Aluminum building wiring

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
  (Redirected from Aluminum wiring)
Jump to: navigation, search

Aluminum building wiring is a type of electrical wiring for residential construction or houses that uses aluminum electrical conductors. Aluminum provides a better conductivity to weight ratio than copper, and therefore is also used for wiring power grids, including overhead power transmission lines and local power distribution lines, as well as for power wiring of some airplanes.[1][2] Utility companies have used aluminum wire for electrical transmission in power grids since around the late 1800s to the early 1900s. It has cost and weight advantages over copper wires. Aluminum wire in power transmission and distribution applications is still the preferred material today.[3]

In North American residential construction, aluminum wire was used for wiring entire houses for a short time from the 1960s to the mid-1970s during a period of high copper prices. Electrical devices (outlets, switches, lighting, fans, etc.) at the time were not designed with the particular properties of the aluminum wire being used in mind, and there were some issues related to the properties of the wire itself, making the installations with aluminum wire much more susceptible to problems. Revised manufacturing standards for both the wire and the devices were developed to reduce to problems. Existing homes with this older aluminum wiring used in branch circuits present a potential fire hazard.

Aluminum wire materials[edit]

New York City utility lines in 1890.

Aluminum wire has been used as an electrical conductor for a considerable period of time, particularly by electrical utilities related to power transmission lines in use shortly after the beginning of modern power distribution systems being constructed starting in the late 1880s. In the early 1960s when there was a housing construction boom in North America and the price of copper spiked, aluminum building wire was manufactured using utility grade AA-1350 aluminum alloy in sizes small enough to be used for lower load branch circuits in homes.[4] Aluminum wire requires a larger wire gauge than copper wire to carry the same load or current, but was still less expensive than copper wire for a particular branch circuit.

In the late 1960s problems and failures related to branch circuit connections for the newer building wire made with the utility grade AA-1350 alloy aluminum began to surface, resulting in a re-evaluation of the use of that alloy for building wire and an identification of the need for newer alloys to produce aluminum building wire. The first 8000 series electric conductor alloy, still widely used in some applications, was developed and patented in 1972 by Aluminum Company of America (ALCOA).[5] This alloy, along with AA-8030 (patented by Olin in 1973) and AA-8176 (patented by Southwire in 1975 and 1980) perform mechanically like copper.

Unlike the older AA-1350 alloy previously used, these AA-8000 series alloys also retain their tensile strength after the standard current cycle test or the Current Cycle Submersion Test (CCST), as described in ANSI C119.4:2004. Depending on the annealing grade, AA-8176 may elongate up to 30% with less springback effect and possesses a higher yield strength (19.8 KSI for a coldworked AA-8076 wire).[citation needed]

A home with aluminum wiring installed prior to the mid-1970s (as the stock of pre-1972 aluminum wire was permitted to be used up) probably has wire made with the older AA-1350 alloy that was developed for power transmission. The AA-1350 aluminum alloy was more prone to problems related to branch circuit wiring in homes due to mechanical properties that made it more susceptible to failures resulting from the electrical devices being used at that time combined with poor workmanship.

Aluminum wiring in modern building construction[edit]

Larger electrical cable with stranded aluminum wires

Aluminum building wiring for modern building construction used for electrical service and distribution wiring is manufactured with the newer AA-8000 series aluminum alloy wire as specified by the National Electrical Code (NEC). Aluminum has roughly twice the resistance of copper for a given wire cross-section. This causes heating of the conductor along its length proportional to the square of the current (P = I squared R, Ohm's Law). It should never be used for branch circuits subject to high current loads such as receptacles supplying high-current devices. Size #12 AWG from "old work" wiring is acceptable in residential circuits supplying standard lighting fixtures as it has roughly the same conductivity as #14 AWG copper and is thus sufficient for up to 15 Amps per National Electrical Code (NEC).

For modern residential construction the use of larger gauge stranded aluminum wire is fairly common in much of North America. Larger aluminum wire is used in residential applications for lower voltage service feeders from the utility to the building. Also, larger aluminum building wire made with the newer AA-8000 series alloy of aluminum is commonly used for electrical services (e.g. service entrance conductors from the utility connection to the service breaker panel) and for larger branch circuits with higher loads such as those for sub-panels, ranges and air-conditioning units.

