2013 Thane building collapse
|Date||4 April 2013|
|Location||Shil Phata, Mumbra, Thane, Maharashtra, India|
|Charges||Culpable homicide not amounting to murder, criminal conspiracy and dereliction of duty.|
On 4 April 2013, a building collapsed on tribal land in Mumbra, a suburb of Thane in Maharashtra, India. It has been called the worst building collapse in the area.[nb 3] 74 people died, including 18 children, 23 women, and 33 men, while more than 100 people survived. The search for additional survivors ended on 6 April 2013.
The building was under construction and did not have an occupancy certificate for its 100 to 150 low- to middle-income residents. Living in the building were the site construction workers and families. It was reported that the building was illegally constructed because standard practices were not followed for safe, lawful construction; land acquisition and resident occupancy.
By 11 April, a total of 15 suspects were arrested including builders, engineers, municipal officials and other responsible parties. Governmental records indicate that there were two orders to manage the number of illegal buildings in the area: a 2005 Maharashtra state order to use remote sensing and a 2010 Bombay High Court order. There were also complaints made to state and municipal officials.
On 9 April, a campaign began by the Thane Municipal Corporation to demolish area illegal buildings, focusing first on "dangerous" buildings. The forest department said that it will address encroachment of forest land in the Thane district. A call centre was established by the Thane Municipal Corporation to accept and track resolution of caller complaints about illegal buildings.
- 1 Collapse
- 2 Investigation
- 3 Background
- 4 Arrests
- 5 Legal proceedings
- 6 Actions to manage illegal buildings
- 7 See also
- 8 Notes
- 9 References
- 10 Additional reading
At 6:30 pm IST (13:00 UTC) on 4 April 2013, a building collapsed in the Shil Phata area of Mumbra, a suburb of Thane in Maharashtra, India. The building collapsed quickly. First, a section of the building collapsed, it tilted, and then the entire building was brought down. A witness described the event, "The building collapsed like a pack of cards within three to four seconds."
According to Hasina Shaikh, a school girl who lived on the fifth floor with her family: "I had just returned from school and was changing when the building started shaking and came down on us... When I regained consciousness later, I was in the hospital." She says she considers herself lucky to be alive. One survivor is a 10-month-old girl whose parents had not been found as of 6 April 2013. Reuters reported the last survivor was rescued on 5 April, a woman who was "found after workers heard her voice and used camera equipment to pinpoint her location under the rubble."
Dubbed the "miracle survivor", a four-year-old girl, Sandhya Thakur, was pulled from the wreckage. She was unable to open her eyes, but awoke on 7 April 2013 to the awareness that she had suffered a disaster. Her father and six brothers and sisters are missing; Her mother died when the building collapsed. She is physically unharmed, but having a hard time adjusting psychologically.
Building occupied while under construction
The building containing offices and apartments was under construction for six weeks prior to the disaster, but there are varying reports on the extent of the construction completion. The Times of India reported that "Twenty-five tenements on five storeys were complete and the sixth and seventh floors were under construction." Although there was no occupancy certificate, the first four storeys of the building were illegally inhabited by site construction workers and families. In addition to families of construction workers, there were also families headed by rickshaw drivers and/or those whose children attended tuition classes in the building. It is believed that the builder wanted the building to be inhabited to prevent it being demolished.
The developers, who intended to build up to 8 such illegal buildings, intended to sell the apartments for ₹1,100 to ₹1,400 per square foot. On average, the apartments were 175 square feet.
The building had come to the attention of the Municipal Commissioner RA Rajeevsaid because the building was said to be built illegally on forest land.[nb 4] Research into the collapsed building's land ownership has determined that it was owned by a tribal family, and the adjoining lot was owned by the forest department.
Although this property was not located on forest land, R.K. Pol, Chief Conservator of Forests, has said that the forest department will address encroachment issues in the Thane district from Jawahar-Mokhada to Alibaug.
