Wikipedia:WikiProject Aviation/AfD record

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
  Main   Participants   Page content   Templates   Categories   New articles   AfD record   Notability  
Other project AfD record pages: Aviation · Aircraft (Engines) · Airlines (Defunct) · Airports · Gliding · Aerospace biography · Air sports · Aviation accident · Military aviation · Rotorcraft


One of the unintended consequences of Articles for Deletion (AfD) discussions is a sense of community consensus on things like notability. As we build our guidelines, referring back to old closed AfDs can be helpful, and thus this record of closed AfDs for reference.

This list may also include articles which had Speedy Deletion ("Speedy") or Proposed Deletion ("PROD") requests added directly to the article without an AfD discussion.

The entries in the following table are transcluded from four WikiProject AfD lists, therefore any changes must be made at one of the following pages:

Wrightflyer thumb.jpg Participants are encouraged to visit the Assessment Department to help clear the backlog of Unassessed articles or assess an article specifically requested here. Please participate !
Article/AfD Nominator Opened Closed Result Comments
Aircraft


List of military aircraft by era MilborneOne 2010-04-20 2010-04-27 Delete
P-47 Thunderbolt survivors Davegnz 2008-09-29 2008-09-30 Keep
Surviving aircraft Twas Now 2008-09-09 2008-09-13 Keep
Jet upset Stifle 2008-08-11 2008-08-16 Keep
Lockheed XF-104 Chergles 2007-10-16 2007-10-17 Keep
Airports
Combs Field Airport Canglesea 2009-11-06 2009-11-29 Delete Former, non-notable, private airfield
Waldorf International Airport Dramatic 2009-07-04 2009-07-05 Delete Hoax
Avi Suquilla Airport 75.209.208.239 2009-07-01 2009-07-01 Keep Speedy deletion request removed by Jredmond
Avi Suquilla Airport Jdavalos 2009-06-30 2009-06-30 Keep Speedy deletion request, removed by Dpmuk
Malmen Airbase T96 grh 2009-02-01 2009-02-02 Keep Proposed deletion, removed by DGG
Kaben Airport Undead warrior 2008-12-28 2009-01-07 Merge to Kaben see Airport article prior to AfD
Republic Helicopters Heliport WhisperToMe 2008-12-22 2008-12-27 Delete Proposed deletion
Ridge Landing Airpark Dismas 2008-11-21 2008-12-01 No consensus Airport with one 3000 x 125 ft. runway, no SIAPs, private use, private owned, (4FL5)
Spruce Creek Fly-In Dismas 2008-11-20 2008-11-24 Keep No coverage in secondary sources. No notability.
Ridge landing Dismas 2008-11-05 2008-11-06 Speedy delete (G11: Blatant advertising) Airport with one 3000 x 125 ft. runway, no SIAPs, private use, private owned, (4FL5)
Pier 126 Heliport Undead warrior 2008-10-15 2008-10-19 Delete Non-notable heliport.
Croman Heliport Undead warrior 2008-10-13 2008-10-18 Merge to Croman Corporation Non-notable heliport.
Erickson Air-Crane Admin Offices Heliport Undead warrior 2008-10-10 2008-10-14 Redirect to Erickson Air-Crane Non-notable heliport.
St. Elizabeth Hospital Heliport (2nd nomination) Undead warrior 2008-10-10 2008-10-14 No consensus, merged to St. Elizabeth Health Services Non-notable heliport.
Amargosa Airport (California) Ikluft 2008-10-07 2008-10-12 Delete Proposed deletion, private-use
Bonny Doon Village Airport Ikluft 2008-10-07 2008-10-12 Delete Proposed deletion, private-use
Borrego Air Ranch Ikluft 2008-10-07 2008-10-12 Delete Proposed deletion, private-use
Likely Airport (California) Ikluft 2008-10-07 2008-10-12 Delete Proposed deletion, private-use
Majors Airport (California) Ikluft 2008-10-07 2008-10-12 Delete Proposed deletion, private-use
San Rafael Airport (California) Ikluft 2008-10-07 2008-10-12 Delete Proposed deletion, private-use
