Walter Campbell (judge)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Sir Walter Campbell
ACQC
21st Governor of Queensland
In office
22 July 1985 – 29 July 1992
Monarch Elizabeth II
Premier Sir Joh Bjelke-Petersen
Mike Ahern
Russell Cooper
Wayne Goss
Preceded by Sir James Ramsay
Succeeded by Leneen Forde
Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Queensland
In office
18 February 1982 – 7 July 1985
Premier Sir Joh Bjelke-Petersen
Preceded by Charles Wanstall
Succeeded by Dormer Andrews
Personal details
Born 4 March 1921
Burringbar, New South Wales
Died 4 September 2004(2004-09-04) (aged 83)
Ascot, Queensland
Alma mater University of Queensland
Military service
Allegiance  Australia
Service/branch Royal Australian Air Force
Years of service 1941–1946
Rank Flight Lieutenant
Battles/wars Second World War

Sir Walter Benjamin Campbell ACQC (4 March 1921 – 4 September 2004) was an Australian judge, administrator and governor. He was a judge of the Supreme Court of Queensland, Chancellor of the University of Queensland, and Governor of Queensland.

Background and early life[edit]

Campbell was born in Burringbar, northern New South Wales, to Archie Eric Gordon Campbell and Leila Mary née Murphy.[1] Archie Campbell was a decorated soldier of the First World War, having won the Military Cross for gallantry against the Turks in Gaza and the Distinguished Service Order for later efforts in Damascus.[2] Leila Campbell died unexpectedly, leaving Walter and his brothers to spend a considerable amount of time with their mother's parents in northern NSW.[3]

The death of his mother had interrupted his early education at a Christian Brothers' convent in Toowoomba and led to Campbell continuing his studies at a college in Lismore, NSW.[4] Campbell completed his education at Downlands College, Toowoomba, becoming the College's first Open Scholar in the late 1930s,[5] having already been named dux of the College twice and earning the highest grade in Queensland for Senior Latin.[6]

University and military service[edit]

Campbell attended the University of Queensland from 1940 with an interruption to his studies the following year to take up service in the Royal Australian Air Force (RAAF).[5] In his first year at the University of Queensland, Campbell became editor of the student paper Semper Floreat,[5] before becoming President of the University of Queensland Union. He graduated in 1948 with first class honours in Law in 1948, having already gained a Master of Arts the previous year.[7] He passed his pilot's examination at Amberley Air Base on 7 December 1941 and was assigned to the 67th Reserve Squadron of the RAAF, which patrolled Australia's eastern coast.[8] He became a Flight Instructor and was based in Tasmania, badly injuring his knee in a biplane crash.[9] After his recovery, the RAAF put Campbell in command of a Liberator Base in the Darling Downs.[9]

Legal career[edit]

Campbell was admitted to the Bar in 1948 and became a Queen's Counsel in 1960. His practice took him as high in the legal world as the Privy Council in London, before which he appeared on several occasions.[10] He became a member of the Law Faculty Board at the University of Queensland in 1954.[10] Campbell himself recalled that when he entered the legal profession "there were only about seventy barristers in private practice in Queensland",[11] contrasting this number with the increase that had taken place by the time he was Governor of Queensland. In 1965, Campbell became President of the Queensland Association, holding this position simultaneously with the presidency of the national equivalent from 1966 to 1967.[10] As a matter of some historical irony, Campbell represented Joh Bjelke-Petersen in a failed High Court appeal against the Australian Taxation Office in 1959.[12]

Judiciary[edit]

In 1967, Campbell gained a position on the bench of the Supreme Court of Queensland. In the late 1960s and early 1970s Campbell would meet with other Justices in Canberra when they had been summoned to various board and committee meetings and discuss various issues facing the judiciary ranging from problems with sentencing to the difficulty of persuading eminent lawyers to enter the judiciary.[13] The issue of lawyers being unwilling to move from the Bar to the Bench remained a concern to Campbell even after he had left the judiciary and become Governor.[13]

