1933 double eagle
|This article needs additional citations for verification. (July 2010) (Learn how and when to remove this template message)|
|Value||$20.00 U.S. dollars|
|Diameter||34.1 mm (1.34252 in)|
|Thickness||2.0 mm (0.07874 in)|
|Edge||Lettered – E Pluribus Unum|
|Composition||90% gold, 10% copper|
|Years of minting||1933|
|Design||Lady Liberty holding a torch and olive branch, backed by a glory|
|Design||Bald eagle in flight, backed by a glory, with motto|
The 1933 double eagle is a United States 20-dollar gold coin. Although 445,500 specimens of this Saint-Gaudens double eagle were minted in 1933, none were ever officially circulated and all but two were ordered melted down. However, 20 more are known to have been rescued from melting by being stolen, and found their way into the hands of collectors. 19 of these were subsequently recovered by the Secret Service, who destroyed nine of them, making this one of the world's rarest coins.
The two intentionally spared coins are in the U.S. National Numismatic Collection, one is in the hands of a private owner who paid US$7.59 million for it in 2002–the second-highest price paid at auction for a single U.S. coin–and ten others are held in Fort Knox.
Section 2. All persons are hereby required to deliver on or before May 1, 1933, to a Federal Reserve bank or a branch or agency thereof or to any member bank of the Federal Reserve System all gold coin, gold bullion, and gold certificates now owned by them or coming into their ownership on or before April 28, 1933, with the exception of the following:
- (a) Such amount of gold as may be required for legitimate and customary use in industry, profession or art within a reasonable time, including gold prior to refining and stocks of gold in reasonable amounts for the usual trade requirements of owners mining and refining such gold.
- (b) Gold coin and gold certificates in an amount not exceeding in the aggregate $100.00 belonging to any one person; and gold coins having recognized special value to collectors of rare and unusual coins.
- (c) Gold coin and bullion earmarked or held in trust for a recognized foreign government or foreign central bank or the Bank for International Settlements.
- (d) Gold coin and bullion licensed for the other proper transactions (not involving hoarding) including gold coin and gold bullion imported for the re-export or held pending action on applications for export license.
Congress additionally passed the Gold Reserve Act in 1934, which outlawed the circulation and private possession of United States gold coins for general circulation, with an exemption for collector coins. This act declared that gold coins were no longer legal tender in the United States, and people had to turn in their gold coins for other forms of currency. The 1933 gold double eagles were struck after this executive order, but because they were no longer legal tender, most of the 1933 gold coins were melted down in late 1934 and some were destroyed in tests. Two of the $20 double eagles were presented by the United States Mint to the U.S. National Numismatic Collection, and they were recently on display in the "Money and Medals Hall" on the third floor of the National Museum of American History.[when?]
These two coins should have been the only 1933 double eagle coins in existence. However, unknown to the mint, a number of the coins (20 have been recovered so far) were stolen, possibly by the U.S. Mint cashier, and found their way via Philadelphia jeweler Israel Switt, into the hands of collectors. The coins circulated among collectors for several years before the Secret Service became aware of their existence. The matter came to the attention of mint officials when an investigative reporter looked into the history of the coins he had spotted in an upcoming Stack's Bowers coin auction and contacted the mint as part of his research, as a result of which an official investigation was begun by the Secret Service in March 1944. Prior to the investigation a Texas dealer sold one of the coins and it was on the way out of the country on February 29, 1944.
During the first year of the investigation seven coins were seized or voluntarily turned in to the Secret Service and were subsequently destroyed at the Mint; an eighth coin was recovered the following year and met the same fate. In 1945 the investigation identified the alleged thief and his accomplice, Switt, who admitted to selling the nine (located) coins, but could not recall how he obtained them. The Justice Department tried to prosecute them, but the statute of limitations had passed. A tenth coin was recovered and destroyed in 1952.
By contrast, the 1933 Eagle was issued before Roosevelt's withdrawal order and so may be legally owned by private citizens. However, it is estimated that no more than 40 exist, the rest having been melted. Thus they are exceptionally rare.
Egyptian double eagle
The missing double eagle was acquired by King Farouk of Egypt, who was a voracious collector of many things, including imperial Fabergé eggs, antique aspirin bottles, paperweights, postage stamps—and coins, of which he had a collection of over 8,500. In 1944 Farouk purchased a 1933 double eagle, and in strict adherence with the law, his ministers applied to the United States Treasury Department for an export license for the coin. Mistakenly, just days before the mint theft was discovered, the license was granted. The Treasury Department attempted to work through diplomatic channels to request the return of the coin from Egypt, but World War II delayed their efforts for several years. In 1952, King Farouk was deposed in a coup d'etat, and many of his possessions were made available for public auction (run by Sotheby's) – including the double eagle coin. The United States government requested the return of the coin, and the Egyptian government stated that it would comply with the request. However, at that time the coin disappeared and was not seen again in Egypt.
