Burying a counter-factual meme about Wikipedia and the putative failure of its administration to cope with racism/antisemitism.
People coming to the page to verify the shocking suggestion that wikipedia allows Jew-baiting antisemites to edit the encyclopedia, despite documented protests at their presence, as ostensibly documented by No More Mr Nice Guy on his main page, and occasionally resurrected as a meme by editors such as Tritomex, and Evildoer, as well as numerous IPs on various pages (here, and here, for example) do well to trust no one, least of all myself, but simply examine the evidence. I am confident that looking at the facts will ensure immediate relief from any momentary anxiety such insinuations about wikipedia might spur.
My putative antisemitism on NMMNG’s page was alluded to in his addition on the 29 Jan 2014 to his page of a link to something I wrote. He used it to state ‘On Wikipedia, it's OK to say that Purim is a celebration of a successful genocide. This theme also has an illustrious history.’
In a further AE case (March 2014), Tritomex used this to sling the same innuendo my way, as did Evildoer on May 3, 2014 here. As late as August 2014 Newmancbn lambasted me as 'an open Japanese anti-Semite,' and after a dozen editors complained of his editing generally wrote:-
I genuinely, and from the bottom of my Israelite-English soul, apologize to you or anyone else who feels I disrespected them or certainly their humanity, with the one exception of User:Nishidani who claims to be an anti-Semite, who I have no love for.
MarciulionisHOF again has repeatedly insinuated I was singling him out as a Jew and justified attacking him on that ground(here)and used his mainpage and three diffs from my work to suggest (I practice a form of Orwellian newspeak), skewers as risible by hyprbolic inflation a passing mention I made of mental health problms in Gaza and likens a note on how news sources are spun to a Chinese toddler learning to wield a writing brush.
All this is piddling smear-mongering, arising from an insinuation first made in NMMGG’s complaint opened formally against me in July 2013 when he made a case against my presence here on the grounds I was a ‘Jew-baiting’ antisemite. It consists of a grossly misinterpreted remark whose putative 'antisemitic' cast was comprehensively refuted, and, because it was self-evidently silly, I initially dismissed the complaint as frivolous. Closer reflecton suggested allowing such smears to pass without comment was dangerous, even if as I am convinced it was, made in absolute good-faith. Joseph Glanvill believed in liberal tolerance, rationality and science: he also affirmed the existence of witches, and was sincere in both cases, though his good faith attestation inadvertently helped the hanging judges at the Salem witch trials. I thus clarified the ‘key’ part of his evidence, a documentary Potemkin village. It was there he stated first that my off-the-cuff remark,(based on a reading of the Book of Esther and the relevant scholarship over the years), that Purim is also ‘a celebration of a successful genocide’ (nb. i.e, the subject is the fesival, and not those who enjoy the salutary revels overwhelmingly in complete innocence of the textual narrative's ancient details) evinces a 'Jew-baiting' mentality. My reply simply consisted in showing that my remark echoes what scholarship has often noted. (‘celebrate’ here, for non-native speakers of English, means ‘commemorate in a solemn religious rite’ as in ‘celebrate mass’)
That case was duly closed with a negative verdict against the petitioner, and, on the accusations and sanction applied being appealed, was re-examined and again closed with a negative verdict. Since it has been repeated, those interested may consult my original evidence.
- Ian S. Lustick, For the Land and the Lord: Jewish Fundamentalism in Israel, Council of Foreign Relations (1988) 1994 p.10
- Human Rights Watch, Center of the Storm: A Case Study of Human Rights Abuses in Hebron District, April 2001 p.82
- Zev Garber, ‘Deconstructing Theodicy and Amalekut: A Personal apologia,’ in James F. Moore (ed.) Post Shoah Dialogues: Re-Thinking Our Texts Together, University Press of America, 2004 pp.231-249 p.241
- James F. Moore 's essay ‘The Genocidal Mind at the Heart of Our Religions’, in the same book 'Post Shoah Dialogues: Re-Thinking Our Texts Together,' University Press of America, 2004 pp.221-230, pp.223,225.
All of these incisive notes and meditations are trumped now by a very fine article recently published by Shaul Magid, an ordained rabbi and the Jay and Jeannie Schottenstein Chair of Jewish Studies in Modern Judaism at Indiana University.
Magid’s article, and another published soon after (Leora Eren Frucht, 'Purim in Jaljulya,', Haaretz 16 March, 2014) shows that my remark, unknown to me, was shared by a great ornament to modern Israel’s conscience, the philosopher Yeshayahu Leibowitz. I have no objection to NMMGG maintaining his belief about me and this subject on his page. But readers directed to my page and work from there should appreciate that NMMGG’s problem is not me, but such distinguished scholars as Leibowitz, Magid and Ian Lustick whose work is a light to the rest of us because they never bridle at, or shrink from, what many in their communities might find problematical, but analyse it in illuminating depth. Numerous festivals, in Christian tradition as well, have this kind of textual problem, but not for that do we ask people to desist from enjoying themselves on the calendrical days that commemorate these traditions.