Aluminum wire sizes smaller than #8 AWG have been banned in more recent revisions of the National Electrical Code (NEC) for "new work".

Aluminum wiring in older homes[edit]

When utility grade AA-1350 alloy aluminum wire was first used in branch circuit wiring in the early 1960s, solid aluminum wire was installed the same way as copper wire with the same electrical devices.

For smaller branch circuits with solid wires (15A/20A circuits) typical connections of an electrical wire to an electrical device are usually made by wrapping the wire around a screw on the device, also called a terminal, and then tightening the screw. At around the same time the use of steel screws became more common than brass screws for electrical devices.

Over time, many of these terminations with solid aluminum wire began to fail due to improper connection techniques and the dissimilar metals having different resistances and significantly different coefficients of thermal expansion, as well as problems with properties of the solid wires. These connection failures generated heat under electrical load and caused overheated connections.

The larger size stranded aluminum wires don't have the same historical problems as solid aluminum wires, and the common terminations for larger size wires are dual-rated terminations called lugs. These lugs are typically made with a coated aluminum alloy, which can accommodate either an aluminum wire or a copper wire. Larger stranded aluminum wiring with proper terminations is generally considered safe, since long-term installations have proven its reliability.

Problems with aluminum wiring[edit]

The use of older solid aluminum wiring in residential construction has resulted in failures of connections at electrical devices, has been implicated in house fires according to the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC), and in some areas it may be difficult to obtain homeowners insurance for a house with older aluminum wiring.[6][7] There are several possible reasons why these connections failed. The two main reasons were improper installations (poor workmanship) and the differences in the coefficient of expansion between aluminum wire used in the 1960s to mid-1970s and the terminations, particularly when the termination was a steel screw on an electrical device.[8][9] The reported hazards are associated with older solid aluminum branch circuit wiring (smaller than No. 8 AWG)

Improper installations[edit]

Many terminations of aluminum wire installed in the 1960s and 1970s that were properly installed continue to operate with no problems. However, problems can develop in the future, particularly if connections were not properly installed initially.

Improper installation, or poor workmanship, includes: not abrading the wires and applying a corrosion inhibitor; not wrapping wires around terminal screws; wrapping wires around terminal screws the wrong way; and inadequate torque on the connection screws. There can also be problems with connections made with too much torque on the connection screw as it causes damage to the wire, particularly with the softer aluminum wire.

Coefficient of expansion and creep[edit]

Thermal expansion rates of wiring metals

Most of the problems related to aluminum wire are typically associated with older (pre-1972) AA-1350 alloy solid aluminum wire, sometimes referred to as "old technology" aluminum wiring, as the properties of that wire result in significantly more expansion and contraction than copper wire or modern day AA-8000 series aluminum wire. Older solid aluminum wire also had some problems with a property called creep, which results in the wire permanently deforming or relaxing over time under load.

Aluminum wire used before the mid-1970s had a somewhat higher rate of creep, but a more significant issue was that aluminum wire critically had a coefficient of expansion that varied significantly from steel screws commonly used in lieu of brass screws around this time for terminations at devices such as outlets and switches. Aluminum and steel expand and contract at significantly different rates under thermal load, so a connection can become loose, particularly for older terminations initially installed with inadequate torque of the screws combined with creep of the aluminum over time. Loose connections get progressively worse over time.

This cycle results from the connection loosening slightly, with a reduced contact area at the connection leading to overheating, and allowing intermetallic steel/aluminum compounds to be formed between the conductor and the terminal screw. This resulted in a higher resistance junction, leading to additional overheating. Although many believe that oxidation was the issue, studies have shown that oxidation was not significant in these cases.[10]

Problems with electrical device ratings[edit]

Many electrical devices used in the 1960s had smaller plain steel terminal screws, which made the attachment of the aluminum wires being used at that time to these devices much more vulnerable to problems. In the late 1960s, a device specification known as CU/AL (meaning copper-aluminum) was created that specified standards for devices intended for use with aluminum wire. Some of these devices used larger undercut screw terminals to more securely hold the wire.

