We Are the World 25 for Haiti (YouTube edition)
|"We Are the World 25 for Haiti (YouTube Edition)"|
|Single by 57 YouTube musicians|
|Released||February 20, 2010|
(360p, 480p, 720p-HD)
|Producer(s)||Lisa Lavie (collaboration) /
Lisa Lavie and Iman Crosson (co-editing)
|"We Are the World 25 For Haiti (YouTube Edition)" on YouTube|
"We Are the World 25 for Haiti (YouTube Edition)" is a collaborative charity song and music video produced by singer-songwriter Lisa Lavie and posted to the YouTube video sharing website to raise money for victims of the January 12, 2010 Haiti earthquake. It was created as a response to the celebrity remake "We Are the World 25 for Haiti" that was released eight days earlier, and is a cover of "We Are the World", the 1985 charity single produced in support of famine relief in Africa. The participants include America's Got Talent season 4 contestant and American Idol season 10 finalist Thia Megia and America's Got Talent season 1 contestant and American Idol season 11 finalist Jessica Sanchez.
Making the video
Lavie conceived, organized, performed in, and with fellow YouTube personality Iman Crosson, co-edited, the video for charity relief of victims of the 2010 Haiti earthquake occurring the month before.
Lavie said that she “was in the car driving and the idea to do a YouTube version of We Are the World popped into (her) head." She determined how to assign portions of the song to respective YouTube singers, by "going to each singer’s (YouTube) channel and listen(ing) to their voices to get a better idea of how high or low a singer could sing, if a particular part would sound better with their tonal quality, etc."
In interviews on CNN and ABC World News, Lavie explained how the video was made, given that its 57 contributors would not be performing in the same studio and generally did not even know each other. After deciding on the assignments of singers to song segments, she sent all the singers the same instrumental backing. A Radio Canada feature included a video segment of Montréal singer Heidi Jutras' vocal performance, in which she suppressed the instrumental accompaniment by using earphones. The singers then returned their respective vocal video segments to Lavie electronically, for the visual segments to be edited, and the audio to be mixed and edited, over the course of "three days (and) one sleepless night." Lavie specifically pointed out the challenge of mixing the vocal segments, made "tedious" by the segments' different sound levels, recorded in different acoustic environments (bathrooms, kitchens, bedrooms), and made by microphones of different type and quality. The resulting composite vocal and visual segments, combined with the single instrumental backing, constituted the resulting video.
The video was posted as a YouTube "video response" to the 2010 celebrity remake video on YouTube, whose last minute included a video annotation inviting such video responses. CNN's Josh Levs made special note of Lavie's use of YouTube's video annotation feature: her video continually provided successive video annotation hyperlinks to the YouTube channels of the respective contributing singers as their images appeared on-screen throughout the performance.
Called "a massive charity collaboration for the digital age" by CTV's national television program Canada AM, within days after it was posted the video became the subject of media attention, including multiple national television features on CNN and a primetime news feature on ABC World News with Diane Sawyer.
CNN's Josh Levs reported that "a lot of people are telling us that this is better than the celebrity remake. It certainly is a sign of the times and a case of where we are right now." In the second CNN interview that was aired, CNN's Richard Lui remarked "This really is sort of—not to be trite here—we are the world," alluding to the song's title "We Are the World." Levs added that "Richard's exactly right. ... Getting together fifty-seven singers, all over the world, ... and they all made their own recordings, and the world therefore put these different (recordings) together."
Portion of the 2010 YouTube edition:
A crescendo performed by singers Blair Perkins, Maria Zouroudis, and Lisa Lavie
|Problems playing this file? See media help.|
ABC's Diane Sawyer conducted a Skype interview with Lavie, asking her motivation for making the video. Lavie responded that "the way we (singers) give back is by singing." Singer Melissa Polinar explained, "We didn't really do it to compete with the remake," with Lavie emphasizing that the YouTube collaboration "reaches people in a different way."
