William Beach Thomas

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
William Beach Thomas in 1917. A photograph by George Charles Beresford.

William Beach Thomas, KBE, (22 May 1868 – 12 May 1957) was a British author and journalist known for his work as a war correspondent during the First World War and for his writings about nature and country life.

His reportage for the Daily Mail in France during the First World War received national recognition, although it was also met with criticism and parodied by soldiers. His book With the British on the Somme (1917) portrayed the English soldier in a very favourable light. Both France and Britain rewarded him with knighthoods after the war.

His real interest, however, was countryside matters. Thomas was conservative in his views, and feared that the post-Second World War socialist governments regarded the countryside only from an economic perspective. He was an advocate for the creation of national parks, and mourned the decline of traditional village society. He wrote extensively, particularly for The Observer newspaper and The Spectator, a conservative magazine. Among his books is The English Landscape (1938), which includes selections from his contributions to Country Life magazine.

Childhood and education[edit]

William Beach Thomas was born in Godmanchester, in the county of Huntingdonshire, England, on 22 May 1868. Although not a hyphenated double-barrelled name, his second name was used as if it formed a part of his surname. His family moved to the rural setting of Hamerton, Huntingdonshire, in 1872 when his father, Daniel George Thomas,[1] was appointed rector of that parish. The countryside location inspired an affection in Beach Thomas and this greatly influenced his later observational writings about natural history and rural subjects.[2]

Beach Thomas was a keen sportsman during his time at Shrewsbury School and was appointed huntsman to the Royal Shrewsbury School Hunt, the world's oldest cross-country running club.[3][4] He continued his interest in sports after earning an exhibition to Christ Church, Oxford. He was a Blue, representing the university in various running events over several years. He became president of the Oxford University Athletics Club and also played football, rugby union and cricket at college level.[2] J. B. Atkins, who competed against him for the Cambridge University athletics team, said that "With his stately height and gigantic stride, he was magnificent in action; his final effort, always, triumphant, when he saw the goal of all, the tape, waiting for him, was a sight never to be forgotten – though I had a strong reason for regretting it at the time."[5] His exhibition was superseded by a scholarship but he was not academically successful, managing only a third-class degree.[2]

Early career[edit]

Athletic prowess and the time spent in achieving it may have contributed to Beach Thomas's poor academic performance, but it probably also assisted him in getting his first job at a public school.[6] He taught at Bradfield School after leaving Oxford in 1891 and, although he described teaching as "uncongenial", subsequently took a similar position at Dulwich College in 1897, where he remained until the following year. Journalism became the object of his interest: he contributed columns for The Globe, The Outlook and The Saturday Review, as well as for many other publications of which he was not a member of staff.[a] He also wrote a book entitled Athletics, published by Ward, Lock in 1901, following his 1900 contribution of a chapter titled Athletics and Schools to the Athletics volume in the Badminton Library series, published by Longman, Green & Co and edited by Montague Shearman.[6] He became a regular reviewer for The Times Literary Supplement from its formation in 1902.[3]

The Daily Mail took on Beach Thomas as a writer of material relating to the countryside and, to his delight, the newspaper's owner, Lord Northcliffe, recognised that for him to do this well it would be necessary for him to live in a rural environment and thus limit his visits to London. He moved to the Mimram Valley in Hertfordshire and thereafter held Northcliffe in high regard.[2]

In 1908, Beach Thomas's From a Hertfordshire Cottage was published. This was followed by a three-volume collaboration with A. K. Collett, The English Year (1913–14).[2] He did not entirely abandon his interest in athletics and was one of those in Britain who criticised his country's poor performance in the 1912 Olympic Games. Noting that the Olympics were by then being seen as a measure of "national vitality", he wrote that

We could not run, so it appeared, either long distances or short; we could not jump either broad or high; we could not throw the javelin ... The men accepted defeat as if the Olympic Games were a competition of parlour tricks in a provincial drawing-room.[9][b]

War correspondent[edit]

War correspondents examining a dud German 42 cm shell. Right to left: Perry Robinson (The Times), William Beach Thomas (Daily Mail) and Captain La Porte (Belgian Mission). Photograph by Ernest Brooks.

