50 Cent Party
|50 Cent Party|
|Literal meaning||five-dime party|
|Literal meaning||Internet commentator|
50 Cent Party, 50 Cent Army and wumao (//) are terms for Internet commentators who are suspected of being hired by the authorities of the People's Republic of China to manipulate public opinion and disseminate disinformation to the benefit of the governing Chinese Communist Party (CCP). It was created during the early phases of the Internet's rollout to the wider public in China.
The name is derived from the allegation that commentators are paid ¥0.50 for every post. They create favourable comments or articles on popular Chinese social media networks that are intended to derail discussions that are unhelpful to the Communist Party and that promote narratives that serve the government's interests, together with disparaging comments and misinformation about political opponents and critics of the Chinese government, both domestic and abroad.
A 2016 Harvard University paper found that in contrast to common assumptions, the 50 Cent Army consists mostly of paid bureaucrats who respond to government directives and rarely defend their government from criticism or engage in direct arguments. Around 80% of the analysed posts involve pro-China cheerleading with inspirational slogans, and 13% involve general praise and suggestions on governmental policies. Despite the common allegation of the commentators getting paid for their posts, the paper suggested there was "no evidence" that they are paid anything for their posts, instead being required to do so as a part of their official party duties.
According to Foreign Policy, it indicated that a supposed "massive secretive operation" to fill China's Internet with propaganda has resulted in some 488 million posts carried out by fake social media accounts, representing about 0.6% of the 80 billion posts generated on Chinese social media. To maximize their influence, such pro-government comments are made largely during times of intense online debate, and when online protests have a possibility of transforming into real life actions. The colloquial term wumao has also been used by some English speakers outside of China as an insult or racial epithet against people with perceived pro-CCP or pro-Chinese views, especially those who are of Chinese descent or are perceived to be Chinese.
In March 2005, the Ministry of Education of the People's Republic of China enacted a systematic censorship of Chinese college bulletin board systems. The popular "Little Lily" BBS, run by Nanjing University, was forced to close. As a new system was prepared to be launched, school officials hired students as part-time web commentators, paid from the university's work-study funds, to search the forum for undesirable information and actively counter it with Party-friendly viewpoints. In the following months, party leaders from Jiangsu began hiring their own teams. By mid-2007, web commentator teams recruited by schools, and party organizations were common across China. Shanghai Normal University employed undergraduates to monitor for signs of dissent and post on university forums. These commentators not only operate within political discussions, but also in general discussions. Afterwards, some schools and local governments also started to build similar teams.
On 23 January 2007, Chinese leader Hu Jintao demanded a "reinforcement of ideological and public opinion front construction and positive publicity" at the 38th collective learning of Politburo. Large Chinese websites and local governments have been requested to publish the sayings of Hu, and select "comrades with good political quality" to form "teams of Internet commentators" by the CCP Central Committee (中共中央办公厅) and General Office of the State Council (国务院办公厅).
Negative reporting of local authorities has increased on the Internet since then. In one instance described on the China Digital Times, the Jiaozuo (Henan) City Public Security Bureau established a mechanism to analyse public opinion after criticism of the police handling of a traffic incident appeared on the Internet. The Bureau responded with 120 staff calling for the truth to be revealed in line with the public opinion, which gradually shifted and eventually supported the police position, denouncing the original poster. In the aftermath of the 2008 Guizhou riot, Internet forums were filled with posts critical of the local authorities; the China News Weekly later reported that "the major task of the propaganda group was to organize commentators to past [sic] posts on websites to guide online public opinions."
In 2010, the Shanghai Communist Youth League's official website published a summary, saying that there were more than 200 topics by Shanghai Municipal Authorities' Internet commentators posted at People's Daily, Xinhua News Agency, Eastday (东方网), Sina and Tianya after many incidents in 2009, including the Lotus Riverside incident, the forced installation of Green Dam Youth Escort software, the Putuo Urban Administrative incident, the control of H1N1, the Shanghai entrapment incident (钓鱼执法), the self-immolation of Pan Rong (潘蓉), etc. It was praised by the Shanghai Internet Publicity Office.
