Andrew Roberts (historian)
13 January 1963 |
London, England, UK
|Occupation||Historian and journalist|
Andrew Roberts, FRSA FRSL (born 13 January 1963), is a British historian and journalist. He is a Visiting Professor at the Department of War Studies, King's College London. His public commentary has appeared in several periodicals such as the Daily Telegraph and The Spectator. Roberts himself is best known for his 2009 non-fiction work The Storm of War. A look at the Second World War covering historical factors such as Hitler's rise to power and the organisation of Nazi Germany, the book has been lauded by several publications such as The Economist, receiving awards such as the British Army Military Book of the Year Award for 2010. In his writings, Roberts supports an interventionist role for the U.K. in global diplomatic and military affairs, advocating for "an active part in defending decency" through the U.K. being "one of the world’s foremost moral policemen".
- 1 Background
- 2 Historical and socio-political viewpoints
- 3 Authorship and television appearances
- 4 Journalism and lecturing
- 5 Disputes and criticisms
- 6 See also
- 7 Publications
- 8 Notes and references
- 9 External links
Andrew Roberts was born in London, England, the son of business executive Simon Roberts and Katie Roberts. Simon Roberts, from Cobham, Surrey, inherited the Job's Dairy milk business and also owned the United Kingdom contingent of Kentucky Fried Chicken restaurants. His parents would later sell their interest in the aforementioned milk business in 1987. A prolific reader as a child, he soon gained a passion for history, particularly for dramatic works relating to "battles, wars, assassinations and death".
Roberts attended Cranleigh School and did well in terms of his relationship to his teachers. However, as he later revealed, he also was "horrifically bullied" by other pupils, at one point being locked in a clothes cupboard and made to think that the building was on fire, and he sought relief partially through alcohol. Though he eventually achieved three As in his A-levels, Roberts ended up being forced to leave Cranleigh due to bouts of intoxication as well as carrying out pranks; he felt under considerable stress.
Nonetheless, Roberts managed to get into Gonville and Caius College, Cambridge, and he went on to chair the Cambridge University Conservative Association while expanding his studies of history. He earned a first class honours B.A. degree in Modern History at Gonville and Caius College in 1985, where he is an honorary senior scholar and honorary PhD. Roberts began his post-graduate career in corporate finance as an investment banker and private company director with the London merchant bank Robert Fleming & Co., where he worked from 1985 to 1988. He published his first historical book in 1991.
He is divorced from his first wife, with whom he had two children. Henry and Cassia Roberts went on to live in Edinburgh. Roberts is married to businesswoman Susan Gilchrist, CEO of the corporate communications firm Brunswick Group LLP and a Governor of the South Bank Centre. They currently live in London.
In his later life, Roberts has worked with think tank organisations such as the Centre for Policy Studies and the Centre for Social Cohesion. He serves as an honorary senior scholar at Gonville and Caius College, Cambridge, as referred to before. He additionally has maintained personal friendships with several British political and social figures such as David Cameron, Michael Gove and Oliver Letwin.
Historical and socio-political viewpoints
Commentary on history
Roberts' analysis of the Second World War has convinced him that the Nazi German government possessed significant advantages in terms of factors such as military organisation and economic power through the early era of the conflict. He has argued that, had some individual other than Adolf Hitler possessed control of the nation's military strategy, the country would likely have forgone a costly direct invasion of Soviet territory (which occurred through Operation Barbarossa) and instead pursued a policy of sweeping through Mediterranean territories before trying to seal off British-controlled Middle East areas. Thus, in Roberts' view, the likely morale-building victories against the comparatively weak forces to the southeast could have given Hitler an opportunity to essentially "win" the war.
In discussing the German declaration of war against the United States, an event happening a mere four days after the Pearl Harbor attacks to which the Nazi regime was under no treaty obligation to do so, Roberts also interprets the decision as a key mistake dooming the Germans as they simply could not keep the U.S. war-making economic machine at bay. In short, Roberts believes that the mistakes, delusions and exaggerated self-confidence complexes that the fascist dictatorship inherently fostered proved to be its undoing. Roberts has also stated that he views Joseph Stalin's control of the Soviet forces as having been disastrous to the allied efforts against the Axis powers, with the historian noting that Stalin's obsessive tactics involving killing his own men for ideological reasons cost him thousands upon thousands of troops. In the Battle of Stalingrad alone, Soviet forces killed the equivalent of two full divisions of their own personnel.