In 1982, the incumbent Chief and Puisne Justices of Queensland were scheduled to retire, having reached the mandatory age of 70.[14] Campbell became the centre of a controversy, as he was chosen to fill the Chief Justiceship instead of Jim Douglas, the favoured candidate of the Liberal Party.[15] Joh Bjelke-Petersen admitted to choosing Campbell as a "compromise candidate" to Justice Douglas and his own preferred Chief Justice, Dormer Andrews.[15] The retiring Chief Justice declared that he had nothing against Campbell personally, but that he found the treatment of Douglas "unjust and unsatisfactory".[14] Campbell emerged largely unscathed from the controversy, but did clash at times with the Bjelke-Petersen government as Chief Justice, criticising the legal integrity of certain legislation when he found it necessary.[16] He was also noted as having contributed significantly to the modernisation of the Court in Queensland during his time as Chief Justice.[16]

Chancellor[edit]

Having been a member of the University of Queensland Senate since 1963,[17] Campbell was well established within the activities of the University. In 1977 he became Chancellor of the University, holding the position for nine years until 1985. As Chancellor, Campbell criticised the method of admitting people into tertiary student positions, claiming some reform was needed.[10] There was also controversy in this period when the government forced the University publishers to withdraw the second volume of Ross Fitzgerald's History of Queensland, and the university awarded an honorary doctorate of law to Premier Bjelke-Petersen.[10]

Governor[edit]

Campbell succeeded Sir James Ramsay as Governor of Queensland on 22 July 1985. There has been some conjecture that the Bjelke-Petersen government may have elevated Campbell to this position to remove him from the Chief Justiceship.[10][16]All of the controversies surrounding Campbell appear to be merely projections of the very controversies affecting Joh Bjelke-Petersen and his government, with Campbell's inauguration as Governor attracting complaint from the Queensland Trades and Labour Council that they had been ostracised from the swearing-in ceremony due to political manoeuvring by the State Government.[18]

This tradition of controversy involving Campbell and the government came to crisis in 1987 when there was internal strife within the National Party between Bjelke-Petersen and his cabinet which almost caused a constitutional crisis in Queensland governance. There had already been murmurs in early 1987 of a vice-regal intervention in Queensland politics when The Australian newspaper in March featured a front page article detailing the threat by State Opposition leader Nev Warburton to ask Governor Campbell to dismiss the Bjelke-Petersen ministry over allegations of illegal conduct by the Government.[19] These suggestions came to nothing. However, later in the year when Bjelke-Petersen lost the confidence of his cabinet, the question was again raised as to what role Campbell as Governor would play in the event of a constitutional crisis.

On 23 November 1987, Premier Bjelke-Petersen visited Campbell at Government House to discuss a restructuring of his ministry.[20] It was Bjelke-Petersen's wish to dissolve his entire ministry and be recommissioned as Premier with a new distribution of ministerial portfolios, however Campbell's advice was for the Premier to seek the individual resignations of those ministers he wanted removed from the ministry.[20] After having approached five ministers about resigning from their offices and being refused by each one, the Premier returned to Campbell on 24 November and requested the termination of the commissions of three of the five ministers, to which Campbell agreed.[20] While the government's problems were already serious, the difficulty for Campbell began on 26 November, when one of the dismissed ministers, Mike Ahern, became Leader of the Parliamentary National Party and wrote to Campbell seeking a new commission that would replace Bjelke-Petersen as Premier with Ahern.[21] As the Sydney Morning Herald had succinctly described the situation, Queensland now had a "Premier who is not leader" and the National Party a "Leader who is not Premier".[22] There was a tense period where Bjelke-Petersen refused to resign his commission and Campbell refused to prematurely terminate it. The legal advice Campbell had received dictated that his course of action should be to only contemplate dismissing Bjelke-Petersen without the Premier's consent if he refused to resign after failing a vote of no confidence,[23] however there were also fears that the Premier might advise Campbell to dissolve Parliament and call elections.[23][24] Some sections of the press attacked Campbell for his apparent inactivity during the crisis, while other voices within the legal and political world supported his course of action.[25] It was Bjelke-Petersen's eventual resignation, effective from 1 December, that ended the crisis,[26] with Campbell receiving the subsequent praise of many in the media for his handling of the undesirable situation.[27]

