Academic grading in France

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Since 1890, the French baccalauréat exam, required to receive a high school diploma, has traditionally scored students on a scale (Barème) of 0-20,[1][2][3] as do most secondary school and university classes. Although the traditional scale stops at 20/20, French baccalauréat results can be higher than 20/20 due to supplementary "options".[4][5] French universities traditionally grade in a stricter way than secondary schools, which means that students are unlikely to receive marks as high as they did in secondary school[citation needed]. Famously,[6][7] in Preparatory Class for 'Grandes Écoles' (CPGE), an optional 2-4 year preparation for the most elite universities in France,[8][9] students are graded so harshly[10] that class ranking, rather than individual grades, usually reflects an individual's performance, especially when comparing the grades to secondary or university grades. Often, an average grade of 7-8 in Preparatory Class for 'Grandes Écoles' (CPGE) can be considered as a satisfactory grade if the best grade in the class is only a 12.[11]

On the Le diplôme national du brevet, awarded for passing the 10th year exam (9th grade), and also on University of Paris, Sorbonne transcripts, scores above 12 on the scale of 20 confer the following mentions (honors):[12][13]

  • 16–20: Mention très bien: TB
  • 14–15.9: bien: B
  • 12–13.9: assez bien: AB

Other Scales in French Schools[edit]

In recent years, the French government began to explore possible conversion of the 0-20 grading scale to 0-4 or 0-5.[14][15] Since 2008, the College Gabriel-Séailles, a middle school in southern France, has abolished grading altogether.[16]

Primary schools generally use a 10-point grading scale or a letter grade.[citation needed]

The European Credit Transfer and Accumulation System (ECTS) scale is gaining popularity in the post-secondary education system[citation needed], since it is the standard for comparing study performance throughout the European Union. The GPA grading scale is becoming more and more common as well since it eases the comparison with American students.[citation needed]

Some Grandes écoles use "exotic" systems, like Ecole Centrale de Lille, which uses a three-letter scale system[citation needed]:

  • A: Excellent
  • S: Satisfactory (satisfaisant)
  • I: Fail (insufficient)

History[edit]

In 12th Century Europe, students were evaluated by oral disputation in Latin. In the 14th century, some written examinations occurred, but were rare. By the 16th century the Catholic Church was struggling against the Protestant Reformation, and trying to advance Catholic scholarship as a defense of doctrine, to which end The Society of Jesus was created, and with it Jesuit Colleges.[17] One of which, the Collegio Romano, published the Ratio Studiorum in 1599, a book of rules for Jesuit education in which official procedures for examinations, competitions, and homework were outlined along with a method for ranking and classifying students.[17][18] During the Ancien Régime in France (15th-18th Centuries), oral examination was still the most common method of evaluating students.[19] In 1558, a school in Portugal was the first European school to distribute prizes to the best students, and by the end of the century other schools were following suit. By the end of the 18th century, schools in France were beginning to publish bulletins with student evaluations and class rankings and the Jesuite College at Caen would develop a numerical 4 point ranking ("4 niveaux: 1 = bien; 2 = assez bien; 3 = médiocre; 0 = mal").[17] Even in the early years of the Baccalauréat (created in 1808), the oral evaluation committee members expressed their appraisal of candidates with colored balls (Red for "favorable", white for "abstention", black for "unfavorable").[20][2] In the Second French Empire, the representation of colored balls was converted into a numerical system of 0-5, and then in 1890[1] the numerical system of 0-20 was created along with the modern French baccalauréat, which comprises several stages of written examinations[21]
In the student rebellions of, 1968, the bulletin of January 6, 1969[1] recommended a change from the 0-20 grading scale to a qualitative evaluation such as "very satisfactory", "unsatisfactory", etc., Or adopting a more general (A, B, C, D, E) letter system, or a simplified numerical system (1,2,3,4,5). Before the change could be fully implemented, the recommendation was reversed in a bulletin on July 9, 1971 which recommended the continuation of the 0-20 system.[22]

Comparison with American grades[edit]

There is no exact formula for converting scores between the French 0–20 scale and American grades,[23] and there are several reasons why the systems are not entirely commensurate. For instance, some American institutions use Rank Based Grading and grading curves, that is, shifting the grades of a class so that the highest scores align with the highest grades on the grading scale and the lowest scores align with the lowest grades on the scale or aligning the median achieved score within the class to a fixed point on the grading scale. Likewise some American institutions use weighted grades, wherein grades for advanced classes are augmented in the official transcripts to compensate for the difficulty of the classes. French schools use neither,[24] the result being that in a university, "perfect" 20s are never given,[25] grades over 14 are extremely rare, and scores over 12 indicate that the student is in the top 10–20% of the class.[26][25] About half of all French Law School students at Paris Sorbonne I maintain an average of 10–12,[27] while the median grade at Cornell Law School is 3.35(B+),[28] at Duke University School of Law is 3.30 (B+),[29] at UC Davis School of Law is 3.25–3.35 (B/B+),[30] and at Columbia Law School the median GPA is estimated at 3.4(B+).[31]


