United Kingdom and the euro

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
eurozone participation
  European Union member states (eurozone) – 18
  European Union member state in ERM II scheduled to join on 1 January 2015 – Lithuania
  European Union member states not in ERM II but obliged to join – 7
  European Union member state in ERM II with an opt-outDenmark
  European Union member state not in ERM II with an opt-out – United Kingdom
  non-European Union member states using the euro with a monetary agreement – 4
  non-European Union member states using the euro unilaterally – 2

The United Kingdom's currency is the pound sterling and it has not declared plans to adopt the euro in the foreseeable future. The UK negotiated an opt-out from the part of the Maastricht Treaty that would have required it to adopt the common currency, and the coalition government elected in May 2010 pledged not to join the euro for the lifetime of the parliament.[1]

British public opinion has consistently opposed joining the euro. Opinion polls in 2005 (57 percent opposed),[2] 11–12 December 2008 (59 percent opposed)[3] and 6–8 January 2009 (64 percent saying they would vote no to a change of currency)[4] demonstrate this opposition. In a poll taken for BBC Radio 4 between 19–21 December 2008, 71% of respondents said they would vote No while 23% of participants would vote Yes, and 6% were undecided. The economic recession in Britain and the fall in value of the pound have not contributed to a change in public opinion.[5] A poll conducted in early May 2009, showed increased opposition, with 75% of respondents pledging to vote against joining the euro.[6] However, an April 2010 YouGov poll, the percentage of those not wanting to join the euro decreased by 10%, the percentage of those wanting to join the euro decreased by 2% and the percentage of those unsure increased by 12%, compared with the ICM poll in the previous year. However two polls in 2011 found over 80% of respondents to be against joining the Euro.

History[edit]

The government of former Prime Minister Tony Blair declared that "five economic tests" must be passed before the government could recommend the UK joining the euro and promised to hold a referendum on membership if those five economic tests were met. The UK would also have to meet the EU's economic convergence criteria (Maastricht criteria), before being allowed to adopt the euro. Currently, the UK's annual government deficit to the GDP is above the defined threshold. The government committed itself to a triple-approval procedure before joining the Eurozone, involving approval by the Cabinet, Parliament, and the electorate in a referendum.

Gordon Brown, Blair's successor, ruled out membership in 2007, saying that the decision not to join had been right for Britain and for Europe.[7]

In the UK general election 2010, the Liberal Democrats increased their share of the vote, but lost seats. One of their aims was to see the UK rejoining ERM II and eventually joining the Euro, but when a coalition was formed between the Liberal Democrats and the Conservatives, the Liberal Democrats agreed that the UK would not join the euro during this term of government.

Economics[edit]

An assessment of British membership based on five economic tests was published on 9 June 2003 by Gordon Brown, when he was Chancellor of the Exchequer. Though maintaining the government's positive view on the euro, the report opposed membership because four out of the five tests were not passed. However, the 2003 document also noted the considerable progress of the UK towards satisfying the five tests since 1997, and the desirability of making policy decisions to adapt the UK economy to better satisfy the tests in future. It cited considerable long-term benefits to be gained from eventual, prudently conducted EMU membership.

Some believe that removing the United Kingdom's ability to set its own interest rates would have detrimental effects on its economy. One argument is that currency flexibility is a vital tool and that the sharp devaluation of sterling in 2008 was just what Britain needed to rebalance its economy.[8] Another objection is that many continental European governments have large unfunded pension liabilities. They fear that if Britain adopts the euro, these liabilities could put a debt burden on the British taxpayer,[9] though others have dismissed this argument as spurious.[10]

Some argue that as intra-European exports are 60% of the UK's total exports, a single currency would enhance the Internal Market by reducing the cost of exchanging currency for businesses and travellers, and reducing currency risk.[11] An interesting parallel can be seen in the 19th century discussions concerning the possibility of the UK joining the Latin Monetary Union.[12]