In March 1988, Campbell gave a lecture on The Role of a State Governor to the Royal Australian Institute of Public Administration, Queensland Division, in which he described the various functions carried out by state governors, the legal and constitutional framework of the office and numerous historical accounts of different situations involving vice-regal figures in Queensland and other Commonwealth domains.

The Brisbane Expo of 1988 also technically brought a short respite to Campbell's vice-regal duties as Queen Elizabeth was present in Queensland for the official opening and would have been capable of performing any of the functions of the Crown should the government have wished.

Retirement[edit]

After seven years as Governor, Campbell retired in July 1992.[28] He did not retire quietly, continuing to speak at various functions and publicly opposing Paul Keating's push for an Australian republic in 1993 by writing to the British newspaper The Daily Telegraph.[29] He continued his advocacy for the monarchy later that year when launching the second volume of "Upholding the Australian Constitution", stating, "republicanism I think is being used by certain people as a pretext or as a blind or a screen to conceal a deeper purpose or purposes".[30]

Personal[edit]

Campbell married Georgina Pearce in 1942,[16] and fathered three children, Deborah, Peter and Wallace Campbell.[31][32] He resided with his family in Clayfield, Brisbane while a member of the Supreme Court judiciary and retired to Ascot after leaving Government House.[33] He died at age 83, in his home on 4 September 2004 after a short period of illness.[34]

Honours[edit]

