Apex (radio band)
Apex radio stations (also known as skyscraper and pinnacle) was the name commonly given to a short-lived group of United States broadcasting stations, which were used to evaluate transmitting on frequencies that were much higher than the ones used by standard amplitude modulation (AM) and shortwave stations. Their name came from the tall height of their transmitter antennas, which were needed because coverage was primarily limited to local line-of-site distances. These stations were assigned to what at the time were described as "ultra-high" frequencies, between roughly 25 and 44 MHz. They employed AM transmissions, although in most cases using a wider bandwidth than standard broadcast band AM stations, in order to provide high fidelity sound with less static and distortion.
In 1937 the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) formally allocated an Apex station band, consisting of 75 transmitting frequencies running from 41.02 to 43.98 MHz. These stations were never given permission to operate commercially, although they were allowed to retransmit the programming from standard AM stations. Most operated under experimental licenses, however this band was the first to include a formal "non-commercial educational" station classification. The FCC eventually decided there was no need for a second AM broadcast band, so the Apex station assignments were eliminated effective January 1, 1941. With this change, a few of the original Apex stations were converted into some of the earliest FM stations.
Through the 1920s and 1930s, radio engineers and government regulators were slowly determining the transmission characteristics of various frequencies being evaluated for use by radio stations. In the United States, by 1930 the original AM broadcasting band consisted of 96 frequencies from 550 to 1500 kHz, with a 10 kHz spacing between adjacent assignments. On this band, a station's coverage during the daytime consisted exclusively of its groundwave signal, which for the most powerful stations might exceed 200 miles (320 kilometers), although it was significantly less for the average station. However, during the nighttime, changes in the ionosphere resulted in additional long distance skywave signals, that were commonly reflected for up to hundreds of kilometers.
Over time, the technology was developed to transmit on progressively higher frequencies. (Although initially these were in general called "ultra-high" frequencies, radio spectrum nomenclature was later standardized, with 3 to 30 MHz transmissions becoming known as "High Frequency" (HF), 30 to 300 MHz called "Very High Frequency" (VHF), and 300 to 3,000 MHz called "Ultra High Frequency" (UHF)). It soon became apparent that there were significant differences in the propagation characteristics of various frequency ranges. Signals from shortwave stations, operating roughly in the range from 5 MHz to 20 MHz, were found to be readily reflected by the ionosphere during both the day and at night, resulting in stations that sometimes could transmit halfway around the world.
Investigation of ever higher frequencies found that, above around 20 MHz, signal propagation by both groundwave and skywave generally became minimal, which meant that station coverage now began to be limited to just line-of-sight distances from the transmitting antenna. This was considered to be a valuable characteristic by the FCC, because it would allow the establishment of broadcasting stations with limited but consistent day and night coverage, that could only be received by their local communities. It also meant that multiple stations could operate on the same frequency throughout the country without interfering with each other.
Because the standard AM broadcast band was considered to be too full to allow any meaningful increase in the number of stations, the FCC began to issue licenses to parties interested in testing the suitability of higher frequencies. Most Apex stations operated under experimental licenses, and were commonly affiliated with and subsidized by a commercially licensed AM station. Until the late 1930s, commercially made radio receivers did not cover these high frequencies, so early Apex station listeners constructed their own receivers, or built converters for existing models.
On March 18, 1934, W8XH in Buffalo, New York, a companion station to AM station WBEN, became the first Apex station to air a regular schedule. Although most of these stations merely retransmitted the programs of their AM station partners, in a few cases efforts were made to provide original programming. In 1936, The Milwaukee Journal's W9XAZ, which initially had relayed the programming of WTMJ, became the first Apex station to originate its own programming on a regular basis.
While monitoring the first group of stations, it was soon realized that, due to the strengthening of the ionosphere during periods of high solar activity, at times the lower end of the VHF frequencies would produce strong, and undesirable, skywave signals. (The December 1937 issue of All-Wave Radio reported that W6XKG in Los Angeles, transmitting on 25.95 MHz, had been heard in both Asia and Europe, while W9XAZ, 26.4 MHz in Milwaukee, Wisconsin had "a strong signal in Australia", and W8XAI, 31.6 MHz in Rochester, New York, "is another station that is often heard in Australia.") This most commonly occurred during the summer months, and during peaks in the 11-year sunspot cycle. This determination led to the FCC moving the developing broadcasting service stations, which by now began to include experimental FM and TV stations, to higher frequencies that were less affected by solar influences.
Apex band establishment (1937)
In October 1937, the FCC announced a sweeping allocation of frequency assignments for the various competing services, including television, relay, and public service, which covered 10 kHz to 300 MHz. Included was a band of Apex stations, consisting of 75 channels with 40 kHz separations, and spanning from 41.02 to 43.98 MHz. The 40 kHz spacing between adjacent frequencies was four times as much as the 10 kHz spacing on the standard AM broadcast band, which reduced adjacent-frequency interference, and provided more bandwidth for high-fidelity programming.
