World Trade Center (PATH station)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
World Trade Center Station
The third entrance, opened in April 2008, of the temporary PATH station
Station statistics
Address World Trade Center
New York City, NY, USA
Coordinates 40°42′42″N 74°00′38″W / 40.711787°N 74.010525°W / 40.711787; -74.010525Coordinates: 40°42′42″N 74°00′38″W / 40.711787°N 74.010525°W / 40.711787; -74.010525
Connections New York City Subway:
NYCS 2 NYCS 3 at Park Place
NYCS A NYCS C NYCS E at Chambers Street – World Trade Center
NYCS N NYCS R at Cortlandt Street
Local Transit NYCT Bus: M5
Platforms 3 island platforms
Tracks 6
Other information
Opened 1903, 2015 (as WTC transportation hub)
Rebuilt 1971, 2003 (temporary station)
Electrified 600V (DC) Third Rail
Accessible Handicapped/disabled access
Owned by Port Authority of New York and New Jersey
Passengers (2006) 12.1 million Increase 9%
Preceding station   PATH logo.svg PATH   Following station
  Regular service  
toward Newark
NWK–WTC Terminus
Handicapped/disabled access
  Weekdays only  
toward Hoboken
HOB–WTC Terminus
Handicapped/disabled access
Rebuilding of the
World Trade Center
One World Trade Center (construction)
Two World Trade Center
Three World Trade Center
Four World Trade Center
Five World Trade Center
Seven World Trade Center
Liberty Park
National September 11 Memorial & Museum
Performing Arts Center
Transportation Hub
Vehicular Security Center
Westfield World Trade Center

World Trade Center is a terminal station in Lower Manhattan built for PATH service. It was originally opened on July 19, 1909 as the Hudson Terminal, but was torn down and rebuilt as the original World Trade Center station, which opened in 1971. Following the September 11, 2001 attacks, a temporary station opened in 2003. This station serves as the terminus for the Newark – World Trade Center and Hoboken – World Trade Center routes. The station is currently undergoing a major reconstruction project and will become the World Trade Center Transportation Hub after its completion, scheduled on December 17, 2015.[1][2]

Station layout[edit]

G Street level Entrance/Exit to Vesey Street and West Broadway/Greenwich Street
Entrance/Exit to the National September 11 Memorial & Museum
Escalators and elevator to mezzanine, Shops, ATMs
At-grade connection to Cortlandt Street subway station (NYCS 1 train, under construction)
Upper Concourse
North mezzanine Ticket machines, one-way faregates, concourse, ramps and staircases to West and East mezzanines
West mezzanine Elevators and stairs to tracks 4 and 5
West Concourse to Brookfield Place
East mezzanine Elevators, escalators, and stairs to track 1
Cortlandt Street platforms Transfer to New York City Subway NYCS N NYCS R trains (under construction)
Lower Concourse
Passageways (under construction) Transfer to New York City Subway (NYCS 2 NYCS 3 NYCS A NYCS C NYCS E trains at World Trade Center and NYCS 2 NYCS 3 NYCS 4 NYCS 5 NYCS A NYCS C NYCS J NYCS Z trains at Fulton Street; under construction)
B3[3] Mezzanine Transfer between platforms
Track 1      HOB–WTC toward Hoboken (Exchange Place)
Island platform (Platform A), doors will open on the left Handicapped/disabled access
Island platform (Platform A), not in service Handicapped/disabled access
Track 2[note 1] No regular service
Track 3[note 2] No regular service
Island platform (Platform B), not in service Handicapped/disabled access
Track 4[note 3] No regular service
Temporary wall
Old Track 4[note 4]      NWK–WTC toward Newark (Exchange Place)
Island platform (Platform C), doors will open on the left, right Handicapped/disabled access
Old Track 5[note 5]      NWK–WTC toward Newark (Exchange Place)
  1. ^ Formerly track 1
  2. ^ Formerly track 2
  3. ^ Formerly track 3
  4. ^ Future track 5
  5. ^ Future track 6

Station overview[edit]

The current station is a temporary station that has opened since November 2003. Due to the redevelopment of the World Trade Center site, the entrances and size of the temporary station have changed over time. The most current entrance to the station is located at Vesey Street, facing Greenwich Street and adjacent to 7 World Trade Center. The current entrance is a one story building on the south side of Vesey Street with a Hudson News outlet and escalators extending into a lower level mezzanine. A connection to Brookfield Place was made available since October 27, 2013 through a permanent passageway known as the West Concourse.

