Warren Cup

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
The Warren Cup
Warren Cup BM GR 1999.4-26.1 n1.jpg
Warren Cup, side A
Exhibition video, Nottingham University 2011
Material Silver
Size height:11 cm (4.3 in), width:9.9 cm (3.9 in) (max.), depth:11 cm (4.3 in)
Created Roman, AD 5–15
Present location Room 70, British Museum, London
Identification GR 1999,0426.1

The Warren Cup is an silver drinking cup decorated in relief with two images of male same-sex acts. It was purchased by the British Museum for 1.8 million pounds in 1999, the most expensive single purchase by the museum at that time. It is usually dated to the time of the Julio-Claudian dynasty (1st century AD), though doubts have been raised about its authenticity.[1]

The cup is named after its first modern owner, Edward Perry Warren, notable for the legacy of his art collection which included Rodin's The Kiss statue and Cranach's Adam and Eve painting as well as the controversially homoerotic Warren Cup.[2]

Imagery[edit]

Warren Cup, side B
Warren Cup, showing musical instruments.

Representations of sexual acts are widely found in Roman art, although in contrast to Greek art, surviving male-female scenes greatly outnumber same-sex couples. It cannot be assumed that homoerotic art was uncommon as the modern record may be biased due to selective destruction or non-publication of pedrastic works in later times.[3] Illustrated drinking cups, often in pairs, were intended as dinner-party conversation pieces.[4] Roman artwork on pottery, glass and wall-paintings with sexual acts represented were popular and were intended to be seen by all sections of society. The Romans had no word for homosexuality and the images on the Warren Cup provide an important insight into this aspect of their culture.[5]

One side of the Warren Cup depicts men engaging in anal sex in a reclining position, with the upper man lowering himself using a rope or support from the ceiling to be penetrated. A boy watches from behind a door.[6] The two figures do not appear to be a great difference in age and are of a similar size, though the lower figure has a close cropped beard.[7] The apparent weight of the upper figure, as he lowers himself onto his lover's penis using the support, makes this a non-traditional passive role. The use of a strap or support during sex can be found in other Greek and Roman artworks,[8] a close example being an erotic cup by Onesimos where a woman spreads her legs in anticipation while grasping a strap with her left hand.[7][9]

The other side depicts another scene of anal sex, between a clean shaven man and a smaller figure with long hair indicating he is a boy (now the "eromenos").[10] The boy's hairstyle is typical of the puer delicatus, a servant-boy or cup or armour bearer. Roman same-sex practice differed from that of the Greeks, among whom pederasty was a socially acknowledged relationship between freeborn males of equal social status. Roman men, however, were free to engage in same-sex relations without a perceived loss of masculinity only as long as they took the penetrative role and their partner was a social inferior such as a slave or male prostitute: the paradigm of "correct" male sexuality was one of conquest and domination.[11] There are significant differences to pederastic scenes found on classical Greek vases. The sex act is presented graphic detail, and the boy appears to encourage the penetration, grasping his lover's arm. In Greek ideology, the citizen youth would take no pleasure in the passive role and anal intercourse is rarely shown on Attic pottery. In Roman artwork there is an assumption that the penetrated youth is a slave or prostitute and on the Warren Cup, a mutual tenderness is represented.[3]

Warren Cup side B showing detail for hairstyles and leaf crown.

Both scenes show draped textiles in the background, as well as a cithara (appearing as an eleven stringed lyre, often symbolic of pleasure and drinking parties[12]) in the former scene and tibiae (reeded pipes) with finger holes being depicted in the latter.[13][14] These, along with the careful delineation of ages and status and the wreaths worn by the youths, all suggest a cultured, elite, Hellenized setting with music and entertainment.[15][16]

The active partners in the two sexual depictions are wearing leaf crowns, likely to be symbolically made from myrtle.[13][17] Myrtle is an evergreen shrub, grown in the Roman period for medical and ritual purposes, such as weddings, and dedicated to Venus, the Roman goddess of sexuality and love. It has a smaller leaf than the more commonly depicted laurel. Myrtle was used to create the corona ovalis, a military crown awarded as an ovation but a far lesser award than the insignis corona triumphalis, one interpretation of the use of myrtle crowns on the Warren Cup, being a visual pun of homosexual penetration as an easy victory.[13]

Modern provenance[edit]

View of the figure in the doorway

Warren purchased the cup in Rome from a dealer in 1911 for £2,000.[18][19][20] It was bought in Jerusalem and said to have been found near the city in Battir[21] (ancient Bethther), with coins of the emperor Claudius, possibly buried during the upheavals of the Jewish Revolt.