The entry of the UK into the Eurozone would likely have a positive effect on trade with the other members of the Eurozone.[13] It could also have a stabilising effect on the stock market prices in the UK.[14] A simulation of the entry in 1999 found that it would have had an overall positive, though small, effect in the long term on the UK GDP if the entry had been made with the rate of exchange of the pound to the euro at that time. With a lower rate of exchange, the entry would have had more clearly a positive effect on the UK GDP.[15] A 2009 study about the effect of an entry in the coming years found that the effect would likely be positive, improving the stability for the UK economy.[16]

In June 2003, Gordon Brown stated that the best exchange rate for the UK to join the euro would be around 73 pence per euro.[17] (On 26 May 2003 the Euro had reached 72.100, a value not exceeded until 21 December 2007).[18] The euro rose above 80 pence in 2008 and peaked at 97.855p on 29 December 2008.[19] With the impact of the Global financial crisis of 2008 on the British economy: failing banks, plunging UK property values and the pound at 85.98p against the euro on 19 November 2008,[20] some British analysts stated that adopting the euro was far preferable to any other possible solutions for Britain's economic problems.[21] On 29 December 2008, the BBC reported that the euro had reached roughly 97.7p, due to poorer economic forecasts. This report stated that many analysts believed that parity with the euro was only a matter of time.[22]

During 2009, the value of the euro against the pound fluctuated between 96.100p on 2 January and 84.255p on 22 June. In 2010 the value of the euro against the pound fluctuated between 91.140p on 10 March and 81.040p on 29 June. On 31 December 2010 the euro closed at 86.075p.[23] The weakness and the volatility of the pound have raised concerns for the costs it entails for British consumers at home,[24][25] and Britons living[26] or travelling abroad.[27] On the other hand, a report in Britain's Daily Telegraph has argued that the high euro has caused problems in the eurozone outside Germany. The Liberal Democrats have expressed interest in seeing Britain join the euro in the long term.[28]

Convergence criteria[edit]

Aside from approval in a domestic referendum, the UK would be required to meet the euro convergence criteria before being granted approval to adopt the euro. As of the last report by the European Central Bank in May 2012, the UK only met 1 of 5 of the criteria.


Convergence criteria
Assessment month Country HICP inflation rate[29][nb 1] Excessive deficit procedure[30] Budget deficit to GDP[31] Debt-to-GDP ratio Exchange rate Long-term interest rate[32][nb 2]
ERM II member[33] Change in rate[34][35][nb 3]
2012 ECB Report[nb 4] Reference values max. 3.1%[nb 5]
(as of 31 Mar 2012)
None open
(as of 31 March 2012)
max. 3.0%
(Fiscal year 2011)[37]
max. 60%
(Fiscal year 2011)[37]
min. 2 years
(as of 31 Mar 2012)
max. ±15%[nb 6]
(for 2011)
max. 5.80%[nb 7]
(as of 31 Mar 2012)
 United Kingdom 4.3% Open 8.3% 85% No -1.2% 2.49%
2013 ECB Report[nb 8] Reference values max. 2.7%[nb 9]
(as of 30 Apr 2013)
None open
(as of 30 Apr 2013)
max. 3.0%
(Fiscal year 2012)[39]
max. 60%
(Fiscal year 2012)[39]
min. 2 years
(as of 30 Apr 2013)
max. ±15%[nb 6]
(for 2012)
max. 5.5%[nb 9]
(as of 30 Apr 2013)
 United Kingdom 2.6% Open 6.3% 90.0% No 6.6% 1.62%
2014 ECB Report[nb 10] Reference values max. 1.7%[nb 11]
(as of 30 Apr 2014)
None open
(as of 30 Apr 2014)
max. 3.0%
(Fiscal year 2013)[41]
max. 60%
(Fiscal year 2013)[41]
min. 2 years
(as of 30 Apr 2014)
max. ±15%[nb 6]
(for 2013)
max. 6.2%[nb 11]
(as of 30 Apr 2014)
 United Kingdom 2.2% Open 5.8% 90.6% No -4.7% 2.25%