In terms of more recent history, Roberts flirted with an affiliation with Trotskyism as a student before whole-heartedly embracing Thatcherism. He has remained a staunch backer of Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher and her socio-political legacy. In Roberts' opinion, Thatcher's insight to push the U.K. into a path in which it kept out of the Euro while still having strong ties to European economies has been validated by the Eurozone crisis in the aftermath of the world economic recession. Besides his sceptical approach to the European Union as an institution, he also holds a dim opinion of the United Nations, believing that the strength of oppressive and autocratic regimes in the UN's sub-groups make it sluggish and corrupt.
Support for the Iraq War and the "Fourth World War"
Roberts supports a strong American military and has generally argued in favour of close relations between the Anglosphere nations. As an advocate for the general principle of democratic pluralism, he has argued generally that "[s]neered at for being 'simplistic' in his reaction to 9/11, Bush's visceral responses to the attacks of a fascistic, totalitarian death cult will be seen as having been substantially the right ones" in the long run. In many writings, he has come out in support of neo-conservative influenced socio-political viewpoints.
During the buildup to the Iraq War, Roberts supported the proposed invasion, arguing that anything less would be tantamount to appeasement, comparing Tony Blair to Winston Churchill in his "astonishing leadership". He additionally argued that acting against Saddam Hussein was in line with the "Pax Americana realpolitik that has kept the great powers at peace since the Second World War, despite the collapse of communism" in his eyes.
Roberts wrote in 2003 "For Churchill, apotheosis came in 1940; for Tony Blair, it will come when Iraq is successfully invaded and hundreds of weapons of mass destruction are unearthed from where they have been hidden by Saddam's henchmen." When such weapons were not found, Roberts still defended the invasion for larger strategic reasons while arguing that his past views were based on credible assessments from "the French, Chinese, Israeli and Russian intelligence agencies" as well as other sources.
He has defended the use of water-boarding by the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA), saying that "sometimes the defense of liberty requires making some pretty unpalatable decisions" and viewed the policies of torture-based tactics used by some of the allied forces during WWII as having promoted their eventual victory. Roberts believes that the Iraq War involved the English-speaking peoples om "an existential war for the survival of their way of life" and that the large-scale conflicts involving Islamic extremism had reached a point in which "this struggle against Islamofascism is the fourth world war", the Cold War being the 'third world war', while "the English-speaking peoples find themselves in the forefront of protecting civilization". He believes that history will judge American President George W. Bush a success, and he's also written in favor of current President Barack Obama's interventionist foreign policies.
Roberts later commented in 2009, on the human cost of the Iraq and Afghanistan wars, that Britain had "lost fewer soldiers than on a normal weekend on the Western Front". Writing for the Daily Mail, Roberts remarked, "The emasculation of British foreign policy after the Iraq War and during the ongoing Afghan War is an extraordinary phenomenon, considering how few Britons gave their lives in those places compared with other wars." He added, "the overthrow of the Taliban in 2001 and the victory over Saddam Hussein two years later were won at an incredibly low cost in historical terms".
Authorship and television appearances
The first of Roberts' books was the biography of Neville Chamberlain's and Winston Churchill's foreign secretary, Edward Wood, 1st Earl of Halifax, entitled The Holy Fox, and published in 1991. Roberts provided a revisionist account of Wood, a one-time Viceroy of India and the Foreign Secretary in Chamberlain's government. Halifax has been charged with appeasement, along with Chamberlain, but Roberts asserts that Halifax in fact began to move his government away from that policy vis-à-vis Hitler's Germany, following the 1938 Munich Crisis.
This work was followed by Eminent Churchillians, in 1994, a collection of essays about friends and enemies of Churchill. A large part of the book is an attack on Admiral of the Fleet Louis Mountbatten, 1st Earl Mountbatten of Burma and other prominent members of the elite. The title is an obvious allusion to the famous and similarly combative book of biographies Eminent Victorians.