We don't know for certain, but it's thought that the Warren Cup was found buried at Bittir, a town a few miles south-west of Jerusalem. How it got to this location is a mystery, but we can make a guess. We can date the making of the cup to around the year 10. About 50 years later, the Roman occupation of Jerusalem sparked tensions between the rulers and the Jewish community, and in AD 66 that exploded and the Jews took back the city by force. There were violent confrontations, and it is thought that our cup may have been buried at this date by the owner fleeing from the fighting.

Neil MacGregor, British Museum Director, A History of the World[21]

The cup became a prized item in Warren's large art collection, referring to it with friends as the "Holy Grail".[18] The first publication featuring the cup was in 1921, when Gaston Vorberg published a volume of 113 plates of erotic artwork from ancient artefacts. The photographs show the cup in an uncleaned state.[7][22] The cup was included in Warren's book "A defence of Uranian Love", first published in 1928 under his pseudonym of Arthur Lyon Raile.[20][23][24]

On Warren's death in 1928, the cup became part of the inheritance for Asa Thomas, Warren's male secretary and eventual business partner. It was part of the auction of the contents of Lewes House[25] in 1929, but failed to sell and stayed hidden away in Thomas' attic.[18] The cup was sent for cleaning after the Lewes House auction and photographs taken of the cup in 1931 show that it had been cleaned before that year.[7][18]

In November 1952 Harold W. Parsons, an art historian[26] and one of Warren's past companions, took responsibility for selling the cup and approached the New York collector Walter Baker,[27] however Baker was hesitant to proceed.[18] In February 1953 it was posted by Thomas to Walter Baker, however US Customs impounded the box requiring a decision from Washington to admit it as pornography, it was refused entry to the US on this basis and took until October 1954 to be returned to the UK, by which time Thomas had died. After this event, a number of museums declined to buy it.[28][29] Thomas' widow sold the cup to the dealer John K. Hewett. Hewett offered the cup to Denys Haynes, Keeper of the Greek and Roman department at the British Museum who then sought an opinion from his friend Lord Crawford, a trustee of the museum. However the decision went no further as they thought that they would never persuade the museum's trustees who were chaired by the Archbishop of Canterbury.[7][18]

In 1966 the Cup was offered for sale at £6,000 and bought by a private collector abroad.[18][30]

In 1998 it was removed from the Metropolitan Museum of Art and sold to a British private collector.[18] The cup was then acquired by its present owner, the British Museum, in 1999 for £1.8 million, with funds provided by the Heritage Lottery Fund, National Art Collections Fund and The British Museum Friends, to prevent its going abroad again.[31] This was, at that time, the most expensive single item ever acquired by the British Museum, and many times the price at which it had been offered to them in the 1950s.[29][32]

Dating[edit]

Hoby silver skyphoi, dated to AD 10–20, showing nude male figures in relief similar to the Warren Cup.

John Clarke, Professor in Fine Arts at the University of Texas at Austin, has approximated the dating of the cup with similarly styled objects found in Pompeii, due to the lack of archaeological context.[33]

Dyfri Williams, previously the Keeper of Greek and Roman Antiquities at the British Museum, dated the cup to AD 5–15. Williams identified several factors supporting this dating. The silver alloy being 95% pure is consistent with other known Roman silver vessels, with silver from later periods having a far higher purity. Cracks in the cup retain chemical corrosion products which are symptomatic of age, remaining despite being cleaned twice during the 20th century.[34] The decorative style and shape have a close parallel with many other vessels of the period, such as the Chryses kantharos[35] and the closely matching figures of nude men on the Hoby skyphoi, discovered a decade after the Warren cup was first recorded.[36][37]

