Hollywood Stuntz gang assault
On September 29, 2013, motorist Alexian Lien was assaulted while driving on the Henry Hudson Parkway in New York City. Lien had gotten into an altercation with motorcyclists who were participating in a rally called Hollywood's Block Party. One of the bikers pulled in front of Lien and slowed dramatically. Lien said that he struck the bike from behind, stopped his vehicle, and was quickly surrounded by bikers, who began beating on his SUV. He testified that he feared for his life so he accelerated, running over several bikes and striking one of the bikers, paralyzing him. A chase ensued, ending in Lien being pulled from his vehicle and beaten. The media later reported that the involved bikers were members of a loose association of high-performance motorcycle enthusiasts known as "Hollywood Stuntz" who had previously been observed and filmed engaging in reckless driving and threatening motorists.
Among the bikers was an off-duty New York City Police Department officer. The attack was caught on video and garnered international attention. Eleven bikers have been convicted of assault and other criminal charges relating to the attack, and legislation has been proposed to regulate motorcycle rallies in New York City.
On September 29, 2013, a group of motorcyclists were participating in an annual rally, titled "Hollywood Stuntz," organized by a man named Jamie Lao. Rallies organized by Lao in the past involved performing motorcycle stunts and an unauthorized ride through Times Square, Manhattan. During the 2012 ride a year prior, "well over a thousand motorcycles, dirt bikes, quads, four-wheel vehicles" rode through Times Square, according to New York Police Commissioner Raymond Kelly. The group did not have permits to do so. Driving through the section of Broadway within Times Square has been illegal since it was pedestrianized in 2009. Kelly reported that the altercation with Lien was not the only problem involving the group on September 29, as over 200 other people had complained to the police about the reckless driving of the bikers on Manhattan's streets that day.
The altercation began when a sport utility vehicle (SUV) driven by motorist Alexian Lien encountered a group of motorcyclists in Lower Manhattan. Lien, a then-33-year-old Chinese American banker, was heading to New Jersey with his wife, Rosalyn Ng and two-year-old daughter, who were also in the vehicle; they were going to celebrate the couple's anniversary. According to Lien, he dialed 911 after he saw several motorcycles run a red light and nearly hit a woman carrying a baby, but reached a New Jersey operator. He said the bikers were "popping wheelies" and slapping the tops of cars as they drove past and one motorcyclist was maneuvering to block other vehicles to allow the bikes to pass. Lien said he was "annoyed" and kept driving past. Following the incident, authorities familiar with motorcycle groups around New York stated that it was a common practice for these groups to "take over the entire highway for the purpose of slowing it down to allow [other bikers] to race in front of them" to perform tricks and be free of other traffic. His wife tossed a half-eaten plum and a water bottle at the bikers. According to Lien, one biker responded by punching the driver's side mirror, shattering it while another was "waiving [sic] for other motorcyclists to come toward us, he was yelling at us and he was threatening us. He was screaming profanities at us, and he was also making slitting-throat gestures."
Shortly after, on the Henry Hudson Parkway in Upper Manhattan, motorcyclist Christopher Cruz merged in front of Lien and applied his brakes, quickly slowing down before being involved in light bumper contact with Lien's Range Rover. Cruz reportedly sustained minor injuries after being struck by the SUV. Lien and many of the motorcyclists stopped their vehicles. The video shows many of the bikers gathering around the Range Rover driven by Lien. "And as they're around my car, I feel it being hit, being kicked", he said. Lien accelerated to escape, reportedly driving over three motorcycles and a rider, named Edwin Mieses, who had dismounted and was in front of the Range Rover. "I'm horrified at this point, and I recall asking my wife, 'What do I do? What do I do?' She says, 'Just go! Just go! And I make a hard right because I see there's an opening and I ... I just go." Lien said. Mieses was severely injured, suffering a fractured spine and punctured lung. Mieses later stated that he was checking on Cruz after his collision with the Range Rover and was walking back to his bike when he was hit.
The bikers then followed Lien for several miles. Lien's wife called 911 four times in an eight-minute time span during the drive. A few minutes later, the video shows Lien stopping for a red light and a biker is seen running up and opening the driver's side door before Lien accelerates again to escape. Several minutes later, the SUV came to a halt behind other vehicles at a red light. One of the bikers then dismounted his motorcycle and struck the driver's window of the Range Rover with his helmet, shattering it. Lien was then dragged from the vehicle and assaulted. Another uploaded video shows Lien lying on the ground with bikers stomping on him and beating him with their helmets.