  Criterion fulfilled
  Criterion potentially fulfilled: If the budget deficit exceeds the 3% limit, but is "close" to this value (the European Commission has deemed 3.5% to be close by in the past),[42] then the criteria can still potentially be fulfilled if either the deficits in the previous two years are significantly declining towards the 3% limit, or if the excessive deficit is the result of exceptional circumstances which are temporary in nature (i.e. one-off expenditures triggered by a significant economic downturn, or by the implementation of economic reforms that are expected to deliver a significant positive impact on the government's future fiscal budgets). However, even if such "special circumstances" are found to exist, additional criteria must also be met to comply with the fiscal budget criterion.[43][44] Additionally, if the debt-to-GDP ratio exceeds 60% but is "sufficiently diminishing and approaching the reference value at a satisfactory pace" it can be deemed to be in compliance.[45]
  Criterion not fulfilled


Notes
  1. ^ The 12-months average for the annual HICP inflation rate must be no more than 1.5% larger than the unweighted arithmetic average of the similar HICP inflation rates in the 3 EU member states with the lowest HICP inflation. If any of these 3 states have a HICP rate significantly below the similarly averaged HICP rate for the eurozone (which according to ECB practice means more than 2% below), and if this low HICP rate has been primarily caused by exceptional circumstances (i.e. severe wage cuts or a strong recession), then such a state is not included in the calculation of the reference value and is replaced by the EU state with the fourth lowest HICP rate.
  2. ^ The annual average for the yield of 10-year government bonds must be no more than 2.0% larger than the unweighted arithmetic average of the bond yields in the 3 EU member states with the lowest HICP inflation. If any of these states have bond yields which are significantly larger than the similarly averaged yield for the eurozone (which according to previous ECB reports means more than 2% above) and at the same time does not have complete funding access to financial markets (which is the case for as long as a government receives bailout funds), then such a state is not be included in the calculation of the reference value.
  3. ^ The change in the annual average exchange rate against the euro.
  4. ^ Reference values from the ECB convergence report of May 2012.[36]
  5. ^ Sweden, Ireland and Slovenia were the reference states.[36]
  6. ^ a b c The maximum allowed change in rate is ± 2.25% for Denmark.
  7. ^ Sweden and Slovenia were the reference states, with Ireland excluded as an outlier.[36]
  8. ^ Reference values from the ECB convergence report of June 2013.[38]
  9. ^ a b Sweden, Latvia and Ireland were the reference states.[38]
  10. ^ Reference values from the ECB convergence report of June 2014.[40]
  11. ^ a b Latvia, Portugal and Ireland were the reference states.[40]

Non-economic factors[edit]

For more details on Eurosceptics, see Euroscepticism.

Some eurosceptics believe the single currency is merely a stepping stone to a unified European superstate which they strongly reject, or argue against it on other grounds. In December 2008, bookmakers were offering odds-on bets that the United Kingdom would adopt the euro by 2014.[46]

Sterling zone[edit]

If the United Kingdom were to join the eurozone, this would affect the Crown dependencies and some British overseas territories that also use the pound sterling, or which have a currency on a par with sterling. In the Crown Dependencies, the Isle of Man, Jersey, Guernsey, and Alderney pounds all share the ISO 4217 code GBP. In the British Overseas Territories, the Gibraltar, Falkland Islands, British Indian Ocean Territory and Saint Helena pounds are also fixed so that £1 in the local currency equals £1 in sterling. The British Antarctic Territory and South Georgia and the South Sandwich Islands do not have their own currencies and use the pound sterling.

When France adopted the euro, so did the French overseas departments and territories that used the French franc. The CFP franc, the CFA franc and the Comorian franc, that are used in overseas territories and some African countries, had fixed exchange rates with the French franc, but not at par – for various historical reasons they were worth considerably less, at 1 French franc = 18.2 CFP francs, 75 Comorian francs or 100 CFA francs. The CFA franc and the Comorian franc are linked to the euro at fixed rates with free convertibility maintained at the expense of the French Treasury. The CFP franc is linked to the euro at a fixed rate.