In December 2014, a Chinese blogger hacked into and published email archives for the Internet Propaganda Department of Zhanggong District in Ganzhou, including over 2,700 emails of 50 Cent Party Internet commentators. For instance, on 16 January 2014, Shi Wenqing, secretary of the Ganzhou branch of the CCP, held a televised "Internet exchange" in which he answered questions from a local news website forum; 50 Cent Party commentators were instructed to post seven discussion points, such as (translated) "I really admire Party Secretary Shi, what a capable and effective Party Secretary! I hope he can be the father of Ganzhou for years to come."
Range of operation
The Ministry of Culture of the People's Republic of China now holds regular training sessions, where participants are required to pass an exam after which they are issued a job certification. As of 2008, the total number of 50-cent operatives was estimated to be in the tens of thousands, and possibly as high as 280,000–300,000. Every large Chinese website is instructed by the Information Office to create a trained team of Internet commentators.
According to the Chinese Communists' opinions of the recruitment of university Work Committee (tentative), the university Internet commentators are mainly selected from cadres or student cadres at the local CCP Publicity Department of universities, Youth League, Office of Academic Affairs, Network Center, Admissions Employment Department, Political Theory Department, Teaching Department and other units.
The court of Qinghe District, Huai'an organized a team of 12 commentators. Gansu Province hired 650 commentators, sorted by their writing abilities. Suqian Municipal Publicity Department's first 26 commentators' team were reported by Yangtse Evening Post in April 2005. According to high-profile independent Chinese blogger Li Ming, the pro-Chinese government web commentators must number "at least in the tens of thousands".
According to an article published by Xiao Qiang on his website China Digital Times, a leaked propaganda directive, sent to 50 Cent Party Internet commentators, stated their objective was the following:
In order to circumscribe the influence of Taiwanese democracy, in order to progress further in the work of guiding public opinion, and in accordance with the requirements established by higher authorities to "be strategic, be skilled," we hope that internet commentators conscientiously study the mindset of netizens, grasp international developments, and better perform the work of being an internet commentator. For this purpose, this notice is promulgated as set forth below:
- (1) To the extent possible make America the target of criticism. Play down the existence of Taiwan.
- (2) Do not directly confront [the idea of] democracy; rather, frame the argument in terms of "what kind of system can truly implement democracy.”
- (3) To the extent possible, choose various examples in Western countries of violence and unreasonable circumstances to explain how democracy is not well-suited to capitalism.
- (4) Use America's and other countries' interference in international affairs to explain how Western democracy is actually an invasion of other countries and [how the West] is forcibly pushing [on other countries] Western values.
- (5) Use the bloody and tear-stained history of a [once] weak people [i.e., China] to stir up pro-Party and patriotic emotions.
- (6) Increase the exposure that positive developments inside China receive; further accommodate the work of maintaining [social] stability.
Those who engaged in incitement are honoured by the government.
There is an alternate official term for the Internet Commentator, as well as several unofficial terms coined by netizens for them:
|Chinese (Simp./Trad.)||Pinyin||Literally in English||Commonly in English||Note|
|Official name (primary)||网络评论员/網絡評論員||wǎngluò pínglùn yuán||Internet commentator||Abbreviation in Chinese: 网评员/網評員 (wǎng píng yuán)|
|Official name (secondary)||网络阅评员/網絡閱評員||wǎngluò yuè píng yuán||Internet examiner and commentator||N/A|
|Unofficial term||五毛党/五毛黨 or simply 五毛||wǔmáo dǎng or wǔmáo||Five-dime Party, or simply "five dimes"||50 Cent Party||The most common name, used pejoratively. Another English translation is "50 Cent Army".|
|Unofficial term||网评猿/網評猿||wǎng píng yuán||ape that comments on the 'net||N/A||A pejorative pronounced identically with the Chinese abbreviation 网评员; wǎng píng yuán above, punning yuán (猿 "ape; monkey") for yuán (员 "personnel, staff member").|
|Other English terms||红马甲/紅馬甲, 红卫兵/紅衛兵||hóng mǎjiǎ, hóng wèibīng||red vest, red guard||The Chinese translation for these English terms are rarely used.|
Among those names, "50 Cent Party" (五毛党) was the most common and pejorative unofficial term.
The term is applied by Chinese netizens to any person who blatantly expresses pro-CCP thoughts online.