(2) With regard to my comment here, taken by NMMGG to be malicious rather than the ironical use of a self-descriptor, one should compare Richard A. Falk's incisive meditation, which cuts both ways, on that traditional self and other descriptor and its problems. See also Gideon Levy, Back to the Israelite Kingdom, Haaretz 15 May 2014.
(3) The repeated insinuation, whose most recent examples I've cited above, that my editing is anti-semitic has led to death threats, both via email, and most recently here here ('I will sl*t your throat.')and here ('I will sl*t your face.'), this time round by the notorious sockmeister User:JarlaxleArtemis. While I take this cum grano salis (any surgical adjustments to my aged face would only be an improvement), I think NMMGG should reflect that maintaining his accusations on his home page, nolens volens can't avoid being read as an incitement for these whackoes.Nishidani (talk) 12:55, 9 June 2014 (UTC)
It seems to me a safe assumption that the disease loosely called nationalism is now almost universal. Antisemitism is only one manifestation of nationalism, and not everyone will have the disease in that particular form. A Jew, for example, would not be antisemitic: but then many Zionist Jews seem to me to be merely antisemites turned upside-down, just as many Indians and Negroes display the normal colour prejudices in an inverted form.'Antisemitism in Britain
For that dying tribe that doesn't google to get quickie results for a desired POV slant, but actually reads, this essay may be found in Sonia Orwell, Ian Angus (eds.), The Collected Essays, Journalism and Letters of George Orwell, 4 vols.,(1968) vol.3 Penguin edition, 1970 vol.3 pp.378-388, p.387. Evidently NMMGG never read to the end of his evidence for a further indictment against me.Nishidani (talk) 19:16, 23 August 2014 (UTC)
Lance Tapley, The Double Identity of an "Anti-Semitic" Commenter Common Dreams 20 August 2014.(A Cautionary Tale on how twisted these accusations can get)
John V. Whitbeck, The only legally, politically and diplomatically correct ways to refer to the 22% portion of historical Palestine occupied in 1967 are now “the State of Palestine”, “Palestine” and “occupied Palestine”. “Palestinian Authority”, “occupied territories” and “occupied Palestinian territories” are no longer acceptable.’ at Counterpunch, Weekend Edition January 18-20, 2013
(The EU's 27 foreign ministers) have also received information from human rights organizations saying Israel is planning to evacuate some 2,500 Bedouins of the Jahalin tribe from their residence in the E1 area near Ma'aleh Adumim to the garbage removal site near the village of Abu Dis.Barak Ravid, 'EU voices protest over Israeli policies in East Jerusalem, West Bank,' at Haaretz, 23 December, 2011.
'Anti-Semitism exists today on the furthest margins of Western society, in obscure sinecures, on the Internet, but perhaps most prevalently in our feverish imaginations. And in our generation that is where it constitutes the biggest threat. ..It would make much more sense if they could outlaw calling people anti-Semites. Not because there aren’t any anti-Semites out there, but because of the damage we do ourselves with this incessant searching and name-calling.' Anshel Pfeffer, 'The new anti-Semitism is whatever Israelis want it to be,' at Haaretz 7 February 2014.
欲以存亡繼絕, (淮南子, 卷二十一 要略 7a.)
ἄγνοια γὰρ ἡ μὲν τῶν ἰσχυρῶν ἐχθρά τε καὶ αἰσχρά— βλαβερὰ γὰρ καὶ τοῖς πέλας αὐτή τε καὶ ὅσαι εἰκόνες αὐτῆς εἰσιν—(Φίληβος,49ξ)
'most - nearly all - websites created in HTML, will not outlive their creators, and the duration of the materials may well be much shorter even than that.' Jerome McGann, 'Our textual history: Digital copying of poetry and prose raises questions beyond accuracy alone,' TLS,November 20, 2009 pp.13-15,p.15
“The historian’s task is not to disrupt for the sake of it, but it is to tell what is almost always an uncomfortable story and explain why the discomfort is part of the truth we need to live well and live properly.” Tony Judt, in William Grimes, ‘Tony Judt, Chronicler of History, Is Dead at 62,’ NYT 7 August 2010
'The State of Israel is at war with the Palestinian people, people against people, collective against collective.' Israel's Ministry of Justice 2009, in Uri Avnery, 'Israel's Most Revolting Law?' Counterpunch, 23/03/2009
'We're not obliged to give 'both sides of the story' when the 'other side' is irr(e)levant.' User:NoCal100 on the Lydda Death March talkpage. The other side consists of Palestinians
'no Palestinian can dig a hole more than 40cm below the ground.' Robert Fisk, ‘In the West Bank's stony hills, Palestine is slowly dying,’ Independent 30 January 2010
'Ainsley Cody . .lives by his own code of honor, which includes respecting others if they deserve it, defending yourself, and never backing down if you are right.' Margaret Atwood, reviewing E. O. Wilson, Anthill, NYRB April 8, 2010 pp.6-8 p.8.
