What Is the Third Estate?
What Is the Third Estate? (French: Qu'est-ce que le tiers-état?) is a pamphlet written by French thinker and clergyman Abbé Emmanuel Joseph Sieyès in January 1789, shortly before the outbreak of the French Revolution. The pamphlet was Sieyès' response to Jacques Necker's invitation for writers to state how they thought the Estates-General should be organized.
In the pamphlet, Sieyès argued that the Third Estate - the common people of France - constituted a complete nation, and would be better off without the "dead weight" of the privileged orders, the First and Second Estates of the clergy and aristocracy. Sieyès stated that the people wanted genuine representatives in the Estates-General, representatives equal to the other two orders taken together, and votes taken by heads and not by orders. These ideas came to have an immense influence on the course of the Revolution.
Contents |
[edit] Summary
The pamphlet is organized around three hypothetical questions and Sieyès' responses. The questions are:
- What is the Third Estate? Everything.
- What has it been until now in the political order? Nothing.
- What does it ask? To become something.
Sieyès continues by analyzing the political situation of the time, arguing that the dominance of the First and Second Estates in the political arena constitutes a monopoly that treats the Third Estate unfairly. He advocates equal representation of all three orders in government, and asserts that taxes and government policy should affect all portions of society equally.
Throughout the pamphlet, Sieyès argues that the First and Second Estates are simply unnecessary, and that the Third Estate is in truth France's only legitimate Estate, representing as it does the entire population. Thus, it should replace the other two Estates entirely.
[edit] Significance
What Is the Third Estate? had a huge influence on the currents of popular thought that contributed to the outbreak of the French Revolution. In his pamphlet, the author outlined the desires and frustrations of the alienated class of people that made up the Third Estate. The author set out to reveal the fraudulent nature of the nobility and the suffering of the overburdened and despondent French people, who he saw as victims of noble parasitism. The pamphlet was essentially the rallying cry that united a voiceless class, whose subjugation by an elitist and self-serving French political culture gave way to an unheard-of political force. The Third Estate came to outline and clearly state grievances that, for the first time, were not to be overlooked in the convocation of the Estates General.
The pamphlet redefined the meaning of “public service” against the conventional wisdom of the time. The aristocracy defined themselves as an elite ruling class charged with the “arduous” task of maintaining the social order in France. On the contrary, Sieyès saw public service as a function performed not by the First or Second Estates but rather solely by the Third Estate. The pamphlet placed sovereignty not in the hands of the idle, self-serving aristocracy, but instead defined the nation of France by its working class, whose economic and social contributions “[were] the activities which support society.”
Furthermore, by defining the Third Estate as the primary mechanism of public service, Sieyès deliberately called into question the role of the aristocracy, portraying them as "foreign" to the national interests of France. The perceived arrogance of the nobles, and their ability to act absolutely and without legal oversight, were the grounds upon which Sieyès justified noble privilege as “treason to the commonwealth” - he effectively established the aristocracy as being an alien body acting outside of the general will and the nation of France. Ironically, it was supposedly for these exact self-serving means that the aristocratic Parlement of Paris pressured King Louis XVI to call the Estates-General in 1788. The resulting conflict between the three Estates inspired the political divisions from which the revolution itself grew.
Perhaps most significant of all was the influence of Sieyès’ pamphlet on the structural concerns that arose surrounding the convocation of the Estates-General. Specifically, the Third Estate demanded their representation be made up of members actually belonging to the Third Estate, that the number of deputies for their order be equal that of the two privileged orders combined, and most controversially, “that the States General Vote, Not by Orders, but by Heads.” The pamphlet took these issues to the masses, and their partial appeasement was met with revolutionary reaction. By addressing the issues of unjust representation directly, Sieyès inspired resentment and agitation that united the Third Estate against the feudalistic traditions of the Ancien Régime.
[edit] See also
- Estates of the realm
- Third World (coined by demograph Alfred Sauvy in 1953 in reference to the French Third Estate and Sieyès' famous saying)
