Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
  (Redirected from Wikipedia:Arbitration committee)
Jump to: navigation, search
For the December 2014 Arbitration Election page, see Arbitration Committee Elections December 2014 (WP:ACE).
For current arbitration proceedings, see Requests or Open Tasks.
"WP:AC" redirects here. For the account creator policy, see Wikipedia:Account creator. For information on autoconfirmed users, see Wikipedia:Autoconfirmed.
All appeals by blocked or banned editors should be sent through the BASC contact page.
Any private material intended for the Committee's attention should be sent through the main contact page.

Please see the Communications and privacy statement below.

The Arbitration Committee is the panel of editors responsible for conducting the Wikipedia arbitration process. It has the authority to impose binding solutions to disputes between editors, primarily for serious conduct disputes the community has been unable to resolve. The arbitration policy describes the Committee's roles and responsibilities in greater detail.

In addition to its role in dispute resolution, the Committee determines which editors have access to CheckUser and Oversight permissions, and considers certain matters where exceptional factors such as privacy preclude a public hearing.

Arbitrators are volunteer users—usually experienced editors and administrators—whom the community of editors at large elects to resolve the most complex or intractable disputes that may arise within the community, and to oversee the few areas where access to non-public information is a prerequisite.


Members

These editors are the elected members of the Arbitration Committee (known as arbitrators). Votes of the committee are taken among the active members. Members are marked active or inactive so that the majority for new votes can be calculated. Members on wikibreak, not participating in arbitration within the past week, or indicating they will be absent are marked inactive.

Members moving back to active may remain inactive on some or all existing business. If you wish to know whether an Arbitrator is active on a particular matter, please ask on their talk page (or check the decision talk page, for cases). The list below is used to determine whether each arbitrator is active by default. Arbitrators who go on to participate in a vote will be counted as active for it even if they are listed as inactive below.

The following list is accurate as of 3 December 2014:

Inactive
  1. Roger Davies (talk · contribs) (mostly inactive on new cases, with effect from 16 Feb)

The Arbitration Committee does not have a chair, but may designate one arbitrator to coordinate timely performance of tasks. The current coordinating arbitrator is Roger Davies.

Subcommittees

Audit Subcommittee

Shortcut:

The Audit Subcommittee (AUSC) investigates complaints concerning the use of CheckUser and Oversight privileges. It consists of three arbitrators (currently LFaraone, NativeForeigner, and Newyorkbrad) and three non-arbitrator community members (currently Callanecc, Joe Decker, and MBisanz).

Ban Appeals Subcommittee

Shortcut:

The Ban Appeals Subcommittee (BASC) considers appeals from users banned or blocked by community processes, usually when all other avenues of appeal have been exhausted. (In contrast, appeals of arbitration sanctions, including arbitration enforcement, are handled by the full committee.) It consists this year of five arbitrators (currently AGK, Beeblebrox, David Fuchs, Seraphimblade, and Worm That Turned).

To appeal a block or ban to the subcommittee, read and follow the instructions on its main page.

Clerks

The Committee's clerk team assists the Committee with procedural tasks, such as opening and closing cases, maintaining arbitration pages, and issuing notifications of decisions. Parties with questions about the arbitration process are encouraged to consult a clerk for assistance.

Contacting the Committee

To appeal a block or ban to the Arbitration Committee's Ban Appeals Subcommittee, e-mail arbcom-appeals-en@lists.wikimedia.org.

For other matters, the arbcom-l mailing list is the primary venue for internal Arbitration Committee discussion on all matters under the Committee's remit. It can also be used by any user as a means of contacting the Committee privately (but see Email and privacy below). The mailing list address is arbcom-l@lists.wikimedia.org. It may also be reached through the "Email this user" feature at "User:Arbitration Committee". All current arbitrators are subscribed to this list, as is project founder Jimbo Wales.

