A Doll's House (1973 Losey film)
|A Doll's House|
|Directed by||Joseph Losey|
|Produced by||Joseph Losey|
Richard F. Dalton
|Written by||Henrik Ibsen|
|Music by||Michel Legrand|
|Edited by||Reginald Beck|
Les Films de la Boétie (France),
World Film Services (UK)
|Distributed by||British Lion (UK),|
Tomorrow Entertainment (US theatrical 1973)
|1 October 1973 (New York Film Festival)|
A Doll's House is a 1973 Franco-British drama film directed by Joseph Losey, based on the play of the same name by Henrik Ibsen. It stars Jane Fonda in the role of Nora Helmer and David Warner as her domineering husband, Torvald. In the United States, the film was broadcast nationally on the ABC television network.
Losey's version of the classic play was extensively adapted for film. From Ibsen's expository dialogue, entire new scenes were developed by playwright David Mercer and integrated through a variety of invented sets. Losey's alterations generated considerable controversy, as did his casting of outspoken actress Fonda – known at the time as "Hanoi Jane" – in the lead role.
Set in nineteenth century Norway, Ibsen's A Doll's House focuses on the married life of banker Torvald Helmer and his wife Nora. A young middle-class couple with three small children, their seemingly respectable marriage is revealed to be a broken and bloodless matter.
The Helmers live in an unequal partnership, dominated by Torvald. Although he professes to love her, Torvald constantly chides Nora for what he calls her careless and childlike nature; he often calls her his "doll". He proudly thinks of himself as the family's breadwinner and protector, but he remains unaware of the secret that Nora holds: she had saved him, when he had become seriously ill and very nearly destitute. Without his knowledge, she had borrowed a large sum of money so that he could temporarily retire and recuperate. She told him the money had been inherited from her family; in truth it had been a private loan from Nils Krogstad, one of Torvald's coworkers. Nora has been scrupulously repaying him in small installments skimmed from her household allowance.
Torvald, it turns out, already holds the boorish Krogstad in contempt for various reasons. When Torvald is appointed bank director, one of his first acts is to fire his unlikable coworker. The desperate Krogstad attempts to blackmail Nora – she must persuade Torvald to keep him on the job, or he will tell all about the secret loan. Its existence would be embarrassment enough for Nora, but Krogstad threatens to reveal the most shocking news of all: Nora had forged her father's signature as a co-signer on the contract.
The story includes important subplots regarding the unexpected tenderness of Krogstad (toward Nora's friend Kristine, his old flame) and the quixotic love interest (toward Nora) of the elderly Dr. Rank. But the essential conflict comes when Torvald gets a letter from Krogstad describing the loan. Indignantly, Torvald pours scorn on his wife for her morals, intellect, and financial sense; he cuts short her explanations, and declares that she will be allowed no hand in raising their children.
His fury seems infinite until suddenly a second letter from Krogstad arrives. It contains Nora's contract, complete with forged signature and surrendered without explanation. Torvald holds the incriminating evidence in his hand, utterly relieved, and begins to make weak apologies for his outburst. But in the meantime Nora has had a transformational realization about her love and marriage. She stands up to Torvald, explains her new vision, and then – against all customs of the day – walks out on him forever.
Ibsen's three-act play was adapted to a screenplay by Losey in collaboration with British playwright David Mercer. The original script takes place in a single room in a single day, but the Mercer/Losey version is much wider ranging. Much of the expository dialogue of Act I is converted into an extensive prologue. Events that are only discussed by the actors in the Ibsen play – such as the early friendship of Nora and Kristine, the romance and breakup of Kristine and Krogstad, the life-threatening illness of Torvald, and the death of Nora's father – are all fleshed out in full separate scenes at the start of the film.
The one-room setting of Ibsen's original is a deliberate device suggestive of Nora's isolation and her imprisonment within her marriage. In the film, however, multiple locations outside the Helmer house are used for visual explication, and to lend dramatic emphasis to plot points. Even within the house, the camera moves from room to room, revealing not just the physical comforts of their home but also its confining nature – its "deadly insularity". The combined effect of Losey's alterations have been praised by some critics for giving the work a comprehensively cinematic quality, and make it "a film rather than a photographed play".
Losey intended his added scenes to step beyond a plain visualization of Ibsen's dialogue and achieve artistic merit in their own right. Critic Colin Gardner points out one exceptional example at the start of the film: "just as we see Nora and Kristine skidding excitedly across the surface of the pond, we also spot a static, black-coated figure lurking ominously outside the teahouse in the exact centre of the shot (i.e. at the spatial vanishing point). This turns out to be Krogstad, steeling himself for his fateful rejection by Kristine. The sweet purity of youth is thus already tainted by the acrid taste of the social outcast – the future man of vengeance – and the source of Nora's own financial enslavement."
Other critics found Losey's bold changes to be off-putting, even blasphemous. Writing in The New York Times, Nora Sayre complained bitterly that the film had been "fattened with feeble lines and even short scenes that the old genius didn't write".
Filming took place in the Norwegian town of Røros, where local residents served as extras for the exterior shots. Camera work was handled by acclaimed British cinematographer Gerry Fisher, who had a long history of work with Losey beginning in the mid-1960s and including such titles as Accident (1967), The Go-Between (1971), and Don Giovanni (1979). French composer Michel Legrand provided the musical soundtrack, a "bright, horn-dominated neoclassical score".