'To engage with China's arguments concerning Tibet is to be subjected to the kind of intellectual entrapment, familiar in the Palestinian conflict, whereby the dispute is corralled into questions which the plaintiff had never sought to dispute. Tibetans complain of being robbed of their dignity in their homeland by having their genuinely loved leader incessantly denounced, and of being swamped by Chinese immigration to the point of becoming a minority in their own country. But China insistently condemns such complaints as separatism, an offence in China under the crime of 'undermining national unity', and pulls the debate back to one about Tibet's historical status. Foreigners raise questions about human rights and the environment, but China again denounces this as a foreign intervention in the internal affairs of a sovereign nation, and pulls the debate back to Tibet's historical status.' George Fitzherbert, 'Land of Clouds', Times Literary Supplement, June 30,2008 p.7
Gaza on the Mind
'It was as though the buildings destroyed by bombs and shells, the central courtyard ploughed up by the war - full of mounds of earth, heaps of twisted metal, damp acrid smoke and the yellow reptilian flames of slowly-burning insulators - represented what was left to him of his own life.'Vasily Grossman, Life and Fate p.246
'Toujours plus désolée et plus solitaire, la Palestine se déroule, infiniment silencieuse'. Pierre Loti, Jérusalem p.34
Hebron Hills on the Mind cf. (1)
- "The South Hebron Hills are a place of great beauty. Gazelles roam the hillsides, birds are abundant in the sky. When you look out over the hills you can see ancient Palestinian villages where people are still living a simple, subsistence lifestyle. They have flocks of sheep and goats. They market lambs, and the women make delicious cheese and butter. In springtime, the valleys are brilliant green with crops of wheat and barley.
- "But this beauty is marked with pain. As you look out across the horizon now, you also see the unmistakable mark of Israeli settlements. They appear as modern suburban developments dropped down on the hilltops in this rugged terrain. Settlement outposts extend the reach of these settlements, and confiscate increasingly more Palestinian land exclusively for Israeli use. Religiously zealous, ideological and violent settlers threaten and attack anyone who dares draw near. Palestinian shepherds here find they have less and less land to graze their flocks, and must take grave risks when they do.
- "As we accompany these shepherds, they often speak of the stories this landscape holds for them. They speak of the land they knew as children; the places they used to roam; the valleys their fathers and grandfathers used to graze the flocks. Recently, as we accompanied one shepherd, Shaadi, he pointed out some of the landmarks in his memory along the way. From high on a hilltop, we can see the nearby settlement and outpost. Although he does not mention it, we are looking across at a place where his children have been repeatedly attacked while walking to school. He continues to send his children to school, knowing that to do so is defiance of the violence and threats to push him and his family off of their land.
- "As we pause at the cistern to water the flocks, he recounts the time when three masked settlers from the outpost attacked him and his young son while they were watering the sheep. The settlers arrived in a truck and began firing stones at them with a slingshot. They broke the legs of two of his sheep. His nine year old son was also hit by the rocks. Shaadi tried to comfort his son, who would not speak after the attack. When he called the Israeli police to report the attack, the police refused to come to the village to take his report saying they were afraid of the settlers, 'We are only two police. We need a whole army to go in there. The settlers will break our windows.' Shaadi replied, 'If you are afraid of the settlers, how do you think I am?'
- "A short walk later, we pass by the place where three years ago a settler from the illegal settlement outpost Havat Maon, stole fifteen sheep from his flock. Despite filing a police report, including video evidence of the entire incident and eyewitness testimony from an international observer, no charges were filed against the settler. As we approach his home, he talks about the forced removal of several hundred people from this area. On April 7, 1998 over one hundred families in the area, including Shaadi's, were served orders to abandon their homes by April 12th. In a dark irony, the deadline given was Easter Sunday. The families refused to leave. The military confiscated their meager belongings, and offered to return them if they agreed to leave. They refused. Shaadi's home is a simple place, closely connected with the homes of his extended family. But even home is a place of scarred memories. Settlers have come and attacked his family. Shaadi shares the painful memory of the time when armed settlers came to the village, and started shooting. His mother was shot in the leg, and his brother was also wounded. For him and his family, there is no safe place of refuge.