In 1996, a double eagle surfaced again after over forty years of obscurity, when British coin dealer Stephen Fenton was arrested by U.S. Secret Service agents during a sting operation at the Waldorf-Astoria Hotel in New York. Although he initially told investigators he bought the coin over the counter at his shop, he later changed his story. Under sworn testimony, he insisted the double eagle had come from the collection of King Farouk, though this could not be verified. Charges against Fenton were subsequently dropped, and he defended his ownership of the coin in court. The case was settled in 2001 when it was agreed that ownership of the double eagle would revert to the United States government, and the coin could then legally be sold at auction. The United States Treasury issued a document to "issue and monetize" the coin, thereby making it a legal-tender gold coin in the United States.
When the coin was seized, it was transferred to a holding place believed to be safe: the treasury vaults of the World Trade Center. When the court settlement was reached in July 2001, only two months before the trade center was destroyed, the coin was transferred to Fort Knox for safekeeping.
On July 30, 2002, the 1933 double eagle was sold to an anonymous bidder at a Sotheby's auction held in New York for $6.6 million, plus a 15-percent buyer's premium, and an additional $20 needed to “monetize” the face value of the coin so it would become legal currency, bringing the final sale price to $7,590,020.00, almost twice the previous record for a coin. Half the bid price was to be delivered to the United States Treasury, plus the $20 to monetize the coin, while Stephen Fenton was entitled to the other half. The auction took less than nine minutes.
Discovery of ten more coins
In August 2005, the United States Mint announced the recovery of ten additional stolen 1933 double eagle gold coins from the family of Philadelphia jeweler Israel Switt, the illicit coin dealer identified by the Secret Service as a party to the theft who admitted selling the first nine double eagles recovered a half century earlier. In September 2004, the coins' ostensible owner, Joan Switt Langbord, voluntarily surrendered the ten coins to the Secret Service. In July 2005, the coins were authenticated by the United States Mint, working with the Smithsonian Institution, as being genuine 1933 double eagles.
According to various accounts, Israel Switt had many contacts and friends within the Philadelphia Mint, and reportedly had access to many points of the minting process. A secondary source reports the Secret Service found that only one man had access to the coins at the time and served prison time for a similar embezzlement in 1940 - George McCann. Switt may have obtained the stolen 1933 double eagles through a relationship with the head mint cashier. One theory is that McCann swapped previous year double eagles for the 1933 specimens prior to melting, thus avoiding compromise of accounting books and inventory lists.
Coin experts in the numismatic world have advanced an argument that Switt could have legally obtained the 1933 coins when he was exchanging gold bullion for coins. Although the Mint records clearly show that no 1933 double eagles were issued, there were allegedly three weeks in March 1933 when new double eagles could possibly have been legally obtained. The mint began striking double eagles on March 15, and Roosevelt's executive order to ban them was not finalized until April 5. On March 6, 1933, the Secretary of the Treasury ordered the Director of the Mint to pay gold only under license issued by the Secretary, and the United States Mint cashier's daily statements do not reflect that any 1933 double eagles were paid out.
Until the early 1970s (when President Nixon took the United States off the gold standard and President Ford signed legislation that again made it legal for the public to own gold bullion) any recovered 1933 double eagle, as gold bullion, was required to be melted. Therefore, while double eagles recovered prior to 1974 were melted down, any double eagle recovered now can be spared this fate. Currently, with the exception of the one sold on July 30, 2002, 1933 double eagle coins cannot be the legal possession of any member of the public, as they were never issued and hence remain the property of the United States government.
On October 28, 2010, United States District Court judge, Legrome D. Davis, released a 20-page decision, which led to a trial in July 2011. On July 20, 2011, after a 10-day trial, a jury ruled unanimously in favor of the United States government concerning ownership of the ten additional double eagles. The court concluded that the circumstantial evidence proved that Israel Switt had illegally obtained the coins from the United States government, and that they are thus still government property. The decision was affirmed on August 29, 2012, and the plaintiffs planned to appeal.