A Doll's House was first aired in the United States on the ABC television network on 23 December 1973. It had been shown at the 1973 New York Film Festival, and was screened at the 1973 Cannes Film Festival, but wasn't entered into the main competition. In June 1980, it was given a nine-day run at one of the Laemmle Theatres in Los Angeles.
Losey's film was one of two English-language versions of Ibsen's play released in 1973: the other version was directed by Patrick Garland and stars Claire Bloom and Anthony Hopkins. The coincidental competition for a relatively small audience meant commercial difficulties for both films.
The choice of Fonda for the principal role has always elicited some commentary on the "controversial" nature of her casting and performance. Known as a high-profile supporter of feminism, Fonda took the role at a time when the U.S. women's rights movement was at its peak. Many film critics praised Fonda's work – Leonard Maltin cited it as the main reason to see the film (which he otherwise deemed only "moderately successful"). Charles Champlin likewise praised her performance, and wrote that her contemporary persona dovetailed well with Mercer's dialogue which "skillfully drops the stilted period rhetoric without going colloquial or slangy".
Others, however, have suggested that the film suffers under the weight of Fonda's public image. Professor Neil Sinyard wrote, "Perhaps the star's own feminist associations obscure our vision of the character's blind and painful quest towards self-awareness and undermine the shock of Nora's startling decision (startling, that is, to a nineteenth century audience) to walk out on her husband and children." More bluntly, Rex Reed wrote that Fonda's "star personality" undercut her performance in an otherwise admirable production: "One never believes her as the macaroon-munching birdbrain or the charming coquette or the toy wife. In the great scene of defiance at the end, she takes the film with a tank".
Cast and director conflict
Fonda's feminist sensibilities not only informed her performance but also her relationship with Losey. The director, who had a history of stormy relationships with his leading ladies, earned the ire of both Fonda and Delphine Seyrig before the film was even released. In a letter from June 1973, Fonda assailed Losey for making "anti-feminist remarks to the press", and charging that "your [Losey's] inability to deal with, to countenance, strong women... has done irreparable harm to the film". On a personal note, she added: "I was never able to penetrate your paranoia or snobbery while we were working together". Losey, for his part, grumbled that Fonda had "little sense of humor" and "was spending most of her time working on her political speeches, instead of learning her lines".
- Jane Fonda – Nora Helmer
- David Warner – Torvald Helmer
- Trevor Howard – Dr. Rank
- Delphine Seyrig – Kristine Linde
- Edward Fox – Nils Krogstad
- Ingrid Natrud – Helene the maid
- Pierre Oudrey – Olssen the porter
- Anna Wing – Anne-Marie the nanny
- The Helmers' children were portrayed by Morten Floor (Bob), Tone Floor (Emmy), and Frode Lien (Ivar).
- Krogstad's son and daughter were portrayed by Dagfinn Hertzberg and Ellen Holm.
- Gardner, p. 234.
- Erskine, et al, p. 97.
- Gardner, pp. 234; 239.
- Gardner, p. 239.
- Gardner, p. 240.
- Sayre, Nora (8 March 1978). "Film: 'A Doll's House', '73 Vintage Jane Fonda". The New York Times. New York. Retrieved 31 March 2016.
- Hayward, Anthony (20 February 2015). "Gerry Fisher: Prolific cinematographer who worked with some of the finest directors of his day – most profitably, Joseph Losey". The Independent. London. Archived from the original on 27 August 2017. Retrieved 3 April 2016.
- Gardner, p. 240.
- "Festival de Cannes: A Doll's House". Festival-cannes.com. Archived from the original on 5 March 2016. Retrieved 29 March 2016.
- Champlin, Charles (6 June 1980). "Fonda's 'Doll' Arrives Late". The Los Angeles Times. p. 115. Archived from the original on 15 November 2018. Retrieved 14 November 2018 – via Newspapers.com.
- Erskine, et al, p. 95.
- Bleiler, p. 165.
- Maltin, p. 640.
- Erskine, et al, pp. 95–96.
- Du Brow, Rick (2 January 1973). "Jane Fonda aptly cast in 'A Doll's House'". The Lowell Sun. Lowell, MA. UPI. Archived from the original on 26 April 2016. Retrieved 30 March 2016 – via Newspapers.com.
- Sinyard, p. 176.
- Reed, Rex (2 April 1978). "Taylor and Fonda both get A's for effort". Dayton Daily News. Dayton, Ohio. p. 193. Archived from the original on 15 November 2018. Retrieved 14 November 2018 – via Newspapers.com.
- Gardner, p. 231.
- Als, Hilton (9 May 2011). "Queen Jane, Approximately". The New Yorker. Condé Nast. Retrieved 3 April 2016.
- Bleiler, David (2001). TLA Film, Video, and DVD Guide 2002–2003: The Discerning Film Lover's Guide. New York: Macmillan. ISBN 9780312282097.
- Erskine, Thomas; Welsh, James Michael; Tibbetts, John C. (2000). Video Versions: Film Adaptations of Plays on Video. Westport, CT: Greenwood Publishing Group. ISBN 9780313301858.
- Gardner, Colin (2004). Joseph Losey. Manchester: Manchester University Press. ISBN 9780719067839.
- Maltin, Leonard (2014). Leonard Maltin's 2015 Movie Guide. New York: Penguin. ISBN 9780698183612.
- Sinyard, Neil (2013). Filming Literature: The Art of Screen Adaptation. London: Routledge. ISBN 9781134054114.