- "As is typical in the area, they once had a toilet out-building adjacent to the house. In May of 2006, the Israeli Civil Administration issued a demolition order for the toilet. A few days later a bulldozer came and destroyed it. He has not been allowed to rebuild it. It seems even the basic human dignity and privacy of a toilet will be denied him.
- "Shepherds in this area continue to face violence and threats on a daily basis. In January of this year, while Shaadi was out grazing his flocks with a few other local shepherds, settlers came out from the outpost and fired six shots at them. The flocks scattered, and the shepherds fled. The Israeli police refused to respond, saying they 'had better things to do'.
- "A few weeks ago, Shaadi was one of several shepherds that went to graze their flocks in a valley called Mshaha, south of the illegal settlement outpost, Havat Maon. They went together as an act of resistance to threats and violence from the settlers. They went to recover the use of their land, and find sustenance for their flocks. On this day, Israeli soldiers arrived and demanded that the shepherds leave. The shepherds responded that this was their land, and that they wanted to appeal to the commander to decide the issue. Settlers from the outpost also came and spoke with the soldiers. The soldiers ran toward the flocks and kicked several sheep, trying to drive them away. Many of these shepherds reported injuries to their sheep, including broken teeth, and internal bleeding. Shaadi lost two lambs later that week from injured ewes.
- "As we were finishing up this long walk, we paused along the way as a young lamb was born. Shaadi tended gently and expertly to the newborn, and invited us back to his house for a meal. We rejoiced in the new birth, hopeful that this might be finally a sign of new life for him and his family."
- 'Investigations fail to result in convictions even when eyewitnesses provide accurate descriptions of Jewish suspects seen at or fleeing the scene, holding incriminating evidence - as in a case reported earlier this month by the Jerusalem Post's Dan Izenberg. According to the April 6 article, a settler from Kedumim was caught by police last summer, fleeing a burning Palestinian orchard while holding a jerrican filled with flammable liquid, and with the smell of the liquid on his hands. The suspect refused to answer police questions during interrogation; and less than a year later, the courts dismissed the case for "lack of evidence." Michael Sfard, Yesh Din's legal advisor, described the court's decision as "scandalous." Lisa Goldman, ‘Who will protect Palestinians from growing settler extremism?,’ Haaretz 24/04/2010
Page starts or significant contributions
Ishida Eiichirō (石田 英一郞, )
Miyata Noboru (宮田登)
Torii Ryūzō (鳥居 龍藏)
Aida Yūji (会田雄次)
Gill, Robin D.
Ishimoda Shō (石母田正)
Kada no Azumamaro (荷田春満)
Kindaichi Haruhiko (金田一春彦)
Kuki Ryūichi (九鬼隆一)
Kuki Shūzō (九鬼周造)
Kumazawa Banzan (熊沢蕃山)
The Kyoto University Research Centre for the Cultural Sciences (京都大学人文科学研究所)
Amino Yoshihiko (網野善彦)
Mitsui, Takatoshi (三井高利)
Murayama Shichirō (村山七郎)
Susumu Kuno (久野 璋)
Susumu Ōno (大野 晋)
Takeda Taijun (武田泰淳)
Takeuchi Yoshimi (竹内好)
Tokunaga Muneo (徳永宗雄)
Tsuramoto Tashiro (田代陣基)
Ueyama Shunpei (上山春平)
Umehara Takeshi (梅原猛)
Watanabe Shōichi (渡部 昇一)
Anonymous, the film
de Vere, Edward
List of Shakespeare authorship candidates
History of the Shakespeare authorship question
Matus, Irvin Leigh
Oxfordian theory of Shakespeare authorship
Shakespeare authorship question
Epic of King Gesar
History of Tibet
Incorporation of Tibet into the People's Republic of China
1903-4 British invasion of Tibet
The Ashkenazi Jews/Khazarian origins theory
Tsepon W. D. Shakabpa
After Saturday Comes Sunday
Awwad, Ali Abu
Apartheid in Israel?, the Dialog poll.
Azzam Pasha quotation
Depiction of Israel in Palestinian textbooks
Eisenmenger, Johann Andreas
Hadassah medical convoy massacre
Houtsma, Martijn Theodoor
al-Husayni, Mohammed Amin
Kıbrıslı Mehmed Emin Pasha
Hebron Massacre, 1929
1834 Hebron massacre
1834 Safed pogrom
2014 kidnapping of Israeli teens
List of violent incidents in the Israeli–Palestinian conflict, 2014
Siege of the Church of the Nativity in Bethlehem.
Falk, Richard A.
