Apart from the victory of a Tones-led selection in the 1943 Armagh Senior Football Championship final, defeating Crossmaglen, the club's highest point in sporting terms came in 1964, when the Tones lost by three points to Mullaghbawn in the SFC final. They had two other SFC final appearances, losing in 1967 to Crossmaglen by 9 points, and in 1973 to Clann na nGael by 15 points. The Tones have also won two JFC championships, in 1930 and 2000.
As most clubs in around the Lurgan area there are quite a lot of rivalries. The two county clubs rival each other Wolfe Tone GAC and Sarsfields GAA. Although in recent years and games it seems that the Wolfe Tones are further ahead in senior and underage football.