Hours after ABC News posted the Skype interview online, the collaboration video's participants were recognized as "Persons of the Week" on the nationally televised ABC World News with Diane Sawyer to close the work week on Friday, March 19, 2010. The television broadcast paired segments of celebrity singers' performances with those of YouTube singers who sang the corresponding segments of the song, with Sawyer narrating: "He may not be Lionel Richie, but the fourteen-year old high school student in his bedroom in Perth, Australia, can sing. Instead of Al Jarreau, this manager of a California youth program. In for Michael Jackson, a community college student. Diana Ross has been replaced by a young woman in Montréal singing in her bathroom. And for Dionne Warwick, this receptionist at a hair salon in Santa Barbara." Sawyer's further explanation: "Perfect strangers, perfect harmony, making a joyful sound... in effect saying, we are the world, too... And so (for "Persons of the Week") we choose Lisa Lavie and the singers she brought together around the globe, who proved that that anthem is not just for glittering names."
The day following the ABC World News feature, CNN online posted a supplemental feature that was being broadcast on CNN International: a "YouTube sensation, a new version of the popular song that's attracted more than 1.7 million views—and not a celebrity in sight."
A Radio Canada feature emphasized the divergent sources of the segments constituting the video, noting that some of the 57 contributors sang "in their bedroom, living room or even in their bathroom" but that the result is assez remarquable (quite remarkable).
CNN's Josh Levs explained that "the official YouTube channel of the celebrity version, is now posting this (YouTube collaboration) version there," meaning that a thumbnail photo link to the YouTube collaboration video was displayed as a "Favorite" on the YouTube channel of the We Are The World Foundation adjacent the official celebrity remake video.
Formal recognition of the video included:
- The video's participants were recognized as "Persons of the Week" on ABC World News with Diane Sawyer (March 19, 2010).
- CNN Newsroom's Josh Levs chose the YouTube video as the best viral video of 2010 in its "Viral Video Rewind" feature (December 26, 2010).
- The video was recognized by YouTube's official "TheYearInReview" channel in its "Moments That Defined YouTube in 2010" feature (December 2010).
Reception by viewers
Within five months of being posted, the YouTube video had been viewed over 3.18 million times, had received almost 20,000 comments, had been "favorited" over 48,500 times, and was the seventh most highly rated YouTube Canada music video of all time. On the video's first and second birthdays in 2011 and 2012, respectively, the video had been viewed 4.34 and 5.11 million times.
Contributors to the video
Singers as recited in the order listed in the subject video's description:
- Editors: Lisa Lavie (audio editing), Iman Crosson (video editing)
- Instrumentals: Mike Kalombo
- Ending graphic: Chris Kalombo
- We Are the World
- We Are the World 25 for Haiti
- Charity record
- 2010 Haiti earthquake
- Social impact of YouTube
- Audio mixing (recorded music)
- Internet band
- Lavie's textual video description ("video sidebar") included a link to the website (WebCite archive (2010-07-22)) of the "We Are the World Foundation" for donations.
- Sawyer, Diane, "Persons of the Week" feature, ABC World News with Diane Sawyer (March 19, 2010). National television news feature can be seen in the "Lisa Lavie's Interview with Diane Sawyer on ABC World News" video Video on YouTube posted to YouTube channel LLjustlikeamovie on March 19, 2010 (WebCite archive (2010-07-22)).
- "We Are The World (YouTube Edition) is one of the top 50 videos that defined YouTube for 2010" includes interviews of Lisa Lavie, J. Rice, members of Ahmir (group), and Maria Zouroudis (WebCite archive), The Star Scoop music news section, December 31, 2010.
- Textual transcripts of programs on which the CNN videos aired, are found at "CNN SATURDAY MORNING NEWS" (March 6, 2010; WebCite archive), "CNN NEWSROOM" (March 6, 2010; WebCite archive), and "CNN SUNDAY MORNING" (March 7, 2010; WebCite archive).
- Church, Rosemary (CNN), "We Are the World, part two", CNN Video (international), March 20, 2010.