Kfar Etzion massacre
History of the Jews in Egypt
List of Israeli price tag attacks
List of Israeli strikes and Palestinian casualties in Operation Protective Edge
List of Israeli assassinations
Kidnapping and murder of Mohammed Abu Khdeir
Operation Protective Edge
List of mayors of Jerusalem
Mustafa bin Abd al-Qadir Sitt Maryam Nasar
Neve Shalom-Wahat as-Salam
Operation Magic Carpet
al-Qassam, Izz ad-Din
Palestine Liberation Organization
Price tag policy
1920 Palestine riots
Refusal to serve in the IDF
Sanballat the Horonite
Salman Abu Sitta
Shulman, David Dean
United Nations resolution on Israeli settlement activity, 2011
2008–2009 Israel–Gaza conflict
2014 Israel–Gaza conflict
Zion square lynching
Elazar, Gush Etzion
United Nations Partition Plan for Palestine
Aida Refugee Camp
Varia Boletus edulis
Capital in the Twenty-First Century
David Kelly, death of
Lloyd, G. E. R.
Forrest River massacre
List of massacres of Indigenous Australians
White, Harry Dexter
What Must Be Said
Adorno, Theodor W.
Burton, Richard Francis
Doi Takeo (土居健郎)
Finley, Moses I.
Fujitani Nariakira(富士谷 成章)
Grierson, Herbert John Clifford
Miller, Roy Andrew
1 Morris, Ivan
Montagne, Michel de
Nishida Kitaro (西田 幾多郎)
Nitobe Inazō (新渡戸稲造)
Ogyū Sorai (荻生 徂徠)
Giovanni Pico della Mirandola
AMIA bombing, 1994
Antisemitism in the New Testament, failed to fix
Arab Peace Initiative
Battles of Latrun
Bombardment of Shimonoseki (下関戦争/馬関戦争)
Bullard, Robert Lee
Bushido: The Soul of Japan
Causes of the 1948 Palestinian exodus
Causes of World War II
Cave of the Patriarchs massacre
Censorship by Google
Center for Advanced Study in the Behavioral Sciences
Christ myth theory
The Chrysanthemum and the Sword
Cubana Flight 455
Donghak Peasant Revolution (東學農民運動)
Effects of the 2008–2009 Israel–Gaza conflict
Exodus from Lydda
Forrest River massacre
Freeman, Charles W. Jr
From Time Immemorial
Ginsberg, Asher Hirsch
Hamersley, Sir Hugh
Hirata Atsutane (平田篤胤)
History of Kazakhstan
Hongwu Emperor (洪武帝/朱元璋)
Hussam ad-Din Jarallah
Ishii, Shiro (石井四郎)
Islam and antisemitism
Izanami (伊弉冉尊/伊邪那美命, )
International Research Center for Japanese Studies (国際日本文化研究センター)
Abu Musa Jābir ibn Hayyān
John of Damascus
Jewish exodus from Arab lands
Joseph II, Holy Roman Emperor
Judaization of Jerusalem
Kamo no Mabuchi (賀茂真淵)
Kav 300 affair
Kafr Qasim massacre
Khan Yunis massacre
Killings and massacres during the 1948 Palestine War
King David Hotel bombing
Kokugaku (: 國學)
2006 Lebanon War
List of terrorist attacks against Israel before 1967
Looney, J. Thomas
Lu Xun (魯迅)
Massacre of Eilaboun
Morimura Seiichi (森村 誠一)
Nihon Ōdai Ichiran (日本王代一覧)
Nuclear program of Iran
Oswald, Lee Harvey
Palestine Liberation Organization
Palin Report 1920
Portraits of Shakespeare
Rite of passage
September 11 attacks
Shakespeare attribution studies
Slavery in Japan
Sugimoto Etsu Inagaki
Surrender of Japan
Suzuki, Daisetz Teitaro (鈴木大拙 )
Takeyama Michio (竹山道雄)
Tannenberg, Battle of
The First Generation of Postwar Writers
Three Character Classic
Tibet, History of
Tōgō Heihachirō (東郷 平八郎)
Tokugawa Iemochi (徳川家茂)
Tokugawa Tsunayoshi (徳川綱吉)
Tuyuhun Kingdom (吐谷渾)
Ueda Akinari (上田秋成)
USS Liberty Incident
von Cramm, Gottfried
White Paper of 1939
1834 Palestinian Arab revolt
2003 invasion of Iraq
2009 L'Aquila earthquake
Patient merit of the unworthy
|An Original Barnstar|
|This Barnstar awarded in recognition of your careful and encyclopedic work in every article you touch. PalestineRemembered 08:25, 11 August 2007 (UTC)|
|The Purple Star|
|In recognition of the insults and other damage you received. As I think we all know by now, there is occasionally a price to be paid for acting with integrity. Thank you for having done so, despite the difficulties involved. John Carter 17:24, 9 November 2007 (UTC)|
|The Original Barnstar|
|In recognition of your fine contributions to a number of articles, including but not limited to Palestine Liberation Organization and Nabi Musa, I am pleased to award you this barnstar. Tiamuttalk 17:02, 28 February 2008 (UTC)|
|The Original Barnstar|
|For substantial improvements to the article on Norman Finkelstein. — [ aldebaer] 22:08, 12 September 2007 (UTC)|
|The Barnstar of Diligence|
|The Barnstar of Diligence is hereby awarded in recognition of extraordinary scrutiny, precision, and community service, especially in regard to article improvement.|
|White Knight defender of Wikipedia Barnstar|
|The project needs scholars now more than ever. PRtalk 18:18, 15 November 2008 (UTC)|