The station currently has three island platforms in a basement four stories underground;[3] one (platform A) is currently split by a wall. Tracks 2 and 3, and the New Track 4 are not currently used. The new Platform A, next to New Tracks 1 and 2, opened as part of the Transportation Hub on February 25, 2014; Platform A only serves HOB-WTC trains on weekdays, while full-time NWK-WTC trains use an older platform between old tracks 4 and 5.[4][5][6]

Adjacent transit connections[edit]

Unlike previous incarnations of the station, the current entrance does not have a direct connection to any adjacent subway station. Vesey Street has been pedestrianized to allow as a passageway between the World Trade Center subway station and the PATH station entrance.

Station service legend
Stops all times Stops all times
Stops all times except late nights Stops all times except late nights
Stops late nights only Stops late nights only
Stops weekdays only Stops weekdays only
Stops rush hours in peak direction only Stops rush hours in the peak direction only
Time period details

The World Trade Center station is adjacent to several New York City Subway services at Chambers Street – World Trade Center / Park Place and Cortlandt Street stations.

Services Line Station
      2 all times
      3 all except late nights
IRT Broadway – Seventh Avenue Line Park Place
      A all times
      C all except late nights
IND Eighth Avenue Line Chambers Street
      E all times IND Eighth Avenue Line World Trade Center
      N late nights
      R all except late nights
BMT Broadway Line Cortlandt Street (currently not connected to the complex)

The Fulton Street station complex (where the Fulton Center is under construction) is two blocks away to the east and features the following services:

Services Line
      2 all times
      3 all except late nights
IRT Broadway – Seventh Avenue Line
      4 all times
      5 all except late nights
IRT Lexington Avenue Line
      A all times
      C all except late nights
IND Eighth Avenue Line
      J weekdays and weekday late nights
      Z rush hours, peak direction
BMT Nassau Street Line

The station complex will be linked to the WTC Transportation Hub by an underground passageway as part of the Fulton Center project.

Additionally, the PATH station will be connected to the 1 train at the Cortlandt Street station on the IRT Broadway – Seventh Avenue Line. The station was previously connected to the 1971 station, but was severely damaged by the September 11 attacks and is being rebuilt as part of the Transportation Hub.[7]

The M5 New York City Bus route runs northbound on Church Street and southbound to South Ferry on Broadway.


Hudson Terminal[edit]

Main article: Hudson Terminal
Hudson Terminal (right) and the Singer Building (left)

Hudson Terminal was built by the Hudson and Manhattan Railroad at the turn of the twentieth century and was located between Greenwich, Cortlandt, Church, and Fulton Streets. The Hudson Terminal included two 22-story office buildings located above the station.

The terminal was an architectural and engineering marvel of its time, designed with ramps to allow pedestrian traffic to flow in and out of the station quickly and easily.[8] The station was served by two single-track tubes connected by a loop to speed train movements. The loop included five tracks and 3 platforms (2 center island and one side) and is somewhat similar to the current arrangement.[9] By 1914, passenger volume at the Hudson Terminal had reached 30,535,500 annually.[8] Volume nearly doubled by 1922, with 59,221,354 passengers that year at the Hudson Terminal.[10]

Overall ridership on New Jersey's Hudson and Manhattan Railroad (H&M) declined substantially from a high of 113 million riders in 1927 to 26 million in 1958, after new automobile tunnels and bridges opened across the Hudson River.[11] The State of New Jersey was interested in getting the Port Authority to take over the railroad, but the Port Authority long viewed it as something unprofitable that they were never interested in. In the late 1950s, the Port Authority proposed to build a "world trade center" in New York City, on the east side of Lower Manhattan along the East River.