The assault continued until a bystander named Sergio Consuegra intervened, stepping in between the bikers and Lien. Consuegra testified that he held out his arms and yelled "That's it, guys, let it go! Let it go!" He said the bikers "froze" at that point and stopped assaulting Lien. Consuegra told police that one biker, later alleged by prosecutors to be Robert Sims, also attempted to pull Lien's wife from the vehicle and allegedly said "you're going to get it, too" before other bystanders yelled at him to stop and the biker let her go. Lien's wife testified that "somehow they got my door open and tried to yank me out of the car, pulling my arm and leg. I tried to kick them off and I screamed, "there's a baby in the car,"' Ng said he was unable to pull her out because she had her seat belt on. After the biker retreated, she managed to get the passenger door shut and climbed into the backseat to check on their daughter, who was covered in broken glass, but otherwise unharmed.
Lien sustained lacerations to his face and sides, requiring stitches at a local hospital. Photos of the SUV after the incident show extensive damage. The driver side, passenger side, and rear windows are smashed. One tire is completely flat, and a second one is missing entirely.
A video of the incident quickly went viral after it was uploaded by a biker to Live Leak with the caption, "A black Range Rover ran over a group of bikers in New York City during an annual street ride." The incident was covered widely by national news networks. Following the publicity for the video shot on September 29, other videos surfaced of the group on other rides. One video, shot in 2011, shows riders driving recklessly, weaving in and out of traffic, driving on sidewalks, running red lights and surrounding and threatening the driver of a Prius. The bikers beat on the window of his car, but the driver was unharmed.
The NYPD faced criticism when some of the bikers involved in the chase and attack were identified as off-duty New York City police officers. Ten-year veteran and undercover detective Wojciech Braszczok surrendered to authorities and was arrested on October 8. An undercover narcotics detective has been identified by the press as being present but not participating in the assault. Sources have reported a total of five off-duty officers were originally present on the West Side Highway, and that at least two saw the assault.
Following the altercation, there was much discussion regarding whether this group of riders was a "biker gang". It was commonly referred to as a biker gang, more specifically, "Hollywood Stuntz gang" in the news. However, Jamie Lao, who organized the rally, asserts that the title "Hollywood Stuntz" does not apply to the riders, but is a moniker he goes by himself. He denies being present for the incident. Many have pointed out a distinction between this group of riders and what people typically think of as a motorcycle gang. A report on the topic by the California Department of Justice stated that "outlaw motorcycle gangs are sophisticated organizations who utilize their affiliation with a motorcycle club as a conduit for criminal activity. The nature of their activity is generally conspiratorial, and their goals are attained through use of violence and intimidation." While many of the bikers were found to have criminal histories and it appeared there were aspects of intimidation in the incident on September 29 as well as on the 2011 video, many pointed out that the bikers who gathered on that day do not have any affiliation with each other aside from participating in the ride. Former New York police chief and future police commissioner William Bratton said these groups are popping up nationally. They are typically organized online and congregate with the intention of performing high speed stunts en masse. Bratton explained that traditional motorcycle gangs are typically white, rooted in a specific neighborhood, and often are involved in drug dealing. These new groups are racially diverse, younger, loosely affiliated, and do not use the group for the purposes of furthering criminal enterprises.
Lawyer Gloria Allred was hired to represent the critically injured Mieses by members of his family, while the law firm of Massimo & Panetta, P.C., represents the Lien family. Allred claims Mieses was the victim in the incident. "He did nothing wrong...all he had done was get off his bike, go over and try to calm everybody down", she said. She reasoned that Lien could have honked his horn or told the bikers to get out of the way to give them a chance to part. Several months after the accident, Mieses reported that physicians have given him a less than 1% chance of walking again. He stated that he was not threatening Lien when he was hit, but was instead checking on Cruz after his accident and does not blame Lien for his injuries.
At the time of the incident, Edwin Mieses was driving on a revoked license. His Massachusetts drivers license was revoked until 2017. He was previously arrested in May 2013 for driving on a revoked license.
A total of 15 people were arrested, 55 motorcycles were confiscated, and 69 summonses were issued in connection with the September 29 event. Eleven bikers were convicted in connection with the attack.
Police have stated that they do not plan to file charges against Alexian Lien. In December 2013, Lien filed a notice of claim regarding the city of New York for the involvement of an off-duty police detective in the attack, accusing the police department of failing to properly train their officers. As of 2018, formal proceeding to a civil suit had not occurred.