The Daily Mail sent Beach Thomas to France as a war correspondent during the First World War. Many newspapers were keen to support the war effort and to take advantage of the demand for news from the front. The British military authorities were opposed to the presence of journalists, preferring instead to control the media through the issue of official press releases.[11] Lord Kitchener in particular was opposed to their presence, having had bad experiences of journalists during the Boer War. He formed a press bureau headed by F. E. Smith, and demanded that all reports be channelled through the bureau for review by censors; the resulting output was bland and impersonal.[12] The newspapers countered with subterfuge. Beach Thomas was one who managed to reach the front lines in Belgium but there he was discovered and imprisoned by the British Army.[11] He described the episode as "the longest walking tour of my life, and the queerest." Even these early unapproved reports, which consisted mostly of human interest stories because there was little opportunity for contact with the British Expeditionary Force, were censored at home owing to a paradox that Beach Thomas described: "the censors would not publish any article if it indicated that the writer had seen what he wrote of. He must write what he thought was true, not what he knew to be true."[13]

When the British government relented in mid-1915, having been warned by Theodore Roosevelt that the reporting limitations were affecting public opinion in the United States,[11][c] Valentine Williams became the Daily Mail's first accredited war correspondent. Beach Thomas was able to resume his role in December of the same year, when Williams enlisted in the Irish Guards.[13][15][d] As with the other accredited journalists, he was paid by the War Office rather than by his newspaper and they were all assured that they would be able to publish memoirs of their service to offset the differential between an officer's pay and that of a journalist.[17] He filed reports from places such as The Somme in a format that matched that of his colleagues, who regularly downplayed the unpleasant aspects of the conflict such as the nature of death.[18] His reports were published in the Daily Mirror as well as the Daily Mail.[17]

While the soldiers were derisive of the few attempts made to indoctrinate them, the British public were more susceptible and Philip Gibbs, a fellow war correspondent, noted that he and his colleagues "identified absolutely with the Armies in the field ... There was no need of censorship in our despatches. We were our own censors."[19] The journalistic support for the cause was appreciated by the military commanders, such as Douglas Haig, who saw the propaganda generated by the correspondents as an integral part of the allied efforts. Haig eventually went so far as to ask Gibbs and Beach Thomas to produce his own weekly news-sheet.[20] Public opinion at home may have been mollified, even uplifted, by the efforts of the correspondents but the troops were not, despite the demand among them for newspapers from home being high.[e] One soldier, Albert Rochester, was court martialled for attempting to send to the Daily Mail a letter that stated the realities as he saw them and which was critical of Beach Thomas's work, noting the "ridiculous reports regarding the love and fellowship existing between officers and men." Beach Thomas himself later regretted his wartime reports of The Somme, saying that "I was thoroughly and deeply ashamed of what I had written for the good reason that it was untrue ... the vulgarity of enormous headlines and the enormity of one's own name did not lessen the shame."[22]

British Mark I male tank at The Somme, September 1916. Photograph by Ernest Brooks.

Northcliffe's brother, Lord Rothermere, expressed frustration with the war correspondents, saying that "They don't know the truth, they don't speak the truth, and we know that they don't". Stephen Badsey, a historian who specialises in study of World War I, has noted that their situation was not easy as they "found themselves as minor players trapped in a complicated hierarchical structure dominated by politicians, generals and newspaper owners."[20] Beach Thomas, however, received particular opprobrium. Paul Fussell, the historian, describes him as "notoriously fatuous" during the war period.[23] Peter Stothard, editor of The Times between 1992–2002, describes him as "a quietly successful countryside columnist and literary gent who became a calamitous Daily Mail war correspondent" and believes that he may have been the inspiration for the character of William Boot in Evelyn Waugh's Scoop.[24][f] John Simpson, a war correspondent, describes him as "charming but unlovable"[25] and thinks that the troops despised Beach Thomas more than they did the other British war correspondents, even though all of these journalists were playing a similar disinformation role. They considered his writing to be a trivialisation of the realities of war, jingoistic, pompous and particularly self-promoting, often giving the reader an impression that he was writing from the battlefield when in fact he was being fed information of dubious value by the authorities while based in their headquarters.[17][24] He was parodied in the Wipers Times,[g] a trench newspaper, but he was also lauded by the readership back in Britain. One example from the Wipers Times, based on a report published in the Daily Mail of 18 September 1916,[27] was