In 1999, Roberts published Salisbury: Victorian Titan, a biography of the Victorian era politician and then Prime Minister Robert Cecil, 3rd Marquess of Salisbury. Historian Michael Korda praised the work as "a masterpiece about one of the greatest and most able Tory political figures of the Victorian age". The book additionally won the Wolfson History Prize and the James Stern Silver Pen Award for Non-Fiction. In September 2001, Napoleon and Wellington, an investigation into the relationship between the two generals, was published by Weidenfeld and Nicolson, and was the subject of the lead review in all but one of Britain's national newspapers.
January 2003 saw the publication of Hitler and Churchill: Secrets of Leadership. In the book, which addresses the leadership techniques of Hitler and Churchill, he delivered a rebuttal to many of the assertions made by Clive Ponting and Christopher Hitchens concerning Churchill.
An accompanying television series based around Roberts' Hitler and Churchill ran on BBC2, with its first episode being broadcast on 7 March 2013. Roberts remarked that he felt grateful for the BBC's support of his work and their unwillingness to cut corners when it came to exploring history in detail, quipping as well about the group's wardrobe policy, "Courtesy of this programme, I now have two Armani suits upstairs."
Also in 2003, he became a fellow of the Royal Society of Arts. In 2004, he edited What Might Have Been, a collection of twelve "What If?" essays written by historians and journalists, including Robert Cowley, Antonia Fraser, Norman Stone, Amanda Foreman, Simon Sebag Montefiore, Lord Black of Crossharbour and Anne Somerset. In 2005, Roberts published Waterloo: Napoleon's Last Gamble, which was published in America as Waterloo: The Battle for Modern Europe.
His A History of the English-Speaking Peoples Since 1900, a sequel to the four volume work of Churchill, was published in September 2006 and won the Intercollegiate Studies Institute Book Award. Masters and Commanders describes how four figures shaped the strategy of the West during the Second World War. It was published in November, 2008 and won the International Churchill Society Book Award and was shortlisted for two other military history book prizes. The Art of War is a two-volume chronological survey of the greatest military commanders in history. It was compiled by a team of historians, including Robin Lane Fox, Tom Holland, John Julius Norwich, Jonathan Sumption and Felipe Fernández-Armesto, working under the general editorship of Roberts.
The Storm of War: A New History of the Second World War came out in August 2009. A detailed look at the history of events behind the Second World War and various key elements within it such as the nature of Nazi Germany's rule, the book received large popular success. Being Roberts' best-known work to date, it reached number two in The Sunday Times bestseller list in particular. The book additionally earned the British Army Military Book of the Year award for 2010.
In terms of critical response, The Storm of War has also received a wide variety of praise in publications such as The Daily Beast, where historian Michael Korda lauded it as written "superbly well" and stated that Roberts' "scholarship is superb", and The Wall Street Journal, where historian Jonathan W. Jordan said that Roberts "splendidly weaves a human tragedy into a story". Support also came from figures such as American political commentator Peter Robinson and fellow English historian Paul Johnson. In the book, the author aims to paint a concise yet highly detailed picture of the conflict in which he argues that dictators Joseph Stalin and Adolf Hitler both took terrible actions due to their repressive ideologies, throwing thousands and thousands of lives away in the process, yet the eventual defeat of the Axis powers constituted a moral triumph of democratic pluralism over authoritarianism that led the way to a better future.
As of 2015, Roberts' most recent work is Napoleon the Great (the American edition is titled Napoleon: A Life), which was awarded the 2015 Los Angeles Times Book Prize for best biography. Published by Allen Lane, an imprint of Penguin Books UK, (and by Viking Press in the US) in 2014, the book attempts to give a fair-minded contemporary assessment of the life of Napoleon as well as his legacy for France and the rest of the western world. In this biography, Roberts seeks to evoke Napoleon's tremendous energy, both physical and intellectual, and the attractiveness of his personality, even to his enemies. The book argues against many long-held historical opinions, including the myth of a great romance with Joséphine. She took a lover immediately after their marriage, as Roberts shows, and Napoleon in fact had three times as many mistresses as he acknowledged. Roberts goes through fifty-three of Napoleon's sixty battlefields, and he additionally evaluates a gigantic new French edition of Napoleon's letters, aiming to create a complete re-evaluation of the man.