The rescue efforts were supervised by District Collector P. Velarasu and Municipal Commissioner R.A. Rajeev, and the rescue was conducted by incident medical teams and fire tenders. A number of local hospitals treated the injured. The most critically injured people were sent to Sion and JJ Hospitals. Moderate injuries were treated at Thane Civil Hospital and Kalwa's Kalsekar and CSM Civic hospitals. As of 6 April 2013, 36 injured people were still receiving treatment.
Workers, including the National Disaster Response Force (NDRF), used bulldozers, hydraulic jacks, power saws and sledgehammers to break through the "mound of steel and concrete" and dug an additional 8 feet (2.4 m) below ground. The rescue effort was complicated by the way in which the floors were "sandwiched" in the collapse, making it difficult to find individuals in the rubble.
The rescue effort ended on 6 April. According to NDRF spokesperson R.S. Rajesh: "We have dug beyond the basement level, and everything is now cleared; there's nothing left."
The building collapse appeared to be the result of poor-quality building material and having been "weakly built", according to Police inspector Digamber Jangale and Police commissioner K.P. Raghuvanshi.[nb 5] Lawful building construction in Thane district requires blueprints to be filed and approved by municipal agencies and permits obtained to connect electricity, water and sewage services. The builders did not file the blueprints in this case.
By 12 April 2013 Hadisulla Rakbulla Choudhary, a partner of the developer, was arrested for his role.
Ramesh Patil, a legislator of the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) party, stated that the week before the incident he had complained the building was unfit and not legal. He wrote and sent photographs of this and other buildings to the Thane Municipal Commissioner R.A. Rajeev, Chief Secretary Jayanthkumar Banthia, and the Chief Minister. However, nothing was done.
At a state assembly meeting, Chief Minister of Maharashtra Prithviraj Chavan assured participants that there would be a thorough investigation of the circumstances leading up to the collapse of the building. Two individuals were suspended from duty: Senior Police Inspector K.P. Naik for collusion and the Deputy Commissioner of Thane, Deepak Chavan, for dereliction of duty.
The prevalence of illegal housing in India is due to a lack of housing coupled with high population growth, and illegal buildings are attractive to lower-income people because of the low housing costs. Many people moved to the greater Mumbai area in search of jobs, and without affordable housing, thousands sleep in slums or on the streets. The Ministry of Housing and Urban Poverty Alleviation reports that there are approximately 19 million families with inadequate housing. To meet the demands, there are many buildings constructed illegally. Further, some builders do not follow proper building practices and laws, or execute proper safety measures. Poor construction materials are also to blame in these circumstances. Within the Mumbai region there are estimated to be hundreds of illegal structures. Sameer Hashmi, a BBC reporter, says that activists "allege that unscrupulous builders often pay hefty bribes to authorities who turn a blind eye to these illegal structures and do not take any action against the builders."
RT reports that: "...incidents of this kind are not rare in India, where builders often care more for cutting construction expenses than for the security and quality of the work being done." This trend has been observed in other municipalities within Mumbai Metropolitan Development Authority in the Navi Mumbai Municipal Cooperation (NMMC) of Nationalist Congress Party, Vasai-Virar sector, and Ulhasnagar.
In February 2013, Sunil Kumar Lahoria, a Navi Mumbai developer, was killed after having lodged complaints about 600 area illegal buildings. His son, Sandeep Kumar, said: "My father paid a very heavy price for exposing irregularities that took place with the active involvement of government officers. He made use of the Right to Information Act to deal with corruption, but he was killed." Forest department officials say that during drives to resolve encroachments and to raze Mumbra-Diva area illegal buildings on forest land, their staff received threats against their lives and threats that women in their families would be raped. A Member of the Legislative Assembly, Jitendra Awhad, and his supporters were said to be the source of these threats. According to Awhad, the threats are "blown out of proportion".[nb 7]
2012 illegal building information
In December 2012 Legislator Pratap Sarnaik obtained information, in accordance with the Right to Information Act, about the scope of the construction of illegal buildings in the Thane district. The following was reported in The Hindu for Thane's divisions:
For the nine divisions under the corporation last year, 505 illegal buildings were demolished, there was action against 829 (which does not mean they were demolished), and in December, 2012 alone, 104 illegal constructions were detected. The year round 146 buildings were given notices, and 53 cases of violations were filed under the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act and 83 cases registered under the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation Act.
