charlton's eyes. Jack O'Connell stated that it had a dream-like quality. "It has a lethargic feel. So it doesn't necessarily seem like reality. There's a hazy sense about it." Dougray Scott stated "We filmed the scene [of the crash] on a military base up in Newcastle...There were some people sitting in seats without a scratch on them, dead, others without a scratch on them alive, some with terrible injuries and dead. It was an emotional part of the shoot."
Ratings and critical reception
Sandy Busby, the son of Matt Busby, said he thought the film was "very poorly done" stating that he was disappointed that the Busby family hadn't been contacted about the film, pointing out the drama is about the "Busby Babes". He went on to state he was "disgusted" with the portrayal of his father and critical about the omission of some players from the film; "Why didn't they include other players that died and were injured in the crash? If I was one of their family I would be very upset." In particular, he criticised film's portrayal of his father, which he thought made him look like a gangster; "I was disgusted with the portrayal of my father. He had this camel coat on, and a fedora, and all through the film he was never seen in a tracksuit. He was known as probably the first tracksuit manager at that time. I was disgusted."
Television reviews such as Gerard Gilbert in The Independent also noted a gangster-like appearance in Busby's costume, and suggested that painting Alan Hardaker as the villain seemed tame; "compared to Jimmy McGovern's Hillsborough, with its burning righteous anger aimed at the police and The Sun, Hardaker seemed like a flimsy scapegoat for what, au fond, was an appalling accident."
Jim White, writing for The Telegraph was more positive stating "United...is brilliant in its evocation of the pipe-puffing Fifties football orbit...the CGI evocation of immediate post-war Old Trafford, with the smokestacks brooding above the open terraces, looks more authentic than the real thing...David Tennant's performance as the central character should alert every award-giving body."
Centre-half Mark Jones was portrayed as United's captain in the film, when in real life the captain of the team was Roger Byrne, who also died in the disaster and was not credited in the film. Indeed, just six of the 17 players involved in the crash were credited in the film.
Sam Wollaston in The Guardian commended the smaller period details, stating "There are lots of nice little differences between football then and football now. Can you imagine any of today's lot feeling that kind of connection not just with the club but with the whole area? Or living with a landlady? Or telling a girl they were a plumber because plumbers had better prospects than footballers? Or smoking a pipe on the way out of the tunnel, as team captain Mark Jones did? Lovely...But, of course, at the heart of Chris Chibnall's poignant drama is the tragedy that claimed eight of the Busby Babes. It's beautifully done – powerful, haunting and very human. And if you didn't shed a tear, then you're harder than I am."
- "BBC Two Programmes - United". BBC. April 2011. Retrieved 17 April 2011.
- Kemp, Stuart (21 April 2011). "Why 'Doctor Who' Vet David Tennant Signed Up for 'United'". The Hollywood Reporter. Retrieved 22 April 2011.
- Wylie, Ian (6 April 2011). "TV drama United to tell story of Busby Babes". Manchester Evening News. Retrieved 17 April 2011.
- "United press pack". BBC. 7 April 2011. Retrieved 17 April 2011.
- "Northern Film & Media and Northstar Ventures sign for United". Northern Film + Media. 2 December 2010. Retrieved 17 April 2011.
- "Clint Mansell’s United Score released". Film Music Reporter. 24 April 2011. Retrieved 25 April 2011.
- "Clint Mansell Scoring United". Film Music Reporter. 29 March 2011. Retrieved 17 April 2011.
- Overnight dailies, 24 April 2011, television-ratings.info
- "Sir Matt Busby's son 'disgusted' at United TV film". BBC. 24 April 2011. Retrieved 25 April 2011.
- "Sir Matt Busby's family incensed over TV portrayal of iconic Manchester United manager". Daily Telegraph. 24 April 2011. Retrieved 24 April 2011.
- "The Weekend's TV: United, Sun, BBC2". The Independent. 24 April 2011. Retrieved 24 April 2011.
- "Jim White: Jimmy Murphy's central part in the resurrection of Manchester United is the key reason to watch United". Daily Telegraph. 22 April 2011. Retrieved 22 April 2011.
- "TV review: Doctor Who; United". The Guardian. 24 April 2011. Retrieved 24 April 2011.
- "Prix Europa 2011: Nominees". Prix Europa. Retrieved 16 September 2011.