Mailing lists

Shortcut:

In addition to the arbcom-l list, the Committee operates several other official mailing lists:

Mailing list Description
functionaries-en The functionaries-en mailing list is used for general discussion among current Arbitration Committee members, former members in good standing, advanced permission (CheckUser and/or Oversight) operators, and other editors with official Wikimedia Foundation status. Please see the functionary page for more details and a list of subscribers.
arbcom-audit-en The arbcom-audit-en mailing list is used for internal discussion by the Audit Subcommittee. Please see the subcommittee page for more details and a list of subscribers.
arbcom-appeals-en The arbcom-appeals-en mailing list is used for internal discussion by the Ban Appeals Subcommittee. Please see the subcommittee page for more information about the subcommittee.
clerks-l The clerks-l mailing list is used for coordination by the Committee's clerk team. Please see the clerk page for more details and a list of subscribers.
arbcom-en-b and arbcom-en-c The arbcom-en-b and arbcom-en-c mailing lists are secondary mailing lists used instead of arbcom-l "solely for discussions involving (i) the conduct of an arbcom-l subscriber or (ii) cases, broadly defined, to which an arbcom-l subscriber is a party" per Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee/Noticeboard/Archive 5#Motion to establish secondary ArbCom mailing list. It is also used for CheckUser and Oversight applications, and may be used when one or more arbitrators recuse on a case. All arbitrators potentially have access to the archives of this mailing list upon conclusion of the incident that the list was used for.

What happens to incoming ArbCom email?

The committee is not necessarily the most appropriate body for every matter we are contacted about. Therefore, emails are shared with other trusted permissions holders on Wikipedia when, in an arbitrator's judgement, they cannot or must not be handled by the committee alone.

  • Spam:  Almost all incoming email is spam that we delete at moderation. Please include an informative subject line to avoid deletion. Messages are normally acknowledged by an arbitrator within 48 hours.
  • Content change requests:  Referred to OTRS, either by forwarding or by an arbitrator writing back to recommend you send to there.
  • Suppression requests:  Normally forwarded to the Oversight team, unless immediately actioned by an arbitrator.
  • Requests for checkuser/sockpuppetry investigations Normally referred either to the Functionaries mailing list or to an individual checkuser.
  • Legal matters outside ArbCom's scope:  Referred to the WMF Legal and Community Liaison.
  • Threats of harm to self or to others:  Referred to the WMF emergency address, emergency@wikimedia.org.
  • Appeals of blocks or bans directly related to Arbitration Committee decisions or arbitration enforcement Discussed and decided by the full committee.
  • Appeals of community bans or indefinite blocks by administrators:  Forwarded to the BASC mailing list and heard by BASC, or forwarded to the Functionaries.
  • Requests about "checkuser" or "oversighter" blocks or bans:  Appeals heard by the full mailing list, sent to AUSC, or forwarded to the Functionaries.
  • Requests to review actions by checkusers or oversighters:  Referred to the Audit Subcommittee (AUSC).
  • Emails about currently open arbitration cases:  Handled according to the arbitration policy.
  • Emails relating to closed cases:  Normally referred to Arbitration Enforcement unless private or non-public personal information is involved.
  • Other:  Handled on a case-by-case basis, according to applicable policy and convention.

Individual arbitrators

Some individual arbitrators have published their personal email addresses. These should be used sparingly as material intended for the Committee as a whole should instead be sent to arbcom-l at arbcom-l@lists.wikimedia.org.

Communications and privacy

Arbitrators usually seek to treat communications with the committee, including emails, as confidential. That said, we cannot guarantee against public disclosure for a number of reasons, including potential security limitations. Accordingly, you should not disclose sensitive personal information in your communications with us.

Once received, your communications may be shared with committee members and – in some limited cases – with third parties as deemed appropriate. Your communications may be archived indefinitely and made available to future members of the committee.

Your email address may contain personal information that could reveal your real-life identity. Many people create email accounts specifically for Wikipedia use. Further information about safeguarding your privacy may be found at On privacy and How to not get outed on Wikipedia.