|Your Opinion is More Important than You Think Barnstar|
|You should know, Nishidani, that you have fans even far-removed from your areas of interest. Your wit and scholarship are only matched by your gentility. You have demonstrated admirable tenacity in the difficult editorial realms you frequent, and I hope you will keep up the exemplary work. Thibbs (talk) 17:19, 12 March 2009 (UTC)|
|The Defender of the Wiki Barnstar|
|For your brave attempts to uphold scholarly standards in the Israel/Palestine-area of WP. Deep regards to Nishidani from Huldra (talk) 16:38, 1 April 2009 (UTC)|
|The Defender of the Wiki Barnstar|
|For your robust defence of scholarly standards in Wikipedia Ian Pitchford (talk) 19:18, 21 March 2009 (UTC)|
|The Defenestrated Wiki Barnstar|
|For being bodily tossed through a sealed plexiglass window for your attempt to put over that you can get away with windbaggery in the defence of scholiastic puffery in the Israel/Palestine-area of WP. With wounded amour-propre to myself Nishidani (talk) 20:56, 2 April 2009 (UTC)Huldra (talk) 16:38, 1 April 2009 (UTC)|
|The Barnstar of Integrity|
|All the interesting people banned! Things will be pretty dull for a while. Will miss you --Ravpapa (talk) 16:15, 13 May 2009 (UTC)|
|The Defender of the Wiki Barnstar|
For hours of fruitless effort trying to protect Wikipedia from nationalist bias. Although you have been sanctioned unfairly, your thoughtful arguments and dogged research have given the community a strong background of information to draw on when denouncing future attempts to portray ideology as fact. untwirl(talk) 14:54, 14 May 2009 (UTC)
Added Sauce Award
I award this Added Sauce award to Nishidani for great efforts in hunting down sourcing my lexical queries (and articles are always better with sauces/sources). Cheers, Casliber (talk • contribs) 14:13, 16 December 2009 (UTC)
|The Beer Barnstar|
|You beat me to it with your correction! RolandR (talk) 19:52, 1 September 2010 (UTC)|
|The Informal Lack of Integrity Wiki Barnstar|
|Informally assigned here|
|The Literary Barnstar|
|Even as an outsider to the discussion, I know that the Shakespeare authorship question was a swamp that could have sucked down a lot of editors. Congratulations on helping turn such a problematic topic into an FA. John Carter (talk) 18:24, 20 April 2011 (UTC)|
|Patron of Joseph's Tomb|
|Awarded in gratitude for your efforts and diligence at Joseph's Tomb. Your valued additions have enhanced the article! Thank you.|
|The Procrastinator's Barnstar|
|In recognition of the long and winding road you've travelled in finally getting around to the Mufti. --NSH001 (talk) 21:14, 13 September 2011 (UTC)|
|The Socratic Barnstar|
|For your wisdom in the analysis of the mess that was the Gilabrand AE case, and the wisdom that your comments continue to show. The Israel-Palestine area needs more editors like you. HJ Mitchell | Penny for your thoughts? 17:56, 10 March 2014 (UTC)|
|The Socratic Barnstar|
|I was meaning to thank you months ago but I forgot to. You've single handedly turned the Khazars article into one worthy of FA status. Not only is it free of edit wars now, but it's nice to be able to read one of my favorite articles without seeing it shrink or inflate with original research. :)))) Khazar (talk) 20:08, 12 May 2014 (UTC)|
|The Special Barnstar|
|for working to keep POINTY articles off WP DocumentError (talk) 12:09, 27 November 2014 (UTC)|
(this will have to do until they make an Anti-Zionism barnstar)
|On 23 July 2012, Did you know? was updated with a fact from the article Ali Abu Awwad, which you created or substantially expanded. The fact was ... that Palestinian activist Ali Abu Awwad, who is featured in the award-winning film Encounter Point, espouses Gandhi's doctrine of nonviolent resistance called satyagraha? The nomination discussion and review may be seen at Template:Did you know nominations/Ali Abu Awwad. You are welcome to check how many hits the article got while on the front page (here's how, quick check) and it will be added to DYKSTATS if it got over 5,000. If you know of another interesting fact from a recently created article, then please suggest it on the Did you know? talk page.|