In the grey and purple light of a September morn [the first tanks used in war] went over. Like great prehistoric monsters they leapt and skipped with joy when the signal came. It was my great good fortune to be a passenger on one of them. How can I clearly relate what happened? All is one chaotic mingling of joy and noise. No fear! How could one fear anything in the belly of a perambulating, peripatetic progolodymythorus. Wonderful, epic, on we went, whilst twice a minute the 17in. gun on the roof barked out its message of defiance. At last we were fairly in amongst the Huns. They were round us in millions and in millions they died ... With a triumphant snort we went through Bapaume pushing over the church in a playful moment and then steering a course for home, feeling that our perspiring proglodomyte had thoroughly enjoyed its run over the disgruntled, discomfited, disembowelled earth. And so to rest in its lair ready for the morrow and what that morrow might hold. I must get back to the battle.[28]

William Beach Thomas (left), Daily Mail war correspondent, being presented to King George V at Abbeville on 9 June 1917. Photograph by Ernest Brooks.

Beach Thomas published a book based on his wartime experiences in 1917: With the British on the Somme was a favourable depiction specifically of the English soldier and as such it ran somewhat against the grain, which had officially tried to emphasise that this was a British war rather than an English one but had arguably shifted the balance too much. A review in The Times Literary Supplement noted that Beach Thomas

rightly emphasised the feats of the English soldier ... as distinct from the Scot, the Irishman or the Colonial. This is as it should be, for the average newspaper reader of late months, even years, has been saturated with epics of different Colonials, Irish regiments and Kilted Companies ... the plain Thomas Atkins [has been] overlooked to a great extent for far too long.[29]

In 1918, Northcliffe asked Beach Thomas to travel to the US. According the Beach Thomas, the rationale was that "he didn't know what the Americans were doing, and they did not know what we were thinking".[30]

Sometimes he accompanied George V and the Prince of Wales when they visited France, noting on one occasion a situation he considered analogous to that of Henry II and Thomas à Beckett

We were walking to see a new heavy howitzer installed in its camouflage in an open grove. About us ran and skipped, appeared and disappeared, round this tree and that, the conscientious wielder of a cinema. The thing got more and more on the Prince's nerves until the irritation was irrepressible, and he turned to me and said with a sort of angry humour: 'Will no-one kill that photographer?'[30]

His war work led to state recognition, as it did for many other of the correspondents and newspaper owners: France appointed Beach Thomas as a Chevalier of the Legion of Honour in 1919 and he was appointed a Knight Commander of the Order of the British Empire (KBE) in 1920.[2][18]

Later years[edit]

After the war, Beach Thomas stayed in Germany until 1919 and returned there in 1923 at the time of the Occupation of the Ruhr. He also undertook a tour of the world for the Daily Mail and The Times in 1922. His main focus, however, returned to his lifelong interest in matters of the countryside, notably in his writings for The Observer from 1923 to 1956.[2][31][h] Beach Thomas was also a regular contributor of notes on nature, gardening and country life to The Spectator for almost 30 years, with some short breaks between 1935 and 1941, when H. E. Bates took responsibility.[32][33][34] In 1928, he produced a history of the magazine, titled The Story of the 'Spectator', in commemoration of its centenary.[3] He wrote many more books and articles in his later years, as well as two autobiographical books: A Traveller in News (1925) and The Way of a Countryman (1944).[2] Fond of peppering quotations throughout his writing,[6] his style was considered to be clear but his hand was poor: a profile of him in The Observer said "perhaps he gave less pleasure to those who had to decipher his handwriting. Rarely has more limpid English been conveyed in a script more obscure."[31]