List of private-use airports in California Ikluft 2008-10-07 2008-10-12 Delete
Davis Heliport Undead Warrior 2008-10-03 2008-10-08 Delete
Reforestation Services Heliport Undead Warrior 2008-10-01 2008-10-09 Delete AfD relisted 2008-10-05
Brownlee Heliport Undead Warrior 2008-10-01 2008-10-06 Redirect to Brownlee Dam
Winston-Dillard Fire District Station Number 2 Heliport Undead Warrior 2008-10-01 2008-10-05 Delete
Billiebob Ultralight Flightpark Undead Warrior 2008-10-01 2008-10-05 Delete
Mc Will Hospital Heliport Undead Warrior 2008-10-01 2008-10-05 Merge to McKenzie-Willamette Medical Center
Gimje Airport Undead Warrior 2008-09-08 2008-09-13 Redirect to Gimje Planned but never built
Stoney Point Airfield Undead Warrior 2008-08-10 2008-08-15 Delete
Breuner Airfield Toddst1 2008-08-10 2008-08-15 Delete R/C airplane landing strip
St. Elizabeth Hospital Heliport Undead Warrior 2008-07-31 2008-08-07 Keep
Meridian Park Hospital Heliport Undead Warrior 2008-07-30 2008-08-07 No consensus
Chadwick Airport Undead Warrior 2008-07-30 2008-08-06 Keep
Mirpur International Airport Accounting4Taste 2008-07-07 2008-07-12 Delete WP:CRYSTAL
Westchester County Airport 68.193.85.33 2008-01-19 2008-01-23 Keep Anon nomination, WP:SNOW
Esterhazy Airport DJBullfish 2008-01-15 2008-01-15 Keep
Bukittinggi Airport UsaSatsui 2008-01-08 2008-01-10 Delete Hoax
List of destinations served by Manchester Airport Terminal 1 (2nd nomination) Spartaz 2007-11-11 2007-11-17 Delete
List of airports that able to offering regular flights by Airbus A380 aircraft MilborneOne 2007-11-06 2007-11-09 Delete
List of destinations served by Manchester Airport Terminal 1 Vegaswikian 2007-11-03 2007-11-09 Keep
West Wyalong Airport Marlith 2007-09-17 2007-09-22 Keep
Former Airlines and Routes of San Francisco International Airport Dcandeto 2007-04-11 2007-04-16 Delete
Singapore Changi Airport passenger traffic by destination (3rd nomination) Arnzy 2006-06-24 2006-06-30 Delete
Singapore Changi Airport passenger traffic by airline Vegaswikian 2005-09-24 2005-10-02 Delete
Singapore Changi Airport passenger traffic by destination (2nd nomination) Vegaswikian 2005-09-24 2005-10-02 No consensus
Singapore Changi Airport passenger traffic by destination Ryan Prior 2005-05-31 2005-06-15 Keep
Airlines
Qantas Flight 32 Bidgee 2010-11-04 Arguing WP:NOTNEWS and recentism.
Aeronais Conti 2009-07-04 PROD: Founded in 2004 and still not active, no fleet, no city approval, etc.
Air Dravida Conti 2009-07-04 PROD: No activity since 2006, website "under construction".
Air Midwest (Nigeria) Conti 2009-07-04 PROD: No activity since 2007, website still says "coming soon".
Air Saipan Conti 2009-07-04 PROD: No activity since 2006, orphan.
Bance Air Conti 2009-07-04 PROD: Orphan, no activity since 2006.
City Air Conti 2009-07-04 PROD: "Plans to start in 2007", no activity since then.
Datang Qili Airlines Conti 2009-07-04 PROD: Orphan, no activity since 2006.
Dazhong Airlines Conti 2009-07-04 PROD: Orphan, no activity since 2005.
EaseOn Air Conti 2009-07-04 PROD: Upcoming airline with no activity since 2005, website not updated since 2006.
FirstJet Conti 2009-07-04 PROD: Defunct airline that never started operating.
Icon (airline) Conti 2009-07-04 PROD: Unreferenced, official website dead for over a year.
Jet-Yi Conti 2009-07-04 PROD: No activity since 2006.
JumpJet Conti 2009-07-04 PROD: "Failed start-up", no activity since 2006, unreferenced.
Phoenix Airline Conti 2009-07-04 PROD: "Now operates as Juneyao Airlines", not active, never will be.
TransCaribbean Airways Conti 2009-07-04 PROD: Unreferenced, website hasn't been updated since last year.