The Hindu reported: "while the TMC says illegal buildings were demolished or given stop work notices, in reality nothing happens. The buildings were rarely brought down and people continued to live there."
2010 Bombay High Court order
The total number of illegal structures are estimated to be about 490,000 in the Thane district according to information in the Bombay (Mumbai) High Court. The structures include slums, shops, chawls and other buildings. Although the court ordered demolition of all such buildings in 2010, the government's response was that no illegal structures built before 2001 would be demolished and no action was taken in response to this judgement.
2005 remote sensing order
According to Raju Phanse, Right to Information (RTI) activist and General Secretary of the Dharmarajya Paksha political party, Thane Municipal Corporation did not act upon the 2005 Maharashtra state resolution to identify illegal buildings. The order called for municipalities to use remote sensing technology to identify illegal buildings by 28 February 2005 and monitor satellite images every six months. R.A. Rajeev, Thane Municipal Commissioner, said that "we are doing what we can"; he admitted that 90% of Mumbra's buildings are illegal.
As of 9 April 13 people were arrested. Information from interrogation of the two builders, and documents found in one of the builder's homes, led to the arrest of the others in this case. Except for the engineers charged with dereliction of duty, the suspects are charged with culpable homicide not amounting to murder and criminal conspiracy. They could be sentenced up to life if convicted.
|Name||Position / role||Arrested on or before||Comments of alleged activity|
|Jamil or Jameel Qureshi||Builder||6 April 2013||He is charged with culpable homicide, not amounting to murder. Qureshi said that 22 of the 74 people killed were his relatives.|
|Salim Shaikh or Sheikh||Builder||6 April 2013||He is charged with culpable homicide, not amounting to murder.|
|Deepak Chavan or Chauhan||Deputy Commissioner, TMC||7 April 2013||Chavan was suspended from active duty for his role in the affair. He was apparently paid ₹500000 (US$7,900) for his final approval of the project.|
|Jehangir Sayyed or Sayeed||Head constable, Diaghar police station||7 April 2013||Sayyed is said to have been paid ₹4,000 for having arranged a meeting with Senior Inspector K. Naik and bribing police officers. The investigation will continue to determine who was bribed.|
|Babasaheb or Baba Shabeb Andhale||Assistant Municipal Commissioner of Thane||7 April 2013||Money was delivered to Andhale by Dawood Kamdar.|
|Hira Patil||Nationalist Congress Party (NCP) corporator||7 April 2013||Hira Patil, pulled into the case by Jabbar Patel, was paid ₹500,000 to co-ordinate co-operation with senior municipal officials in Thane and Kisna Madke.|
|Afroz Alam Ansari||Building material supplier||7 April 2013||Ansari supplied low cost building material.|
|Jabbar Patel||Real estate agent||7 April 2013||According to police, Patel connected the builders with Diaghar policemen to arrange for a no-objection certificate. He requested a meeting with senior officials was arranged through Diaghar officer Sayeed and he contacted Afroz Ansari for low cost building material.|
|Kiran Madke||Municipal Corporation clerk||7 April 2013||Madke was paid ₹500,000 to introduce Babasaheb Andhale to the developers.|
|Farooq Abdul Latif Chapra||Made building plans||9 April 2013||Called the "fake architect", he has no degree in architecture but created the building plan. On the date of arrest he was 59.|
|Rafiq Dawood Kamdar||Middleman / bribes||9 April 2013||A local journalist, he is suspected of co-ordinating the bribes of local officials and police for the builders; His name was found in one of the builder's diary. On the date of arrest he was 44. He is said to have "clicked photographs of the illegal buildings and had then taken money from the builders." Kamdar ran Aapka Buland Ujala, a local paper.|
