Wall Street reform
Wall Street Reform or Financial Reform, commonly called the Dodd-Frank Bill, was signed by President of the United States Barack Obama on July 22, 2010. Since the economic crisis of 2008-present (including jobs lost, businesses failed, house prices dropped, and personal savings affected), there was an ongoing debate taking place whether there was sufficient oversight and regulation of the US financial system, non-regulated OTC derivative market, and non-existence of consumer protection authority which was viewed by some as the major cause of the financial crisis. The law was passed with the intent to make US financial system more transparent and accountable, avoid another economic crisis, and to ensure that there is a system in place that will work towards protecting investors’ money. Some of the major topics it includes are: creation of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and the Financial Stability Oversight Council, limiting large complex financial instruments and making derivative market more transparent, many new requirements and oversight of Credit Rating Agencies, giving shareholders a say on CEO's bonuses (and many others) - with the main purpose of strengthening the economy, and protecting consumers.
The Glass-Steagall Act of 1933
The Glass-Steagall Act of 1933 placed a "wall of separation" between banks and brokerages, which was largely repealed by the Financial Services Modernization Act of 1999. Though some commentators regard the restoration of the 1933 bill as crucial, even calling it "the most vital element of Wall Street reform", House Democratic leaders refused to allow an amendment by Rep. Maurice Hinchey (D-NY) to restore Glass-Steagall as part of the 2009 Frank bill. Hinchey introduced his proposal as a separate bill, the Glass-Steagall Restoration Act of 2009. Nonetheless, the "Volcker rule" proposed by the Obama administration has been described as a "new Glass-Steagall Act for the 21st century", as it establishes stringent rules against banks using their own money to make risky investments.
Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002
The Sarbanes-Oxley Act, by Sen. Paul S. Sarbanes (D-MD) and Rep. Michael G. Oxley (R-OH), was signed into law by George W. Bush in July 2002. The bill was enacted as a reaction to a number of major corporate and accounting scandals including those affecting Enron and WorldCom.
2009 and 2010 reform
As of May 2010, both the House and Senate bills had been passed, but the differences between the bills were to be worked out in United States congressional conference committee. Differences which must be resolved include: whether the new consumer protection agency would be independent (Senate) or part of the Federal Reserve; whether to require banks to issue credit derivatives in separately capitalized affiliates (Senate); how exactly the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) will wind down or bail out large institutions which fail; the circumstances under which large institutions could be broken up; a 15 to 1 leverage limit in the House bill; the terms of a Fed audit (continuous as in the House bill or one-time as in the Senate bill); both bills include the Volcker rule which prohibits proprietary trading by bank holding companies, but both have a caveat which allow for regulators to overrule the rule; both bills propose to regulate credit rating agencies, but the Senate's bill is much stronger.
H.R. 4173, the Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act of 2009 by Rep. Barney Frank (D-MA), passed by the House of Representatives in December 2009, and awaiting action by the Senate as of April 2010.
S.3217 was introduced by Senate Banking Committee chairman Chris Dodd (D-CT) on April 15, 2010. Dodd's bill included a $50 billion liquidation fund which drew criticism as a continuing bailout, which he was pressured to remove by Republicans and the Obama administration. The Senate bill passed on May 20, 2010.
The "Volcker Rule" was proposed by President Barack Obama based on advice by Paul Volcker, and a draft of the proposed legislation was prepared by the U.S. Treasury Department. It limited any one bank from holding more than 10% of FDIC-insured deposits, and prohibited any bank with a division holding such deposits from using its own capital to make speculative investments. The Volcker rule faced heavy resistance in the Senate and was introduced as part of the subsequent Dodd bill only in a limited form.
Financial Stability Oversight Council
Chaired by the United States Secretary of the Treasury, a new multi-authority oversight body called the Financial Stability Oversight Council of regulators will be established. The council will consist of nine members including regulators from the Federal Reserve System, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Federal Housing Finance Agency, and many other agencies. The main purpose of the council is to identify risk in the Financial system. Also, the council will look at the interconnectivity of the highly leveraged financial firms and can ask companies to divest holdings if their structure poses a great threat to the Financial system. The council will have a solid control on the operations of the leveraged firms and also help in increasing the transparency.
- Binyamin Applebaum and David M. Herszenhorn (2010-078-15). "Financial Overhaul Signals Shift on Deregulation". The New York Times. Check date values in:
- Pam Martens (2010-03-26). "The Most Vital Ingredient in Wall Street Reform Goes Missing". CounterPunch.
- Robert Scheer (2010-01-06). "McCain Gets It, Obama Doesn't". The Nation.
- "[Text of H.R. 4375]". thomas.loc.gov.
- Jill Treanor (2010-01-21). "Obama announces dramatic crackdown on Wall Street banks: Obama's 'new Glass-Steagall Act' will prevent banks with customer deposits taking risky investment bets". London: The Guardian.
- "Wall Street reform". PBS. 2002-08. Check date values in:
- "[Text of H.R. 3763 (6 versions)]". thomas.loc.gov.
- Indiviglio D. (2010). The Conference Challenges Congress Faces for Financial Reform. The Atlantic.
- "[Text of H.R. 4173 (3 versions)]". thomas.loc.gov.
- "H.R.4173 - Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act of 2009". OpenCongress.org. Retrieved 2010-04-17.
- Ben Protess (2009-12-18). "Barney Frank Vs. The Credit Raters (VIDEO)". Huffington Post Investigative Fund.
- "[Text of S.3217]". thomas.loc.gov.
- CNN Senior White House Correspondent Ed Henry (2010-04-17). "White House signals shift on Wall Street reform". CNN.
- Damian Palmetta (2010-02-24). "'Volcker Rule' Stalls in Senate". Wall Street Journal.
- Kevin Drawbaugh and Karey Wutkowski (2010-03-03). "Obama reasserts Volcker rule". Reuters.
- "Factbox: Key elements of Dodd's financial reform bill". Reuters. 2010-03-15.
- David Scheer, Gregory Mott, Lawrence Roberts (2010-07-15). "'Congressional Overhaul Maps the Future of Financial Regulation'". Bloomberg Businessweek.