- "La version revisitée de « WE ARE THE WORLD » sur YOUTUBE", Radio Canada, "Entrevue du mercredi 24 février 2010" (Interview of Wednesday February 24, 2010) (WebCite archive (2010-07-22)).
- Jones, Anthony, "Lisa Lavie And Participants Talk YouTube Version Of 'We Are The World'", gantdaily.com (central Pennsylvania, U.S.), February 23, 2010 (WebCite archive (2010-07-22)). Same article posted on NCbuy.com on same day (WebCite archive (2010-07-22)).
- "YouTubers version of 'We Are the World' goes viral", Star Tribune.com, (Minneapolis-St. Paul, Minnesota, U.S.), March 6, 2010 (downloaded 2010-05-03). (WebCite archive (2010-07-22))
- "YouTube Glossary: Video Responses" (WebCite archive (2010-07-27)) defines "video responses." Clickable thumbnail links of video responses are shown beneath the original video.
- Gundersen, Edna, "Behind the scenes for 'World: 'A good vibe going on'" (WebCite archive), USA Today, February 2, 2010.
- See YouTube's "Getting Started: Creating or editing annotations" (WebCite archive (2010-07-27)) page. Video annotations are usually textual blocks superimposed on the video, and may constitute hyperlinks to other videos or channels.
- "Lisa Lavie 'Angel' Live on CTV's Canada AM" on YouTube video (WebCite archive (2010-07-22)) posted to YouTube channel "LLjustlikeamovie" on July 13, 2010 (downloaded 2010-07-17) (WebCite's archive 2010-07-15).
- "Diane Sawyer gives props to visionary behind YouTube phenom 'We Are the World 25 For Haiti'", (WebCite archive (2010-07-22)), Kindness section of USA Today, March 22, 2010 (USA Today online article includes link to online version of the ABC World News feature three days earlier--WebCite archive (2010-07-22)).
- Custeau, Jonathan (La Tribune), "Une Drummondvilloise dans une vidéo internationale de We Are The World", ("Drummondville Woman in international video of We are the World") (WebCite archive), La Presse (Canadian newspaper), February 27, 2010.
- The Conversation: 'We Are the World' YouTube Edition (ABC World News) (WebCite archive (2010-07-22)) and "Conversation: 'We Are the World' 2.0" (ABC World News Tonight) (WebCite archive (2010-07-22)) show the same informal video feature by Diane Sawyer that was conducted by Skype and posted online March 19, 2010, several hours before the television production broadcast (TV feature is referenced in a separate footnote).
- Huffington Post article, "Lisa Lavie's 'We Are the World YouTube Edition' Keeps Focus on Haiti", March 19, 2010 (downloaded 2010-05-02) (WebCite archive (2010-07-22)).
- WebCite's archive (2010-07-17) of the WeAreTheWorld YouTube Channel. Video thumbnails do not always appear in WebCite archives; favoriting of the collaboration is confirmed in lower left of web page which states "wearetheworld favorited a video (4 months ago)."
- We Are The World Foundation (charitable foundation) website (WebCite archive (2010-07-22)).
- "CNN's Josh Levs picks his favorite Viral Video Rewind highlights of 2010" feature (WebCite archive), under "CNN Newsroom" on CNN.com, and Josh Levs announcement of selection. Textual transcript: "CNN NEWSROOM...Aired December 26, 2010-16:00 ET" (WebCite archive). Television broadcast of December 26, 2010 CNN "Viral Video Rewind" was recorded and uploaded to CNN.com website on December 29, 2010.
- "The Moments That Defined YouTube in 2010" feature (WebCite archive) on YouTube's official "TheYearInReview" channel, mid-December 2010. Find subject video in "February" segment of timeline.
- WebCite's archive (2010-07-15) of the subject video.
- WebCite's archive (2010-07-15) of YouTube's page showing most "favorited" (Canada) music videos of all time.
- WebCite's archive (2010-07-15) of YouTube's page showing most highly rated (Canada) music videos of all time.
- WebCite archives of the video's YouTube page, for 2011-02-20 and 2012-02-20.
- WebCite's archive (2010-12-31) of the subject video.