As a bi-state agency, Port Authority projects require approval from both the states of New Jersey and New York. Toward the end of 1961, negotiations with outgoing New Jersey Governor Robert B. Meyner regarding the World Trade Center project reached a stalemate. In December 1961, Port Authority executive director Austin J. Tobin met with newly elected New Jersey Governor Richard J. Hughes, and made a proposal to shift the World Trade Center project to a west side site where the Hudson Terminal was located.[12]

In acquiring the Hudson & Manhattan Railroad, the Port Authority would also acquire the Hudson Terminal and other buildings which were deemed obsolete.[12] On January 22, 1962, the two states reached an agreement to allow the Port Authority to take over the railroad and to build the World Trade Center on Manhattan's lower west side.[13] The shift in location for the World Trade Center to a site more convenient to New Jersey, together with Port Authority acquisition of the H&M Railroad, brought New Jersey to agreement in support of the World Trade Center project.

Old PATH stations[edit]

Original PATH station[edit]

1969 view of the original WTC bathtub looking northeast from Liberty Street. The frame of the south tower is on the left. PATH eastbound tunnel F can be seen in the center, penetrating the slurry wall on its way up Cortlandt Street to Hudson Terminal. The slurry wall runs along the west side of Greenwich Street. The IRT 1 subway tunnel runs below the street (behind the slurry wall).

Groundbreaking on the World Trade Center took place in 1966. The site of the World Trade Center was located on landfill, with the bedrock located 65 metres (213 ft) below.[14] A new method was used to construct a slurry wall that would keep water from the Hudson River out. During excavation of the site and construction of the towers, the original Hudson Tubes remained in service as elevated tunnels. The Hudson Terminal was shut down in 1971 when a new PATH station was completed.[15] The new WTC PATH station cost $35 million to build. At the time, the station had a passenger volume of 85,000 daily.[16]

1969 view of the original WTC bathtub looking northwest from Liberty Street. Note PATH eastbound tunnel F supported on a temporary trestle in foreground. Slurry wall with tie-backs can be seen on the left, and the frame of the north tower in the background. Also note the since-removed elevated west-side highway, which ran above West Street (today's West Side Highway).

The new PATH station opened on July 6, 1971, and was sited at a different location from the original Hudson Terminal.[17] Larger balloon loops in the PATH station platform allowed 10-car trains to be utilized, as the previous station could handle 6-car trains due to tight loops.[15] While construction of the World Trade Center neared completion, a temporary corridor was provided to take passengers between the station and a temporary entrance on Church Street. When it opened, the station had nine high-speed escalators between the platform level and the mezzanine level.[16] The WTC PATH station was served by Newark – World Trade Center and Hoboken – World Trade Center trains. The PATH station was connected to the World Trade Center towers, via an underground concourse and a shopping center. There were also underground connections to the New York City Subway (A C E trains at World Trade Center, and N R trains at Cortlandt Street). By 2001, the volume of passengers using the WTC PATH station was approximately 25,000 daily.[18]

The station did not sustain significant damage during the 1993 World Trade Center bombing, although a section of ceiling in the station collapsed and trapped dozens.[19][20] Within a week, the Port Authority was able to resume PATH service to the World Trade Center.[21] On September 11, 2001, the station was shut down by the Port Authority after the first attack. A train from Newark that came into the terminal at 8:55 am stopped only to pick up passengers. A second train, from Hoboken, came through at 9:00 am but did not stop and returned to New Jersey. PATH sent an empty train to the station at 9:10 am to pick up a dozen PATH employees and a homeless individual leaving the PATH station empty.[22]

Temporary PATH station[edit]

With the station destroyed, service to Lower Manhattan was suspended for over two years. Exchange Place, the next station on the Newark – World Trade Center line, also had to be closed because it could not operate as a terminal station. Instead, two uptown services (Newark – 33rd Street (red) and Hoboken – 33rd Street (blue)) and one intrastate New Jersey service (Hoboken – Journal Square (green)) were put into operation.[23]

Cleanup of the Exchange Place station was needed after the attacks. As well, the downtown Hudson tubes had been flooded, which destroyed the track infrastructure.[24] Modifications to the tracks were also required since the Exchange Place station was never designed as a terminal station.[23] The Exchange Place station re-opened in June 2003. PATH service to Lower Manhattan was restored when a temporary station opened on November 23, 2003. The inaugural train was the same one that had been used for the evacuation.