According to Foreign Policy, Chinese cyberspace is also noted for its ideological contests between "rightists" - reformists who advocate Western style democratic reforms, versus "leftists" - conservatives and neo-Confucianists who advocates Chinese nationalism and restructured socialism. In this backdrop, rightists sometimes refer to leftists derogatorily as "50 Centers", regardless of their actual employment background.
Effects and opinions
The Internet commentator/50 Cent Party's activities were described by CCP general secretary, Chinese President Hu Jintao, as "a new pattern of public-opinion guidance"; they represent a shift from simply erasing dissenting opinions to guiding dialogue. In 2010, a contributor to The Huffington Post stated that some comments she received on one of her posts were from the 50 Cent Party; she also stated that the 50 Cent Party monitors popular US websites, news sites and blogs and posts comments that advance Chinese governmental interests.
David Wertime of Foreign Policy argued that the narrative where a large army of paid Internet commentators are behind China's poor public dialogue with its critics is "Orwellian, yet strangely comforting". Rather, many of the Chinese netizens spreading nationalist sentiment online are not paid, but often mean what they say.
The colloquial term wumao, from the Chinese pronunciation of the term, has been used as an insult by some English speakers against people with perceived pro-CCP or pro-Chinese views, and has been cited in discussions of Sinophobia. An analyst at the Wilson Center has noted that ethnic Chinese are more likely to be called wumao than other groups of people in the English-speaking world; she attributed some of this to racism due to its use even outside of a political context. In Australia, the term has been used derogatively in the ongoing debate over increasing "Chinese influence" in the country.
- Astroturfing, a form of advocacy in support of a political, organizational, or corporate agenda, designed to give the appearance of a "grassroots" movement
- State-sponsored Internet sockpuppetry, a list of other similar programs internationally
- Internet censorship in China
- Internet Water Army, private astroturfing from paid Chinese writers paralleling the 50 Cent Party
- Great Firewall, a Chinese system to censor and regulate the Internet
- PLA Unit 61398, Chinese PLA online hacking and malware implantation unit
- Little Pink
- Russian web brigades, Russian state-sponsored propaganda trolls
- Internet Research Agency, a Russian-owned company engaged in online influence operations
- Operation Earnest Voice, the use of sockpuppet accounts to spread pro-American propaganda on social networking services based outside of the United States
- Public opinion brigades, state-sponsored propaganda party working for Vietnam's Communist Party
- Force 47, Vietnamese military unit that disseminates pro-regime propaganda and hacks anti-government websites
- Bristow, Michael (16 December 2008). "China's internet 'spin doctors'". BBC News Online. Archived from the original on 15 February 2009. Retrieved 30 June 2009.
- "Internet Spin for Stability Enforcers" Archived 26 October 2011 at the Wayback Machine, Sophie Beach, China Digital Times, 25 May 2010
- Meiu, George Paul; Comaroff, Jean; Comaroff, John L. (25 September 2020). Ethnicity, Commodity, In/Corporation. Indiana University Press. ISBN 9780253047960 – via Google Books.
- Steinfeld, Jemimah (17 December 2018). "The new "civil service" trolls who aim to distract: The government in China is using its civil servants to act as internet trolls. It's a hard management task generating 450 million social media posts a year". Index on Censorship. 47 (4): 102–104. doi:10.1177/0306422018819361. ISSN 0306-4220.
- China employs army of piece-rate ‘netizens’ for online thought control Archived 22 July 2011 at the Wayback Machine. Tibetan Review. 2 January 2009
- Vembu, Venkatesan (2 January 2009). "Big Brother 2.0 is here". Daily News and Analysis. India. Retrieved 11 January 2009.
- Cook, Sarah; Shum, Maggie (11 October 2011). "China's growing army of paid internet commentators". Freedom House. Archived from the original on 13 October 2011.
- "China's Paid Trolls: Meet the 50-Cent Party". www.newstatesman.com. Archived from the original on 28 August 2016. Retrieved 27 August 2016.
- "Chinese trolls write 488 million fake social media posts a year and don't even earn 50 cents for it". Shanghaiist. 20 May 2016. Archived from the original on 2 July 2016. Retrieved 27 August 2016.
- "China Banned The Term '50 Cents' To Stop Discussion Of An Orwellian Propaganda Program". Archived from the original on 16 August 2016. Retrieved 27 August 2016.