|On 11 August 2012, Did you know? was updated with a fact from the article Khirbet Zanuta, which you created or substantially expanded. The fact was ... that residents of the Iron Age village of Khirbet Zanuta near Hebron achieved a revision of the planned demolition of their dwellings by the Israeli military authorities? The nomination discussion and review may be seen at Template:Did you know nominations/Khirbet Zanuta. You are welcome to check how many hits the article got while on the front page (here's how, quick check) and it will be added to DYKSTATS if it got over 5,000. If you know of another interesting fact from a recently created article, then please suggest it on the Did you know? talk page.|
The bodkins' quietus
Blocked 1: August 2007
Blocked 2: October 2007
The penalty was incurred while trying to restore a passage, vigorously deleted by several posters in tagteam edits, in which I cited Walter Laqueur, Benny Morris, and Lenni Brenner three highly reliable sources on Zionist history, two of whom pro-Zionist, whose statement of facts was not appreciated by the others. I thought they were vandalising the text. But rules are rules, as roses are roses, and ruses ruses.Nishidani (talk) 15:26, 15 March 2008 (UTC)
Blocked 3: December 2007
For snoopers, this block was overruled, as I did not violate WP:3RR, or edit-war. Administrative snafu Nishidani (talk) 15:26, 15 March 2008 (UTC)
- (4) Self-blocked for violation of WP:Civil for I month, 29-4-2008 to June 2, 2008.
- (5) Self-blocked indefinitely for violation of WP:Civil.in protest at the triumph of legalism over substance, starting 7 November 2008
(6) Perma-banned by Arbcom, for the I/P area,
For the historical record, the evidence against me was summed up as follows: Nishidani
Passed 13 to 0, 15:35, 12 May 2009 (UTC)
I don't challenge the verdict. I would simply note that the evidence in the judgement has almost no bearing on the formulation of misdemeanours attributed to me. I was so disinterested at the time that I never even checked through this until this evening, after I followed a long train of reflection on a wholly unrelated matter.Nishidani (talk) 19:18, 29 June 2010 (UTC)
(2) translates out to my being blocked twice for very brief periods in 2007, when I began to edit. The two other blocks (2007 December) (2009 April, concurrent with the arbitration) were for reports leading to administrative action that were almost immediately overturned after clarification on AN/I, where it was shown the administrators had made a mistake or misread. The only block I had from December 2007 to April 2009 was in April 2009 and lasted 1 hour, till it was cancelled as a mistake. I had therefore no operative block from October 2007 when this record was adduced as one of two items attesting to 'repeated and extensive edit-warring'.
(3) graphs revert behaviour, 8 reverts in 45 days, which is the only other evidence for 'repeated and extensive edit-warring'. The reverts I performed were to an expression that was subsequently adopted as the proper one for the area.
(4) consists of a link to a comical post I sent to my fellow editor, Ashley Kennedy, which Jehochman suspended me for, until it was explained to him that it was not an attack on Kennedy, but a note, on the wrong board, between friends, using humour and hyperbole to try and warn him not to exaggerate in editing, in a way that would get him banned. Jehochman's ban was, once this was clarified, immediately reversed.
(5) I thought arbitration was to analyse past behaviour. In the meantime, as deliberations ensued, I wrote up the page on Susya, esp. on the synagogue there. As soon as I touched the documentary evidence for the eviction of local people 4 editors stepped in and edit-warred. Two turned out to be the same person, socks of each other and were permabanned just a few months later, though informally the fact was well known.
(6) Anyone is welcome to read this, and the preceding, to check whether my measured and detailed analyses of the problems of editing there, over two days, constitute 'incivility, personal attacks, and assumptions of bad faith' as a characteristic of my editing over the three years to that date. The content of (5) and (6) are the essential evidence for banning me permanently from that area. Nishidani (talk) 19:38, 29 June 2010 (UTC)
This was after a long day and inadvertent. Details
(2)When Off2riorob restored that CAT, I then reverted him.
(3) Like a true gent, after a short discussion, Riorob self-reverted to the status-quo, which in turn meant my option of reverting my edit to what he had added was no longer possible.
