American Academy of the Fine Arts
The American Academy of the Fine Arts was an art institution founded in 1802 in New York City, to encourage appreciation and teaching of the classical style. It exhibited copies of classical works and encouraged artists to emulate the classical in their work. The mayor of New York city at the time, Richard Varick, and Gulian Verplanck, a New York politician, were some of the Academy's original organizers. Younger artists grew increasingly restive under its constraint, and in 1825 left to found the National Academy of Design.
The Academy's original name was the New York Academy of the Fine Arts. Its founders included New York Mayor Richard Varick and Gulian Verplanck, a future influential politician in the state and nationally.
A conservative organization, the Academy was from 1817-1836 led by the painter John Trumbull as president. He had long practiced the classical ideal of art and became known as a tyrant in his attitude toward young painters. The Academy's conservatism and Trumbull's unyielding attitude eventually led to such a level of dissatisfaction among the younger painters that they formed a splinter group.
In 1825 they abandoned the American Academy to found the National Academy of Design, also in New York. The American Academy said it regretted the loss of the young artists, but affirmed its traditions. Ultimately it did not attract enough students and support, and closed in 1841. The National Academy has continued as a vital institution.
The West commission
In 1818, Trumbull, representing the American Academy, commissioned a portrait of his former teacher and mentor, the painter Benjamin West, from Sir Thomas Lawrence, widely considered to be the most accomplished English portraitist of the age. Lawrence set a price of 400 guineas for the project. According to Carrie Rebora's 20th-century account, to pay for the work, Trumbull opened a subscription fund before finally taking delivery of the painting in 1822 for the Academy. Two earlier 19th-century accounts had said that Lawrence was made a member of the Academy and painted the portrait in exchange. 
- Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts
- National Academy of Design
- Thomas Lawrence
- Samuel Morse
- John Trumbull
- Richard Varick
- Gulian Verplanck
- Benjamin West
- "A History of the Metropolitan Museum of Art" Page 7, 1913
- Collection Tour Glossary, The National Gallery of Art, Washington D.C..
- Bolger, Doreen. Ambrose Andrews and His Masterpiece, "The Children of Nathan Starr", American Art Journal, Vol. 22, No. 1, Spring 1990, Kennedy Galleries, Inc., p. 5.
- Art Value Terms, AskArt.com.
- Trumbull's paintings by then were considered out of style. "John Trumbull (painter)", Encyclopedia.com.
- American Academy of the Fine Arts, entry at Encyclopedia.com.
- Verplanck, Gulian C., An address delivered at the opening of the 10th exhibition of the American Academy of the Fine Arts, 2nd ed., Carvill, 1825. OCLC 83572267. Google book.
- History of the Academy, National Academy of Design. Retrieved May 8, 2010.
- Correspondence of Trumbull to Lawrence, Royal Academy LAW/2/256, 24 Jan 1818.
- Rebora, Carrie, "Sir Thomas Lawrence's Benjamin West for the American Academy of the Fine Arts", (excerpt), American Art Journal, Vol. 21, No. 3, 1989, p. 19, Kennedy Galleries, Inc.
- In D.E. Williams' The Life and Correspondence of Sir Thomas Lawrence, KT Vol II, 1831, pp. 4-5. Williams cites Lawrence's honorary diploma:
AMERICAN ACADEMY OF THE FINE ARTS. New York, 20 day of Jan. 1818.
Be It Known, that Sir Thomas Lawrence, R. A., London, has been duly chosen an Honorary Member of the American Society of Fine Arts, and, as such, is entitled to all the rights and privileges given to Honorary Members by the bye-laws of the said Academy. In testimony whereof, the seal of the said Academy is affixed to these presents, and the same are signed by the President of the said Academy, and countersigned by the Secretary, the day and year above written.A. Robertson, Secretary.
John Turnbull, President.
Williams continues: "In appreciation of this honour, Sir Thomas Lawrence immediately painted for the academy a full-length likeness of Mr. West, the president of the English academy, and, as it is well known, a native of America."
- Cook, Dutton, Art in England, Hoppner and Lawrence, section VII, ed. Sampson Low, 1869. Quote: [The membership] "an honour he repaid by painting and presenting to the Academy a portrait of their countryman Benjamin West."
- Cowdrey, Mary Bartlett, American Academy of Fine Arts and American Art-Union, 1816–1852, with a history of the American Academy by Theodore Sizer, New York Historical Society, 1953. Google book.
- Morse, Samuel Finley Breese, Examination of Col. Trumbull's address, in opposition to the projected union of the American Academy of Fine Arts, and the National Academy of Design / by Samuel F.B. Morse, president of the National Academy; made at the request of the Council, Includes the "Address of Col. Trumbull", p. -20, American Academy of the Fine Arts/National Academy of Design New York, Clayton & Van Norden, printers, 1833.
- Papers of the American Academy of the Fine Arts : acts of incorporation, by laws, etc., minutes of meetings (1802–1817, 1817–1830, 1830–1839), secretary's book, American Academy of the Fine Arts, New York Historical Society, 1951.
- Verplanck, Gulian Crommelin, American Academy of the Fine Arts, Address delivered before the American Academy of Fine Arts, Wiley, 1824. Google book. ISBN 978-1-144-30684-5
- Official website, National Academy of Design