- King, Gary; Pan, Jennifer; Roberts, Margaret E. (2017). "How the Chinese Government Fabricates Social Media Posts for Strategic Distraction, Not Engaged Argument" (PDF). American Political Science Review. 111 (3): 484–501. doi:10.1017/S0003055417000144. ISSN 0003-0554.
- Meet the Chinese Trolls Pumping Out 488 Million Fake Social Media Posts Archived 7 March 2017 at the Wayback Machine. Foreign Policy. 19 May 2016
- Gallagher, Sean (13 June 2016). "Red astroturf: Chinese government makes millions of fake social media posts". Ars Technica. Archived from the original on 7 September 2017. Retrieved 14 June 2016.
- Christina Michelle Kleisath (2012). Tibet Beyond Black and White: Racial Formations and Transnational Collusions (PDF). University of Washington - Department of Anthropology. p. 185.
- Bertie Vidgen; Matt Hall; Ella Guest (2020). Annotation Codebook for East Asian Prejudice (part of a paper titled: Detecting East Asian Prejudice on Social Media). The Alan Turing Institute, Oxford Internet Institute, University of Surrey. p. 13.
- Publicity Department of Hefei (24 May 2006). "关于南昌、长沙、郑州宣传文化工作的考察报告 (An Investigative Report Regarding Cultural Propaganda Work in Nanchang, Changsha, and Zhengzhou)" (in Chinese).[dead link] Screenshot Archived 17 July 2011 at the Wayback Machine
- Bandurski, David (July 2008). "China's Guerrilla War for the Web". Far Eastern Economic Review. Archived from the original on 22 January 2009. Retrieved 11 January 2009.
- As Chinese Students Go Online, Little Sister Is Watching Archived 15 March 2017 at the Wayback Machine. The New York Times. 9 May 2006
- "Archived copy" 宿迁26名网评员今上岗 (in Chinese). sohu. Archived from the original on 2 February 2016. Retrieved 10 September 2010.CS1 maint: archived copy as title (link)
- "Archived copy" 关于进一步加强互联网管理工作的实施意见 (in Chinese). Government of Golog, Qinghai. Archived from the original on 7 July 2011. Retrieved 10 September 2010.CS1 maint: archived copy as title (link)
- "404" 巴中市人事局采取四大措施加强网络舆情监控 (in Chinese). Sichuan Provincial People's Government. Archived from the original on 16 March 2016. Retrieved 10 September 2010.
- 胡锦涛：以创新的精神加强网络文化建设和管理 (in Chinese). xinhua. Archived from the original on 30 August 2010. Retrieved 10 September 2010.
- 特稿：党布阵网络人民战争 (in Chinese). dwnews. Archived from the original on 10 July 2011. Retrieved 10 September 2010.
- Nan, Wu. Chinese Bloggers on the History and Influence of the “Fifty Cent Party” Archived 13 July 2011 at the Wayback Machine. China Digital Times. 15 May 2008
- Zhong, Wu. China's Internet awash with state spies Archived 6 January 2010 at the Wayback Machine. Asia Times Online. 14 August 2008
- "市级机关团工委2009年度工作总结 (2009 summary of works of the Municipal Authorities Youth League Working Committee)" (in Chinese). Shanghai Communist Youth League official site. 20 January 2010. Archived from the original on 22 December 2015. Retrieved 20 January 2010.
2009年，市级机关网评员在市网宣办的业务指导下，先后参与了莲花河畔景苑倒楼事件、强制安装"绿坝"网络屏蔽软件、普陀区城管打人事件、甲型 H1N1 流感防控、"倒钩"执法事件、闵行区潘蓉自焚事件、地铁事故频发等以涉沪舆情为重点的网上舆论引导工作，在人民网、新华网、东方网及新浪、天涯社区等国内重点网站、主要商业网站、大型网络社区。发帖、跟帖、转帖200余篇，东方网评论频道录用各类网评文章20余篇，工作得到市网宣办的肯定。
- Thousands of Local Internet Propaganda Emails Leaked Archived 2 January 2015 at the Wayback Machine, China Digital Times, 3 December 2014.
- Zhanggong Leaks: History is the Best Judge Archived 2 January 2015 at the Wayback Machine, China Digital Times, 10 December 2014.
