2006 United States Senate election in New York
Clinton: 40–50% 50–60% 60–70% 70–80% 80–90%
Spencer: 40–50% 50–60%
|Elections in New York State|
The 2006 United States Senate election in New York was held November 7, 2006. Incumbent Democrat Hillary Rodham Clinton won, by a more than two-to-one margin, a second term representing New York in the United States Senate. Clinton was challenged by Republican John Spencer, a former Mayor of Yonkers, New York. Spencer won his party nomination by defeating former national security staffer K. T. McFarland in a primary.
- 1 Democratic nomination
- 2 Republican nomination
- 3 Third party nominations
- 4 General election
- 5 Legacy
- 6 See also
- 7 References
- 8 External links
Hillary Rodham Clinton announced in November 2004 that she would seek a second term in the Senate, and began fundraising and campaigning. Clinton faced opposition for the Democratic party nomination from the anti-war base of her own party, that had become increasingly frustrated with her support for the Iraq War.
On October 12, 2005 New Paltz firefighter and activist Steven Greenfield, a former Green Party leader, announced he would run as a Democrat. On December 6, 2005, labor advocate Jonathan Tasini announced that he would run as well, running as an antiwar candidate, calling for immediate withdrawal of troops from Iraq, universal health care, expansion in Medicare benefits, the creation of Universal Voluntary Accounts for pensions, and what he termed "New Rules For the Economy", a more labor-centric as opposed to the corporate-centric approach to economic matters espoused by Clinton. Tasini was president of Economic Future Group and former president of the National Writers Union. Tasini was supported by anti-war activist Cindy Sheehan, who had in October said of Clinton, "I will resist her candidacy with every bit of my power and strength...I will not make the mistake of supporting another pro-war Democrat for president again."
On March 31, 2006, businessman Mark Greenstein announced his run for the seat. Greenstein, endorsed by the New Democrats, presented himself as a non-liberal Democrat who was campaigning to "bring the far left back to reality that Big Government is the source of most ongoing problems Democrat constituents face." He contended that Clinton was "too liberal" in her support for regulations, "too wishy-washy" on the Iraq war and on gay rights, and had lost integrity by using the Dubai Ports issue for political purposes. Greenstein challenged Clinton to sign a pledge that she would serve out her full 6 year Senate term if re-elected. However, in May 2006, Greenfield endorsed Tasini and essentially dropped out of the race.
On June 1, 2006, Clinton accepted the unanimous endorsement of the New York State Democratic Party's convention in Buffalo. Eight days later, Greenstein dropped out of the race. Tasini pressed on, submitting 40,000 signatures to the State Election Commission on July 14, far more than the 15,000 needed to force a primary. Clinton's campaign said that she would not challenge the signatures.
|Democratic||Hillary Rodham Clinton (Incumbent)||640,955||83.00%|
|Democratic||Jonathan B. Tasini||124,999||17.00%|
New York Republicans originally had high hopes of mounting a serious challenge to Clinton, and derailing her expected future presidential bid. However, Clinton was politically strong in the state and no major Republican entered the race, with Governor George Pataki and early 2000 senate opponent Rudy Giuliani both declining to run. The two most prominent Republicans contemplating a challenge to Clinton were lawyer Ed Cox (the son-in-law of former President Richard M. Nixon) and Westchester County District Attorney Jeanine Pirro.
Pirro was considered the front-runner, but her campaign had immediate difficulties. During her August 10, 2005 live televised candidacy announcement in New York City, she paused for more than thirty seconds looking for a missing part of her speech, then asked, on the air, "Do I have page 10?" Democrats re-aired the sequence as part of a Jeopardy! theme parody. The Conservative Party of New York was also reluctant to embrace Pirro. On August 18, 2005, another Republican candidate, former Mayor of Yonkers John Spencer, gave a radio interview in which he attacked Pirro, calling her chances of winning the Conservative Party of New York State nomination "a Chinaman's chance." Spencer later apologized.