George Orwell wrote in the Manchester Evening News that

It is uncertain whether the general public would think of Sir William Beach Thomas primarily as a war correspondent or as a naturalist, but he is in no doubt about the matter himself. The world, as he sees it, really centres round the English village, and round the trees and hedges of that village rather than the houses and the people.[35]

Even as traditional English village living was in collapse, he saw the Romanticised paternalism and general life of the village – including that "comparative wealth [there] is admired, not envied" – as the epitome of English society and equivalent to anything that might be found elsewhere in the world.[36] He also viewed the natural world as something to be wondered at rather than scientifically examined. In his last column for The Spectator, written in September 1950, he wrote that

The country scene is a department of art, not of science. The essential is the discovery of beauty, not of knowledge. Science comes second, and a bad second, to art. We do not listen to the nightingale in order to find out whether his song is erotic or polemic. We listen for the pleasure of the mood that the song and the scene engender. Flight matters more than its mechanics. The prime value of knowledge itself is to enlarge the circle of wonder. The chronicler does a better deed if he helps someone to enjoy the country more than if he botanises or ornithologises or entomologises or meteorologises.[37]

In his desire to encourage a love of the countryside, especially during the Second World War, Beach Thomas was similar to other writers on rural matters, such as G. M. Trevelyan and H. J. Massingham.[38] He described Massingham as "perhaps the best of all present writers on Rural England" and considered writers such as him to be "so fond of the past that they seem sometimes almost to despair of the future."[39] Malcolm Chase, a historian, says that these authors, including Beach Thomas himself, advocated an ultra-conservative, socially reactionary and idealistic philosophy that formed an important part of a national debate about the future of the land and agriculture. This attitude was coupled to an increasing public interest in pastimes such as cycling, motoring and walking; it was supported by the publication of popular, fairly cheap and colourful articles, books and maps that catered both for those pursuing such interests and those who were concerned about conservation and the effects of the influx of urban and suburban visitors.[38] However, John Musty, in his comparative literary review of the works of Beach Thomas and Massingham, thinks that Beach Thomas had a more "gentle touch" than Massingham, whose writings have "frequently been judged as narrow and reactionary"; he quotes Beach Thomas as saying of the likes of Massingham that they "preach an impossible creed, albeit an attractive one."[40]

Panorama of some of the Snowdon Massif including Snowdon (centre right) taken from Mynydd Mawr. The Glyderau are visible in the distance. Beach Thomas supported moves to make Snowdonia a National Park.

Much of one book, The English Landscape (1938), had previously appeared in various issues of Country Life magazine and in part echoed the concerns raised by Clough Williams-Ellis. Beach Thomas argued in favour of creating national parks, for which he thought that the coastline would be the most suitable candidate. He stressed the relationship between the people and the land and saw a need for planning control to manage human ingress into areas that remained mostly untouched.[41] In 1934 he supported the Nature Lovers Association in their appeal to make the mountainous Snowdonia region, near the coast of North Wales, such an entity.[42][i] He also supported the Commons, Open Spaces and Footpaths Preservation Society.[44]

In 1931, Beach Thomas had lamented the inability of the National Farmers Union of England and Wales to arrest what he saw as the decline of the farming industry.[45] Later, in 1946, he harked back to a lost world, perhaps even a world that was more of his imagination than it ever was fact. As F. R. Leavis had done before him, Beach Thomas sought a rural revival to curtail what he perceived to be the rapid changes to traditional modes of living which had been evident in particular in the aftermath of World War I and were now ideologically challenged followed the substantial victory of the socialist Labour Party in the 1945 general election. The new government, according to Robert Hemmings, saw the countryside "as merely a giant dairy and granary for the city."[46]

Beach Thomas was opposed to the use of the toothed steel trap for catching rabbits, supporting the RSPCA in its efforts to outlaw the device and noting that it both inflicted unnecessary pain and was indiscriminate in nature, sometimes trapping other animals such as domesticated cattle and pet dogs.[47]

Death[edit]