Even though no exact conversion exists between the two systems, there are several scales that approximate a conversion and many American universities require that grades from foreign institutions, such as grades in the French 20 point scale, be converted into the American system on applications.[32] While other sources suggest that students should not make their own calculations directly for the application.[33]


Table of various conversion scales for university level classes:

French Grade World Education
Services Scale[34][32]
CampusFrance
Scale[27]
University of
Minnesota Scale[25]
l’École Nationale
Supérieure de Géologie Scale[35]
l'université Paris 1
Panthéon-Sorbonne Scale[36]
18–20 A A+ A 4 (A+/A) A+
17–17.9 A A+ A 4 (A+/A) A
16–16.9 A A+ A 3.7 (A–) A–
15–15.9 A A A 3.7 (A–) B+
14–14.9 A A A– 3.5 (B+) B
13–13.9 B+ B B+ 3.2 (B) B–
12–12.9 B+ B B+ 3.0 (B) C+
11–11.9 B C B 2.7 (B–) C
10.5–10.9 B– C B– 2.7 (B–) C
10.1–10.4 C+ C B– 2.7 (B–) C
10 C C B– 2.7 (B–) C
9–9.9 C– D C+ 2.5 (C+) C–
8–8.9 D D C 2.5 (C+) C–
7–7.9 F F C– 2.2 (C) D+
6–6.9 F F D+ 2.2 (C) D+
5–5.9 F F D 2.2 (C) D
4–4.9 F F F 2.2 (C) D
1–3.9 F F F 2.0 (C) D–
0-0.9 F F F 2.0 (C) none


Table of various conversion scales for secondary school classes:

French Grade Lycée
Rochambeau
Scale[37]
Lycée
Rochambeau
Scale[37]
French
Consulate
(Miami) Scale[23]
Fulbright
Scale[38][38]
Lycée
Rochambeau
Scale[37]
Lycée
Rochambeau
Scale[37]
French
Consulate
(Miami) Scale[23]
Fulbright
Scale[38][38]
Grades 11–13
Honors Classes
Grades 11–13
Non-Honors Classes
Grades 10–12 Grades 10–12 Grades 9–10
Honors Classes
Grades 9–10
Non-Honors Classes
Grades 6–9 Grades 6–9
17–20 A+ A+ A+ A+ A+ A+ A+ A+
16–16.9 A+ A+ A+ A+ A+ A+ A A+
15.5–15.9 A+ A+ A+ A+ A+ A A A
15–15.4 A+ A+ A A+ A+ A A A
14–14.9 A+ A A A A A– A– A–
13.5–13.9 A A– A A– A– B+ B+ B+
13–13.4 A A– A– A– A– B+ B+ B+
12–12.9 A– B+ A– B+ B+ B B B
11–11.9 B+ B B+ B B B– B– B–
10.5–10.9 B B– B B– B– C+ B– C+
10–10.4 B B– B B– B– C+ C+ C+
9.5–9.9 B– C+ B– C+ C+ C C+ C
9–9.4 B– C+ B– C+ C+ C C C
8.5–8.9 C+ C C+ C C C– C C–
8–8.4 C+ C C C C C– C– C–
7.5–7.9 C C– C C– C– D+ C– D+
7–7.4 C C– C– C– C– D+ D+ D+
6.5–6.9 C– D+ D+ D+ D+ D D D
6–6.4 C– D+ D D+ D+ D D– D
5.5–5.9 D+ D D– D D D– F D–
5–5.4 D+ D F D D D– F D–
4–4.9 D D– F D– D– F F F
0–3.9 D– F F F F F F F

Honors terminology compared to American and Latin Honors[edit]

French diplomas grant "Mentions" similar to American "Honors" or "Latin Honors" titles[27][25]

French "Mention" Typical % of French students
attaining this "mention"
Latin Honor American Honor Typical % of American students
attaining this level
"Mention Très Bien" the top 1–2%[25] "summa cum laude" "Highest Honors" the top 1–5%
"Mention Bien" the top 2–5%[27] "magna cum laude" "High Honors" the top 10–15%
"Mention Assez Bien" the top 10%[27] "cum laude" "With Honors" the top 20–30%

References[edit]