On October 14, 2005, Governor Pataki endorsed Pirro. Later that day, Cox withdrew from the race; his campaign had raised only $114,249 in contributions in the prior three months. On October 18, 2005, remarks by Pirro that appeared to suggest that Democrats were indifferent to child molesters and murderers drew sharp criticism from the Clinton campaign and others.
Pirro trailed Clinton badly in fund-raising and in polls; her campaign had failed to gain traction. Under pressure from state party officials, she dropped out of the race on December 21, 2005, to run for New York State Attorney General instead, leaving the Republicans without a well-known candidate. The announcement was timed to coincide with the 2005 New York City transit strike, so as to draw minimal attention to the Republicans' difficulties. Pirro did not mention her campaign woes, but instead said, "I have concluded that my head and my heart remain in law enforcement, and that my public service should continue to be in that arena."
Declared Republican nominees now included Spencer and K. T. McFarland, who was a Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Public Affairs under President Ronald Reagan. Cox considered reentering the race but did not. Politically, Spencer was generally opposed to abortion, against gun control, and a supporter of tighter border security. He supported the George W. Bush administration and its policies, including the war in Iraq. Spencer came out in favor of New York's Court of Appeals denying same-sex marriage to 42 gay and lesbian couples who challenged that denial as unconstitutional. Spencer said that marriage equality for same-sex couples equated to "special rights for gays." Spencer was endorsed by Republican officials such as Congressman Vito Fossella. In contrast, McFarland was pro-choice. However, McFarland ran into trouble with a March comment that appeared to allege that the Clinton campaign had been flying helicopters low over her Southampton, New York house and spying on her; she later said she had been joking, but the episode upset her. In May, McFarland's campaign manager Ed Rollins made personal life charges against Spencer, to which the latter responded, "Shame on you."
On May 31, 2006, Spencer won the endorsement of the state Republican Party organization but did not achieve the threshold of 75 percent he needed to prevent McFarland from gaining an automatic position on the primary ballot. He received 63 percent and would thus have to face McFarland in the September 12 Republican primary. Spencer called on McFarland to step aside after the vote, but McFarland said she would not. In a June 2006 radio ad, Spencer attacked national Republicans for not funding his campaign. On August 22, McFarland announced that she would be suspending her campaign until further notice after her daughter was caught shoplifting.
On September 12, 2006, Spencer defeated McFarland in the Republican Primary, winning 61 to 39 percent of the vote. Republican turnout was less than 6%, the lowest level in more than 30 years. Spencer would also gain the Conservative Party line.
Third party nominations
Howie Hawkins was the Green Party's candidate for the United States Senate in the state of New York.
His signature campaign issue was the Iraq War. Specifically, Hawkins criticized Senator Clinton's endorsement of the Iraq war resolution, and continued support for an American troop presence in Iraq.
Hawkins pledged to implement what he described as a modern-day version of the Hatfield–Kennedy Amendment (a proposed Senate resolution intended to cut off funding for the Vietnam War) which would defund military operations for the U.S. Armed Forces unless and until they were redeployed out of theater, and possibly replaced by an international peacekeeping force.
He called upon supporters of Tasini to vote for him in the general election.
- Hillary Rodham Clinton (Democrat) - incumbent U.S. Senator from New York, serving since January 3, 2001. The wife of Bill Clinton, the 42nd President of the United States, she was First Lady of the United States during his two terms from 1993 to 2001. Before that, she was a lawyer and the First Lady of Arkansas. Clinton was also on the lines of the Independence Party of New York and the Working Families Party. The Liberal Party of New York did not appear on the ballot in 2006.
- John Spencer (Republican) - former Mayor of Yonkers, New York (1995–2003). Prior to entering politics as a member of the Yonkers City Council in 1991, he worked in retail, food service, construction, waste management and banking. Spencer was also on the line of the Conservative Party of New York.
- Bill Van Auken (Socialist Equality)- a full-time writer for the World Socialist Web Site and the 2004 Socialist Equality Party candidate for U.S. President.
- Roger Calero (Socialist Workers)- a writer for The Militant, associate editor of Perspective Mundial, and the 2004 Socialist Workers Party candidate for US President.
