At-large bid

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

An at-large bid is a bid or berth in a sporting tournament granted by invitation, not right. This term is most commonly used in the United States to refer to berths that the NCAA grants in its annual Division I men's and women's basketball tournaments, although at-large berths are granted in almost all championship tournaments the NCAA conducts. At-large bids are functionally the same as wild cards in other leagues.

The NIT, held for the best teams that didn't make the NCAA Tournament, was at one time an entirely at-large event (hence its name, the National Invitation Tournament); new regulations, however, offer automatic bids to teams regular season conference champions which failed to win their post-season conference tournament. The College Basketball Invitational and Postseason Tournament both seed their entire tournaments with at-large bids.

This article focuses mainly on the most common use of the term, in reference to the basketball tournaments. However, a similar procedure applies in most other NCAA-sponsored tournaments, and in other tournaments that use an NCAA-style system.

Each year, the NCAA grants automatic berths in both the men's and women's Division I basketball tournaments to the winners of 32 conferences. In all cases, the conference's automatic berth is granted to the team that wins its conference postseason tournament, including the Ivy League, which conducted its first men's and women's postseason tournaments in 2017.

The NCAA has established Selection Committees for both the men's and women's tournaments. Teams that did not win their conference tournament may be eligible to earn an at-large berth. At-large berths are determined by record, ranking, strength of schedule, and many other factors. A key factor in determining at-large berths is the Ratings Percentage Index, popularly referred to as the RPI.

The fields of 68 teams that participate in the men's tournament, and 64 for the women's tournament, are filled as follows:

  • 32 automatic berths
    • 32 conference tournament champions
    • Starting in the 2016-17 season, the top four teams in the Ivy League that finish with the best record compete in a four-team conference tournament to which the winner will represent the Ivy League in the men's tournament.
  • At-large berths
    • 36 in the men's tournament
    • 32 in the women's tournament

After all automatic berths are filled, the teams that did not win their conference tournaments are studied to see if they can make the tournament anyway. Once conference tournaments are complete, the Selection Committee need not consider conference affiliations in determining at-large berths, making it free to select as many teams from one conference as it deems correct. Most mid-major conferences or smaller conferences will receive no at-large berths, and only the winner of the conference tournament will advance to the NCAA Tournament, making for some heartbreaking moments in the tournaments of smaller conferences.

The conference tournaments of major conferences are generally less important, as most losers will make the "Big Dance" via an at-large bid, but often lesser big conference teams will sneak in using the conference tournament, stealing a bid from a deserving mid-major team in the long run.

At-large berths are not necessarily lesser teams than automatic berths. They simply did not play well enough at the time of their conference tournaments. Often, at-large berths will get higher seeds than the teams that beat them in the conference tourney, because the Selection Committee judges base their judgment on the entire season.

Division I independents do not play a conference tournament and therefore do not have an automatic berth, and can only receive an at-large bid to the tournament, which rarely happens in today's game. Sometimes, a team that is otherwise deserving of a bid may be ineligible for the tournament due to an NCAA post-season ban, applied only as a punishment for egregious violations of NCAA rules in that school's program in that sport.

With a 68-team field (64 for women), and 32 automatic berths, the Selection Committee must pick the 36 (men's) or 32 (women's) most deserving teams that are left, which ends up being a long difficult process, which culminates in one of the most intense days in U.S. sports, Selection Sunday. Selection Sunday is a televised event where the brackets are revealed. There are almost always interesting arguments about who should be in and who should be out because there are often more than 34 teams that could be considered deserving of a bid. Many final teams that make it, and final teams that are cut are often thought of as interchangeable. This ends up resulting, sometimes, in major surprises of who makes the tournament as at-large teams. At-large teams often will win the tournament which included the last three NCAA Men's Basketball Champions (Connecticut in 2014, Duke in 2015, Villanova in 2016 and North Carolina in 2017).

The conferences that are known for many at-large bids are generally the so-called "Power Five" conferences that receive automatic places in the bowl games associated with the College Football Playoff—the ACC, Big Ten, Big 12, Pac-12, and SEC.

Other conferences that receive multiple at-large bids on a regular basis are the Atlantic 10, the Missouri Valley, Mountain West, and the two offshoots of the original Big East Conference, the current Big East and The American. In recent years, the Horizon League, Mid-American Conference and West Coast Conference have also received more than just the automatic berth several times.

Certain conferences have never, and probably will not in the near future, get an at-large bid, simply because no team in the conference can ever be one of the best 68 teams in the country, and even if one does, two at the same time would be virtually unheard of. Therefore, it is also often argued that these very small conferences do not even deserve their one automatic bid and it should be given to a more deserving large conference team. Most argue that this would take away from the point of the 68-team large tournament style, that always gives the underdog the chance for an upset. These conferences include the Big Sky Conference and the Southwestern Athletic Conference. One of these conferences recently made an argument for their best team to make the tournament, even though it lost in the conference tourney. Oral Roberts of the Mid-Continent Conference blew through their conference in the regular season but lost in the conference tournament, ending with a conference record of 17-1. They did not make the tournament, and Oakland University won the bid. Utah State and Holy Cross also had arguments like this recently. A new way to solve the problem is to attempt to switch to a more prominent conference, a phenomenon that was especially prevalent in 2005 and the early 2010s. Many teams made significant moves in that period, with some making multiple moves. A few of the more notable moves were:

  • Butler (Horizon League to A10 in 2012, then to the new Big East in 2013)
  • Louisville (C-USA to Big East in 2005, spent one season in The American after the 2013 Big East split, then to the ACC in 2014)
  • TCU (C-USA to MW in 2005, then to the Big 12 in 2012)
  • UCF (Atlantic Sun Conference to C-USA in 2005, then to The American in 2013)
  • Utah (MW to Pac-12 in 2011)

Arguments such as this continue and there will always be much controversy surrounding at-large bids.

The College Football Playoff consists entirely of at-large bids; with only four teams and five conferences competing for bids, it would be impossible to fairly grant automatic bids as other sports do into a tournament that small. (Although ten conferences compete at the Bowl Subdivision level, the CFP selection committee has categorically rejected all bids from outside the Power Five; this was particularly evident in 2017, when the only undefeated team in the subdivision, Central Florida, was denied entry into the CFP in favor of four teams that had all lost one game. Central Florida would go on to win its bowl game against Auburn, the same team that had given the two teams in the 2018 College Football Playoff National Championship Game their losses.)