Divine fallacy

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

The divine fallacy, also known as argument from incredulity or personal incredulity,[1] is the logical fallacy that, because something is so incredible/amazing/ununderstandable/unimaginable it is wrong. It is a type of informal fallacy called a non sequitur.[2] It often happens when people say something must be the result of superior, divine, alien or supernatural cause because it is unimaginable for it not to be so.[3]

Arguments from incredulity can take the form:

  1. I cannot imagine how P could possibly be true; therefore P must be false.
  2. I cannot imagine how P could possibly be false; therefore P must be true.[4]