Like Storm of War, Roberts's life of Napoleon received critical praise from a wide range of publications. For example, journalist Jeremy Jennings wrote for Standpoint in October 2014 that "Napoleon could have had few biographers more dedicated to their subject." Jennings additionally labelled the book a "richly detailed and sure-footed reappraisal of the man, his achievements— and failures— and the extraordinary times in which he lived". The book earned the Prix du Jury des Grands Prix de la Fondation Napoléon for 2014, an award given by the historical organisation Fondation Napoléon.
Praise additionally came from fellow historian Jay Winik: ‘With his customary flair and keen historical eye, Andrew Roberts has delivered the goods again. This could well be the best single volume biography of Napoleon in English for the last four decades. A tour de force that belongs on every history-lover’s bookshelf!’  Historian Bernard Cornwell describes the book as 'Simply dynamite ... [Napoleon was] a mass of contradictions and Roberts's book encompasses all the evidence to give a brilliant portrait of the man. The book, as it needs to be, is massive, yet the pace is brisk and it's never overwhelmed by the scholarly research, which was plainly immense ... Roberts suggests looking at Europe for the Emperor's monument, but this magnificent biography is not a bad place to start.' 
In announcing in 2013 that it would present a three-part television series based on Roberts's analysis of Napoleon's life and legacy, BBC Two declared in its press release that "Roberts sets out to shed new light on the emperor... an extraordinary, gifted military commander and a mesmeric leader whose private life was littered with disappointments and betrayals." However, the series has had mixed reviews. The Daily Telegraph declared it "unconvincing", saying "there was no getting away from Roberts’s regular lapses into hero-worship," and "Roberts’s remarks on the refreshing qualities of dictatorship made me wonder if he had taken leave of his senses".
Journalism and lecturing
Roberts has appeared on US television during royal funerals and weddings. He first came to prominence in the USA due to acting as an expert on the funeral of Princess Diana, in 1997, and he was later in a similar role during the CNN broadcast of the death of the Queen Mother and on the wedding of Prince Charles and Camilla Parker Bowles. In Britain in 2003, he presented The Secrets of Leadership, a four-part history series on BBC 2 about the secrets of leadership which looked at the different leadership styles of Churchill, Hitler, John F. Kennedy and Martin Luther King. Roberts is a Director of the Harry Frank Guggenheim Foundation in New York, a founder member of José Maria Aznar’s Friends of Israel Initiative, and in 2010 chaired the Hessell-Tiltman Award for Non-Fiction.
Roberts is a judge on the Elizabeth Longford Historical Biography Prize. He chaired the Conservative Party's Advisory Panel on the Teaching of History in Schools in 2005, and is a Fellow of the Royal Society of Literature. He has also been elected a Fellow of the Napoleonic Institute and an Honorary Member of the International Churchill Society (UK). He is a Trustee of the Margaret Thatcher Archive Trust and of the Roberts Foundation.
During the autumn of 2013, Roberts served as the inaugural Merrill Family visiting professor in history at Cornell University. He taught a course entitled "Great European Leaders of the 19th and 20th Centuries and their Influence on History." He's additionally spoke in many other American universities such as the University of Montana.
Disputes and criticisms
Although Roberts's 2006 work A History of the English-Speaking Peoples since 1900 won critical acclaim from some sections of the media, The Economist drew attention to some historical, geographical and typographical errors, as well presenting a generally scathing review of the book. The news-magazine referred to the work as "a giant political pamphlet larded with its author's prejudices".
One claim made by Roberts in A History of the English-Speaking Peoples since 1900 was that Harvard historian Caroline Elkins had committed "blood libels against Britain" in her Pulitzer prize-winning book Imperial Reckoning: The Untold Story of Britain's Gulag in Kenya. Elkins was subsequently vindicated when files released by the National Archives showed that abuses were described as "distressingly reminiscent of conditions in Nazi Germany or Communist Russia" by the Solicitor General of the time. The Foreign Secretary William Hague subsequently announced compensation for the first round of victims with statements that the British government "recognises that Kenyans were subjected to torture and other forms of ill-treatment" and "sincerely regrets that these abuses took place" during the Kenya Emergency.