The temporary PATH station was designed by Port Authority chief architect Robert I. Davidson[25] and constructed at a cost of $323 million.[26] The station features a canopy entrance along Church Street and a 118-by-12 foot mosaic mural, “Iridescent Lightning,” by Giulio Candussio[25] of the Scuola Mosaicisti del Friuli in Spilimbergo, Italy. The station is also adorned with opaque panel walls inscribed with inspirational quotes attesting to the greatness and resilience of New York City. These panels partially shield the World Trade Center site from view.

In the 9/11 attacks, some sections of the station including the floor and the signage on the northeast corner, were only lightly damaged in the collapse of the World Trade Center. These sections of the station were retained in the temporary PATH station, and will remain in the new station, where it connects with the platforms for the A C E 2 3 trains. Following its reopening and the resumption of Newark – World Trade Center and Hoboken – World Trade Center services, the station quickly reclaimed its status as the busiest station in the PATH system.

The World Trade Center PATH station was also home to a Storycorps booth which opened in 2005. Through this program, visitors could arrange to give oral recorded histories of the disaster. The booth closed in Spring 2007 to make way for construction at the World Trade Center site.[27] In June 2007, the street entrance to the temporary station was closed and demolished as part of the ongoing site construction. A set of new staircases was constructed several feet to the south, and a “tent” structure was added to provide cover from the elements. The tent structure, by Voorsanger Architects and installed at a cost of $275,000, was designed to have an “aspiring quality” according to architect Bartholomew Voorsanger.[28] That entrance on Church Street was closed in April 2008 when the entrance was relocated once again. On April 1, 2008, the third new temporary entrance to the PATH station opened for commuters. The entrance is located on Vesey Street, adjacent to 7 World Trade Center. It will serve as the entrance until the opening of the permanent station, designed by Calatrava.[29]

World Trade Center Transportation Hub[edit]


Preliminary site plans for the World Trade Center rebuild
WTC Transportation Hub rendering
The WTC Transportation Hub under construction in September 2014

The temporary PATH station will be replaced with a permanent World Trade Center Transportation Hub, which is being built by the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey at an estimated cost of $3.44 billion. The design is composed of a train station with a large and open mezzanine under the National September 11 Memorial plaza; the plaza lights the station via skylights in the daytime, and vice versa in the nighttime.[30] The mezzanine is connected to an aboveground head house structure, called the Oculus, located between 2 World Trade Center and 3 World Trade Center.[2][31][32]

A large transit station was not part of the 2003 Memory Foundations master plan for the site by Daniel Libeskind, which called for a smaller station along the lines of the original subterranean station that existed beneath the World Trade Center. Libeskind's design called for the Oculus space to be left open, forming a "Wedge of Light" so that sun rays around the autumnal equinox would hit the World Trade Center footprints each September.

In early 2004, the Port Authority, which owns the land, modified the Libeskind plan to include a large transportation station downtown, intended to rival Penn Station and Grand Central Terminal. In a nod to the Libeskind concept, the Oculus will be at an angle to maximize the effect of the autumnal equinox rays.

