2013 Buffalo mayoral election
|Elections in New York State|
- 1 Background
- 2 Debates
- 3 Democratic primary
- 4 Conservative primary
- 5 Republican campaign
- 6 Endorsements
- 7 References
- 8 External links
The 2013 Buffalo mayoral race is notable as the first mayoral election in Buffalo's history to not feature any white, non-Hispanic candidates in either the primary or the general elections. A Buffalo News editorial noted that despite the historic racial aspect of the election, Buffalo voters that year tended to be more concerned with traditional issues such as crime and education, in sharp contrast to the deep ethnic divisions that have normally characterized city politics.
Brown was challenged in the Democratic primary by Bernard Tolbert, the former Special Agent-in-Charge of Buffalo's FBI field office, the former Vice-President of Security for the National Basketball Association, and a former executive with the Coca-Cola Company.
Rodriguez, a 32-year-old, Dominican-born Marine Corps veteran, small business owner, and Medaille College administrator, ran unopposed as Buffalo's first Republican mayoral candidate since 2005.
Other potential candidates
Local businessman Matthew Ricchiazzi was reported in June 2013 to be circulating petitions for a possible mayoral campaign. If a Ricchiazzi campaign had actually materialized, it would have touched off a rare Republican primary between him and Rodriguez.
Leading up to the primary elections on September 10, Brown, Tolbert and Rodriguez participated in three televised debates.
The first mayoral debate took place on August 14, 2013 at the Buffalo News auditorium, sponsored by the Buffalo Association of Black Journalists and moderated by Al Vaughters of WIVB-TV. The dominant issue at the first debate was crime, with Rodriguez disputing Brown's assertion that crime has decreased in the city since the previous election; Brown rebutted by calling Rodriguez's statistics "absolutely false" and "nonsense". In addition, both Tolbert and Rodriguez claimed that Buffalo's police department is understaffed and inefficient, with Brown disputing Tolbert's specific claims that there has been a net loss in officers employed by the Buffalo Police since Brown's mayoral tenure began. Other issues that were debated included unemployment, with Brown forced to defend his administration in the face of statistics cited by Rodriguez showing that the unemployment rate in Buffalo rose from 6.3% to 10% during Brown's two terms as mayor, and low graduation rates in the Buffalo Public Schools, with Tolbert calling for more involvement by the mayor's office in the school system and Rodriguez going even further, favoring complete mayoral control of the school board as is the case in New York City and Yonkers, while Brown reaffirmed his commitment to cooperation with the Board of Education but denied he had the authority to directly participate in school-district policymaking.
The second debate was held on August 22, 2013 at St. Mary's School for the Deaf, sponsored by the Parkside Community Association and moderated by Buffalo News reporter Brian Meyer, with questions fielded directly from the audience. The beleaguered state of the Buffalo Public Schools was the dominant topic in the second debate, with Tolbert elaborating on his earlier position regarding mayoral involvement in the school board by proposing that three of the nine school board members, as well as the school superintendent, be appointed directly by the mayor, while Rodriguez repeated his earlier call for direct mayoral control of the schools. Brown, for his part, touted his success in restoring music programs to Buffalo city schools as well as the hiring of more school security officers. In addition, the Brown administration's record on economic development was attacked by both challengers, with Brown's boasts of $1.7 billion in development projects currently underway in the city countered by Tolbert's criticism that Brown allowed the Buffalo Economic Renaissance Corporation to fold under his watch, as well as his characterization of economic development in Buffalo as concentrated in downtown at the expense of the neighborhoods. As well, Rodriguez cited statistics showing that Buffalo's employment base has been reduced by 10,000 people since Brown took office in 2006.
The third and final mayoral debate was held on August 27, 2013 at WNED-TV studios. The candidates reiterated the points covered in the first two debates on police department staffing issues, unemployment, economic development, and problems in the Buffalo Public Schools. On the subject of crime, both Rodriguez and Tolbert derided Brown's use of gun buyback programs as a remedy for crime, with Tolbert characterizing the buybacks as "stunts". Also in the third debate, Tolbert was put on the defensive when he was asked about a sexual harassment lawsuit that had been filed against him while he was an executive at the National Basketball Association, while Brown was compelled to deny reports that his administration was rewarding campaign donors with patronage jobs as a quid pro quo and described a lawsuit filed against the city by a housing development company alleging a pay-to-play policy for awarding contracts as "baseless" and "absolute nonsense".
