Alternative wine closure
Alternative wine closures are substitute closures used in the wine industry for sealing wine bottles in place of traditional cork closures. The emergence of these alternatives has grown in response to quality control efforts by winemakers to protect against "cork taint" caused by the presence of the chemical trichloroanisole (TCA).
The closures debate, chiefly between supporters of screw caps and natural corks, has increased the awareness of post-bottling wine chemistry, and the concept of winemaking has grown to continue after the bottling process, because closures with different oxygen transmission rates may lead to wines that taste different when they reach consumers.
The cork-industry group APCOR cites a study showing a 0.7–1.2% taint rate. In a 2005 study of 2800 bottles tasted at the Wine Spectator blind-tasting facilities in Napa, California, 7% of the bottles were found to be tainted.
Synthetic corks are made from plastic compounds designed to look and "pop" like natural cork, but without the risk of TCA contamination. Disadvantages of synthetic corks include a risk of harmful air entering a bottle after as little as 18 months, difficulty in extracting them from the bottle, and difficulty in using the cork to reseal the wine. James Laube of Wine Spectator notes that some can also impart a slight chemical flavour to the wine.
Unlike natural corks, many synthetic corks are made from material that is not biodegradable but recyclable as resin identification code #4 or #7. There are two main production techniques for synthetic wine closures: injection molding and extrusion. There are also methods claimed to combine the two techniques of injection and extrusion. A 2007 study by Victor Segalen Bordeaux 2 University showed that injection-molded synthetic corks allowed the highest levels of oxygen permeation when compared to natural cork and screw caps, offering the lowest protection against oxidation of the wine.
Synthetic wine bottle closures may allow for a controlled oxygen transfer rate, which affects the sensory characteristics.
Screw caps or "Stelvin caps" are closures made only from aluminium material that threads onto the bottleneck. They are the predominant closure used by Austrian, Australian and New Zealand wineries. This can be attributed in part to the New Zealand screw cap initiative which promotes the use of screw caps instead of cork. Screw caps form a tighter seal and can keep out oxygen for a longer time than cork. These benefits aid in maintaining the wine's overall quality and aging potential. Michel Laroche of Domaine Laroche noted that this played a role in his decision to adopt screwcaps. "Extensive quality tests show convincing results: apart from protecting against cork taint, screwcaps are also beneficial in the aging of wine, particularly preserving the aromatic freshness."
An often cited contradiction is the case of experiments carried out by Château Haut-Brion in the 1970s, when 100 bottles were placed under screwcap for long term observation. The result was, according to Haut-Brion manager Jean-Bernard Delmas, that "it worked perfectly for the first ten years, until the plastic in the caps went brittle and let air in".
A disadvantage of screw caps according to wine expert Jancis Robinson is the opposite of oxidation: reduction, which may suppress a wine's aroma and possibly cause unpleasant ones, a problem that particularly affects Sauvignon blanc which is a grape variety with natural tendencies toward reduction. Furthermore, there is the screwcap's public image, as "consumers still perceive screwcaps as being for 'cheap' wines (regardless of the price tag)".
In a 2004 study of consumer opinions conducted by the wine consulting firm Wine Intelligence found that nearly 52% of American consumers and 60% of British consumers reject the idea of using screwcaps for their fine wine. The 2007 Victor Segalen University study in Bordeaux showed that screw caps closures allowed the lowest amount of oxygen permeation when compared to natural and synthetic corks, offering the highest level of protection against oxidation of the wine.
Following studies by the faults clinic at the International Wine Challenge in September 2006, it became widely reported in British newspapers that test results show that one in 50 screwcap bottles, 200,000 bottles worldwide, may be affected by the chemical process sulphidisation, resulting in a flaw in which a consumer would be "confronted with the reek of sulphur—likened to burning rubber or rotten eggs—rather than an attractive bouquet". Jamie Goode presented arguments against reports he described to "represent the science of closures badly, are filled with inaccuracies and misunderstandings, and do not serve the wine industry well", and addressed the inaccuracies in specific points.
Vino-Seal and Vinolok
Vino-Seal, also sold as Vinolok, is a plastic/glass closure originally developed by Alcoa and now produced by a Czech crystal glass producer Preciosa. Since its introduction into the European market in 2003, over 300 wineries have utilized the closure. Using a glass stopper with an inert o-ring, the closure is claimed to create a hermetic seal that prevents oxidation and TCA contamination. A disadvantage of the closure is the relatively high cost of each plug (70 cents each) and cost either of manual bottling, or else obtaining compatible bottling equipment.