Christopher Cruz, who collided with Lien's vehicle at the beginning of the incident, was arraigned in Manhattan on charges of reckless driving and criminal imprisonment. Cruz pleaded guilty to second-degree assault and riot and was sentenced to four months in jail and five years probation.
Motorcyclist Reggie Chance, who was identified as the one who broke Lien's window with his helmet, turned himself in to Manhattan's 33rd Precinct on October 4. Chance pleaded guilty to felony assault and criminal mischief in exchange for two years in prison and three years post-release supervision.
Robert Sims of Brooklyn, who is shown on the video attempting to open the SUV's driver's door, turned himself in to Manhattan's 33rd Precinct on October 4. Sims is also alleged to have attempted to pull Lien's wife out of the vehicle. Robert Sims and Wojciech Braszczok were tried together, opting to have a judge decide the verdict instead of a jury. On June 9, 2015, Sims was convicted of attempted gang assault, second-degree assault, coercion, riot and criminal possession of a weapon. He was sentenced to three and a half years in prison. He was acquitted of the top charge of first-degree gang assault.
Off-duty undercover officer Wojciech Braszczok was initially charged with assault, gang assault, riot and criminal mischief. Braszczok is not believed to have physically assaulted Lien, but was charged with assault because he was part of the larger group involved in the attack. He was allegedly captured on video wearing a black vest that said "Front Line Soldiers" on the back, punching and kicking the SUV Braszczok, whose police work led him to pose undercover as a protestor to infiltrate the Occupy Wall Street movement, asserted that he never harmed Lien and was hitting the vehicle to maintain his cover. Prosecutors argue that "Braszczok completely abdicated his responsibility as a police officer by first and foremost failing to take any action." He testified that he was unable to help Lien because, without his badge and gun, he was helpless to stop the melee. "I didn’t think they would have believed me that I was a cop," he said. "I wish I could have done more to help the driver." Braszczok said he followed Lien to detain him after hitting Mieses, but was unable to do so for safety reasons. He also said he failed to report seeing the assault to his supervisors because he feared losing his job. On June 9, 2015, Braszczok was convicted of second-degree assault, coercion, riot and criminal mischief. He was acquitted of the top charge of first-degree gang assault. Braszczok received one year on the assault conviction and one year for coercion. The sentences for those charges will run concurrently. He also received one year for criminal mischief for breaking the SUV's window. This sentence will run consecutively with the other two, leaving him with two years in jail. Braszczok was fired from the NYPD for his role in the attack.
Jason Brown pleaded guilty to second-degree assault and riot and was sentenced to three and a half years in jail.
Several defendants have accepted plea deals. Allen Edwards and Edwin Rodriguez were each sentenced to five years probation on charges of second-degree assault and first-degree rioting. Craig Wright, Kalik Douglas, and James Kuehne also pleaded guilty to the same charges, and were sentenced to two years in prison and three years post-release supervision. Clint Caldwell, who played a more minor role, pleaded guilty to the same charges and was sentenced to one year in prison.
Lawmakers are attempting to introduce motorcycle safety legislation that would require a permit for gatherings of 50 or more motorcycles, and notification to the communities through which they would be riding. "We’re not splicing atoms here. This is something that's very not uncommon. You know, permits are required for all kinds of public assembly and activities, and there should be a similar process for motorcycles", said state senator Adriano Espaillat. The legislation was inspired by the September 29 incident as well as the death of Marian Kurshik, 78, in December 2013 after being struck by a motorcycle traveling in a pack and performing stunts. The driver of the motorcycle was also killed in the accident. "His feet was [sic] on the seat; the front wheel pulled up. He was going very fast", said a bystander. "This not only, I think, protects pedestrians. I think it also protects the motorcyclists themselves", said Espaillat.
- Parascandola, Rocco; Jacobs, Shayna; Mcshane, Larry (October 8, 2013). "Undercover NYPD detective charged for role in Manhattan biker gang beatdown: sources". Daily News. Retrieved October 14, 2013.
- "Biker Christopher Cruz charged in New York road crash". BBC News. October 2, 2013. Retrieved October 14, 2013.
- "State Bill Seeks To Prevent Another Biker Melee". CBS New York. December 23, 2013.
- Hislop, Rachel (October 7, 2013). "The man behind Hollywood Stuntz breaks his silence on brutal NYC biker SUV brawl". Global Grind.