Controversial journalist Johann Hari alleged that Roberts' writings defended the Amritsar massacre, the concentration camps for Afrikaners during the Anglo-Boer War and mass internments in Ireland. Hari also wrote that Roberts addressed the expatriate South African Springbok Club that flies the pre-1994 South African national flag and calls for "the re-establishment of civilised rule throughout the African continent". Roberts responded by saying that he did not realise the Springbok Club was racist when he took on the speaking engagement.
- The Holy Fox: A Biography of Lord Halifax, London : Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 1991 ISBN 0-297-81133-9.
- Eminent Churchillians, London : Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 1994 ISBN 0-297-81247-5; Simon & Schuster, 1994, ISBN 978-0-671-76940-6
- The Aachen Memorandum, London : Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 1995 ISBN 0-297-81619-5.
- Salisbury: Victorian Titan, Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 1999, ISBN 978-0-297-81713-0
- The House of Windsor, Berkeley, Calif. : University of California Press, 2000, ISBN 0-520-22803-0.
- Napoleon and Wellington : The Battle of Waterloo—And the Great Commanders Who Fought It. New York: Simon & Schuster. 2001. ISBN 0-297-64607-9.
- Hitler and Churchill: Secrets of Leadership, Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 2003, ISBN 978-0-297-84330-6
- What Might Have Been, Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 2004, ISBN 978-0-297-84877-6
- Waterloo: June 18, 1815: The Battle for Modern Europe. New York: HarperCollins. 2005. ISBN 978-0-06-008866-8.
- A History of the English Speaking Peoples since 1900, Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 2006, ISBN 978-0-297-85076-2
- Masters and Commanders: How Roosevelt, Churchill, Marshall and Alanbrooke Won the War in the West (2008), Allen Lane, ISBN 978-0-7139-9969-3 (UK edition); Masters and Commanders: How Four Titans Won the War in the West, 1941–1945 (2009), Harper, ISBN 978-0-06-122857-5 (US edition).
- The Art of War: Great Commanders of the Ancient and Medieval World, Quercus, 2008, ISBN 978-1-84724-515-1
- The Art of War: Great Commanders of the Modern World Since 1600, Quercus, 2009, ISBN 978-1-84724-516-8
- The Storm of War: a New History of the Second World War. Allen Lane. 2009. ISBN 978-0-7139-9970-9.; HarperCollins, 2011, ISBN 978-0-06-122859-9
- Love, Tommy: Letters Home, from the Great War to the Present Day. Osprey Publishing. 2012. ISBN 1849087911.
- Napoleon: A Life. Viking Press. 2014. ISBN 9780670025329.
- Napoleon the Great. Allen Lane. 2015. ISBN 9781846140273.
- Virtual History (1997) One Essay
- What If? (1999) One Essay
- The Kings and Queens of England (2000) One Chapter
- The Railway King: A Biography of George Hudson (2001) Introduction
- Historian’s Holiday (2001) Introduction
- What If? Volume 2 (2001) One Essay
- Protestant Island (2001) Introduction
- Spirit of England (2001) Introduction
- The Secret History of P.W.E. (2002) Introduction
- Rich Dust (2002) Introduction
- A History of the English-Speaking Peoples (2002) Introduction
- Spirit of England (2002) Preface
- Historian's Holiday (2002) Preface
- What Ifs of American History? (2003) One Essay
- The Multicultural Experiment (2003) One Chapter
- British Military Greats (2004) One Chapter
- Lives for Sale (2004) One Chapter
- Hitler's Death: Russia's Last Great Secret from the Files of the KGB (2005) Foreword
- Liberty and Livelihood (2005) One Chapter
- The Eagle’s Last Triumph (2006) Introduction
- The Eagle's Last Triumph : Napoleon's Victory at Ligny, June 1815 (2006) Foreword
- Postcards from the Russian Revolution (2008) Introduction
- Postcards of Political Icons (2008) Introduction
- Postcards from Checkpoint Charlie (2008) Introduction
- A Week at Waterloo (2008) Introduction
- The Future of National Identity (2008) One Chapter
- Postcards from the Trenches (2008) Introduction
- Postcards from Utopia: The Art of Political Propaganda (2009) Introduction
- Postcards of Lost Royals (2009) Introduction
- Napoleon Bonaparte by Georges Lefevre (2010) Introduction
- Letters from Vicky: The Letters of Queen Victoria to Vicky, Empress of Germany 1858–1901 (2011) Introduction and Selection
- A History of the World in 100 Weapons (2011) Introduction
Notes and references
- Roberts, Andrew (13 May 2009). "How Torture Helped Win WWII". The Daily Beast. Retrieved 18 March 2015.
