American flag sort
This article needs additional citations for verification. (July 2017)
An American flag sort is an efficient, in-place variant of radix sort that distributes items into buckets. Non-comparative sorting algorithms such as radix sort and American flag sort are typically used to sort large objects such as strings, for which comparison is not a unit-time operation. American flag sort iterates through the bits of the objects, considering several bits of each object at a time. For each set of bits, American flag sort makes two passes through the array of objects: first to count the number of objects that will fall in each bin, and second to place each object in its bucket. This works especially well when sorting a byte at a time, using 256 buckets. With some optimizations, it is twice as fast as quicksort for large sets of strings.
This article may be confusing or unclear to readers. In particular, it is mentioned above that (1) American flag sort is typically used to sort large objects such as strings, and (2) American flag sort is twice as fast as quicksort for large sets of strings; yet this section states that American flag sort can only sort integers. The additional clarification "or objects that can be interpreted as integers" is quite meaningless since every concievable object in computer memory can be interpreted as an integer. (October 2020)
Sorting algorithms in general sort a list of objects according to some ordering scheme. In contrast to comparison-based sorting algorithms, such as quicksort, American flag sort can only sort integers (or objects that can be interpreted as integers). In-place sorting algorithms, including American flag sort, run without allocating a significant amount of memory beyond that used by the original array. This is a significant advantage, both in memory savings and in time saved copying the array.
American flag sort works by successively dividing a list of objects into buckets based on the first digit of their base-N representation (the base used is referred to as the radix). When N is 3, each object can be swapped into the correct bucket by using the Dutch national flag algorithm. When N is larger, however, objects cannot be immediately swapped into place, because it is unknown where each bucket should begin and end. American flag sort gets around this problem by making two passes through the array. The first pass counts the number of objects that belong in each of the N buckets. The beginning of each bucket is then computed as the sum of sizes of the preceding buckets. The second pass puts each object into the correct bucket.
American flag sort is most efficient with a radix that is a power of 2, because bit-shifting operations can be used instead of expensive exponentiations to compute the value of each digit. When sorting strings using 8- or 7-bit encodings such as ASCII, it is typical to use a radix of 256 or 128, which amounts to sorting character-by-character.
It is worth noting that for pure English alphabet text, the counts histogram is always sparse. Depending on the hardware, it may be worth clearing the counts in correspondence with completing a bucket (as in the original paper.) Or it may be worth maintaining a max and min active bucket, or a more complex data structure suitable for sparse arrays. It is also important to use a more basic sorting method for very small data sets, except in pathological cases where keys may share very long prefixes.
Most critically, this algorithm follows a random permutation, and is thus particularly cache-unfriendly for large datasets. It is a suitable algorithm in conjunction with a k-way merge algorithm. (The original paper was written before cached memory was in common use.)
american_flag_sort(Array, Radix) for each digit D: # first pass: compute counts Counts <- zeros(Radix) for object X in Array: Counts[digit D of object X in base Radix] += 1 # compute bucket offsets Offsets <- [ sum(Counts[0..i]) for i in 1..Radix] # swap objects into place for object X in Array: swap X to the bucket starting at Offsets[digit D of X in base Radix] for each Bucket: american_flag_sort(Bucket, Radix)
Sample implementation in Python
This example written in the Python programming language will perform American flag sort for any radix of 2 or greater. Simplicity of exposition is chosen over clever programming, and so the log function is used instead of bit shifting techniques.
def get_radix_val(x, digit, radix) -> int: return int(floor(x / radix ** digit)) % radix def compute_offsets(a_list, start: int, end: int, digit, radix): counts = [0 for _ in range(radix)] for i in range(start, end): val = get_radix_val(a_list[i], digit, radix) counts[val] += 1 offsets = [0 for _ in range(radix)] sum = 0 for i in range(radix): offsets[i] = sum sum += counts[i] return offsets def swap(a_list, offsets, start: int, end: int, digit, radix) -> None: i = start next_free = copy(offsets) cur_block = 0 while cur_block < radix - 1: if i >= start + offsets[cur_block + 1]: cur_block += 1 continue radix_val = get_radix_val(a_list[i], digit, radix) if radix_val == cur_block: i += 1 continue swap_to = start + next_free[radix_val] a_list[i], a_list[swap_to] = a_list[swap_to], a_list[i] next_free[radix_val] += 1 def american_flag_sort_helper(a_list, start: int, end: int, digit, radix) -> None: offsets = compute_offsets(a_list, start, end, digit, radix) swap(a_list, offsets, start, end, digit, radix) if digit == 0: return for i in range(len(offsets) - 1): american_flag_sort_helper(a_list, offsets[i], offsets[i + 1], digit - 1, radix) def american_flag_sort(a_list, radix) -> None: for x in a_list: assert type(x) == int max_val = max(a_list) max_digit = int(floor(log(max_val, radix))) american_flag_sort_helper(a_list, 0, len(a_list), max_digit, radix)