Since the Hudson Terminal was demolished, Lower Manhattan has not had an ambitious transit or railroad center, as the former complex at the World Trade Center was built beneath the buildings. The station is designed to connect the PATH to the New York City Subway system. An underground passageway east, along Dey Street, is being constructed as part of the Fulton Center project, which will link the new station with the subway's 2 3 4 5 A C E J N R Z services, as well as the 1 service at Cortlandt Street. There will also be a passageway west to the World Financial Center and the Battery Park City Ferry Terminal. A proposal for a connection to the Long Island Rail Road and John F. Kennedy International Airport via a new tunnel under the East River, the Lower Manhattan-Jamaica/JFK Transportation Project, was studied starting in 2004, but as of 2009 was a lower priority than other projects competing for funding.[33]


Spanish Architect Santiago Calatrava, designer of the station, said the Oculus resembles a bird being released from a child's hand. The roof was originally designed to mechanically open to increase light and ventilation to the enclosed space. Herbert Muschamp, architecture critic of The New York Times, wrote:

Another critic wrote:

However, Calatrava's original soaring spike design has been scaled back because of security issues. The Times observed:

The design was further modified to eliminate the opening and closing roof mechanism because of budget and space constraints.[37]

The station has also stirred problems with developer Larry Silverstein, who owns the lease for the World Trade Center site, since it took away available space for his proposed buildings.


Progress on structure in October 2013

Construction of the station called for relocation of the landmark World Trade Center cross in 2006. The permanent station is scheduled to be completed and open on December 17, 2015.

On July 8, 2008, the first prefabricated "ribs" for the pedestrian walkway under Fulton Street were installed on the site.[38] The mezzanine level of the station is undergoing major construction and work on the foundation is still underway.[39]

As of March 1, 2011, over 225 of the 300 steel pieces which make up the roof of the station have been installed.[40] Later that month installation of the Vierendeel Truss, one of the hub's key components, began with the installation of a 50-ton section of the truss. When fully installed the combined weight of the truss will weigh 271 tons. The truss will serve as the mezzanine roof and also act as a support for the northeast corner of the WTC Memorial.[41]

By July 6, 2012, the following events were occurring:

  • Steel erection for oculus substructure
  • Construction connecting to Vehicle Security Center complex
  • Greenwich Street corridor (1 train subway box): steel and concrete placing under 1 train subway box
  • Preparations for installation of east arch truss
  • Hub construction contract awarded to Skanska in summer 2010

As of June 2013, 10 pieces of exterior arches have been installed for the Oculus. The initial construction is expected to conclude in the end of 2014 or beginning of 2015, and the internal construction including paint, turnstiles, ticket booths, etc. is expected to complete in the end of 2015, with an official opening scheduled on December 17, 2015.[42]

By November 2013, about 110 arches, and the beginning of the wings, had been installed, and 20 more arches were installed by January 2014.[43]

On February 25, 2014, the first platform of the new station, Platform A, was opened to the public with service to Hoboken. The new platform, an island platform, is fully modernized and contains new lighting, speakers, illuminated signs, escalators and elevators. The west side of the platform is walled off, giving Platform A the appearance of a side platform.[5]

As of March 10, 2014, 106 out of 114 ribs have been installed for the Oculus, as well as one rafter, or wing; by June 1, 2014, nine wings have been installed, as well as the remaining 8 ribs.[43]

In May 2014, all the ribs out of 114 ribs were all installed, and the construction of the white spikes, or tips started, with the first 3. In late May, 2 more spikes have been added, making the number of spikes added 5.

In June 2014, 14 more spikes have been added, the construction of the spikes continues.

By the end of July 2014 a total of 36 spikes had been installed.

In August 2014, 53 of 114 spikes had been installed, and all 114 spikes are estimated to be completely installed by October 2014.

By mid-October 2014, 99 out of 114 spikes have been installed, with installation completed by the end of October. Painting of the Hub has also begun

West Concourse[edit]

The West Concourse

The new West Street pedestrian underpass (the West Concourse, formerly the "east-west connector") links the WTC station mezzanine with Battery Park City's Brookfield Place (formerly World Financial Center) on the west side of the World Trade Center site just south of 1 WTC and across West Street. It opened on the afternoon of October 23, 2013.[44][45]

Cost controversy[edit]