Air UK Leisure Oo7565 2009-02-06 2008-02-11 Keep
Armenian Krikorian Airways Russavia 2008-10-15 2008-10-19 Delete
Pegasus Airlines destinations Themfromspace 2008-10-14 2008-10-19 Merge to Pegasus Airlines
Airline liveries and logos TEB728 2008-10-14 2008-10-19 No consensus
AHM Air Hawaiian717 2008-10-05 2008-10-05 Speedy Delete
Alsek Air Service SchuminWeb 2008-10-03 2008-10-08 No consensus After PROD by Beeblebrox, see [1]
Destination One Mr.Z-man 2008-09-21 2008-09-30 Delete
Alaska Seaplane Service Beeblebrox 2008-09-25 2008-09-30 Keep After PROD, see [2]
Skyworld Hawaiian717 2008-09-04 2008-09-08 Delete
Emirates Airline Services Russavia 2008-08-26 2008-09-04 Merge to Emirates Airline
Emirates Airline Cabins Russavia 2008-08-26 2008-09-04 Merge to Emirates Airline
Emirates Lounge Russavia 2008-08-16 2008-08-22 Delete WP:ADVERT
Angel Medflight Arsenikk 2008-08-13 2008-08-18 Delete
Naming of Qantas aircraft Russavia 2008-07-22 2008-07-27 Keep
Oneworld destinations (2nd nomination) Russavia 2008-06-29 2008-07-04 Delete Not airlines. Also Star Alliance and SkyTeam
Virgin Atlantic Airways Fleet Butterfly0fdoom 2008-05-05 2008-05-11 Delete
Transatlantic International Airlines Aaporter 87 2008-02-11 2008-02-17 Delete Proposed airline, not flying as of deletion
Air Whitsunday Russavia 2008-01-17 2008-01-17 Speedied and Undeleted Requested speedy deletion (CSD A7), see [3]
Emirates Airlines awards and accolades Russavia 2008-01-16 2008-02-01 Delete also deleted similar pages for Malaysia Airlines and Singapore Airlines awards and accolades
Emirates Airline Marketing and sponsorships Russavia 2008-01-16 2008-01-22 Delete
Northwest Regional Airlines 2008-01-09 Speedied Requested speedy deletion per (CSD A7)
Former Delta Air Lines destinations Mlaroche 2007-12-01 2007-12-06 Delete also deleted similar pages for Jat Airways, US Airways, LOT Polish Airlines, Continental Airlines
United Airlines former destinations Mlaroche 2007-11-24 2007-11-30 Delete
Western Air ^demon 2007-11-12 2009-04-13 Speedied and Undeleted Requested speedy deletion (CSD A7), undeleted per Wikipedia: Notability (Transportation) #Airlines
List of largest airlines in Oceania Russavia 2007-10-06 2007-10-12 Keep
Previous United Airlines destinations Plinth molecular gathered 2007-09-18 2007-09-22 Delete
List of Airline Holding Companies Vegaswikian 2007-08-30 2007-09-07 Delete
Air South Charter Russavia 2007-08-16 2007-08-22 Delete WP:CORP
List of airlines in Ukraine Russavia 2007-07-17 2007-08-01 Keep included List of airlines in Serbia
List of airlines based in Nepal Russavia 2007-07-22 2007-07-26 Deleted then restored and Merged to List of airlines of Nepal
Air Culebra Boricuaeddie 2007-06-25 2007-06-30 Keep
Destination lists 2 AKMask 2007-05-15 2007-05-22 Keep American Airlines destinations, etc.
Singapore Airlines awards and accolades Russavia 2007-04-23 2007-04-29 Keep then Deleted under this
Destination lists Jobjörn 2007-01-13 2007-01-20 Keep all lists at Category:Airline destinations
Livingston Airline Destinations GMS508 2007-01-07 2007-01-13 Delete, then Undeleted after Review
Airline destinations Dave 2006-10-24 2006-11-03 Keep, later moved to here
Singapore Airlines fleet Dbinder 2006-01-28 2006-02-03 No consensus
Singapore Changi Airport passenger traffic by airline Vegaswikian 2005-09-24 2005-10-02 Delete
Accidents
  Main   Participants   Page content   Templates   Categories   New articles   AfD record   Notability  
Other project AfD record pages: Aviation · Aircraft (Engines) · Airlines (Defunct) · Airports · Gliding · Aerospace biography · Air sports · Aviation accident · Military aviation · Rotorcraft