Walter Campbell was appointed a Knight Bachelor in 1979.[35] He was appointed a Companion of the Order of Australia (AC) in 1989.[36] On 1 January 2001, he was awarded the Centenary Medal.[37]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Barlow & Corkery, (2007)
  2. ^ Angus Innes, "Sir Walter Campbell", Shoulder to Shoulder: The Journal of the Society of St. Andrew of Scotland (QLD): (Brisbane: Society of St. Andrew of Scotland, February 2000) 9–24.
  3. ^ Angus Innes, "Sir Walter Campbell Pt. 2", Shoulder to Shoulder: The Journal of the Society of St. Andrew of Scotland (QLD), (Brisbane: Society of St. Andrew of Scotland, June 2000).
  4. ^ Barlow & Corkery (2007), p.2
  5. ^ a b c Innes "Sir Walter Campbell Pt. 2."
  6. ^ St. John's Cathedral – Paul de Jersey, State funeral service for the Honourable Sir Walter Benjamin Campbell AC QC, 4 March 1921 – 4 September 2004 (Brisbane: Queensland Government, 2004): 4.
  7. ^ St. John's Funeral for Walter Campbell, 4.
  8. ^ Royal Australian Air Force, Amberley Air Field during World War II: War in the Pacific http://home.st.net.au/~dunn/airfields/amberley.htm
  9. ^ a b Barlow & Corkery (2007), pp.3–4
  10. ^ a b c d e f "Former Governor no stranger to disputes" Courier Mail 7 September 2004.
  11. ^ Walter Campbell "Opening address to the 30th Legal Symposium" (4 March 1990) in Speeches of Sir Walter Campbell Vol. I Nos. 1–25. Brisbane: Supreme Court Library, 1972–1993.
  12. ^ Rae Wear, Johannes Bjelke-Petersen: The Lord's Premier (Brisbane: University of Queensland Press, 2002): 92.
  13. ^ a b Walter Campbell, "Opening of Conference of Supreme and Federal Court Judges, 25 January 1988": 2 in Speeches of Sir Walter Campbell Vol. I Nos. 1–25. Brisbane: Supreme Court Library, 1972–1993.
  14. ^ a b Courier Mail 18 February 1982
  15. ^ a b Johannes Bjelke-Petersen, Don't you worry about that! The Joh Bjelke-Petersen Memoirs (NSW: Angus & Robertson Australia, 1990) 243.
  16. ^ a b c d Telegraph, 16 September 2004 http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2004/09/17/db1702.xml
  17. ^ University of Queensland "UQ farewells eminent graduate and former Chancellor" http://www.uq.edu.au/update/archive/index.html?page=21935&pid=3684
  18. ^ Courier Mail 23 July 1985.
  19. ^ Barlow & Corkery (2007), p.9
  20. ^ a b c Walter Campbell "Letter from Governor Walter Campbell to Premier Bjelke Petersen, 25 November 1987," 1 in Walter Campbell, Johannes Bjelke Petersen & Michael J. Ahern, Copies of correspondence relating to the change-over from the Bjelke-Petersen government to the Ahern government in late 1987. (Brisbane: Queensland Government, 1988).
  21. ^ Michael J. Ahern, "Letter from Parliamentary Leader of the State Parliamentary National Party Mike Ahern to His Excellency Governor Walter Campbell on 26 November 1987," in Walter Campbell, Johannes Bjelke Petersen & Michael J. Ahern, Copies of correspondence relating to the change-over from the Bjelke-Petersen government to the Ahern government in late 1987. (Brisbane: Queensland Government, 1988).
  22. ^ Peter Bowers and Greg Roberts, 'Ahern leads, but Joh rules', Sydney Morning Herald, 27 November 1987. Cited in Barlow & Corkery (2007), p.23
  23. ^ a b "Memorandum from the Solicitor General, 26 November 1987," Section 7, in Walter Campbell, Johannes Bjelke Petersen & Michael J. Ahern, Copies of correspondence relating to the change-over from the Bjelke-Petersen government to the Ahern government in late 1987 (Brisbane: Queensland Government, 1988).
  24. ^ "Correspondence between Dr. Christopher D. Gilbert and Cleary & Hoare Solicitors," in Walter Campbell, Johannes Bjelke Petersen & Michael J. Ahern, Copies of correspondence relating to the change-over from the Bjelke-Petersen government to the Ahern government in late 1987 (Brisbane: Queensland Government, 1988).
  25. ^ Barlow & Corkery (2007), pp.23–25
  26. ^ "Letter from Sir Joh Bjelke Petersen to His Excellency Governor Walter Campbell submitting resignation of himself and Ministry, 30 November 1987," in Walter Campbell, Johannes Bjelke Petersen & Michael J. Ahern, Copies of correspondence relating to the change-over from the Bjelke-Petersen government to the Ahern government in late 1987. (Brisbane: Queensland Government, 1988).
  27. ^ Barlow & Corkery (2007), pp.28–29.
  28. ^ St. John's Funeral for Walter Campbell, 2.
  29. ^ Australian League of Rights, "Former Governor challenges Keating," On Target Vol. 29 No. 32 (1993). http://www.alor.org/Volume29/Vol29No32.htm
  30. ^ "Launch of Upholding the Australian Constitution – Vol. 2, Samuel Griffith Society, 26 October 1993," 2–3 in Walter Campbell Speeches of Sir Walter Campbell
  31. ^ St. John's Funeral for Walter Campbell, 1.
  32. ^ Patricia Kelly, "Lady Georgina Campbell," The Courier Mail 4 November 2006.
  33. ^ W.J. Draper, Who's Who in Australia 1983 24th Edition (Melbourne: Crown Content) 2004: 391.
  34. ^ Courier Mail 6 September 2004.
  35. ^ It's an Honour: Knight Bachelor
  36. ^ It's an Honour: AC
  37. ^ It's an Honour: Centenary Medal

Further reading[edit]

External links[edit]

Legal offices
Preceded by
Charles Wanstall
Chief Justice of Queensland
1982–1985
Succeeded by
Dormer Andrews
Government offices
Preceded by
Sir James Ramsay
Governor of Queensland
1985–1992
Succeeded by
Leneen Forde