- Davies, Alex (October 2, 2013). "Transportation More: New York City Motorcycles New York Police Department Old Videos Show That Motorcycle Rallies In NYC Are Totally Nuts". Business Insider.
- Goodman, J. David (October 1, 2013). "2 Bikers Are Charged; Investigation Continues". The New York Times. Retrieved October 14, 2013.
- "NYPD: Biker Arrested, Another Surrenders In Attack On SUV Driver". CBS New York. October 1, 2013.
- McKinley, James (May 18, 2015). "Driver Testifies About Attack by Motorcyclists on West Side Highway". The New York Times.
- "Alexian Lien's family: We were 'in grave danger'". Newsday. Retrieved March 22, 2015.
- McKinley Jr., James C. (May 21, 2015). "Opposing Views of Menace at Trial in Motorcycle Assault". The New York Times.
- "Bikers assault banker in New York highway clash". South China Morning Post. October 3, 2013.
- Goodman, David (October 1, 2013). "2 Bikers Are Charged; Investigation Continues". The New York Times.
- CHOUDHURY, Narmeen (May 18, 2015). "Trial begins for undercover NYPD detective in biker melee". Pix 11 News.
- Long, Colleen (May 18, 2015). "Assault trial begins for undercover NYPD detective embroiled in biker melee with SUV driver". Star Tribune.
- Rosenberg, Rebecca (May 18, 2015). "Dad publicly details biker gang beating for first time".
- Danielle Tcholakian (October 12, 2014). "The West Side Highway biker gang assault: A timeline". Metro. Retrieved March 22, 2015.
- Parascandola, Joe Kemp, Bill Hutchinson, Rocco. "PICTURED: Wealthy couple attacked by wild pack of motorcyclists after harrowing 4-mile chase on the West Side Highway following fender bender turned hit-and-run — driver fled after running over biker - NY Daily News".
- Long, Colleen (May 18, 2015). "Biker Melee Victim Testifies in Undercover NYPD Cop's Trial". ABC News.
- "Motorcyclists Chase, Attack SUV driver in New York". ABC News. September 30, 2013.
- Goldstein, Joseph (October 4, 2013). "Biker Was Playing Peacemaker When S.U.V. Hit Him, Lawyer Says". The New York Times. Retrieved January 1, 2014.
- "Undercover NYPD Cop Present At NY Biker Attack". Newsone. Associated Press. October 5, 2013. Retrieved January 1, 2014.
- Brown, Stephanie (March 5, 2014). "Biker doesn't blame SUV driver who left him paralyzed". Daily News. New York.
- "Gloria Allred's defense of 'innocent' injured biker". New York Post. October 4, 2013.
- McKinley, James (November 8, 2013). "11 Motorcyclists Are Indicted in Assault on an S.U.V. Driver". The New York Times.
- Berry, Andrew (October 1, 2013). "New York City Motorcycle Attack: Two Arrested, More Video Surfaces In Terrifying Road Rage Incident [VIDEO] New York City Motorcycle Attack: Two Arrested, More Video Surfaces In Terrifying Road Rage Incident". International Business Times.
- Stuart, Hunter (October 23, 2013). "New Video Shows Alexian Lien Pulled From SUV By Bikers And Beaten". Huffington Post New York.
- Jr, James C. Mckinley (May 21, 2015). "Man Who Intervened in Manhattan Biker Assault Testifies". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved May 22, 2015.
- Miles, Darla (October 6, 2013). "Good Samaritan in SUV incident honored". ABC New York 7.
- Smith, Alexander; Connor, Tracy (October 2, 2013). "Biker injured in NYC clash with SUV hires celebrity attorney Gloria Allred". NBC News. Retrieved October 14, 2013.
- "Biker gang DID try to grab tech exec's wife as they brutally beat SUV driver after chase through Manhattan, reveals hero who intervened". October 6, 2013. Retrieved January 20, 2013.
- "Wife of banker recounts being brutalized by biker gang during attack". Retrieved May 20, 2015.
- "In New York trial, woman describes terror as bikers beat her husband". Los Angeles Times. ISSN 0458-3035. Retrieved May 20, 2015.
- "Timeline: The biker gang attack on Alexian Lien". New York Post. October 10, 2013.
- Orlove, Raphael (October 4, 2013). "This is alexian lien's range rover after it was attacked by bikers". Jalopnik.com.
- Curry, Colleen (September 30, 2013). "Motorcyclists Pull Driver from Car in NYC, Beat Him After Collision". ABC News.