It has been suggested that the sterling zone territories therefore have four options:

  • Enter the eurozone as a non-EU member and issue a distinct national variant of the euro—just as Monaco and the Vatican have done. The EU has demanded that 'monetary agreements' be entered into by non-EU members who wish to issue their own euro coinage, and has pressured Andorra into not issuing their own coins until this is resolved. Such agreements, the EU has stated, must include adherence to EU banking and finance regulation.
  • Use standard euro coins issued by the UK and other eurozone countries. This may be perceived by some as losing an important symbol of independence.[citation needed]
  • Maintain their existing currency, but peg at a fixed rate with the euro. Maintaining a fixed rate against currency speculators can be extremely expensive, as the UK found on Black Wednesday. However, if the UK supports the keeping of the fixed rates of these small currencies, it would be so trustworthy that no speculation would take place.
  • Adopt a free-floating currency, or a currency fixed to another currency, as the Jersey government has hinted.[47]

Gibraltar is in a separate position, as it is within the EU (as part of the UK's membership). If the UK were to adopt the euro it might not be possible to implement an opt-out for Gibraltar. It is unclear whether Gibraltar would be subject to its own referendum or would be included in a UK referendum, since Gibraltar votes as a part of the UK in European parliamentary elections.

Official use of euro in British overseas territories in Cyprus[edit]

In Akrotiri and Dhekelia (Sovereign bases in Cyprus), Euro is the official currency since January 1, 2008. Since the independence of Cyprus, treaties rules that British territories in Cyprus will have the same currency as the Republic of Cyprus that switched to euro. This is the only places in the United-Kingdom where Euro has legal tender.

Banknotes[edit]

Currently, some private banks in Scotland and Northern Ireland print and issue banknotes of their own design. The Banking Act, 2008[48] amended the right of Scottish and Northern Irish banks to produce banknotes. This does not apply in Wales which uses Bank of England notes.

In November 1999, in preparation for the introduction of the euro notes and coins across the Eurozone, the European Central Bank announced a total ban on the issuing of banknotes by entities that were not National Central Banks ('Legal Protection of Banknotes in the European Union Member States'). A move from sterling to the euro would end the circulation of sub-national banknotes as all euro banknotes have an identical design. However, as national variation is a requisite of euro coins, it remains an option for the Royal Mint to incorporate the symbols of the Home Nations into its designs for the British national sides of euro coinage.

New Sterling coin designs[edit]

The United Kingdom released new coin designs in 2008 following the Royal Mint's biggest redesign of the national currency since decimalisation in 1971. German news magazine Der Spiegel suggested that this decision was to reinforce the idea that the euro will not be adopted in the UK for a long while.[49] It is however an unwritten convention that the coin designs should be changed every 40 years to keep the coinage fresh.[50]

Parity with the euro[edit]

During the final months of 2008, the pound declined in value dramatically against the euro. This led many to believe that parity between the pound and the euro was imminent and created some media discussion about the possibility of adopting the euro. Alex Salmond, the First Minister of Scotland called for more Scottish businesses to accept the euro to encourage tourism from the Eurozone, noting that this is already done by organisations such as Historic Scotland.[51]

At that time, some shops in Northern Ireland accepted the euro at parity, causing a large influx of shoppers from across the Irish border. This made some shops the most successful in their company for several weeks.[52][53]

Between February 2009 and March 2010 the value of the pound fluctuated between 84 and 95 pence per euro. This compares with its value between March and October 2008, when the value of the euro was about 78 pence, and its value of about 70 pence between April 2003 and August 2007. The lowest value of the pound was on 29 December 2008, when it took 97.855 pence to buy one euro.[19]

Polls[edit]

Polls on the question of whether the UK should join the euro. The wording of the question may have varied, but the figures show that the majority of British people are against joining the Euro.