One of the unintended consequences of Articles for Deletion (AfD) discussions is a sense of community consensus on things like notability. As we build our guidelines, referring back to old closed AfDs on air incidents can be helpful, and thus this record of closed AfDs for reference.

This list may also include air incident articles which had Speedy Deletion ("Speedy") or Proposed Deletion ("PROD") requests added directly to the article without an AfD discussion.

The entries in the following table are also transcluded into a project wide listing which can be found at Wikipedia:WikiProject Aviation/AfD record.

Wrightflyer thumb.jpg There are articles that have been assessed, but a peer review has been requested. Check out Category:Requests for aviation peer review and see what you think!
Article/AfD Nominator Opened Closed Result Comments

</noinclude>

2009 Pel-Air Westwind crash YSSYguy 2010-03-07
Continental Flight 11 Weyes 2005-05-08 2005-05-14 Delete Hoax; now a redirect
2007 Hukou F-5F crash MilborneOne 2009-07-02 2009-07-09 No consensus
TAM Flight 8095 MilborneOne 2009-07-08
2009 West Java airliner crash ApprenticeFan 2009-07-07
2008 Conviasa Boeing 737 crash ApprenticeFan 2009-07-07
Compass Airlines Flight 2040 ApprenticeFan 2009-07-07
Continental Airlines Flight 1883 Tavix 2009-06-24 2009-07-09 No consensus
2009 French helicopter crash ThaddeusB 2009-06-24 2009-07-02 Delete
Continental Flight 61 AlbertHerring 2009-06-19 2009-06-26 Delete Pilot passed away in-flight
2009 Romania Extra 300L crash MZMcBride 2009-06-06 2009-06-13 Delete Single fatality general aviation crash
List of fatalities from aviation incidents Unbordel 2009-06-03 2009-06-09 Keep Unanimous; 2nd nom
Northwest Airlines Flight 1726 MZMcBride 2009-06-01 2009-06-10 Delete Engine failure/runway excursion
Carpatair Flight 128 MZMcBride 2009-03-23 2009-03-27 Delete Forward landing gear collapse
Air Canada Flight 190 Blood Red Sandman 2009-02-22 2009-02-27 Delete 2nd nom
List of deaths by aircraft misadventure and List of people who died in aviation accidents and incidents B.Wind 2009-02-22 2009-02-27 No consensus
Asian Spirit Flight 321 Star Mississippi 2009-02-20 2009-02-25 Delete 2nd nom
BA CityFlyer Flight 8456 Akradecki 2009-02-14 2009-02-19 Delete During heavy news coverage
2008 Kenosha helicopter crash Blood Red Sandman 2009-02-11 2009-02-17 Delete
Qantas Flight 72 Mvjs 2008-10-07 2008-10-12 Delete Deletion review opened 2008-10-14
Restored 2008-10-16
2008 South Carolina Learjet 60 crash Everyme 2008-09-20 2008-09-21 Speedy Keep
A. D. Williams Engineering crashes Mjroots 2008-09-15 2008-09-20 Delete
Conversation of pilots of KLM 4805 and Pan-Am 1736 Reyk 2008-09-08 2008-09-12 Delete
2008 Ohrid 172N crash Blood Red Sandman 2008-09-03 2008-09-08 Delete
Ryanair Flight 9336 Fram 2008-08-26 2008-08-31 Delete WP:NOT#NEWS, cabin depressurization, earache injuries.
Air Transat Flight 961 Sandstein 2008-08-22 2008-08-27 Keep
Delta Air Lines Flight 1989 Mattcontinental 2008-08-19 2008-08-20 Withdrawn
American Airlines Flight 31 Hawaiian717 2008-08-08 2008-08-13 Delete
XL Airways Flight 237 Akradecki 2008-08-03 2008-08-08 Delete Disorderly passengers kicked off flight
Flybe Flight 7016 Ben W Bell 2008-08-03 2008-08-08 Delete Smoke in cabin, diversion