- Howie Hawkins (Green)- an American politician and activist. He co-founded the anti-nuclear Clamshell Alliance in 1976 and the Green Party in the United States in 1984.
- Boris Krymskiy (I) - an independent candidate according to some FEC filings, but he was not listed on the ballot or included in final results.
- Jeff Russell (Libertarian)- Russell's campaign slogan was "A Vote for Peace and Liberty is Never a Wasted Vote."
Clinton spent $36 million for her re-election, more than any other candidate for Senate in the 2006 elections.
Polls during the campaign generally showed Clinton with a 20-point lead or better over Spencer, with none of the third-party candidates — Hawkins, Bill Van Auken of the Socialist Equality Party, and Jeff Russell of the Libertarian Party — showing strength.
On November 7, 2006, Clinton won easily, garnering 67% of the vote to Spencer's 31%.
|Source||Date||Clinton (D)||Spencer (R)|
|Marist College||September 30, 2005||62%||31%|
|Strategic Vision (R)||October 27, 2005||66%||19%|
|Strategic Vision (R)||December 8, 2005||67%||20%|
|Quinnipiac||January 20, 2006||60%||30%|
|Siena Research Institute||January 30, 2006||58%||31%|
|Marist College||January 30, 2006||62%||33%|
|Strategic Vision (R)||March 2, 2006||63%||24%|
|Quinnipiac||March 30, 2006||60%||30%|
|Zogby International||April 4, 2006||54%||33%|
|Strategic Vision (R)||April 28, 2006||58%||24%|
|Siena Research Institute||May 4, 2006||58%||33%|
|Marist College||May 10, 2006||63%||33%|
|Quinnipiac||May 18, 2006||63%||27%|
|Siena Research Institute||June 19, 2006||58%||32%|
|Quinnipiac||June 22, 2006||57%||33%|
|Marist College||July 19, 2006||61%||34%|
|Rasmussen||August 5, 2006||61%||31%|
|Siena Research Institute||August 7, 2006||58%||32%|
|Marist College||August 23, 2006||60%||35%|
|Marist College||September 8, 2006||62%||32%|
|Siena Research Institute||September 18, 2006||62%||33%|
|Quinnipiac||October 5, 2006||66%||31%|
|Siena Research Institute||October 16, 2006||59%||32%|
|Quinnipiac||October 19, 2006||65%||30%|
|Marist College||October 20, 2006||67%||30%|
|Siena Research Institute||November 3, 2006||65%||28%|
|Marist College||November 3, 2006||65%||32%|
The election was not close, with Clinton winning 58 of New York's 62 counties. Clinton had a surprisingly strong performance in upstate New York which tends to be tossup. When Clinton's upstate margins combined with her huge numbers out of New York City, there was no coming back for the Republicans. Clinton was sworn in for what would be her last term in the senate serving from January 3, 2007 to January 21, 2009 when she assumed the office of United States Secretary of State.
|Democratic||Hillary Rodham Clinton||2,698,931|
|Independence||Hillary Rodham Clinton||160,705|
|Working Families||Hillary Rodham Clinton||148,792|
|total||Hillary Rodham Clinton (Incumbent)||3,008,428||67.0||+11.7|
|Socialist Equality||Bill Van Auken||6,004||0.1||n/a|
|Socialist Workers||Roger Calero||6,967||0.2||+0.2|
- Percentages do not add to 100% due to rounding.
- Per New York State law, Clinton and Spencer totals include their minor party line votes: Independence Party and Working Families Party for Clinton, Conservative Party for Spencer.
- In addition, 213,777 ballots were blank, void, or scattered, and are not included in the Turnout sum or percentages.
Clinton's victory margin over her Republican opponent (67%–31%) was a significant gain over her showing in the 2000 senate race against Rick Lazio (55%–43%). She carried all but four of New York's sixty-two counties.