In 2008, Maria Teresa Marabini Moevs argued in an article for Bollettino d'Arte that the Warren Cup is not in fact a Roman product of the early Imperial period, but rather was executed around 1900 by a gifted silversmith trained in the contemporary Liberty style, perhaps commissioned by the amateur archaeologist and dealer Fausto Benedetti (1874–1931), to meet what he knew to be the taste of his foreign client and friend Edward Perry Warren. Benedetti may have worked in collaboration with the Castellani brothers of Rome, who were leading goldsmiths in classical styles, and collectors and dealers in antiquities. Moevs, an authority on Roman pottery, claims that the images on the cup derive from fragments of several scenes on Greek and Roman ceramics, including some in the Castellani collection, which were combined and modified to create the scenes on the Warren cup. An appendix to that article by silversmith Claudio Franchi provides corroborating technical evidence.[38]

Luca Giuliani, a professor of classical archaeology at Humboldt University, has argued that the Warren cup was likely to be a 20th-century fake, on the basis of the unique subject matter and several incoherences in the iconography.[39][40] At a King's College seminar on 12 March 2014, where counter-arguments were put forward by Dyfri Williams, Giuliani conceded that, if the British Museum was to produce evidence for traces of silver chloride corrosion on the inner side of the cup's shell, this would be a decisive argument for the authenticity of the piece.[1][41][42]

Manufacture and condition[edit]

The Warren Cup is an estimated 95% pure silver with some copper and trace amounts of lead and gold.[34] It was made in five sections:[5][28][43]

  1. the main bowl, which was hammered thin from inside and subsequently finished off from the outside to produce the figures in relief;
  2. a separate plain inner liner bowl of thicker sheet silver with a solid rim, to make the cup easier to use and to clean;
  3. a base in solid silver;
  4. a cast foot soldered to the base;
  5. two handles, now missing.

The cup is etched and pitted due to the effect of corrosive cleaning deposits, however remnants of silver chloride and black silver sulphide survive in crevices. A crack runs from the rim, around the figure of the boy on one side. The base is distorted and broken with the pedestal having been pushed up, denting the cup and causing the cup to lean at an angle. The damage to the base was in modern times, thought to have occurred when the cup was cleaned in the 20th century.[44] The foot was soldered back on to the cup in modern times. It is thought that the cup was moulded twice in modern times due to remains of plaster and silicone rubber found in crevices.[45]

Exhibition history[edit]

During the 1920s, Warren lent the cup to the Martin von Wagner Museum in Wurzburg.[46]

In 1985 through to 1991 the Warren Cup was on loan and on display by the Antikenmuseum Basel und Sammlung Ludwig, Basel. From 1992 to 1998, the cup was put on display at Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York as an anonymous loan.[7][45]

It was the subject of a devoted exhibition in Room 3 at the British Museum from 11 May to 2 July 2006, entitled "The Warren Cup: Sex and society in ancient Greece and Rome."

We wanted to show this fantastic object in a context in which we could ask how much we understand about attitudes to sexuality when it was made. These objects seem extraordinary to us now, but there were many objects in common use, and wall paintings and mosaics in baths and in private houses, showing very similar imagery.

Dyfri Williams, British Museum Keeper[29]

From December 2006 to January 2007 it was exhibited at the Yorkshire Museum.[47] The Warren Cup is the 36th object in A History of the World in 100 Objects, a BBC Radio 4 series first broadcast in 2010.[28] In 2011 (January to April) it was loaned to Nottingham University for an exhibition in the Weston Gallery titled "Roman Sexuality: Images, Myths and Meanings."[48]

In 2012 the cup was exhibited at Plymouth City Museum and Art Gallery in a LGBT "Pride in Our Past Exhibition".[49][50]

An exhibition on the Isle of Wight on "Roman Sexuality: Images, Myths and Meanings" featured the cup in February to July 2014, at the Brading Roman Villa.[51][52][53]

Replicas[edit]

Due to his interest in the cup, Warren had a replica made for John Beazley. The replica was donated to the Ashmolean Museum, Oxford as part of the Beazley Gift in 1966. The replica became a prominent feature in an exhibition at the museum in 1985.[7]

There are six known replicas of the original Warren Cup. In April 2014, a copy owned by an anonymous private collector in Cape Town, South Africa, was stolen.[54]