William Beach Thomas died at his home in Wheathampstead, Hertfordshire, on 12 May 1957.[j] He had married Helen Dorothea Harcourt, a daughter of Augustus George Vernon Harcourt, in April 1900, and she survived him. The couple had three sons and one daughter. One of their sons was a naval officer and predeceased his parents, being killed in World War II.[2] Beach Thomas was buried in the village churchyard.[48]

Among the obituaries to him were those published in Nature[49] and The Times.[3]

Books[edit]

Aside from his journalism, Beach Thomas wrote and contributed to many books, all published in London and some also in places such as New York. These include:[50]

  • Athletics at School (chapter in Athletics, ed. Montague Shearman, Longmans, Green & Co.: 1898)
  • Athletics (Ward, Lock & Co.: 1901)
  • The Road to Manhood (G. Allen: 1904)
  • On Taking a House (Edward Arnold: 1905)
  • From a Hertfordshire Cottage (Alston Rivers: 1908)
  • Preface to C. D. McKay's The French Garden: a diary and manual of intensive cultivation (Associated Newspapers: 1908, reprinted as The French Garden In England, 1909)
  • Our Civic Life (Alston Rivers: 1908)
  • The English Year (three volumes, co-authored with A. K. Collett; T. C. & E. C. Jack, 1913–14)
  • With the British on the Somme (Methuen: 1917)
  • Birds Through The Year (co-authored with A. K. Collett; T. C. & E. C. Jack, 1922)
  • An Observer's Twelvemonth (Collins: 1923)
  • A Traveller in News (Chapman and Hall: 1925)
  • England Becomes Prairie (Ernest Benn: 1927)
  • The Story of the 'Spectator' (Methuen: 1928)
  • The Happy Village (Ernest Benn: 1928)
  • Events of the Great War (G. Routledge & Sons: 1930)
  • A Letter to My Dog (G. Routledge & Sons: 1931)
  • Why the Land Dies (Faber & Faber: 1931)
  • Introduction to Land and Life: The Economic National Policy for Agriculture (Viscount Astor and Keith Murray., Gollancz: 1932)
  • The Yeoman's England (A. Maclehose & Co.: 1934)
  • Village England (A. Maclehose & Co.: 1935)
  • The Squirrel's Granary: A Countryman's Anthology (A. Maclehose & Co.: 1936, republished by A. & C. Black in 1942 as A Countryman's Anthology)
  • Hunting England: a survey of the sport and of its chief grounds etc (B. T. Batsford: 1936)
  • The Home Counties (chapter in Britain and the Beast, ed. Clough Williams-Ellis, B. T. Batsford: 1937)
  • The English Landscape (Country Life: 1938)
  • The Way of a Countryman (M. Joseph: 1944)
  • The Poems of a Countryman (M. Joseph: 1945)
  • A Countryman's Creed (M. Joseph: 1946)
  • In Praise of Flowers (Evans Bros.: 1948)
  • The Way of a Dog (M. Joseph: 1948)
  • Hertfordshire (R. Hale: 1950)
  • A Year in the Country (A. Wingate: 1950)
  • Gardens (Burke: 1952)
  • Introduction to The New Forest and Hampshire in Pictures (Odhams: 1952)

References[edit]