|Subash Rawal||Executive Engineer, responsible for removing illegal construction||9 April 2013||Rawal is one of the "two top Thane municipal corporation engineers" charged with dereliction of duty. According to a senior police official, the engineers accepted bribes. Doing so, they did not conduct their assigned duties to remove encroached buildings.|
|Ramesh Inamdar||Deputy Engineer, responsible for removing illegal construction||9 April 2013||Inamdar is the other engineer charged with dereliction of duty.|
|Shyam Thorbole||Assistant Municipal Commissioner||11 April 2013||Thorbole was arrested for taking bribes of ₹100,000 related to illegal housing on 23 January 2013 and later suspended. He was arrested 11 April for taking a bribe to stop the demolition drive.|
|Hadisulla Rakbulla Choudhary||Developer's partner||12 April 2013||The Thane Police crime Branch Choudhary, also called "Uncle", was arrested by the crime branch of the Thane Police on 12 April 2013. He was a partner of the developer of the collapsed building.|
|Subhash Waghmare||employee of Thane Municipal Corporation||14 April 2013||Waghmare's name figured in the diary of builder Jameel Qureshi who bribed civic officials to overlook violations in the construction of the seven-storey building.|
|Ramdas Burud||employee of Thane Municipal Corporation||14 April 2013||Burud would regularly demand money from Qureshi who maintained a record of the cash paid to the officials.|
Chart of suspects' alleged roles
This chart was created based upon the builders, police and municipal suspects' alleged roles as identified in an article by the Pune Mirror.
|Chart of suspects' alleged roles|
In addition, TMC engineers Subash Rawal and Ramesh Inamdar allegedly received bribes so that they would not demolish the building.
The local court on 18 May 2013 granted bail to Afroz Ansari who had supplied materials and Ramdas Burud, a driver to one of the accused officials of TMC. Judge KR Warrier granted bail to them against personal bonds of Rs 15,000. The court on 17 May 2013, rejected the bail pleas of Deputy Municipal Commissioners Deepak Chavan, Shreekant Sarmokdam and Assistant Municipal Commissioner Shyam Thorbole and engineer Ramesh Inamdar.
Actions to manage illegal buildings
A formal campaign to demolish area illegal buildings began on 9 April 2013 and is expected to be conducted before the monsoon season. It will be led by Anil Patil, Senior Engineer. The first phase of a "demolition drive" begins as 57 illegal buildings in the district (including Mumbra-Kausa area) are vacated, taken over by the Thane Municipal Council (TMC) and demolished. To support the effort, 15 additional officials will be added to the demolition cell and 9 legal advisors will be added to address legal matters. The police are engaged to facilitate evictions.
Cut off utilities to all illegal buildings
Further, the TMC intends to have sewer, water, and electricity service disconnected at all illegal buildings in the district. Water and sewer should be able to be turned off immediately; TMC is requesting that electricity is turned off by the electric service.
Call centre established
The Thane Municipal Corporation established a call centre to receive complaints about illegal buildings on 10 April 2013. Its responsibilities include: notifying municipal officials of the complaints, tabulating information about actions taken and preparing reports of complaints and activities for the Municipal Commissioner. It is a 24 hours a day operation.
- Corruption in India
- Housing in India
- Illegal housing in India
- Poverty in India
- Parsik Hill, Illegal Housing section
- 2013 Savar building collapse, another building collapse that occurred during the same month
- 2013 Mumbai building collapse
- Reports from a day or two earlier reported 72 killed.
- The Voice of America reported on 6 April 2013 that 36 people were still being treated at local hospitals.
- It has also been called the worst building collapse disaster in the past 10 years within the state of Maharashtra, and the worst in the country in 20 years.