- Marre, Oliver (26 July 2009). "Andrew Roberts: The history man who loves to party". The Observer (London). Retrieved 17 March 2015.
- "Esteemed Military Historian to Lecture at UM". University of Montana – News. 2 October 2013. Retrieved 17 March 2015.
- "The Storm of War". Uncommon Knowledge on YouTube. 6 January 2012. Retrieved 17 March 2015.
- "ANDREW ROBERTS: Hideously amoral Little England has stepped through the looking glass". Daily Mail (As archived by the Wayback Machine). 31 August 2013. Retrieved 18 March 2015.
- Churchill, Hitler and me.
- Korda, Michael (16 May 2011). "'The Storm of War' by Andrew Roberts: Best History of World War II". The Daily Beast. Retrieved 17 March 2015.
- "The UN: Right or wrong?". London: The Guardian. 8 March 2003. Retrieved 17 March 2015.
- "Blast from the past". London: The Guardian. 19 February 2003. Retrieved 18 March 2015.
- Roberts, Andrew (14 January 2009). "History will show that George W Bush was right". London: The Daily Telegraph. Retrieved 18 March 2015.
- Jordan, Jonathan W. (2 July 2011). "Hell's Ethos". The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved 17 March 2015.
- Jennings, Jeremy (October 2014). "The Enlightenment on Horseback". Standpoint. Retrieved 17 March 2015.
- "Home – Andrew Roberts, British historian, British history writer, Masters and Commanders, A History of the English Speaking Peoples since 1900". Andrew Roberts, British historian, British history writer, Masters and Commanders, A History of the English Speaking Peoples since 1900.
- "Napoleon the Great: Amazon.co.uk: Andrew Roberts: 9781846140273: Books". amazon.co.uk.
- From Caligula to Napoleon, BBC Two announces new collection of history commissions
- Andrew Roberts web-site
- Andrew Roberts (26 August 2013). "HIST 1502 Great European Leaders of the 19th and 20th Centuries and their Influence on History" (PDF). Retrieved 2 October 2014.
- Daniels, Anthony (2 November 2006). "The case for the defence". The Spectator. Retrieved 16 April 2010.
- Massie, Allan (22 Oct 2006). "Happy is he who speaks English". The Daily Telegraph (London). Retrieved 16 April 2010.
- "Going out in the midday sun". The Economist. 2 November 2006.
- Andrew Roberts (16 December 2010). A History of the English-Speaking Peoples since 1900. Orion. p. 278. ISBN 978-0-297-86524-7.
One way that the Left in the West has attempted to undermine its legacy is to try to argue that was a 'moral equivalence' between Soviet communism and English-speaking capitalism. Thus in 2004 the University of California Press published a book by Mark Dow entitled American Gulag and subtitled Inside US Immigration Prisons, and in 2005 a book entitled Britain's Gulag was published about British detention camps in Kenya, written by a Harvard historian named Caroline Elkins, whose blood-libels against Britain won her the Pulitzer Prize.
- "British colonial 'cover up' in Mau Mau camp revealed in new secret document release". The Daily Telegraph. 30 November 2012. Retrieved 2015-06-06.
Serious concerns about the clampdown were raised as far back as 1953, the second year of the uprising, when the then Solicitor General described reported abuses as distressingly reminiscent of conditions in Nazi Germany or Communist Russia, according to one of the secret documents.
- "Mau Mau torture victims to receive compensation – Hague". BBC News. 6 June 2013. Retrieved 2015-06-03.
- "UK to compensate Kenya's Mau Mau torture victims". The Guardian. 6 June 2013. Retrieved 2015-06-03.
- Hari, Johann (31 July 2009). "The dark side of Andrew Roberts". The Independent (London).
- Official website
- Web page at Capel & Land
- Andrew Roberts at the Internet Movie Database
- Works by or about Andrew Roberts in libraries (WorldCat catalog)
- BBC Article by Roberts about Hitler and Churchill
- Andrew Roberts is the social historian (Evening Standard)
- Appearances on C-SPAN