The Transportation Hub has been dubbed "the world's most expensive transportation hub" due to its massive cost for reconstruction—$3.74 billion dollars.[46][47] Originally, the reconstruction was to be funded by the Federal Transit Administration, which gave approximately $1.9 billion to the project. The costs of the hub were still expensive, but it was to be finished at budget in 2009. In 2014 dollars, the cost of the hub and the adjacent Fulton Center, combined, is $5.1 billion.[48] A single hallway in the elegantly constructed hub cost $225 million and was billed as the "world's most expensive hallway".[49] By contrast, the proposed two-mile PATH extension of the NWK-WTC service costs $1.5 billion.[50] The hub's skyrocketing costs also attracted much controversy, with an editor at The New York Times saying that "Mr. Calatrava is amassing an unusually long list of projects marred by cost overruns, delays and litigation", referring to other projects around the world designed by Calatrava that have been over-budgeted.[51]


See also[edit]


  1. ^ "Project Updates: World Trade Center Transportation Hub". Lower Manhattan Construction Command Center. Retrieved September 2, 2010. 
  2. ^ a b Grynbaum, Michael M. (February 24, 2011). "Trade Center Transit Hub’s Cost Now Over $3.4 Billion". The New York Times. Retrieved February 25, 2011. 
  3. ^ a b c d e Permanent PATH / Tubes WTC Station Plans: PATH Trains Hudson Tubes Hudson & Manhattan RR. (2004-12-16). Retrieved on 2014-06-23.
  4. ^ Hinds, Kate. "Photos That Will Make You Want To Ride The PATH Train". WNYC. Retrieved February 27, 2014. 
  5. ^ a b "Port Authority to open first platform for new World Trade Center PATH station |". Retrieved February 27, 2014. 
  6. ^ "Port Authority Opens First Platform At New WTC PATH Station « CBS New York". Retrieved February 27, 2014. 
  7. ^ Work at Cortlandt Street station #1 train continues above ground at WTC Transportation Hub
  8. ^ a b Droege, John Albert (1916). Passenger Terminals and Trains. McGraw-Hill. pp. 157–159. 
  9. ^ Cudahy, Brian J. (2002). Rails Under the Mighty Hudson (2nd ed.). New York: Fordham University Press. pp. 59–60. ISBN 0823221903. OCLC 48376141. 
  10. ^ "315,724,808 Came or Left City in 1922". The New York Times. April 15, 1923. p. E1. Retrieved May 30, 2010. 
  11. ^ Cudahy, Brian J. (2002). Rails Under the Mighty Hudson (2nd ed.). New York: Fordham University Press. p. 56. ISBN 0823221903. OCLC 48376141. 
  12. ^ a b Grutzner, Charles (December 29, 1961). "Port Unit Backs Linking of H&M and Other Lines". The New York Times. p. 1. Retrieved May 30, 2010. 
  13. ^ Wright, George Cable (January 23, 1962). "2 States Agree on Hudson Tubes and Trade Center". The New York Times. p. 1. Retrieved May 30, 2010. 
  14. ^ Iglauer, Edith (November 4, 1972). "The Biggest Foundation". The New Yorker. 
  15. ^ a b Carroll, Maurice (December 30, 1968). "A Section of the Hudson Tubes is Turned into Elevated Tunnel". The New York Times. p. 33. Retrieved May 30, 2010. 
  16. ^ a b "Air-Cooled PATH Terminal in World Trade Center Opens Tuesday". The New York Times. July 1, 1971. p. 94. Retrieved May 30, 2010. 
  17. ^ Burks, Edward C. (July 7, 1971). "New PATH Station Opens Downtown". The New York Times. p. 74. Retrieved May 30, 2010. 
  18. ^ Wyckoff, P.L. and Rudy Larini (September 13, 2001). "Next Stop, Semi-Normalcy". The Star-Ledger (Newark). 
  19. ^ McFadden, Robert D. (February 27, 1993). "Blast Hits Trade Center, Bomb Suspected; 5 Killed, Thousands Flee Smoke In Towers". The New York Times. 