- He said, "We had repeatedly asked the forest department to take action. We had asked MSEB to cut electricity to the building. We have issued notices to about 250 illegal buildings in this belt. We try forcible removal. It is not easy. Also it's a congested area; our equipment is unusable here."
- An unidentified local witness stated that: "They made an eight-story building of what was supposed to be a four-story building. People from the municipality used to visit the building but the builder still continued to add floors."
- The builders constructed an illegal apartment and 50 chawls in Vasai-Virar. The buildings were built on land in Acholegaon to be used to build a hospital, school, and police training facility. Although there were attempts to bribe Vasai-Virar Municipal Corporation (VVMC) officials, the attempts were rebufffed and the buildings demolished.
- Awhad said: "I intervened in the action initiated against structures that have been around since 1980s. As far as threatening officials is concerned, everyone knows mild language doesn't work with them. "80% of constructions in Thane are illegal. That does not mean you demolish all of them."
- "Thane building collapse: 74 dead, both builders arrested". Zee News. 7 April 2013. Retrieved 9 April 2013.
- "Thane building collapse: 9 arrested, sent to police custody". IBN. 7 April 2013. Retrieved 7 April 2013.
- Associated Press. "Indian police arrest 9 in Mumbai building collapse ." The Times. 7 April 2013. Retrieved 7 April 2013.
- "India ends search for survivors in Mumbai rubble". BBC. Retrieved 2013-04-06.
- Prakash, Vivek. "Death toll rises to 72 in Mumbai building collapse". Reuters. Retrieved 2013-04-06.
- "Death toll rises to 72 in India building collapse". CNN. Retrieved 2013-04-06.
- "72 Dead in Indian Building Collapse ". Voice of America. 6 April 2013. Retrieved 6 April 2013.
- "Thane building collapse: Police arrest 2 civic engineers". Press Trust of India. 9 April 2013. Retrieved 9 April 2013.
- "Two top Thane municipal corporation engineers held for killer cave-in". The Times of India. 10 April 2013. Retrieved 10 April 2013.
- "Is Municipality as much to blame as builders for Thane building collapse?" IBN. 4 April 2013. Retrieved 5 April 2013.
- Nitin Yeshwantrao (6 April 2013). "Thane building collapse toll rises to 72, rescue ops end". Times of India. Retrieved 7 April 2013.
- "Thane: Four-year-old girl recovered from debris opens her eyes". IBN. 7 April 2013. Retrieved 7 April 2013.
- "India ends search for survivors in Mumbai rubble". BBC. 6 April 2013. Retrieved 6 April 2013.
- "Thane building collapse: Two more arrested, TMC begins demolition drive". DNA. 9 April 2013. Retrieved 9 April 2013.
- "45 killed as building collapses in India (PHOTOS)" RT News 5 April 2013. Retrieved 5 April 2013.
- "India building collapse near Mumbai kills 45." BBC News. 5 April 2013. Retrieved 5 April 2013.
- "Thane building collapse: 2 developers arrested; toll touches 72". The Hindu. 6 April 2013. Retrieved 6 April 2013.
- "Death toll in Thane building collapse mounts to 72." The Hindu Business Line. 6 April 2013. Retrieved 6 April 2013.
- Jethro Mullen and Harmeet Shah Singh. "At least 46 people killed in India building collapse." CNN. 5 April 2013. Retrieved 5 April 2013.
- Shoaib Ahmed, CNN-IBN. "Thane building collapse: 67 dead, marathon rescue operation still on." CNN-IBN 5 April 2013. Retrieved 5 April 2013.
- "Death Toll Hits 72 in India Building Collapse". NPR. Associated Press. Retrieved 6 April 2013.
- "Thane: Four-year-old girl recovered from debris opens her eyes." The Times of India. 7 April 2013. Retrieved 7 April 2013.
- Nitin Yeshwantrao. "Thane building collapse: 56 including 19 children dead, many missing". The Times of India. 6 April 2013. Retrieved 6 April 2013.