See also[edit]

Footnotes[edit]

  1. ^ a b "King's College London – The Warren Cup – modern forgery?". Kcl.ac.uk. 13 February 2014. Retrieved 23 May 2014. 
  2. ^ (Williams 2006, p. 31)
  3. ^ a b Skinner, Marilyn B. (2013), Sexuality in Greek and Roman Culture (undefined ed.), John Wiley & Sons, ISBN 9781118611081 
  4. ^ (Pollini 1999, p. 37)
  5. ^ a b "The Warren Cup (highlights)". British Museum. 26 April 1999. Retrieved 25 May 2014. 
  6. ^ (Pollini 1999, pp. 38–39)
  7. ^ a b c d e f g (Clarke 1993)
  8. ^ (Williams 2006, p. 12)
  9. ^ Brendel, Otto (1970), The scope and temperament of erotic art in the Greco-Roman world, Basic Books, p. Fig.19, OCLC 633564109 
  10. ^ (Clarke 1993, p. 275)
  11. ^ (Pollini 1999)
  12. ^ Johnson, Marguerite; Ryan, Terry (2005), Sexuality in Greek and Roman society and literature : a sourcebook, Routledge, p. 134, ISBN 9780415173308 
  13. ^ a b c (Pollini 1999, p. 42)
  14. ^ (Williams 2006, pp. 11–12)
  15. ^ (Pollini 1999, pp. 21–55)
  16. ^ (Clarke 1998, pp. 70–72)
  17. ^ (Williams 2006)
  18. ^ a b c d e f g h (Williams 2006, pp. 25–31)
  19. ^ Ancient West & East, Volume 6, Brill, 2007, p. 447, ISSN 1783-8363, OCLC 637450000 
  20. ^ a b Irving, Mark (13 May 2006). "Perfectly divine: Rome's gay pin-up". The Times. 
  21. ^ a b Neil MacGregor (4 September 2008). "A History of the World – About: Transcripts – Episode 36 – Warren Cup (10:00—10:45)". BBC. Retrieved 28 June 2010. 
  22. ^ Vorberg, Gaston (1921), Die Erotik der Antike in Kleinkunst und Keramik (in German), G. Müller, OCLC 9972870 
  23. ^ Raile, Arthur Lyon (1928), A defence of Uranian love, Private print, OCLC 244481167 
  24. ^ Warren, Edward Perry; Kaylor, Michael Matthew; Miner, Mark Robert (2009), A defence of Uranian love, Valancourt classics, Valancourt Books, ISBN 193455569X 
  25. ^ "The story of Lewes House". Lewes District Council. Retrieved 4 June 2014. 
  26. ^ LIFE, 10 Mar 1961, Vol. 50, No. 10, ISSN 00243019, Published by Time Inc, page 40A.[1]
  27. ^ "Walter C. Baker, financier and art collector, elected Vice-President of Metropolitan Museum". Metropolitan Museum of Art Press Releases. 15 September 1960. Retrieved 4 June 2014. 
  28. ^ a b c Paul Roberts, curator, British Museum. "A History of the World – Object: Warren Cup". BBC. Retrieved 10 June 2010. 
  29. ^ a b c Kennedy, Maev (12 May 2006). "British Museum exhibition reveals saucy side of the ancient world". The Observer. 
  30. ^ "The Warren Cup". The Times. 12 May 1999. "Mr Sandy Martin, McWhirter Works of Art: In the early 1960s I bought the Warren Cup, a Roman silver wine goblet (report and photograph, May 5), and offered it for sale at £6,000. In those days (before the enactment of the Wolfenden report) the homosexual scenes decorating the cup precluded its acquisition by any museum and most collectors. Now, thirty-five years or so later, it is being acquired by the nation for Pounds 1.8 million and its true "value" as a work of art is now realised." 
  31. ^ "The secrets of Cupboard 55". The Telegraph. 19 June 1999. 
  32. ^ Nigel, Reynolds (5 May 1999). "Gay loving cup bought by museum for £1.8m". The Electronic Telegraph (1440). 
  33. ^ (Clarke 1998)
  34. ^ a b (Williams 2006, p. 7)
  35. ^ British museum, GR 1960,0201.1
  36. ^ "The silver cups from Hoby". National Museum of Denmark. 22 May 2014. Retrieved 3 June 2014. 