  20. ^ Newkirk, Pamela (February 28, 1993). "Now, the Cleanup, Work begins assessing the damage". Newsday (New York). 
  21. ^ Marks, Peter (March 1, 1993). "PATH and Subway Service Is Being Restored". The New York Times. 
  22. ^ Schwaneberg, Robert (September 19, 2001). "Quick-Acting P.A. Steered 5,000 Commuters to Safety". The Star-Ledger (Newark). 
  23. ^ a b "PATH Service Restoration". Port Authority of New York and New Jersey. Archived from the original on March 6, 2008. Retrieved April 22, 2008. 
  24. ^ "Temporary World Trade Center PATH Station". New York Construction. Retrieved April 22, 2008. 
  25. ^ a b Dunlap, David W. (May 15, 2003). "At Ground Zero, a Conduit of People and Memory". The New York Times. p. B3. Retrieved May 30, 2010. 
  26. ^ Dunlap, David W. (November 24, 2003). "Again, Trains Put the World In Trade Center". The New York Times. p. A1. 
  27. ^ "About the World Trade Center". Silverstein Properties. Retrieved April 20, 2008. 
  28. ^ Dunlap, David W. (April 10, 2008). "Folding a Large and Symbolic Tent Downtown". The New York Times. 
  29. ^ Dunlap, David W. (April 1, 2008). "A New Twist at the PATH Station". The New York Times. 
  30. ^
  31. ^ Calatrava's WTC Transportation Hub Soars –
  32. ^ Gralla, Joan (October 2, 2008). "NYC World Trade Center site faces fresh delays". Yahoo! News. Retrieved October 3, 2008. [dead link]
  33. ^ Brown, Eliot (March 24, 2009). "The Tunnel From Nowhere". New York Observer. Retrieved February 28, 2010. 
  34. ^ Muschamp, Herbert (January 23, 2004). "AN APPRAISAL; PATH Station Becomes A Procession of Flight". The New York Times. Retrieved July 13, 2008. 
  35. ^ Kimmelman, Michael (February 1, 2004). "ARCHITECTURE; Ground Zero Finally Grows Up". The New York Times. Retrieved July 13, 2008. 
  36. ^ Dunlap, David W. (July 28, 2005). "Approval Expected Today for Trade Center Rail Hub". The New York Times. Retrieved July 13, 2008. 
  37. ^ Dunlap, David W. (July 2, 2008). "Design of Ground Zero Transit Hub Is Trimmed". The New York Times. Retrieved July 13, 2008. 
  38. ^ Dunlap, David W. (July 11, 2008). "Among the Hard Angles, a Few New Curves". The New York Times. Retrieved July 13, 2008. 
  39. ^ "PANYNJ continues to post progress on WTC Transportation Hub". Progressive Railroading. October 25, 2010. Retrieved October 25, 2010. 
  40. ^ "World Trade Center Transportation Hub". Port Authority of New York & New Jersey. Retrieved October 2, 2011. 
  41. ^ "World Trade Center Image Gallery". Port Authority of New York & New Jersey. Retrieved October 2, 2011. 
  42. ^ "Transportation Hub - World Trade Center". Retrieved February 27, 2014. 
  43. ^ a b WTC Transportation Hub Progress on Twitter
  44. ^ New PATH tunnel opens this week, Monday, October 21, 2013 - 10:42 PM By JESSICA GOULD
  45. ^ "Lower Manhattan : World Trade Center Transportation Hub". October 24, 2013. Retrieved February 27, 2014. 
  46. ^
  47. ^ "Calatrava to Build World’s Most Expensive Transportation Hub". ArchDaily. Retrieved 2014-04-24. 
  48. ^ "Daily News: On the Transit Center to nowhere :: Second Ave. Sagas". Retrieved 2014-04-24. 
  49. ^ Smith, Stephen J. (2013-11-06). "World’s Most Expensive Hallway Even More Expensive Than We Thought – Next City". Retrieved 2014-04-24. 
  50. ^ Geiger, Daniel (2013-09-11). "Sources: Christie to back $1B PATH extension in Newark | Crain's New York Business". Retrieved 2014-04-24. 
  51. ^ Daley, Suzanne (September 24, 2013). "A Star Architect Leaves Some Clients Fuming". Newspaper (The New York Times). Retrieved April 24, 2014. 

External links[edit]