Date YES NO Unsure Number of participants Held by Ref
November 2000 18% 71% N/A N/A BBC [5]
January 2002 31% 56% N/A N/A BBC [5]
9–10 June 2003 33% 61% 7% 1852 YouGov [54]
10–15 February 2005 26% 57% 16% 2103 Ipsos MORI [2]
11–12 December 2008 24% 59% 17% 2098 YouGov [3]
19–21 December 2008 23% 71% 6% 1000 ICM [5]
6–9 January 2009 24% 64% 12% 2157 YouGov [4]
1–4 May 2009 23% 75% 2% 1002 ICM [6]
17–18 April 2010 21% 65% 14% 1433 YouGov [55]
2–4 July 2011 8% 81% 11% 2002 Angus Reid [56]
9–12 August 2011 9% 85% 6% 2700 YouGov [57]
10 August 2012 6% 81% 13% 2004 Angus Reid [58]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ BBC News 'David Cameron and Nick Clegg pledge 'united' coalition'
  2. ^ a b "EMU Entry and EU Constitution". Ipsos MORI. 2005. Retrieved 2009-05-23. [dead link]
  3. ^ a b "Welcome to YouGov". Yougov.com. Retrieved 2009-04-16. 
  4. ^ a b "Welcome to YouGov". Yougov.com. Retrieved 2009-04-16. 
  5. ^ a b c d "Most Britons 'still oppose euro'". BBC. 1 January 2009. Retrieved 4 January 2009. 
  6. ^ a b "ICM Poll". taxpayersalliance.com. 2009. Retrieved 2009-05-22. 
  7. ^ Treneman, Ann (24 July 2007). "Puritanism comes too naturally for 'Huck' Brown". London: The Times. Retrieved 2007-08-13. 
  8. ^ "Why Britain Shouldn't Join The Euro Zone". Forbes.com. Retrieved 2009-04-16. 
  9. ^ "The Euro and its consequences for the United Kingdom". Retrieved 24 September 2013. 
  10. ^ "Brussels bogey: pensions.(UK MOS skeptical of the European Union worry about unfunded pension liabilities)(Brief Article)". http://www.highbeam.com. Retrieved 2013-09-24. 
  11. ^ "Joining The Euro". Ipsos MORI. 2006. Archived from the original on 11 December 2008. Retrieved 2006-09-12. 
  12. ^ Einaudi, Luca (2001). European Monetary Unification and the International Gold Standard (1865–1873) (PDF). Oxford University Press. ISBN 0-19-924366-2. Retrieved 2007-08-13. 
  13. ^ "Exchange rate uncertainty, UK trade and the euro". Applied Financial Economics. 2004. Retrieved 2009-09-15. 
  14. ^ The Euro and Stock Markets in Hungary, Poland, and UK. Journal of Economic Integration. 2007. Retrieved 2009-09-15. 
  15. ^ [Pesaran,Smith,Smith.pdf "What if the UK had Joined the Euro in 1999?"]. papers.ssrn.com. 2005. Retrieved 2009-09-15. 
  16. ^ "Euro Membership as a U.K. Monetary Policy Option: Results from a Structural Model". NBER Working Paper No. w14894. 2009. Retrieved 2009-09-15. 
  17. ^ Tempest, Matthew (9 June 2003). "Britain not ready to join euro". London: Guardian Unlimited. Retrieved 2006-09-12. 
  18. ^ "Pound sterling (GBP)". European Central Bank. Retrieved 2009-12-25. 
  19. ^ a b "ECB: Euro exchange rates GBP". Ecb.int. Retrieved 2013-09-24. 
  20. ^ "ECB official rates against the British pound". ECB. Retrieved 2008-11-19. 
  21. ^ Hutton, Will (16 November 2008). "It might be politically toxic – but we must join the euro now". London: guardian.co.uk. Retrieved 2008-11-19. 
  22. ^ "Business | Pound hits new low against euro". BBC News. 29 December 2008. Retrieved 2009-04-16. 
  23. ^ "ECB official rates against the British pound.". ECB. Retrieved 2011-01-01. 
  24. ^ O'grady, Sean (9 April 2009). "Weak pound heaps food inflation on poorest". The Independent (London). Retrieved 26 May 2010. 
  25. ^ "Weak pound triggers unexpected rise in inflation - The Scotsman". Business.scotsman.com. 2009-03-24. Retrieved 2013-09-24. 
  26. ^ Steed, Alison (4 November 2009). "Wild sterling fluctuations cost expat pensioners billions". The Daily Telegraph (London). Retrieved 26 May 2010. 
