Thirty-year rule

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
  (Redirected from 30 year rule)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

The "thirty-year rule" is the informal name given to laws in the United Kingdom, the Republic of Ireland, and the Commonwealth of Australia that provide that certain government documents will be released publicly thirty years after they were created. Other countries' national archives also adhere to a thirty-year rule for the release of government documents.

United Kingdom[edit]

In the United Kingdom, the Public Records Act 1958 stated that "Public records...other than those to which members of the public have had access before their transfer...shall not be available for public inspection until they have been in existence for fifty years or such other period...as the Lord Chancellor may,...for the time being prescribe as respects any particular class of public records";[1] the closure period was reduced from fifty to thirty years by an amending act of 1967, passed during Harold Wilson's government. Among those who had repeatedly urged the scrapping of the fifty-year rule was the historian A. J. P. Taylor.

There were two elements to the rule: the first required that records be transferred from government departments to the Public Record Office (now The National Archives) after thirty years unless specific exemptions were given (by the Lord Chancellor's Advisory Council on Public Records); the second that they would be opened to public access at the same time unless their release was deemed likely to cause "damage to the country's image, national security or foreign relations".

Significant changes were made to the rules as a consequence of the Freedom of Information Act 2000 (FOIA) (which came into full effect on 1 January 2005). FOIA essentially removed the second of the thirty-year rules (the access one), and replaced it with provisions allowing citizens to request a wide range of information before any time limit has expired; and also removed some of the exemptions which had previously applied at the thirty-year point. After thirty years, records are transferred to The National Archives, and are reviewed under FOIA to see if they should be opened. The only rationale for keeping them closed within The National Archives is if a FOIA exemption applies.

As a result of this change, releases now happen monthly, rather than annually, and include more recent events, rather than only those over thirty years old.

An independent inquiry chaired by Paul Dacre, editor of the Daily Mail, recommended in January 2009 that the last restrictions on the release of information, such as Cabinet minutes, should be reduced to a fifteen-year embargo and phased in over a 15-year period.[2]

Change to a twenty-year rule[edit]

Under the Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010, the UK Government started moving towards a twenty-year rule. Files from 1983 were released in August 2013 rather than January 2014 as would previously have been the case, and files from 1984 in January 2014. There will continue to be two releases per year until 2022 when the National Archives will receive the files from 2001 and 2002, having caught up with the transition.[3]

Australia[edit]

In Australia, the thirty-year rule applied to Commonwealth (federal) government records, except for Cabinet handbooks (closed for fifty years) and raw census records (closed for 99 years). These periods were set out in the Archives Act 1983.

In 2009, the Archives Act was amended to reduce the closed period from thirty to twenty years, with Cabinet notebooks reduced from fifty to thirty years. Census records remain closed for 99 years to protect the privacy of individuals.[4]

Cabinet papers for a full year are released on 1 January each year. From 2011, two years of cabinet papers and three years of cabinet notebooks are released together until 2020 when the new periods are reached.

Canada[edit]

The Supreme Court of Canada has recognized that Cabinet confidentiality is essential to good government. In the decision Babcock v AG Canada[5] the Court explained the reason as:[6]

To preserve this rule of confidentiality, subsection 70(1) of the Privacy Act provides that the Act does not apply to confidences of the Queen's Privy Council for Canada. Other notable cases that expand upon the doctrine of cabinet confidentiality include Canada (Minister of Environment) v. Canada (Information Commissioner), 2003 FCA 68 and Quinn v. Canada (Prime Minister), 2011 FC 379.[6] As of 2013, after a time lag of 20 years Canadians can submit access-to-information requests for cabinet records through the Privy Council Office, but this comes at a cost of $5 per request and can take months to process.[7] In May 2018, it was disclosed that the Supreme Court of Canada under Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin had placed a "50-year from the time they rule on a case" embargo on public access to files related to the deliberations of the judges.[8]

According to Archivist Michael Dufresne, it was not until 1940 and the advent of the Second World War that Cabinet kept an agenda and minutes of its deliberations.[9] From 1867 to 1940, a succession of six men served as Clerk of the Privy Council, and their duties included serving as the only institutional memory bank of the Government of Canada. The appointment in 1940 of Arnold Danforth Patrick Heeney[10] as Clerk and as first Secretary to the Cabinet changed the format of memory bank from biological to scriptural. Heeney was surprised upon arrival by the informal ways in which important business was conducted:[9]

Order-in-Council PC 1940-1121 of March 25, 1940 ushered in a significant change in the documentation of government. The Order-in-Council read, in part:[9]