Though praised for his experience in crimefighting and community service and his "straight-shooting vibe", Tolbert was criticized for waiting until relatively late in the election to announce his candidacy, spending many months courting potential backers and conspicuously attending community events as speculation grew, but not establishing a campaign finance committee until April 2 nor officially entering the race until May 11.
In the run-up to the primary, a Siena College poll commissioned by the Buffalo News and WGRZ-TV and conducted between August 11 and 13, 2013 favored Brown to win the Democratic primary election against Tolbert by a margin of 61-32. According to a Buffalo News editorial published on August 17, though his fundraising prowess, his name recognition and the other benefits of incumbency, and the great progress in waterfront development that took place during his administration would have made any primary challenge difficult, Brown's especially formidable lead was described as first and foremost a product of the shortcomings of his opponent's campaign, an anemic one by a political novice whose muddled message has failed to resonate with voters, and particularly with the African-American community whose loyalty to Brown Tolbert had hoped to challenge. For his part, Tolbert accused Brown of pressuring city workers to donate to his campaign as a condition of continued employment as well as engaging in intimidation tactics against volunteers on opposing campaigns, the latter of which was echoed by Rodriguez.
Despite an impressive performance by Tolbert in the three mayoral debates that frequently put Brown on the defensive, a subsequent Siena College poll taken three weeks after the aforementioned one showed that Brown had widened his lead over Tolbert by four points.
Commenting on Brown's official nomination the day after the election, a Buffalo News editorial reiterated the points made in the August 17 editorial regarding Brown's name recognition and the capital investments on the waterfront, also opining that the incumbent benefited from an electorate that largely believed Buffalo is heading in the right direction despite the problems facing the city school system, on which Tolbert tried and failed to capitalize. The editorial also mentioned the ample airtime on local television the Brown campaign purchased with its massive "fundraising war chest" for its commercial, which prominently featured President Barack Obama's praise of the sitting mayor during a visit to the University at Buffalo on August 22, 2013.
Contrary to predictions, turnout in the primary was historically low, with roughly 20% of registered Democrats voting. This apathy was attributed variously to Brown's perceived invincibility given his overwhelming lead in the polls, or to a failure by both Brown and Tolbert to inspire enthusiasm among city voters.
In July 2013, under the terms of New York State's electoral fusion law, Rodriguez announced plans to mount a write-in candidacy as a Conservative to challenge that party's official endorsement of Brown, much as 2005 Republican candidate Kevin Helfer did, and also to circulate petitions for a possible independent run. Rodriguez was indeed able to collect the required number of valid signatures to run as a Conservative, but the Erie County Conservative Party, who had earlier endorsed Brown, vigorously sought to fend off Rodriguez's challenge by distributing a mailer to Conservative-registered city voters assailing Rodriguez for his support of the NY SAFE Act and his past unpaid student loans, a move Rodriguez described as "ugly, dirty, slanderous and baseless politics that people have grown to detest" employed in order "to deny voters a choice". The party also legally challenged all of the petitions collected by Rodriguez based on a little-known stipulation that the notaries public who distribute Opportunity To Ballot petitions must swear in the signers; this effort was dismissed by Erie County Supreme Court Justice John Michalek, setting the stage for a Conservative primary.
The Conservative primary was held on September 10, 2013. Brown captured 70 of the votes cast, while Rodriguez captured 44 and Tolbert 11.
Rodriguez officially announced his candidacy on February 6, 2013. His robust campaign featured an active social media presence and an emphasis on grassroots campaigning as exemplified by his "30 Day Every Neighborhood Tour" in September and October, which saw the candidate go door-to-door interacting with and fielding questions from residents of all parts of the city. Nonetheless, it was remarked in the Buffalo News that although Rodriguez has generated some buzz among Buffalo Hispanics, he has as yet failed to unite the city's Latino community in support of his long-shot candidacy.
In addition to his pursuit of the Conservative line, Rodriguez's petitions for an independent run also bore fruit with his announcement on September 25 that he would be running on a new ballot line, dubbed the Progressive Party. The party's name and platform make direct reference to the Progressive or "Bull Moose" Party founded by Theodore Roosevelt in 1912, with a stated goal of reforming city government by transcending partisan divisions and "making governmental changes parallel with the changing needs of its people... with a dignity defined by moral strength and urgency".