- Hacked emails reveal China’s elaborate and absurd internet propaganda machine Archived 1 January 2015 at the Wayback Machine, Quartz, 18 December 2014.
- Fareed, Malik. China joins a turf war Archived 28 January 2017 at the Wayback Machine. The Guardian. 22 September 2008
- 清河法院组建互联网网评工作队 (in Chinese). Huai'an Intermediate People's Court. Archived from the original on 14 April 2010.
- "甘肅將建650人網絡評論員隊伍引導輿論". Sina. 20 January 2010. Archived from the original on 21 July 2011. Retrieved 4 March 2011.
- "宿迁26名网评员今上岗". Sohu. 29 April 2005. Archived from the original on 2 February 2016. Retrieved 4 March 2011.
- "China's web spin doctors spread Beijing's message". Sydney Morning Herald. 12 May 2011. Archived from the original on 19 September 2011. Retrieved 28 November 2011.
- "China 'flooding' social media with fake posts (20 May 2016)". BBC News. Archived from the original on 22 May 2016. Retrieved 22 May 2016.
- Qiang, Xiao. "Leaked Propaganda Directives and Banned "Future" | China Digital Times (CDT)". China Digital Times. Archived from the original on 14 July 2011. Retrieved 28 November 2011.[self-published source]
- http://chinadigitaltimes.net/chinese/2011/06/网评员《上级通知》/ (in Chinese)[self-published source]
- 《党校阵地》网评员管理办法 [Party school front Internet commentators Regulations] (in Chinese). 中国衡阳党建网 (China Hengyang Party-building website). 8 January 2010. Retrieved 22 January 2010.[dead link] Screenshot Archived 17 July 2011 at the Wayback Machine
- 中共衡阳市委党校《党校阵地》网评员管理办法 (in Chinese). Cenews. 21 January 2010. Archived from the original on 20 July 2011. Retrieved 3 March 2011.
- "新华网2007年度优秀网评人评选揭晓". Archived from the original on 13 January 2008. Retrieved 24 July 2018.
- Elgan, Mike (8 January 2009). "How China's '50 Cent Army' Could Wreck Web 2.0". Datamation. JupiterOnlineMedia. Archived from the original on 16 January 2009. Retrieved 11 January 2009.
- Garnaut, John (14 July 2010). "China's plan to use internet for propaganda". The Age. Australia. Archived from the original on 18 August 2010. Retrieved 17 October 2010.
- "China hires, trains 'online commentators' to influence public opinion – daily". Apple Daily. 5 October 2007
- Podger, Corrinne (21 August 2008). "China marshalls army of bloggers". Radio Australia. Archived from the original on 1 December 2008. Retrieved 11 January 2009.
- "Propaganda leaders scurry off to carry out the "spirit" of Hu Jintao's "important" media speech". China Media Project. 25 June 2008. Archived from the original on 28 September 2011. Retrieved 11 January 2009.
- Usha, Haley (4 October 2010). "China's Fifty Cent Party for Internet Propaganda". Huffington Post. Archived from the original on 7 April 2011. Retrieved 19 February 2011.
- "What's a WUMAO anyway? (mentioned at 1:28, 2:57)". Public Radio International. January 2020. Retrieved 14 November 2020.
- Marshallsea, Trevor (22 June 2018). "Is racism worsening Australia's China influence row?". BBC. Archived from the original on 22 June 2018. Retrieved 23 June 2018.
- Lee, Dave (20 August 2019). "Twitter and Facebook block HK misinformation". BBC News. Retrieved 19 June 2020.
- "Disclosing networks of state-linked information operations we've removed". Twitter Blog. 12 June 2020. Retrieved 19 June 2020.
- Han, Rongbin (2015). "Manufacturing Consent in Cyberspace: China's "Fifty-Cent Army"". Journal of Current Chinese Affairs. 44 (2): 105–134. doi:10.1177/186810261504400205. - PDF
- King, Gary; Pan, Jennifer; Roberts, Margaret E. (2017). "How the Chinese Government Fabricates Social Media Posts for Strategic Distraction, not Engaged Argument". American Political Science Review. 111 (3): 484–501. doi:10.1017/S0003055417000144. S2CID 84837873. - Article PDF (Alternate link) and Supplementary Appendix and Symposium info