Zork is an alternative wine closure for still wines, that seals like a screw cap and pops like a cork, created by an Australian company of the same name. The closure has three parts: an outer cap providing a tamper-evident clamp that locks onto the band of a standard cork mouth bottle; an inner metal foil which provides an oxygen barrier similar to a screw cap, and an inner plunger which creates the ‘pop’ on extraction and reseals after use. Introduced in 2010, it is the first on-bottle, resealable closure for sparkling wines.
There is continuing opposition to the use of alternative closures in some parts of the winemaking industry. In March 2006, the Spanish government outlawed the use of alternative wine closures in 11 of Spain's wine-producing regions as part of their (Denominación de Origen) D.O. regulations.
Although environmentalists lament the loss of cork forests to commercial crops such as eucalyptus, advocates of artificial corks claim that "natural corks" are just "granules and dust bonded with solvents", and no more biodegradable than the artificial product. "Granules and dust bonded with solvents" describes "agglomerate corks." These differ from "natural corks" that are one piece made out of cork bark.
- Shriver, Jerry, USA Today (August 3, 2006). And now for something completely different
- Business Wire (August 9, 2005). 'Just Say No' – To Cork! Don Sebastiani & Sons Announces Plans to Focus Exclusively on Alternative Wine Closures
- Goode, Jamie, Ph.D. Wines & Vines (August 2008). "Finding Closure". Archived from the original on 2009-04-10.
- Laube, James, Wine Spectator (March 31, 2006). Changing With the Times(subscription required) Archived 2006-03-14 at the Wayback Machine
- Robinson, Jancis (June 10, 2006). "Down with synthetic corks!". jancisrobinson.com. Archived from the original on July 28, 2006.
- Kramer, Matt, Wine Spectator (October 31, 2007). Seeking Closure Archived 2008-07-19 at the Wayback Machine p. 36
- Impact of post-bottling oxygen exposure on the sensory characteristics and phenolic composition of Grenache rosé wines. J. Wirth, S. Caillé, J.M. Souquet, A. Samson, J.B. Dieval, S. Vidal, H. Fulcrand and V. Cheynier, Food Chemistry, 15 June 2012, Volume 132, Issue 4, pp. 1861–1871, 6th International Conference on Water in Food, doi:10.1016/j.foodchem.2011.12.019
- Ciampa, Gail, The Providence Journal (August 2, 2006). Don't get caught without your wine notes
- Lechmere, Adam, Decanter.com (May 30, 2002). "Kiwis spread the screwcap gospel". Archived from the original on June 5, 2008. Retrieved December 2, 2008.
- South African Wine News (July 26, 2006). The Winery goes out to bat for screwcaps
- Robinson, Jancis, jancisrobinson.com (June 11, 2004). "Will our grandchildren need a corkscrew?". Archived from the original on September 5, 2008. Retrieved December 2, 2008.
- Robinson, Jancis, jancisrobinson.com (June 29, 2006). "Zork talk". Archived from the original on July 5, 2010. Retrieved December 2, 2008.
- APCOR, realcork.org Wine Intelligence – Closures: The US Consumer View Archived 2008-03-12 at the Wayback Machine
- Alleyne, Richard, The Daily Telegraph (September 20, 2006). "Screwcaps blamed for tainting wine".
- Elliott, Valerie, The Times (January 16, 2007). "Why screwtops may not be such a corking way to keep red wine fine". London.
- The Daily Mail (January 15, 2007). "Experts raise a stink over screw-top wine bottles".
- Goode, Jamie (January 19, 2007). "In defence of screwcaps". wineanorak.com.
- Robinson, Jancis; Harding, Julia (2015). The Oxford Companion to Wine. Oxford University Press. p. 192. ISBN 0198705387.
- Perdue, Andy, Wine Press Northwest (Summer 2006). "Glass adds class to Oregon Wine"
- Business Wire (March 27, 2006). "Put a Cork in It" Says New Spanish Law; Spain's Top Wine Producers Outlaw Alternative Closures in 11 Spanish Regions
- BBC News (Sep. 18, 2008). Urging vintners to put a cork in it
- "Put a cork in it: the environmental cost of the screw cap" The Guardian (Aug. 22, 2010)