Brown received the endorsement of the Erie County Democratic Party, and also of the Erie County Conservative, Working Families, and Independence parties. He was also endorsed by, among others, New York Governor Andrew Cuomo, U.S. Senator Charles Schumer, U.S. Congressman Brian Higgins, New York State Senator Tim Kennedy, Erie County Executive Mark Poloncarz, New York State Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli, New York State Assemblypeople Crystal Peoples-Stokes, Sean Ryan, and Michael Kearns (the latter of whom had been his primary challenger in the previous election), the Buffalo Niagara Partnership, and the Buffalo Niagara Association of Realtors.
Tolbert, whose criticism of Brown in the months leading up to the Democratic primary largely centered on the incumbent mayor's crime-fighting efforts, received the endorsement of the Buffalo Police Benevolent Association in July 2013. Tolbert also received the endorsement of Challenger Community News, one of Buffalo's two African-American community newspapers.
Rodriguez received the endorsement of the City of Buffalo Republican Committee. However, the Erie County Republican Party has declined to endorse Rodriguez, amid accusations from Rodriguez's camp that county Republican officials have pressured him to drop out of the race for fear that increased voter turnout in heavily Democratic Buffalo could be a detriment to Republican candidates for countywide office. Rodriguez also received the endorsement of "The Griffin", the Canisius College student paper.
- "City Hall Holiday Schedule". City of Buffalo. Retrieved May 11, 2013.
- Terreri, Jill (August 4, 2013). "Historic Buffalo mayoral race has voters asking, 'What will you do?'". Buffalo News. Retrieved August 31, 2013.
- Warner, Gene (May 11, 2013). "Tolbert officially announces bid to unseat Brown as Buffalo mayor". Buffalo News. Retrieved July 25, 2013.
- "Meet Bernie Tolbert". Bernie Tolbert for Mayor. Archived from the original on August 13, 2013. Retrieved August 18, 2013.
- McCarthy, Robert J. (April 2, 2013). "Ex-Buffalo FBI chief Tolbert ready to enter mayoral race". Buffalo News. Retrieved September 24, 2013.
- Hassett, Ashley (February 6, 2013). "Republican Rodriguez announces candidacy for Buffalo mayor". WBFO. Retrieved September 27, 2013.
- McKinley, Dave (May 9, 2013). "The Tolbert Factor in the Race for Buffalo Mayor". WGRZ. Archived from the original on June 30, 2013. Retrieved May 23, 2013.
- "About Sergio Rodriguez for Mayor of Buffalo". Archived from the original on September 28, 2013. Retrieved August 18, 2013.
- Terreri, Jill (September 15, 2013). "Brown avoids Democratic factionalism, gains wide support for re-election bid". Buffalo News. Retrieved September 24, 2013.
- McCarthy, Robert J. (June 14, 2013). "City GOP backs Rodriguez for mayor". Buffalo News. Retrieved June 29, 2013.
- Spewak, Danny (August 15, 2013). "Mayoral Candidates Argue About Crime at Debate, Among Other Issues". WGRZ. Archived from the original on September 1, 2013. Retrieved September 1, 2013.
- Smallwood, Brittni (July 23, 2013). "Mayoral candidates to debate August 14". WIVB. Archived from the original on September 1, 2013. Retrieved September 1, 2013.
- Preval, Jeff (August 15, 2013). "Truth Test: First Debate in Buffalo Mayor Race". WGRZ. Archived from the original on September 1, 2013. Retrieved September 1, 2013.
- "Candidates for Buffalo mayor debate". YNN Buffalo. August 14, 2013. Retrieved September 1, 2013.
- Kingston, Rachel (August 22, 2013). "FULL VIDEO: 2nd Buffalo Mayoral Debate". WIVB. Archived from the original on August 24, 2013. Retrieved September 1, 2013.
- Desmond, Mike (August 22, 2013). "Mayoral candidates hold second debate". WBFO. Retrieved September 1, 2013.
- "Buffalo Mayoral Candidates Face Off in Debate". WKBW. August 27, 2013. Archived from the original on September 1, 2013. Retrieved September 1, 2013.