Heeney established procedures and for the first time recorded the minutes and conclusions of a cabinet body - the Cabinet War Committee.[11] In 1942, the Statutory Orders and Regulations Division was set up under PC 7992, 4 September 1942. Also under PC 7992, a registry for maintaining orders and minutes of council, Treasury Board Minutes and other government orders was established.[11] It was not until 1944 that the formal collection of "Cabinet Conclusions" was created.[9]

In the early 1980s, the PCO began a voluntary transfer of cabinet records, which had been declassified after a 30-year holding period, to the National Archives (which became Library and Archives Canada in 2004) where they became publicly available,[7] under the label "Cabinet Conclusions".[12] After an initial document dump that included records dated from 1937 to 1952, the PCO released the records on an annual basis.[7]

In 2008, two years after Prime Minister Stephen Harper was elected, the tradition of annual voluntary releases of Cabinet Conclusions stopped.[7]

In September 2013 while the Harper government was in power, PCO spokesman Raymond Rivet told a news organisation that the office was “committed” to making government documents and information accessible but that “Processing these records requires a significant investment of resources. We will continue to process and release records as resources permit.”[7]

In May 2017, it came to light that the Government of Canada was under no obligation to release documentary records after a number of years. NDP MP Murray Rankin, a legal scholar, said at the time:[13]

[14]

Israel[edit]

Israel adopted the British model of a thirty-year rule as the basis for reviewing and declassifying its foreign policy documents.[15] Israeli declassification policy is based on the Archives law of 1955. The principle of the law is that all material is to be released after thirty years, subject to limitations based on damage to state security, foreign policy or personal privacy. In practice this means that declassification of documents are fixed at different periods based on type of material and date of production.[16]

The original law has been modified and updated a number of times.[16] Following a 2010 update of the legislation, the office of the Prime Minister released as statement explaining that "the new regulations shorten the period after which non-security-related material may be viewed, from 30 to 15 years, while lengthening the confidentiality period of certain defense-related documents to 70 years in cases in which Israel's security conditions require it".[17]

Germany[edit]

The German Federal Archives generally makes its holdings available after 30 years. Exceptions are for personnel files, which are opened only 10 years after the death of the individual or 100 years after the person's birth if the date of death is unknown, and records dealing with taxation, credit, and banking, which are sealed for 60 years.

Additionally, Federal Archives holdings originating with the Communist Party and communist organizations of the former German Democratic Republic (East Germany) have been available for decades with almost no limitations. The Federal Archives has also worked to make East German government records available with a minimum of time limitation. In any event, in October 2020, 30 years will have passed since the dissolution of the GDR.[18]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ UK Public Records Act 1958
  2. ^ Deborah Summers "30-year rule on government disclosure should be halved, Dacre inquiry says", The Guardian, 29 January 2009.
  3. ^ The National Archives "20-year rule".
  4. ^ "Explanatory Memorandum to Freedom of Information (Removal of Conclusive Certificates and Other Measures) Bill 2008" (PDF). Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet. Archived from the original (PDF) on 14 May 2009.
  5. ^ 2002 SCC 57 at paragraph 18
  6. ^ a b canada.ca: "Confidences of the Queen's Privy Council for Canada (Cabinet confidences)", 2014-04-30
  7. ^ a b c d e canada.com: "Release of government documents backlogged", 2 Sep 2013
  8. ^ theglobeandmail.com: "Supreme Court of Canada to keep records of deliberations secret for at least 50 years", 14 May 2018
  9. ^ a b c d Library and Archives Canada Blog: "The beginning of the Conclusions: documenting the exercise of power", 16 Feb 2018
  10. ^ sic?
  11. ^ a b "Archives Search", 2018-05-20
  12. ^ Library and Archives Canada: "Cabinet Conclusions", 2018-02-16
  13. ^ cbc.ca: "Government accused of hoarding Canadian history in 'secret' archives", 25 May 2017
  14. ^ theglobeandmail.com: "Supreme Court of Canada to keep records of deliberations secret for at least 50 years", 14 May 2018
  15. ^ Pappe, Ilan (1999). The Israel/Palestine Question. Routledge. p. 153. ISBN 0415169488.
  16. ^ a b Fischer, Louise (2008). 8e Conference Internationale Des Editeurs de Documents Diplomatiques 8th International Conference of Editors of Diplomatic Documents: Des Etats Et de ... about States and Uno (Diplomatie Et Histoire). European Interuniversity Press. p. 78. ISBN 9052013896.
  17. ^ Ravid, Barak (28 July 2010). "State archives to stay classified for 20 more years, PM instructs". Haaretz. Retrieved 2012-10-18.
  18. ^ "Fristen zur Benutzung".

External links[edit]