At the time it was estimated that there were about 50 Apex-style stations currently in operation, although transmitting on a variety of frequencies. In January 1938 the band's first 25 channels, from 41.02 to 41.98 MHz, were reserved for non-commercial educational stations, with the Cleveland City Board of Education's WBOE in Cleveland, Ohio the first station to begin operation within this group.
Apex band assignments (1937-1941)
|Frequency||Station assignments||Frequency||Station assignments|
|41.02 MHz||42.54 MHz|
|41.06 MHz||42.58 MHz|
|41.10 MHz||WCNY/WNYE Brooklyn, New York - N. Y. Board of Education (1939-1940)||42.62 MHz|
|41.14 MHz||42.66 MHz|
|41.18 MHz||42.70 MHz|
|41.22 MHz||42.74 MHz|
|41.26 MHz||42.78 MHz|
|41.30 MHz||42.82 MHz|
|41.34 MHz||42.86 MHz|
|41.38 MHz||42.90 MHz||WBKY Beattyville, Kentucky - University of Kentucky (1940-1941)|
|41.42 MHz||42.94 MHz|
|41.46 MHz||42.98 MHz|
|41.50 MHz||WBOE Cleveland, Ohio - Cleveland City Board of Education (1938-1941)||43.02 MHz|
|41.54 MHz||43.06 MHz|
|41.58 MHz||43.10 MHz|
|41.62 MHz||43.14 MHz|
|41.66 MHz||43.18 MHz|
|41.70 MHz||43.22 MHz|
|41.74 MHz||43.26 MHz|
|41.78 MHz||43.30 MHz|
|41.82 MHz||43.34 MHz|
|41.86 MHz||43.38 MHz|
|41.90 MHz||43.42 MHz|
|41.94 MHz||43.46 MHz|
|41.98 MHz||43.50 MHz|
|42.02 MHz||43.54 MHz|
|42.06 MHz||W8XWJ Detroit, Michigan - Evening News Association (WWJ)||43.58 MHz|
|42.10 MHz||43.62 MHz|
|42.14 MHz||W3XIR Philadelphia, Pennsylvania - WCAU Broadcasting Co. (WCAU) (February 1938 - 1941)||43.66 MHz|
|42.18 MHz||W2XWF New York, New York - William G. H. Finch (1940)||43.70 MHz|
|42.22 MHz||W1XKA Boston, Massachusetts - Westinghouse E. & M. Co. (WBZ) (1940)||43.74 MHz|
|42.26 MHz||W9XAZ Milwaukee, Wisconsin - The Journal Co. (WTMJ)||43.78 MHz|
|42.30 MHz||W6XDA Los Angeles, California - Columbia Broadcasting System (KNX) (1940)
W6XRE Los Angeles, California - Ben S. McGlashan (KGFJ) (1940)
W9XHW Minneapolis, Minnesota - Columbia Broadcasting System (WCCO) (1940)
W1XEQ New Bedford, Massachusetts - E. Anthony & Sons (WNBH) (1940)
W2XDV New York, New York - Columbia Broadcasting System (WABC) (1940)
|42.34 MHz||W1XER Mount Washington, New Hampshire - Yankee Network (1940)
W8XNT Cleveland, Ohio - United Broadcasting Co. (WHK) (1940)
|42.38 MHz||W1XKB Springfield, Massachusetts - Westinghouse E. & M. Co. (WBZA) (1940)||43.92 MHz|
|42.42 MHz||43.96 MHz|
|42.46 MHz||W1XEH Hartford, Connecticut - Travelers Broadcasting Service Corp. (WTIC) (1940)
W9XER Kansas City, Missouri - Midland Broadcasting Co. (KMBC) (1940)
Conversion to FM (1941)
At the time the Apex band was established, the FCC noted that "The Commission at an early date will consider carefully the needs and requirements for high-frequency broadcast stations using both conventional [AM] modulation and frequency modulation". As of January 15, 1940, only 2 non-commercial and 14 experimental stations held Apex band licenses, all of which were assigned operating frequencies in the bottom half of the band. (A similar number of experimental stations held grants for frequencies in the 25-26 MHz region.) In addition, at this same time 20 experimental FM stations had been assigned slots within the top half of the Apex band frequencies.
The commission's studies soon found significant advantages to FM transmissions over the Apex AM signals. Sound quality, and especially resistance to interference from static, including from lightning, was found to be far superior for FM. Although FM assignments required five times the bandwidth of Apex stations (200 kHz vs. 40 kHz), the "capture effect" allowed FM stations operating on the same frequency to be spaced closer together than Apex stations. By 1939 the FCC began encouraging Apex stations to consider changing to the technically superior FM transmissions. In 1940, the FCC decided to authorize a commercial FM band effective January 1, 1941, operating on 40 channels spanning 42–50 MHz (this was later changed to 88–106 MHz, and still later to 88–108 MHz.)
This new assignment also resulted in the elimination of the Apex band, and the Apex stations were informed that they needed to either go silent or convert to FM. The last of the Apex stations to leave the air were WBOE, which shut down its Apex operation in February 1941 and converted to FM that month, and WBKY, which suspended operations after June 27, 1941 due to financial reasons. Currently, the frequencies that had been used by the Apex band are allocated for land mobile communication.