It was the second-largest margin of victory for a Senate race in New York history, and the third-largest for a statewide race in New York. Clinton's 2006 margin did not quite equal the percentage received by Eliot Spitzer in the concurrent gubernatorial race (69%%–29%) nor by Charles Schumer in his 2004 Senate re-election campaign (71%%–24%), both of which had also been against little-known Republican opponents.
Clinton was criticized by some Democrats for spending too much in a one-sided contest, while some supporters were concerned she did not leave more funds for a potential presidential bid in 2008. In the following months she transferred $10 million of her Senate funds toward her 2008 presidential campaign.
Following her Attorney General loss, Pirro left electoral politics and became a television judge and political commentator. Spencer left politics altogether. Tasani ran for a House seat in 2010 but was not competitive. Clinton fell short in her 2008 presidential nomination bid, served as U.S. Secretary of State for four years, and then ran again in the United States presidential election, 2016 but suffered a general election loss. The candidate from this 2006 senate campaign whose officeholding instanced furthest into the future turned out to be McFarland, who in 2017 became U.S. Deputy National Security Advisor.
- "Tasini Launches Bid To Defeat Clinton - December 7, 2005 - The New York Sun". Nysun.com. December 7, 2005. Retrieved December 14, 2010.
- Jonathan Tasini for New York Primary campaign site.
- "Opinion". Madison.com. Archived from the original on September 19, 2008. Retrieved December 14, 2010.
- "家具の運送は引っ越し業者にお任せ". Newdems2008.org. Retrieved July 18, 2016.
-  Archived September 28, 2007, at the Wayback Machine
- "Attorney general contender says to give peace candidate a chance". Thevillager.com. Retrieved December 14, 2010.
- "Regional & NY State News on". Newsday.com. December 1, 2010. Retrieved December 14, 2010.
- PaulKB (June 9, 2006). "Senate Race Dropout - Capitol Confidential". Blogs.timesunion.com. Archived from the original on October 13, 2007. Retrieved December 14, 2010.
- Murray, Mark (September 5, 2006). "GOP unable to stop Hillary in 2006". NBC News.
- Raymond Hernandez and Patrick J. Healy (December 22, 2005). "Pirro Quits Senate Race to Run for Attorney General". The New York Times. Retrieved November 11, 2008.
- [dead link]
-  Archived December 18, 2005, at the Wayback Machine
- Hernandez, Raymond (October 20, 2005). "Pirro's Jab at the Assembly Infuriates State Democrats". The New York Times. Retrieved May 27, 2010.
- Hirschkorn, Phil (December 21, 2005). "Sen. Clinton's GOP challenger quits race". CNN. Retrieved August 22, 2006.
- "Online Guide to New York Politics". Politics1. Retrieved December 14, 2010.
- Issues - Spencer for Senate. Retrieved April 17, 2006.
- Horrigan, Marie (May 31, 2006). "NY Senate: Spencer Wins GOP Nod, But Still Faces Primary". Congressional Quarterly. Archived from the original on August 29, 2006.
- "KT McFarland Suspends Senate Campaign After Daughter's Arrest". NY1. August 22, 2006. Archived from the original on October 8, 2007.
- "GOP Primary Turnout Was Lowest In More Than 30 Years". Newsday. September 17, 2006.
- "Sample Ballot of Voting Machine, General Election, November 7, 2006" (PDF). New York State Board of Elections. Archived from the original (PDF) on October 30, 2008.
- "Socialist Equality Party announces candidates in New York, Michigan and California". Wsws.org. March 21, 2006. Retrieved December 14, 2010.
- FEC Disclosure Report Search Results Archived January 12, 2016, at the Wayback Machine
- "Is America Ready?". Newsweek. December 25, 2006. Retrieved September 27, 2007.
- New York State Board of Elections: Attorney General Archived November 5, 2013, at the Wayback Machine
- Kornblut, Anne E.; Zeleny, Jeff (November 21, 2006). "Clinton Won Easily, but Bankroll Shows the Toll". The New York Times. page A1.
- "Record millions roll in for Clinton White House bid". CNN. April 1, 2007. Retrieved April 2, 2007.