Air Mauritius Flight MK745 Blood Red Sandman 2008-07-29 2008-08-04 Delete Bird strike, no fatalities or injuries
Qantas Flight 692 Bg 2008-07-29 2008-07-30 Delete
Qantas Flight 30 Mvjs 2008-07-25 2008-07-30 Keep
2008 Atlanta runway incursion Tavix 2008-05-22 2008-05-28 Delete
2008 Cessnas collision Blood Red Sandman 2008-05-11 2008-05-16 Delete
2008 Cessna Compton crash Blood Red Sandman 2008-05-11 2008-05-16 Delete
2008 Farnborough plane crash Biruitorul 2008-04-06 2008-04-06 Speedy Keep Two notable people killed
Cirrus Airlines flight 1569 Biruitorul 2008-04-06 2008-04-11 Delete
American Airlines Flight 55 Trashbag 2008-03-04 2008-03-06 Delete
AirAsia Flight 104 Russavia 2008-01-29 2008-02-05 Delete Runway overrun on landing, 2 minor injuries
Asian Spirit Flight 321 Blood Red Sandman 2008-01-21 2008-01-29 Keep Runway overrun, no injuries
Air Canada Flight 190 Blood Red Sandman 2008-01-21 2008-01-28 No consensus, default Keep Severe turbulence, 10 injuries
British Airways Flight BA38 Kingboyk 2008-01-17 2008-01-17 Withdrawn
United Airlines Flight 858 Flyguy649 2007-09-11 2007-09-16 Delete Stowaway in landing gear dies
CH-46 shootdown in Iraq (February 2007) PBP 2007-08-20 2007-08-25 Delete
Thai Airways flight 358 Sacxpert 2007-08-15 2007-08-22 No consensus met our proposed notability guidelines
Delta Air Lines Flight 2315 Zntrip 2007-07-21 2007-07-22 Merge to United Airlines flight 175
2007 San Francisco International Airport runway incursion Xoloz 2007-07-12 2007-07-19 No consensus
Flight 952 Lipsticked Pig 2007-06-29 2007-07-07 Delete Suspected hoax
SkyWest Airlines flight 5741 Corvus cornix 2007-07-05 2007-07-06 Keep overturned @ DRV & relisted
Oceanic Flight 815 Cheeser1 2007-06-24 2007-06-30 Delete / redirect Fictitious flight
Southwest Airlines Flight 1455 Eluchil404 2007-06-14 2007-06-15 Keep
United Airlines Flight 897 Akradecki 2007-06-06 2007-06-11 Delete
NC16002 disappearance JzG 2007-05-07 2007-05-11 Keep
Air West Flight 612 Fighting for Justice 2007-05-06 2007-05-11 Keep
2006 Brisbane Cessna 206 crash Black Falcon 2007-04-24 2007-04-29 No consensus
Malaysia Airlines Flight 91 Zntrip 2007-04-24 2007-04-28 Delete
Azerbaijan Airlines flight 3026 Khoikhoi 2007-03-19 2007-03-24 Delete Probable hoax
FedEx Flight 597 Zntrip 2006-09-15 2006-09-20 Delete
FedEx Flight 7145 Zntrip 2006-09-13 2006-09-17 Delete
1963 Rochester air crash Zntrip 2006-09-11 2006-09-17 Keep
Mohawk Airlines Flight 405 Zntrip 2006-09-11 2006-09-17 Keep
Mohawk Airlines Flight 411 Zntrip 2006-09-11 2006-09-16 Keep
Airwork Flight 23 Zntrip 2006-09-11 2006-09-16 Keep
2005 Logan Airport runway incursion Blood red sandman 2006-08-28 2006-09-06 No consensus
United Flight 923 Blood red sandman 2006-08-28 2006-09-01 Delete
Northwest Airlines Flight 42 Tariqabjotu 2006-08-27 2006-08-31 Delete
2002 Tampa plane crash Chacor 2006-08-04 2006-08-11 No consensus also 2002 Pirelli Tower plane crash
JetBlue Airways Flight 292 (2nd nom) Batmanand 2006-07-12 2006-07-18 No consensus
American Airlines flight 1740 Batmanand 2006-07-06 2006-07-12 Delete
JetBlue Airways Flight 292 Evil Monkey 2005-09-22 2005-09-23 Keep
Pan Am Flight 125 Ral315 2005-07-31 2005-08-09 Delete Recreated January 2 2007