Unfortunately, CU/AL switches and receptacles failed to work well enough with aluminum wire, and a new specification called CO/ALR (meaning copper-aluminum, revised) was created. These devices employ brass screw terminals that are designed to act as a similar metal to aluminum and to expand at a similar rate, and the screws have even deeper undercuts. The CO/ALR rating is only available for standard light switches and receptacles; Cu/Al is the standard connection marking for circuit breakers and larger equipment.

Aluminum oxidation[edit]

Most metals (with a few exceptions, such as gold) oxidize freely when exposed to air. Aluminium oxide is not an electrical conductor, but rather an electrical insulator. Consequently, the flow of electrons through the oxide layer can be greatly impeded. However, since the oxide layer is only a few nanometers thick, the added resistance is not noticeable under most conditions. When aluminum wire is terminated properly, the mechanical connection breaks the thin, brittle layer of oxide to form an excellent electrical connection. Unless this connection is loosened, there is no way for oxygen to penetrate the connection point to form further oxide.

Result improperly joined aluminum and copper wires in old apartment, done by qualified electrician

If inadequate torque is applied to the electrical device termination screw or if the devices are not CO/ALR rated (or at least CU/AL rated for breakers and larger equipment) this can result in an inadequate connection of the aluminum wire. Also, due to the significant difference in thermal expansion rates of older aluminum wire and steel termination screws connections can loosen over time allowing the formation of some additional oxide on the wire. However oxidation was found not to be a substantial factor in failures of aluminum wire terminations.[10]

Joining aluminum and copper wires[edit]

Another issue is the joining of aluminum wire to copper wire. In addition to the oxidation that occurs on the surface of aluminum wires which can cause a poor connection, aluminum and copper are dissimilar metals. As a result, galvanic corrosion can occur in the presence of an electrolyte, and these connections can become unstable over time.

Aluminum wiring upgrades/repairs[edit]

Several upgrades or repairs are available for homes with older pre-1970s aluminum branch circuit wiring:

  • Completely rewiring the house with copper wires (usually cost prohibitive)
  • "Pig-tailing" which involves splicing a short length of copper wire (pigtail) to the original aluminum wire, and then attaching the copper wire to the existing electrical device. The splice of the copper pigtail to the existing aluminum wire can be accomplished with special crimp connectors, special miniature lug-type connectors, or approved twist-on connectors (with special installation procedures).

However, the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) currently only recommends two alternatives for a permanent repair using the pig-tailing method. The more extensively tested method uses special crimp-on connectors called COPALUM connectors. As of April 2011, the CPSC has also recognized miniature lug-type connectors called AlumiConn connectors.[6][11] The CPSC considers the use of pigtails with wire nuts a temporary repair, and even as a temporary repair recommends special installation procedures, and notes that there can still be hazards with attempting the repairs.

COPALUM connectors use a special crimping system that creates a cold weld between the copper and aluminum wire, and is considered a permanent, maintenance-free repair. However, there may not be sufficient length of wires in enclosures to permit a special crimping tool to be used, and the resulting connections are sometimes too large to install in existing enclosures due to limited space (or "box fill"). Installing an enclosure extender for un-finished surfaces, replacing the enclosure with a larger one or installing an additional adjacent enclosure can be done to increase the available space. Also COPALUM connectors are costly to install, require special tools that cannot simply be purchased and electricians certified to use them by the manufacturer, and it can sometimes be very difficult to find local electricians certified to install these connectors.

The AlumiConn miniature lug connector can also be used for a permanent repair.[6] The only special tool required for an electrician installing them is a special torque screwdriver that should be readily available to qualified electrical contractors. Proper torque on the connectors set screws is critical to having an acceptable repair. However, use of the Alumiconn connectors is a relatively newer repair option for older aluminum wiring compared to other methods, and use of these connectors can have some of the same or similar problems with limited enclosure space as the COPALUM connectors.

