Walter of St Victor
Nothing is known about Walter except that, in about the year 1175, he was prior of St. Victor's Abbey, Paris; that about the time of the Third Lateran Council (1179) he wrote the celebrated polemic, Contra quatuor labyrinthos Franciae; and that he died about the year 1180.
César-Egasse du Boulay in his "Hist. Univ. Paris." (1665) first called attention to Walter's treatise Contra quatuor labyrinthos Franciae (Against the Four Labyrinths of France) and published excerpts from it.
The "four labyrinths" against whom the work is directed are four of the major masters of early scholastic thought: Abelard, Gilbert de la Porrée, Peter Lombard, and Peter of Poitiers. It is a bitter attack on the dialectical method in theology, and condemns the use of logic in the elucidation of the mysteries of faith.
Walter is indignant at the thought of treating the mysteries of the Trinity and the Incarnation "with scholastic levity". Discarding the best traditions of the School of St-Victor, he pours abuse on the philosophers, the theologians, and even the grammarians. "Thy grammar be with thee until perdition", he cries. This violence, however, defeated his purpose, which was to discredit the dialecticians.
Not only did he fail to convince his contemporaries, but he very probably hastened the triumph of the method which he attacked. Four years after his polemic was published, Peter of Poitiers, one of the "labyrinths", was raised by the pope to the dignity of Chancellor of the Diocese of Paris, and before the end of the decade Peter Lombard, another of the "Labyrinths", was recognized as an authority in theology, his method adopted in the schools, and his famous Books of Sentences used as a text and commented on by all the great teachers — a distinction which it retained all through the thirteenth century.
Some of Walter's sermons also survive.
- Denifle described the manuscript and Geyer published a critical text of the second book, with the text then being published in Patrologia Latina 194. The Latin text of the work is reproduced in Pierre Glorieux, ‘Le Contra quatuor labyrinthos Franciae de Gauthier de Saint-Victor’, Archives d’histoire doctrinale et littéraire du moyen âge 27, (1952), 187-335.
- Jean Châtillon, ed, Galteri a Sancto Victore et quorundam aliorum, Sermones ineditos tringinta sex, (Turnhout: Brepols, 1975)
- Alexander Murray, Suicide in the Middle Ages (1998), vol. 1 p.38: "At one point, punning with Latin terms, he compares the self-killer unfavourably with the fratricida, an established Latin word." This is in Quatuor labyrinthos, in a critique of the pagan Seneca.