Notes

  1. ^ When Beach Thomas ended his employment with The Globe in 1903, his primary responsibility there, which was the compilation of a diary column titled By The Way, passed to P. G. Wodehouse. Beach Thomas had taught Wodehouse at Dulwich College, supervised his involvement in the school magazine and introduced him to The Globe in the preceding year when he needed someone to cover his duties while he holidayed.[7][8]
  2. ^ Later still, writing in the magazine of the Over-Seas Club, Beach Thomas expressed a preference for the amateur ethos of the British Empire Games, which were established in 1930, over the perceived professionalism and seriousness of the Olympic Games.[10]
  3. ^ In contrast to the British, the German military authorities were relatively open to journalistic endeavour, at least in part because they wanted to influence the neutral US.[14]
  4. ^ The accredited war correspondents, who included Philip Gibbs and Basil Clarke, were given the honorary rank of captain, were dressed in uniform and wore a green armband. They were supposed to be escorted by officers at all times.[16] Smith and Higgins describe the new arrangements as having "parallels" to what is now known as embedded journalism.[17]
  5. ^ Nicholas Hiley explains the paradox of the troops' high demand for newspapers from home despite their disdain for the war correspondents: "although the frontline soldiers had a good view of the fighting, they had a poor view of the war and welcomed the broader perspective given by the London press." Their name for the Daily Mail was Daily Liar.[21]
  6. ^ Another potential model for the character of William Boot was Bill Deedes.
  7. ^ The parodies of Beach Thomas in the Wipers Times were under the by-line of "Teech Bomas".[26]
  8. ^ Beach Thomas had worked under James Louis Garvin at The Outlook and it was he who brought him to The Observer.[3]
  9. ^ Snowdonia was eventually designated a National Park in October 1951.[43]
  10. ^ Beach Thomas had bought a house in Wheathampstead in 1923. That fifteenth-century building, now Grade 2 listed and variously known as Wheathampstead Place or Place Farm, had been previously owned by two British Prime Ministers, Lord Melbourne and Lord Palmerston. He had moved from it by 1932 and his home at the time of death was High Trees, in the Gustard Wood area of the village.[2][48] That house appears to have been built for him in the 1930s.[31]

Citations

  1. ^ Anon (Aberdeen Evening Express) (1917), p. 2
  2. ^ a b c d e f g h i j Hudson (2004)
  3. ^ a b c d e Anon (The Times) (1957), p. 13
  4. ^ Robinson (1998), p. 28
  5. ^ Atkins (1950), p. 6
  6. ^ a b c Musty (1985), p. 99
  7. ^ Cawthorne (2013), pp. 2, 4
  8. ^ Wodehouse (2013), p. 37
  9. ^ Llewellyn (2014), p. 97
  10. ^ Gorman (2012), p. 167
  11. ^ a b c Wyatt & Manning (2011), p. 457
  12. ^ David (2013), p. 26
  13. ^ a b Farish (2001), p. 280
  14. ^ Greenslade (2014)
  15. ^ West (2009), pp. 580–581
  16. ^ Rankin (2009), p. 51
  17. ^ a b c d Smith & Higgins (2012), p. 133
  18. ^ a b Hochschild (2011), pp. 223, 233
  19. ^ Moorcraft (2008), pp. 41–42
  20. ^ a b Badsey (2011), pp. 19, 22
  21. ^ Hiley (1994)
  22. ^ Knightley (2004), p. 106
  23. ^ Fussell (2013), p. 44
  24. ^ a b Simpson (2011), pp. 124–126
  25. ^ Simpson (2011), p. 2
  26. ^ Simpson (2011), p. 171
  27. ^ Tate (1998), p. 123
  28. ^ Bomas (1916), p. 7
  29. ^ Black (2004), pp. 76–77
  30. ^ a b Beach Thomas (1925), quoted in Anon (Yorkshire Post and Leeds Intelligencer) 1925, p. 4
  31. ^ a b c Anon (The Observer) (1956), p. 3
  32. ^ Baldwin (1987), p. 120
  33. ^ Bates (1941), p. 13
  34. ^ Anon (The Spectator) (1957), p. 8
  35. ^ Orwell (1944)
  36. ^ Chase (1989), pp. 131–132
  37. ^ Beach Thomas (1950), p. 12
  38. ^ a b Chase (1989), pp. 129–131
  39. ^ Musty (1985), p. 100
  40. ^ Musty (1985), pp. 94, 99
  41. ^ Lowe (2012), p. 126.
  42. ^ Anon (Nottingham Evening Post) (1934), p. 3
  43. ^ Snowdonia National Park Authority (2014)
  44. ^ Anon (Western Daily Press) (1934), p. 11
  45. ^ Anon (Western Gazette) (1933), p. 16
  46. ^ Hemmings (2008), pp. 20–21
  47. ^ Beach Thomas (1933), p. 2
  48. ^ a b Wheathampstead Parish Council (2012), p. 1
  49. ^ Pitt (1957)
  50. ^ Musty (1985), p. 101

Bibliography