  1. ^ a b c Pénombre. "Pénombre – LG n° 7 – C'est la note qui compte – Notes historiques". olivier.hammam.free.fr. Retrieved 1 August 2018.
  2. ^ a b "Notation des élèves: «En 1808, le baccalauréat était évalué avec des boules de couleur»". 20minutes.fr. Retrieved 1 August 2018.
  3. ^ "Data" (PDF). wenr.wes.org.
  4. ^ "Meilleure note en Picardie : 20,92 sur 20 – Le Courrier Picard" (in French). Courrier-picard.fr. Retrieved 2018-08-01.
  5. ^ "Pour avoir plus de 20/20 au bac, mieux valait être en S". Lemonde.fr. Retrieved 1 August 2018.
  6. ^ "Quand les étudiants de prépa craquent". Lemonde.fr. Retrieved 1 August 2018.
  7. ^ "Classes prépa : " Le plus dur, c'est l'équilibre entre travail et vie saine "". Lemonde.fr. Retrieved 1 August 2018.
  8. ^ "France's educational elite". Telegraph.co.uk. 17 November 2003. Retrieved 1 August 2018.
  9. ^ "What's a french prepa?". Sieben.fr. 2 January 2014. Retrieved 1 August 2018.
  10. ^ "Première année de prépa : 7 conseils pour tenir le choc". Etudiant.lefigaro.fr. Retrieved 1 August 2018.
  11. ^ "En prépa, dois-je m'attendre obligatoirement à une chute des notes ?". Letudiant.fr. Retrieved 1 August 2018.
  12. ^ "Notes" (PDF). www.paris-sorbonne.fr/article/releve-de-notes.
  13. ^ "Bulletin officiel n°31 du 1er septembre 2005". Education.gouv.fr. Retrieved 1 August 2018.
  14. ^ "La notation de 0 à 20 ne sera pas supprimée… du moins pas tout de suite". Lemonde.fr. Retrieved 1 August 2018.
  15. ^ "Vers une révolution de l'évaluation des élèves ?". Lemonde.fr. Retrieved 1 August 2018.
  16. ^ "Un collège métamorphosé par l'abandon des notes". Lemonde.fr. Retrieved 1 August 2018.
  17. ^ a b c "Les notes à l'école, idée folle ?". Unige.ch. Archived from the original on 1 August 2018. Retrieved 1 August 2018.
  18. ^ Robert L. Johnson; James A. Penny; Belita Gordon (10 October 2008). Assessing Performance: Designing, Scoring, and Validating Performance Tasks. Guilford Press. p. 20. ISBN 978-1-60623-744-1.
  19. ^ "A quand remontent les notes sur 20 à l'école?". Salte.fr. 27 June 2014. Retrieved 1 August 2018.
  20. ^ "A quoi sert le baccalauréat ?". Senat.fr. Retrieved 1 August 2018.
  21. ^ Lelièvre, Claude. "Des évolutions de notation difficiles". Blogs.mediapart.fr. Retrieved 1 August 2018.
  22. ^ Gimonnet, Bertrand (2007). Les notes à l'école ou le rapport à la notation des enseignants de l'école élémentaire. Paris: L'Harmattan. ISBN 978-2296024922.
  23. ^ a b c "Grade conversion table" (PDF). consulfrance-miami.org.
  24. ^ "Application" (PDF). fulbright-france.org. 2016. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2017-03-31. Retrieved 2017-10-24.
  25. ^ a b c d e "Grades" (PDF). Retrieved 2018-08-01.
  26. ^ "Academic Life > USA". Usa.campusfrance.org. Archived from the original on 1 August 2018. Retrieved 1 August 2018.
  27. ^ a b c d e "Info" (PDF). boston.consulfrance.org.
  28. ^ Technologies, Instructional and Web Services, Cornell Information. "FAQ". Lawschool.cornell.edu. Retrieved 1 August 2018.
  29. ^ "Duke OCS" (PDF). Law.duke.edu. Retrieved 1 August 2018.
  30. ^ "UC Davis School of Law – Registrar – Law School Regulations 2017–2018". law.ucdavis.edu. Retrieved 1 August 2018.
  31. ^ "Data" (PDF). wwws-db.law.columbia.edu.[permanent dead link]
  32. ^ a b "GPA – Duke Graduate School". gradschool.duke.edu. Retrieved 1 August 2018.
  33. ^ "Archived copy". Archived from the original on 2017-10-25. Retrieved 2017-10-25.CS1 maint: archived copy as title (link)
  34. ^ "Education in France – WENR". Wenr.wes.org. 8 September 2015. Retrieved 1 August 2018.
  35. ^ Department, ENSG Communication. "The French higher education system". École Nationale Supérieure de Géologie. Retrieved 1 August 2018.
  36. ^ "Data" (PDF). www.univ-paris1.fr.
  37. ^ a b c d "Rochambeau French International School". Rochambeau.org. Retrieved 1 August 2018.
  38. ^ a b c d "School profile" (PDF). www.lelycee.org. 2014.

External links[edit]