  27. ^ Howard, Bob (3 January 2009). "Holidays affected by weak pound". BBC News. Retrieved 26 May 2010. 
  28. ^ Evans-Pritchard, Ambrose (21 December 2009). "The rise of Germany belies the chaos a strong euro is causing". The Daily Telegraph (London). Retrieved 26 May 2010. 
  29. ^ "HICP (2005=100): Monthly data (12-month average rate of annual change)". Eurostat. 16 August 2012. Retrieved 6 September 2012. 
  30. ^ "The corrective arm". European Commission. Retrieved 2014-07-05. 
  31. ^ "Government deficit/surplus data". Eurostat. 22 April 2013. Retrieved 22 April 2013. 
  32. ^ "Long-term interest rate statistics for EU Member States (monthly data for the average of the past year)". Eurostat. Retrieved 18 December 2012. 
  33. ^ "What is ERM II?". European Commission. 31 July 2012. Retrieved 8 September 2012. 
  34. ^ "Euro/ECU exchange rates - annual data (average)". Eurostat. Retrieved 5 July 2014. 
  35. ^ "Former euro area national currencies vs. euro/ECU - annual data (average)". Eurostat. Retrieved 5 July 2014. 
  36. ^ a b c "Convergence Report May 2012". European Central Bank. May 2012. Retrieved 2013-01-20. 
  37. ^ a b "European economic forecast - spring 2012" (PDF). European Commission. 1 May 2012. Retrieved 1 September 2012. 
  38. ^ a b "Convergence Report". European Central Bank. June 2013. Retrieved 2013-06-17. 
  39. ^ a b "European economic forecast - spring 2013" (PDF). European Commission. February 2013. Retrieved 4 July 2014. 
  40. ^ a b "Convergence Report". European Central Bank. June 2014. Retrieved 2014-07-05. 
  41. ^ a b "European economic forecast - spring 2014" (PDF). European Commission. March 2014. Retrieved 5 July 2014. 
  42. ^ "Luxembourg Report prepared in accordance with Article 126(3) of the Treaty" (PDF). European Commission. 12 May 2010. Retrieved 18 November 2012. 
  43. ^ "EMI Annual Report 1994" (PDF). European Monetary Institute (EMI). April 1995. Retrieved 22 November 2012. 
  44. ^ "Progress towards convergence - Nov. 1995 (report prepared in accordance with article 7 of the EMI statute)" (PDF). European Monetary Institute (EMI). November 1995. Retrieved 22 November 2012. 
  45. ^ "Progress towards convergence - November 1995 (report prepared in accordance with article 7 of the EMI statute)" (PDF). European Monetary Institute (EMI). November 1995. Retrieved 17 March 2013. 
  46. ^ "Britain odds-on to adopt euro by 2014". Politics.co.uk. Retrieved 2009-04-16. 
  47. ^ What should the Island do in the wake of Jersey’s curve ball?, PDMS, 2003-09-01. Retrieved 2007-01-07.[dead link]
  48. ^ "UK Parliament site". Services.parliament.uk. 1 April 2009. Retrieved 2009-04-16. 
  49. ^ "Make Way for Britain's New Coin Designs". Retrieved 2008-05-17. 
  50. ^ Poulter, Sean (29 June 2009). "Have you a 20p worth £50 in your pocket? Royal Mint error results in undated coins". Daily Mail (London). Retrieved 29 June 2009. 
  51. ^ Salmond in call for euro rethink, BBC News 4 January 2009. Retrieved 6 January 2009.
  52. ^ Seeking bargains across borders, BBC News 14 October 2008. Retrieved 6 January 2009.
  53. ^ 'Euro tourists' crossing border, BBC News 22 December 2008. Retrieved 6 January 2009.
  54. ^ "YouGov Survey Results: The Euro". Yougov.com. Retrieved 2009-10-03. 
  55. ^ "YouGov Survey Results: The Euro". Yougov.com. Retrieved 2010-04-20. 
  56. ^ "AngusReid PublicOpinion". Retrieved 2010-09-11. 
  57. ^ "Bloomberg poll". Retrieved 2011-09-15. 
  58. ^ "AngusReid PublicOpinion". Retrieved 2014-06-27. 

External links[edit]