There would be at least one attempt to revive the Apex band concept. Beginning in May 1946, consulting radio engineer Sarkes Tarzian operated a 200-watt experimental AM station, W9XHZ, on 87.75 MHz in Bloomington, Indiana. After two years of successful operation of what he referred to as his "HIFAM" station, in 1948 he proposed that the FCC allocate a small high-frequency broadcast band, 400 kHz wide with 10 kHz spacing between frequency assignments. Tarzian promoted this as a low-cost alternative to expensive FM transmitters and receivers, saying that a $5.95 converter could be added to existing AM radios that would allow them to pick up the HIFAM stations. He continued to operate his experimental station, which eventually became KS2XAP, until 1950, although by then its transmitting hours were greatly restricted, as the FCC required the station to remain off the air whenever nearby WFBM-TV in Indianapolis was broadcasting. This was due to the fact that the TV station's audio transmitter used the same frequency as Tarzian's station. Moreover, after his station's final license expired on June 1, 1950 the FCC denied Tarzian any further renewals, concluding it would not reverse its earlier determination that there was no need for a second AM broadcast band.
- "Why Do Radio Signals Travel Farther at Night than in the Day?" by Dan Elder, January 27, 2015. (todayifoundout.com)
- Allocation of Radio Spectrum in the United States" (jneuhaus.com)
- "The VHF/UHF Line of Sight Horizon" (em.hawaii.edu)
- "Pioneering" (WBEN advertisement), Broadcasting, April 1, 1936, page 29. W8XH is a direct predecessor of current Buffalo FM station WTSS.
- "Apex Station On Its Own", Broadcasting, Jan. 1, 1937. "Milwaukee Station Using Apex Band Tells of Results", Broadcasting, May 15, 1937. W9XAZ eventually became WTMJ-FM, which was deleted in 1950. Nine years later a new WTMJ-FM was licensed; it is the current day WKTI-FM at 94.5 MHz.
- "Ultra-High: When to Listen - What to Listen For" by Perry Ferrell, Jr., All-Wave Radio, December 1937, page 628.
- "Upper Bands Set Aside for Television", Broadcasting, November 1, 1937, pages 60-61.
- "Listening to Learn", Radio Guide, November 26, 1938, page 14.
- "Educational Radio's First Rural Radio Station" Public Telecommunication Review, September-October 1979. (jeff560.tripod.com) Other accounts state that WBKY remained operational as an Apex station until 1944. An article on page 12 of the April 5, 1944 Lexington (Kentucky) Leader, "University Will Establish Founders'-Day Observance", reported that "The [University of Kentucky] board also approved a recommendation by Elmer G. Sultzer, director of the school's public relations and radio department, that the school's educational radio station WBKY, at Beattyville, be dismantled and moved to Lexington. The board authorized the school authorities to move this station to Lexington, retaining the same frequency, but increasing the power from 100 to 500 watts, and changing the emission from amplitude modulation to frequency modulation..."
- "Globetrotting Via Shortwave" (PDF). Radio Index (118): 9. April 1, 1938. Retrieved 2017-01-11.
- New York Radio Guide: WFAN-FM (nyradioguide.com)
- "Early Experiments at WTMJ" (October 1, 2001) (warci.org)
- "Non-Commercial Educational Broadcast Stations", Broadcasting Yearbook (1940), page 387. The two stations were WBOE in Cleveland, Ohio and WNYE in Brooklyn, New York. WBKY in Beattyville, Kentucky would become the third non-commercial educational station later in the year.
- "High Frequency Broadcasting Stations in the United States", Broadcasting Yearbook (1940), page 374.
- "Education by FM", Broadcasting, February 10, 1941, page 49.
- "FCC Online Table of Frequency Allocations" (fcc.gov)
- "HiFam Radio Bans Static with Gadget" (AP), Williamsport (Pennsylvania) Sun-Gazette, June 27, 1947, page 9. "HIFAM" was a contraction of "high frequency amplitude modulation".
- "HIFAM" by Larry Christopher, Broadcasting/Telecasting, May 3, 1948, pages 22, 72.
- "HIFAM Renewal", Broadcasting/Telecasting, April 4, 1950, page 13.
- "HIFAM Renewal", Broadcasting/Telecasting, June 5, 1950, page 46.
- America's Apex Broadcasting Stations of the 1930's by John Schneider, Monitoring Times Magazine, December, 2010. (theradiohistorian.org)
- A Detroit Apex Station in 1936 by John Schneider, September 17, 2013. (radioworld.com)
- Pre-History: Detroit's Experimental Amplitude Modulation (AM) "Apex" Station, W8XWJ (michiguide.com)
- Apex Radio in Milwaukee (jeff560.tripod.com)
- Apex and FM chronology (jeff560.tripod.com)
- Apex broadcast stations in the U.S. in 1939 (jeff560.tripod.com)
- U.S. High Frequency Stations as of 1940 (jeff560.tripod.com)
- High Frequency and FM broadcast stations in the U.S. in 1942 (jeff560.tripod.com)
- "Sarkes Tarzian and His HiFAM Experiment" by Andrew Mitz, Radio Age, July 2004.