From 2003, the ten double eagles were stored at the United States Bullion Depository, Fort Knox, Kentucky. They were shown to jurors in Philadelphia during the July 2011 trial, but were then returned to Fort Knox, where they were to remain until a decision regarding their disposition. In April 2015 a United States federal appeals court ordered the coins returned to the Langbord family because the original asset seizure was conducted improperly, as the government failed to file a judicial civil forfeiture complaint within 90 days of the family's seized asset claim. This order was reversed on July 28, 2015, and in October 2015 the 13-judge en banc Third Circuit Court of Appeals heard oral argument in the ongoing appeal. On August 1, 2016, the en banc court reversed the previous ruling, finding the coins to be property of the United States government. The Langbords vowed to appeal to the Supreme Court.
In 2004, National Collectors Mint released gold-plated replicas of the 1933 double eagle, ostensibly under the authority of the Northern Mariana Islands, a U.S. Commonwealth. The NCM advertised and certified the coins as "legal tender of the CNMI", a bogus designation.
The replica coins did not include any "replica" or "copy" indications on their faces. The replica coins match the original coins in concept of design, though were not physical replicas. The only difference in basic design between the NCM replicas and the original double eagle was the addition of the CNMI territorial seal under the U.S. motto on the reverse.
After some controversy over the nature and marketing of these replicas, the coins were reissued with the word "copy" stamped across the eagle's abdomen.
Notes and references
- 1933 TEN DOLLARS OR EAGLE
- Laren Donovan (December 26, 2006). "Buried Treasure". Trusts and Estates. Archived from the original on 24 December 2010. Retrieved 26 January 2011.
- Leon Worden (January 2006). "1933 Double 'Legal' Barry Berke: The Saints' Biggest Advocate". COINage magazine. Retrieved 26 January 2011.
- Farouk-Fenton 1933 Double Eagle Sets New World Record Price!, Gold Rush Gallery
- Auction brings $7.6 million for 'Double Eagle', CNN July 30, 2002
- "United States Mint Recovers 10 Famed Double Eagles" (Press release). United States Mint. August 11, 2005. Retrieved July 23, 2011.
- "Double Eagle Trouble", ANS magazine 2002
- "The United States Mint Press Release", US Mint
- "Trial Likely for Langbord 1933s", numismaster.com
- Loftus, Peter (July 21, 2011). "Family Loses Coins Worth Millions in Dispute With U.S.". Wall Street Journal. Archived from the original on 22 July 2011. Retrieved July 23, 2011.
- Loftus, Peter (September 6, 2012). "Rare Gold Coins Belong to Mint, Judge Decides". Wall Street Journal. Retrieved September 7, 2012.
- Roach, Steve (July 21, 2011). "1933 double eagle trial: At long last, a conclusion". Coin World. Retrieved July 23, 2011.
- Ashby Jones (April 17, 2015). "Court Orders U.S. Mint to Return Famed Coins to Family". Wall Street Journal. Retrieved April 20, 2015.
- Hardiman, Thomas. "Decision in Langbord v. US Treasury, 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals". Retrieved November 20, 2016.
- Guarino, Ben (August 2, 2016). "'A high-stakes dispute over ten pieces of gold': Court reclaims priceless Double Eagle coins for U.S. government". washingtonpost.com.
- Hunt for Double Eagle, French version: A la recherche de la pièce perdue, produced by Laura Jones (Fulcrum TV), directed by Tilman Remme, 53 min, 2010
- Alison Frankel, "Double Eagle: the epic story of the world's most valuable coin." New York: Norton, 2006 ISBN 0-393-05949-9
- David Tripp, "Illegal tender: gold, greed, and the mystery of the lost 1933 Double Eagle." New York: Free Press, 2004 ISBN 0-7432-4574-1
- Bryan Christy, "Curse of the Double Eagle," Playboy Magazine, April 2004
- COINage Magazine, January 2006, "Barry Berke and the 1933 Double 'Legal'," pp. 46–48
- Linda Fairstein, "The Kills: Fictional story based on the King Farouk owned 'Double Eagle' coin." Little Brown, 2004 ISBN 978-0-7515-4284-4
- James Twining, "The Double Eagle," an investigation novel involving the FBI, United States Department of Treasury, Fort Knox, etc.
- The Double Eagle : the history of the $20 United States Gold Coin 1849–1933
- United States Mint: The Story of the 1933 Gold Double Eagle (original link, no longer valid)
- United States Mint: The Story of the 1933 Gold Double Eagle (archived version on archive.org)
- Press Release US Mint: United States Mint Recovers 10 Famed Double Eagles
- BBC news report