- "72 dead in Thane building collapse; 2 builders arrested." Hindustan Times. 6 April 2013. Retrieved 7 April 2013.
- "India Arrests 9 People in Fatal Building Collapse". The Wall Street Journal. 7 April 2013. Retrieved 8 April 2013.
- "Two developers arrested for Thane building collapse". The Times of India. 6 April 2013. Retrieved 6 April 2013.
- Imran Fazal (9 April 2013). "Killer builders put up chawls on government land". DNA. Retrieved 9 April 2013.
- "Police arrest two more in Thane building collapse case". 12 April 2013. Retrieved 12 April 2013.
- "Thane building collapse: Municipal officer suspended, probe ordered". IBN. 5 April 2013. Retrieved 5 April 2013.
- Alok Deshpande, Meena Menon (7 April 2013). "Illegal structures abound in Thane (photo of builders)". The Hindu (Mumbai). Retrieved 9 April 2013.
- "38 killed as building collapses in India (PHOTOS)" RT News 5 April 2013. Retrieved 5 April 2013.
- Vijay Singh, TNN (10 April 2013). "Lahoria's expose of illegal buildings led to murder?". The Times of India. Retrieved 10 April 2013.
- "Govt knew Thane district had 5 lakh illegal buildings, but did little." The Times of India. 6 April 2013. Retrieved 7 April 2013.
- HT Correspondent. "Illegal Buildings a big issue in Vasai-Virar." Hindustan Times. 5 July 2011. Retrieved 7 April 2013.
- Pradeep Gupta. "Ulhasnagar corporator accused of illegal construction on river bed". The Times of India. 26 October 2012. Retrieved 7 April 2013.
- Surendra P Ganga (11 April 2013). "Forest officials threatened for demolition". Hindustan Times. Retrieved 11 April 2013.
- Rajiv Singh (9 April 2013). "Fake architect, journalist held in Mumbra building collapse case". India TV News. Retrieved 9 April 2013.
- "Mumbai Bldg architect, local scribe held, taking number of arrests to 11". Hindustan. 9 April 2013. Retrieved 9 April 2013.
- "Mumbra collapse: Police, civic officials took ₹ 20 lakh to clear killer building". Pune Mirror. 8 April 2013. Retrieved 10 April 2013.
- Debasish Panigrahi (9 April 2013). "Cops, officials took bribe after bribe for illegal Thane building". Hindustan Times. Retrieved 10 April 2013.
- Gautam S Mengle (10 April 2013). "Authorities 'threatened' builders before striking deal to turn blind eye". The Indian Express. Retrieved 10 April 2013.
- "Thane building collapse: 2 more arrested". Mumbai. India Blooms News Service. 9 April 2013. Retrieved 9 April 2013.
- Pratik Salunke (10 April 2013). "Two Mumbra civic engineers arrested for accepting bribe". Hindustan Times. Retrieved 10 April 2013.
- "Another TMC official arrested in Thane building collapse case". DNA. 11 April 2013. Retrieved 11 April 2013.
- "Another TMC employees arrested in Thane building collapse case". Times od India. 15 April 2013. Retrieved 15 April 2013.
- "Thane building collapse case: Two get bail". CNN-IBN. 18 May 2013. Retrieved 18 May 2013.
- Varsha Dugar (10 April 2013). "Thane civic body goes hammer and tongs against illegal buildings". DNA. Retrieved 10 April 2013.
- "Thane building collapse: Two more arrested (with photo)". The Hindu. 9 April 2013. Retrieved 9 April 2013.
- "Building collapse: Thane municipal corporation sets up call centre for plaints". Business Line (Thane). 10 April 2013. Retrieved 10 April 2013.
- BBC. "In pictures: Deadly Mumbai building collapse" (slideshow). BBC. 7 April 2013.
- Times of India. "Govt knew Thane district had 5 lakh illegal buildings, but did little." Times of India. 6 April 2013. Retrieved 7 April 2013.