Special twist-on connectors (or "wire nuts") are available for joining aluminum to copper wire, which are pre-filled with a special antioxidant compound in a low-residue polybutene base[12] with a zinc dust added to the compound, intended to abrade the wires and prevent corrosion of the connection. As of 2014 there was only one twist-on connector rated or "UL Listed" for connecting aluminum and copper branch circuit wires in the U.S., which is the Ideal No. 65 "Twister Al/Cu wire connector". These special twist-on connectors have a distinctive purple color, have been UL Listed for aluminum to copper branch circuit wire connections since 1995, and according to the manufacturer's current literature are "perfect for pig-tailing a copper conductor onto aluminum branch circuit wiring in retrofit applications".[13] The CPSC still considers the use of twist-on connectors, including the Ideal No. 65 "Twister Al/Cu wire connector", to be a temporary repair.

According to the CPSC, even using (listed) twist-on connectors to attach copper pigtails to older aluminum wires as a temporary repair requires special installation procedures, including abrading and pre-twisting the wires. However, the manufacturer's instructions for the Ideal No. 65 Twister[14] only recommends pre-twisting the wires, and does not state it's required. Also the instructions do not mention physically abrading the wires as recommended by the CPSC, although the manufacturer current literature states the pre-filled "compound cuts aluminum oxide". Some researchers have criticized the UL listing/tests for this wire connector, and there have been reported problems with tests (without pre-twisting) and installations.[15] However, it is unknown if the reported installation problems were associated with unqualified persons attempting these repairs, or not using recommended special installation procedures (such as abrading and pre-twisting the wires as recommended by the CPSC for older aluminum wire, or at least pre-twisting the wires as recommended by Ideal for their connectors).

The use of newer CO/ALR rated devices (switches and receptacles) can be used to replace older devices that did not have the proper rating in homes with aluminum branch circuit wiring to reduce the hazards.[15] These devices are reportedly tested and listed for both AA-1350 and AA-8000 series aluminum wire, and are acceptable according to the National Electrical Code.[4][16]

However, some manufacturers of CO/ALR devices recommend periodically checking/tightening the terminal screws on these devices which can be hazardous for unqualified individuals to attempt, and there is criticism of their use as a permanent repair as some CO/ALR devices have failed in tests when connected to "old technology" aluminum wire.[6] Furthermore, just installing CO/ALR devices (switches and receptacles) doesn't address potential hazards associated with other connections such as those at ceiling fans, lights and equipment.

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Telecommunications and networks, Khateeb M. Hussain, Donna Hussain
  2. ^ Aircraft Wire. mechanicsupport.com
  3. ^ "Anaheim Aluminum Wiring Facts and Fallacies | CA Electrician". Accurateelectricalservices.com. 2011-02-04. Retrieved 2012-03-07. 
  4. ^ a b "The Evolution of Aluminum Conductors Used for Building Wire and Cable" (PDF). NEMA. 2012. 
  5. ^ Patent application filed in 1969
  6. ^ a b c d "Repairing Aluminum Wiring" (PDF). CPSC Publication 516, June 2011 www.cpsc.gov. 
  7. ^ "What Owners Need to Know About Wiring Dangers". Washington Post Article, Real Estate, July 3, 2004. 
  8. ^ "Aluminum Building Wire Installation & Terminations" (PDF). Christel Hunter, IAEI News (January/February 2006). 
  9. ^ "Aluminum Building Wire 40 Years Later". Southwire Article. 
  10. ^ a b "Observations on the Mechanisms of High Resistance Junction Formation in Aluminum Wire Connections" (PDF). Journal of Research of the National Bureau of Standards, June 1980, Pgs. 429-440, by D.Newbury and S. Greenwald. 
  11. ^ "CPSC Approval Letter for AlumiConn Connectors" (PDF). CPSC. 
  12. ^ "Ideal Noalox Antioxidant Material Safety Data Sheet" (PDF). 
  13. ^ "Twister Al/Cu Wire Connector" (PDF). Ideal Twister Brochure. 2014. 
  14. ^ "Ideal Twister Al/Cu Plus Wire Connector Instruction Sheet" (PDF). LA-2669-3, Ideal Industries. 
  15. ^ a b "Reducing the Fire Hazard in Aluminum-Wired Homes" (PDF). Report by Jesse Aronstein, PE Updated 11/25/2011. 
  16. ^ "2014 National Electrical Code".