Wikipedia:WikiProject New York/Assessment

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Flag of New York.svg WikiProject New York
Project news
Assessment
Department home (WP:WPNY/A) talk
Project statistics:
Table
Log
Category
Recognized content (WP:WPNY/RC) talk
Statewide overview (WP:WPNY/A/O) talk
related changes

Welcome to WikiProject New York's assessment department. This department focuses on assessing the quality of Wikipedia's New York articles. While much of the work is done in conjunction with the WP:1.0 program, the article ratings are also used within the project itself to aid in recognizing excellent contributions and identifying topics in need of further work.

The ratings are done in a distributed fashion through parameters in the {{WikiProject New York}} project banner; this causes the articles to be placed in the appropriate sub-categories of Category:New York articles by quality and Category:New York articles by importance.

Frequently asked questions[edit]

Who can assess articles? 
Any editor is free to add or change the rating of an article, but please follow the quality and importance criteria specified below.
Why didn't the reviewer leave any comments? 
Unfortunately, due to the volume of articles that need to be assessed, reviewers are unable to leave detailed comments in most cases. If you have particular questions, you might ask the person who assessed the article; they will usually be happy to provide you with their reasoning.
Where can I get more comments about my article? 
You may leave a post on Wikipedia talk:WikiProject New York or list it for peer review.
What if I don't agree with a rating? 
You may contact the editor who reviewed the article and ask them to take another look, or leave a post on Wikipedia talk:WikiProject New York.
Aren't the ratings subjective? 
Yes, they are, particularly in terms of judging importance. However, the criteria used by WPNY are no more nor no less subjective than those used by any other WikiProject.
Why does WPNY only tag some New York-related articles, not all of them? 
In the past, some of WPNY's subprojects, particularly WikiProject New York City, had removed the WPNY banner from any and (nearly) all articles within their scope, leaving said articles covered only by the subproject. In 2012, it was decided at the WPNY level to tag articles covered by subprojects based solely on the article's importance to the state, both to avoid the slippery slope of endless article tagging by one parent project after another and to codify when articles should and should not be solely tagged by a subproject. The end result is that the subprojects can maintain articles of local importance while WPNY can focus its efforts on articles of greater importance to the state.

If you have any other questions not listed here, please feel free to ask them on the discussion page for this department, or leave a post on Wikipedia talk:WikiProject New York.

Instructions[edit]

Current assessment statistics

An article's assessment is generated from the values entered in the {{{class}}} and {{{importance}}} parameters of the {{WikiProject New York}} talk page banner template.

Assessing for quality[edit]

An article's quality assessment is generated from the class parameter in the {{WikiProject New York}} project banner on its talk page:

{{WikiProject New York|class=???}}

The following values may be used for the class parameter to describe the quality of the article (see Wikipedia:Quality scale for assessment criteria):

FA (for featured articles only; adds articles to Category:FA-Class New York articles) Featured article FA 
A (adds articles to Category:A-Class New York articles) A-Class article A 
GA (for good articles only; adds articles to Category:GA-Class New York articles)  GA 
B (adds articles to Category:B-Class New York articles) B-Class article B 
C (adds articles to Category:C-Class New York articles) C-Class article C 
Start (adds articles to Category:Start-Class New York articles) Start-Class article Start 
Stub (adds articles to Category:Stub-Class New York articles) Stub-Class article Stub 
FL (for featured lists only; adds articles to Category:FL-Class New York articles) Featured list FL 
List (adds articles to Category:List-Class New York articles)  List 

For pages that are not articles, the following values can also be used for the class parameter:

Book (for Wikipedia books; adds pages to Category:Book-Class New York articles) Wikipedia Book Book 
Category (for categories; adds pages to Category:Category-Class New York articles) Category page Category 
Disambig (for disambiguation pages; adds pages to Category:Disambig-Class New York articles) Disambiguation page Disambig 
FM (for files; adds pages to Category:FM-Class New York articles) Featured media FM 
File (for files; adds pages to Category:File-Class New York articles)  File 
Redirect (for redirect pages; adds pages to Category:Redirect-Class New York articles) Redirect page Redirect 
Portal (for portal pages; adds pages to Category:Portal-Class New York articles)  Portal 
Project (for project pages; adds pages to Category:Project-Class New York articles)  Project 
Template (for templates; adds pages to Category:Template-Class New York articles)  Template 
NA (for any other pages where assessment is unnecessary; adds pages to Category:NA-Class New York articles)  NA 
??? (articles for which a valid class has not yet been provided are listed in Category:Unassessed New York articles)  ??? 

Assessing for importance[edit]

An article's importance assessment is generated from the importance parameter in the {{WikiProject New York}} project banner on its talk page:

{{WikiProject New York|importance=???}}

The following values may be used for the importance parameter to describe the relative importance of the article within the project:

Top (adds articles to Category:Top-importance New York articles)  Top 
High (adds articles to Category:High-importance New York articles)  High 
Mid (adds articles to Category:Mid-importance New York articles)  Mid 
Low (adds articles to Category:Low-importance New York articles)  Low 
NA (adds articles to Category:NA-importance New York articles)  NA 
??? (articles for which a valid importance rating has not yet been provided are listed in Category:Unknown-importance New York articles  ??? 

The importance parameter should be assigned according to the importance scale below.

Quality scale[edit]

WikiProject article quality grading scheme

Importance scale[edit]

The criteria used for rating article importance are not meant to be an absolute or canonical view of how significant the topic is. Rather, they attempt to gauge the probability of the average reader of Wikipedia needing to look up the topic (and thus the immediate need to have a suitably well-written article on it). Thus, subjects with greater popular notability may be rated higher than topics which are arguably more "important" but which are of interest primarily to students of military history. Importance does not equate to quality; a featured article could rate 'mid' on importance.

Note that general notability need not be from the perspective of editor demographics; generally notable topics should be rated similarly regardless of the country or region in which they hold said notability. Thus, topics which may seem obscure to a Western audience—but which are of high notability in other places—should still be highly rated. Rate international region/country-specific articles from the perspective of someone from that region.

WikiProject New York article importance grading scheme
Importance Criteria Examples Assessment tagging
Top Subject is a "core" or "key" topic for New York, or is generally notable to the public at large. Articles in this category shall be tagged for WPNY even if they also fall within the scope of one or more of New York's subprojects.
High Subject is notable in a significant and important way within the field of New York, but not necessarily outside it. Articles in this category shall be tagged for WPNY even if they also fall within the scope of one or more of New York's subprojects.
Mid Subject contributes to the total subject of the New York WikiProject. Subject may not necessarily be famous.

Articles to tag for WPNY even if they also fall within the scope of one or more of New York's subprojects:

Articles to tag for WPNY only if they do not fall within the scope of one or more of New York's subprojects:

Articles in this category shall be tagged for WPNY as noted under "Examples".
Low Subject is not particularly notable or significant even within the field of New York, and may have been included primarily to achieve comprehensive coverage of another topic.
  • Former state legislators and U.S. Representatives, except where they had particular importance in the state's history
  • Semi-pro and amateur sports teams, including individual college sports teams
  • Defunct athletic teams of all sorts
  • All other articles, particularly buildings, companies and organizations that just happen to be located in New York, and people who just happened to have lived in New York without contributing significantly to the state's history.
Articles in this category shall be tagged for WPNY only if they do not fall within the scope of one or more of New York's subprojects.