- Terreri, Jill (August 28, 2013). "3rd debate raises fact-check issues in Buffalo mayoral contest". Buffalo News. Retrieved September 1, 2013.
- Bedenko, Alan (August 28, 2013). "Buffalo Mayoral Debate the Third". Artvoice. Retrieved September 1, 2013.
- Esmonde, Donn (August 17, 2013). "Tolbert is woefully unprepared for mayoral race". Buffalo News. Retrieved August 18, 2013.
- Terreri, Jill (August 17, 2013). "Buffalo News/WGRZ poll shows strong support for Buffalo Mayor Byron W. Brown". Buffalo News. Retrieved August 22, 2013.
- Kompos, Athan (August 18, 2013). "Buffalo Mayoral Race Poll: Brown Holds Large Lead". WGRZ. Archived from the original on August 18, 2013. Retrieved August 18, 2013.
- Kelly, Geoff (August 15, 2013). "Welcome to the Brown Machine". Artvoice. Retrieved August 18, 2013.
- Lionti, Kaitlyn (August 2, 2013). "Buffalo mayoral race heats up as the primary election approaches". YNN Buffalo. Retrieved August 18, 2013.
- "Poll shows incumbent mayors lead in upstate NY". Associated Press. September 8, 2013. Retrieved September 9, 2013.
- Fink, James (September 11, 2013). "Brown coasts to mayoral primary victories". Buffalo Business First. Retrieved September 11, 2013.
- Terreri, Jill (September 11, 2013). "Brown breezes to victory". Buffalo News. Retrieved September 13, 2013.
- Elzufon, Rachel (September 10, 2013). "Voters Head to Polls for Primary Election". WKBW. Retrieved September 18, 2013.
- McCarthy, Robert J. (September 11, 2013). "20% turnout for Democratic mayoral primary is by far the lowest in memory". Buffalo News. Retrieved September 15, 2013.
- McCarthy, Robert J. (July 5, 2013). "Rodriguez plans independent, Conservative candidacies". Buffalo News. Archived from the original on August 18, 2013. Retrieved July 25, 2013.
- McCarthy, Robert J. (September 9, 2013). "On Primary Day, races for mayor, sheriff command attention". Buffalo News. Retrieved September 15, 2013.
- Bedenko, Alan (September 6, 2013). "Conservative Party Defames Sergio Rodriguez". Artvoice. Retrieved September 29, 2013.
- Caputo, Michael R. (August 8, 2013). "Conservatives Tossed: Party's Legal Challenges Go Up in Smoke". Politics NY. Retrieved August 19, 2013.
- "Our Campaigns - Buffalo NY Mayor - C Primary Race - Sep 10, 2013". Our Campaigns. Retrieved September 15, 2013.
- Lionti, Kaitlyn (September 16, 2013). "Rodriguez begins '30 Day Every Neighborhood Tour' of Buffalo". YNN Buffalo. Retrieved September 23, 2013.
- Terreri, Jill (September 25, 2013). "Rodriguez to announce new ballot line". Buffalo News. Archived from the original on September 25, 2013. Retrieved September 27, 2013.
- "Progressive Party: The People's Party". WNYmedia Network. Retrieved September 27, 2013.
- Ross, Shannon (September 5, 2013). "Cuomo endorses Brown for Buffalo mayor". WIVB. Archived from the original on October 4, 2013. Retrieved September 6, 2013.
- "Endorsements". Re-Elect Mayor Byron Brown. Retrieved June 29, 2013.
- McCarthy, Robert J. (July 21, 2013). "Buffalo police union endorses Tolbert for mayor". Buffalo News. Retrieved July 25, 2013.
- "We Endorse TOLBERT FOR MAYOR: 'A BETTER CHOICE'". Challenger Community News. September 2, 2013. Archived from the original on September 25, 2013. Retrieved September 24, 2013.
- Kelly, Geoff (August 15, 2013). "Small talk". Artvoice. Retrieved August 18, 2013.
- "Was Republican Candidate For Buffalo Mayor Encouraged to Drop Out of Race?". WGRZ. March 22, 2013. Archived from the original on June 30, 2013. Retrieved May 23, 2013.
- "For Mayor, Sergio Rodriguez". The Griffin: Canisius College Student Paper. November 1, 2013. Retrieved January 9, 2013.