- "Video from 2011 Shows NYC Bikers Attacking Toyota Prius, Plus Latest Developments". Car Scoops. October 1, 2013.
- "Same NYC bikers attacked a Prius in 2011". Retrieved March 3, 2014.
- "5 off-duty officers among bikers in SUV incident". ABC. October 4, 2013. Retrieved October 14, 2013.
- coscarelli, joe (October 8, 2013). "The Man Behind Hollywood Stuntz Swears He Doesn't Have a Real Biker Gang". New York.
- O'Reilly, Andrew (October 3, 2013). "After Road Rage Fracas, Motorcycle Clubs Combat Image Problem". Fox News Latino.
- Peters, Justin (October 2, 2013). "Yes, "Motorcycle Gangs" Still Exist. No, They Didn't Attack a Man in New York". Slate.
- "Dangerous new breed of biker gang seeks Internet glory, taunting police". NBC News. Retrieved February 23, 2014.
- Morgan, Piers (October 7, 2013). "Gloria Allred on motorcycle victim involved in SUV swarm". CNN.
- O'Ryan Johnson. "Run-over Mass. biker has long criminal record". bostonherald.com. Retrieved March 22, 2015.
- "9th Suspect Charged In Manhattan Motorcycle-SUV Melee". CBS New York. October 23, 2013.
- Tcholakian, Danielle (October 2, 2013). "Biker gang assault: Who's the man behind Hollywood Stuntz?". Metro.
- "2 bikers in terrifying chase of SUV take plea deals, avoid jail". January 7, 2015.
- Rosenberg, Rebecca (December 20, 2013). "Charges set to be reduced against SUV biker bash thugs". New York Post.
- "Victim of motorcyle gang beating sues city, biker cops". New York Post. January 18, 2014. Retrieved December 4, 2018.
A city Law Department spokeswoman said: “At this time, this is just a notice of claim — not a lawsuit.
- Parascandola, Rocco; Kemp, Joe; Mcshane, Larry (October 4, 2013). "Motorcyclist charged with gang assault; Off-duty and undercover cops did nothing to stop biker beatdown of dad". Daily News. Retrieved October 14, 2013.
- "MORE PLEA DEALS IN WEST SIDE HIGHWAY BIKER ROAD RAGE CASE". ABC 7. March 25, 2015.
- Antenucci, Antonio; Rosenberg, Rebecca (March 25, 2015). "Biker takes plea deal, to get 2 years in prison for role in gang beating". New York Post. ISSN 1090-3321. Retrieved August 10, 2015.
- Rosenberg, Rebecca (May 20, 2015). "Wife of dad beaten by bikers cries as she details harrowing ordeal". New York Post. Retrieved May 20, 2015.
- Jr, James C. Mckinley (August 6, 2015). "Final Biker Is Sentenced in Assault on S.U.V. Driver". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved August 10, 2015.
- Jr, James C. Mckinley (June 9, 2015). "2 Motorcyclists Found Guilty in 2013 Attack on Driver but Acquitted of Top Charge". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved June 10, 2015.
- Gringas, Brynn; Prokupecz, Shimon (October 10, 2013). "Charges Upgraded to Gang Assault for Undercover NYPD Cop in Biker Beating". NBC New York.
- Rosenberg, Rebecca (June 5, 2015). "Undercover cop in biker-gang beating rattled on the stand". New York Post.
- Associated Press (May 18, 2015). "'I feared for my life': Father weeps as he relives 'horrifying' moment biker gang attacked him, his wife and child in road rage clash as undercover COP who took part in melee is pictured for the first time". Daily Mail UK.
- Jr, James C. Mckinley (June 2, 2015). "Detective Charged in Biker Attack Says He Fled Because He Was Scared". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved June 3, 2015.
- Miles, Darla (August 5, 2015). "NYPD DETECTIVE GETS 2 YEARS IN WEST SIDE HIGHWAY BIKER ASSAULT CASE". ABC7NY.
- Gregorian, Dareh. "Ex-NYPD cop Wojciech Braszczok sentenced to 2 years for 2013 biker gang attack - NY Daily News".
- Macmillan, Thomas (July 1, 2015). "Man Sentenced for Role in Biker Assault on Manhattan SUV Driver". The Wall Street Journal. ISSN 0099-9660. Retrieved August 10, 2015.
- on YouTube
- on YouTube
- Piers Morgan interview with Gloria Allred and the wife of Edwin Mieses at piersmorgan.blogs.cnn.com
- Gang related legislation in New York at www.nationalgangcenter.gov