To my mind at the moment I did my revert, the preceding partial deletion was not a revert, and therefore I was within the 1RR rule. I don’t really understand these things except very generically. I notified EdJohnson in case he didn't catch the sanctionable error, and slept on it. I woke to find an email by an authority, not an admin, not unfriendly to my presence here, who wrote that it did constitute a 1RR violation, and that I should pull my finger out. To save people and admins time, I have therefore applied the sanction myself. The law does not admit ignorance. Unless this is extended by the usual processes, I'll see you all sometime in September. Happy editing. Nishidani (talk) 06:50, 8 August 2011 (UTC)
- (5) Self-blocked from editing articles for violation of WP:IRR for I month, 5 Decembert 2011 to 10 January, 2012 at Jerusalem
The error occurred when, as I pasted my edit in, it accidentally ran partially over the preceding sentence. Someone35, seeing the elision, but not taking any note of the two important additions I had made, rather than restore the elided bit, made a blanket revert, thus wiping out my RSs' important qualifications. I restored my edits, but inadvertently, in reverting, also removed the same sentence my first edit wiped out. All of this is an egregious example of editors not using their commonsense, and making a mountain out of a molehill. Editors still retain the habit of disregarding the page out of excessive scrutiny of the page's editors rather than of the literature required to write it. A simply query in these cases is sufficient to allow someone to correct an oversight. The same goes for 'Hadr', which drifted into the text instead of entering my 'search box' as I opened the page to edit. There is no need to agonize and dialogue in extenso over these things. One fixes them as a courtesy, and to prove that even in the I/P area, WP:COMMONSENSE still has a fragile toehold. A self-ban for a technical violation is a rule I wish to adopt for myself. It's a relief to not have to waste one's time for a month. Nishidani (talk) 18:30, 5 December 2011 (UTC)
- I violated my own block, by slipping from a talk page to what I noted in poor editing at Al-Bireh. I'll extend the article ban by a few days to the 10th of January.Nishidani (talk) 16:54, 8 December 2011 (UTC)
- (6) Self-blocked from editing articles for violation of WP:IRR at Zeitoun for I month, 4th May 2012 to 4th June 2012.
This may be modified if insufficient. See here. The block officially extends from the expiry of my self-block (4th June above for all of wikipedia) to 13 June 2012, but given my liability to make occasional slips, perhaps that is not sufficient, and I may roll it over month by month. Cheers
- (7) Self-blocked for what looks like an (inadvertent in my view) 1R violation, for one month from today at Zion square assault.
In lieu of a decision at AE on this request by User:Activism1234, but not intended to preempt it. It was inadvertent but good faith demands I apply the principle. This is not preemptive of any more severe sanction, but merely the application of my standing rule. Unless admins consider the infraction worthy of a longer suspension I will refrain from editing wikipedia until October 3 2012.Nishidani (talk) 08:56, 2 September 2012 (UTC)
- (8) Self-blocked for an inadvertent 1R violation, for one month from today 9 Dec 2012 at List of indigenous peoples. Failed to note that the page came under the Arbcom 2008 sanctions re 3 R. No excuses. See both this and this. Nishidani (talk) 19:48, 8 December 2012 (UTC)
- (9) Blocked for dropping a friendly New Year note to Nableezy, which was a parody of the insults he gets, was misunderstood by everyone except anyone in the I/P area, and earned a day's suspension. It began with this, and then the fresh insults were erased from the record. Nishidani (talk) 15:43, 1 January 2013 (UTC)
- 10) Self-suspended for a month for my (inadvertent) double revert (here and here) at Palestinian people 24 April, 2013 Nishidani (talk) 21:51, 23 April 2013 (UTC)
- 'On Jewish Identity,', Falk blog entry, January 15, 2011:'I have felt uncomfortable since childhood with biblical claims, often repeated in contemporary social settings, that Jews are ‘the chosen people’ of God even if this is understood benevolently and temporally as a special destiny associated with doing justice rather than as a matter of societal achievement via wealth and professional success. As soon as exclusivity or superiority is claimed for any ethnic or religious fraction of the human whole, there is implicitly posited a belief in the inferiority of ‘the other,’ which unconsciously and indirectly gives rise to the murderous mentality of warfare and gives a moral and religious edge to many forms of persecution, culminating in a variety of inquisitions.'
- The most disturbing thing about this point of view is the solecistic use of 'sinecure'.(b)In Larry Derfner's view, 'As a matter of fact, the ADL and the entire American Jewish establishment should suspend their campaigns against anti-Semitism indefinitely and take a look at what’s going on in Israel.'Larry Derfner,‘Israel's Everyday Racism — and How American Jews Turn a Blind Eye to It:Refocus Anti-Semitism Outrage on Our Own Dirty Laundry,’ The Jewish Daily Forward , August 12, 2013.