  37. ^ (Williams 2006, pp. 45–47)
  38. ^ Moevs, M.T. Marabini (October–December 2008), "Per una storia del gusto: riconsiderazioni sul Calice Warren", Bollettino d'Arte 146, Ministero per i Beni e le Attività Culturali, pp. 1–16 
  39. ^ Lepper, Marcel; Schlak, Stephan; Ritter, Henning; Bohrer, Karl Heinz (2013), "Luca Giuliani: Ein Kelch für Mr. Warren", Zeitschrift für Ideengeschichte Heft VII/3 Herbst 2013 Konservative Ästhetik (in German), München C.H.Beck, pp. 77–92, ISBN 3406649904 
  40. ^ £1.8m Roman goblet bought by Britain is branded a fake: German archaeologist challenges British Museum's view that drinking vessel dates from the first century, Dalya Alberge, 12 March 2014, The Daily Mail
  41. ^ Dalya Alberge. "German archaeologist suggests British Museum's Warren Cup could be forgery | Science". The Guardian. Retrieved 23 May 2014. 
  42. ^ Tronchin, Francesca (14 March 2014). "New questions on the authenticity of the Warren Cup". Tronchin. Archived from the original on 5 May 2014. Retrieved 4 June 2014. 
  43. ^ How they would have appeared can be seen in an intact example of a skyphos from the Getty Museum.
  44. ^ (Williams 2006, p. 13)
  45. ^ a b "The Warren Cup". British Museum. Retrieved 26 May 2014. 
  46. ^ (Clarke 1993, p. 276)
  47. ^ "Warren Cup on show in York". York Press. 28 November 2006. Retrieved 10 June 2010. 
  48. ^ "Nottingham to host the Warren Cup in a major exhibition of Roman artefacts". University of Nottingham. 12 January 2011. Retrieved 26 May 2014. 
  49. ^ "Plymouth LGBT History – LGBT Exhibition". Lgbt-history.prideinplymouth.org.uk. 28 April 2012. Retrieved 26 May 2014. 
  50. ^ "Pride in Our Past Exhibition 2012 – a gallery on Flickr". Flickr.com. Retrieved 26 May 2014. 
  51. ^ "Roman 'sex goblet' comes to island". BBC. 14 February 2014. Retrieved 26 May 2014. 
  52. ^ Roman Sexuality (poster), Brading Roman Villa, 2014, archived from the original on 26 May 2014 
  53. ^ Crossley, Lucy (27 March 2014). "Awkward moment for Edward! Prince keeps a straight face while viewing ancient artifacts during a tour of exhibition on Roman sexuality". Daily Mail. Archived from the original on 28 March 2014. 
  54. ^ Oktober, Dylan (4 April 2014). "Treasured silver cup disappears". IOL. Retrieved 30 May 2014. 

References[edit]

  • Clarke, John R (1998), Looking at lovemaking : constructions of sexuality in Roman art, 100 B.C.-A.D. 250, University of California Press, ISBN 9780585327136 
  • Clarke, John R. (June 1993), "The Warren Cup and the Contexts for Representations of Male-to-Male Lovemaking in Augustan and Early Julio-Claudian Art", The Art Bulletin (College Art Association), 75, No. 2: 275–294, JSTOR 3045949 
  • Pollini, John (1999), The Warren Cup: Homoerotic Love and Symposial Rhetoric in Silver, The Art bulletin. 81, no. 1: College Art Association of America, doi:10.2307/3051285, ISSN 0004-3079 
  • Williams, Dyfri (2006), The Warren Cup, British Museum objects in focus, The British Museum Press, ISBN 9780714122601 

Further reading[edit]

  • Williams, Dyfri (1999), "The Warren silver cup", British Museum Magazine, th-12, 35 (Autumn/Winter 1999): 25–28 
  • Sox, David (1991), Bachelors of art: Edward Perry Warren & the Lewes House brotherhood, Fourth Estate, ISBN 9781872180113 

External links[edit]

This article is about an item held in the British Museum. Object reference: GR 1999,0426.1.