Attempted purchase of Time Warner Cable by Comcast
On February 13, 2014, Comcast Corporation announced its intent to acquire Time Warner Cable. The deal was proposed to take the form of a stock swap, estimated at the time of announcement to be worth about $45.2 billion. The two companies argued that the merger would increase their overall scale, allowing the company to become more competitive, improve customer service quality, and quicken innovation. The companies also argued that the deal would increase competition in the United States' cable television and internet markets, as they planned to divest subscribers to Charter Communications to regulate the market share of their combined operation.
The deal was supported primarily by Comcast, along with groups that were affiliated with Comcast or received financial support from Comcast or the National Cable & Telecommunications Association. It was also found that some letters in support of the merger were ghostwritten by Comcast representatives. The merger was widely opposed by various individuals, groups, and corporations, arguing that it would reduce competition through consolidation of the cable industry, lead to higher costs of service, and give Comcast greater leverage in how it distributes content owned by its NBCUniversal division to competitors, such as over-the-top services.
Citing the reduction of competition in the broadband and cable industries that would result from the merger, the Department of Justice planned to file an antitrust lawsuit against Comcast and Time Warner Cable in an effort to block it. On April 24, 2015, Comcast announced that it would withdraw its proposal to acquire TWC. Afterward, TWC would enter into an agreement to be acquired by Charter Communications.
- 1 Overview
- 2 Details by topic
- 3 Regulatory review
- 4 Positions on the merger
- 5 Abandonment, aftermath
- 6 See also
- 7 References
- 8 External links
On November 22, 2013, it was widely reported that Comcast was seeking advice on a possible bid for Time Warner Cable. Charter Communications was also thinking of making an offer. Charter made a total of three attempts to buy Time Warner, offering $37.4 billion on January 13, 2014. Comcast's $45.2 billion offer effectively won Comcast the bidding war, though Charter continued to challenge the acquisition by forecasting difficulties with the regulatory review process. By April 27, however, Charter had backed off its opposition to the deal after reaching a deal to acquire a portion of Time Warner Cable's subscribers as part of it.
Under the deal, Comcast would acquire Time Warner Cable by exchanging each of Time Warner Cable's current 284.9 million shares for 2.875 shares of Comcast's CMCSA stock. In addition, Comcast would divest 1.4 million Time Warner Cable subscribers to Charter Communications for about $7.3 billion, and divest 2.5 million subscribers to a new public company which would be owned 66% by Comcast shareholders, and 33% by Charter, which would manage its network and customers. Finally, Comcast and Charter would swap about 1.6 million subscribers with each other. The proposed merger was approved by Comcast shareholders on October 8, 2014 and Time Warner shareholders the next day.
Comcast touted that the merger would create a "world class media and technology company"; Comcast CEO Brian L. Roberts explained that the companies would be able to innovate quicker, and remain competitive with newer entrants into the industry, such as Verizon and Google Fiber. Similarly, TWC CEO Robert D. Marcus stated that the merger would "[create] a company that delivers maximum value for our shareholders, enormous opportunities for our employees and a superior experience for our customers."
Details by topic
Comcast and Time Warner Cable did not directly compete for customers; there was no physical overlap in the respective service areas where they offer services. More generally, there is almost no physical overlap in the service areas of any of the US cable providers. Unlike countries where local-loop unbundling allows multiple companies to offer competing service over the same physical lines, current policy in the United States allows incumbent companies to maintain exclusive use of the telecommunications infrastructure that they own.
In advocating for their 2011 purchase of NBC Universal, Comcast did identify Time Warner Cable as a competitor and cited the nature of their competition as an argument for regulatory approval of that purchase.
At the end of 2013, Comcast and Time Warner Cable had about 20.7 million and 11.1 million internet subscribers, respectively. Together, the two companies would have controlled about two-thirds of the broadband cable market, or about 40% of the U.S. wired broadband market as a whole. Comcast noted that the combined companies' share of all U.S. broadband internet, both wired and wireless was 21.5%. However, because wireless internet is generally slower, more expensive, and has much lower data caps, the wireless comparison remains controversial.
In 2010, Comcast won a lawsuit with the FCC which struck down the agency's net neutrality rules on jurisdictional grounds. As a condition of its acquisition of NBC Universal in 2011, Comcast agreed to abide by the same Open Internet rules that it argued be struck down. Because these rules would be extended to Time Warner Cable customers in the event of a merger, Comcast argued the acquisition would be a benefit for consumers. On the other hand, critics noted that the provision expires in January 2018, and questioned Comcast's record of abiding by legal mandates.
As of March 31, 2014, Comcast and Time Warner Cable had 22.6 million and 11.2 million video subscribers, respectively. Together, the two companies served about 33% of paid TV customers in the US.
After the announcement of the merger, Comcast considered selling off about 3 million subscribers. This divestiture would bring Comcast's share of US TV subscribers below just below 30%, a threshold that was formerly used by the FCC as a strict limit on the TV market share for one company, before Comcast successfully sued to have the rule overturned by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit in August 2009. Comcast reached a deal with Charter Communications in April 2014 to sell Charter both 1.4 million customers and a 33% stake in a company of an additional 2.5 million subscribers.
Time Warner Cable has few media properties, most of which are local news channels such as NY1, and regional sports networks such as Time Warner Cable SportsNet and SportsNet LA. Comcast owns several similar services through NBCUniversal, including New England Cable News and Comcast SportsNet, which serve different markets from TWC's news and sports channels. Both companies also own minority stakes in SportsNet New York and MLB Network.
Time Warner Cable should not be confused with Time Warner Inc., which owns several other national cable channels such as HBO and CNN and other properties which compete with Comcast's NBCUniversal division, but which spun off Time Warner Cable as a completely separate company in 2009.
After initially scheduling the hearing for March 25, the Senate Judiciary Committee hearing on the deal was held on April 9, 2014. The House Judiciary Committee also held a hearing concerning the acquisition on May 8, 2014. The congressional hearings have no direct effect on the outcome of the review process.
Federal Communications Commission
The FCC's review of the acquisition began on April 8, 2014, when Comcast filed their public interest statement. The FCC review was headed by chairman of the FCC and former cable industry lobbyist Tom Wheeler. Wheeler's appointment in May 2013 was widely praised by the cable industry. Some raised concerns about Wheeler's previous work as the head of the main U.S. cable lobby, the National Cable & Telecommunications Association. Comcast donated $110,000, and Time Warner paid $22,000 for a fundraiser benefitting Mignon Clyburn, an FCC officer.
The FCC timed its review of the merger with a 180-day "shot clock", a non-binding estimate of how long it would take to come to a decision regarding the merger. The clock began on July 10, 2014, when the FCC set a deadline for comments on the merger. From October 3, 2014 to October 29, 2014, the FCC paused the clock at day 85, waiting for Comcast to submit additional information regarding their business practices. From December 22, 2014 to January 12, 2015, the FCC paused the clock at day 105, to give it time to review documents which Time Warner Cable had submitted late. On March 13, 2015 the FCC paused the clock again, waiting for court decisions regarding the public disclosure of information about companies' retransmission consent contracts.
Department of Justice
The Antitrust Division of the U.S. Department of Justice officially announced that it would be reviewing the merger on March 6, 2014. Concurrent with the announcement, the current head of the antitrust at the DOJ, Bill Baer, recused himself from the review. Baer previously represented General Electric during their sale of NBCUniversal to Comcast. With Baer recused, the DOJ review was led by Principal Deputy Assistant Attorney General Renata B. Hesse and Deputy Assistant Attorney General David Gelfand. A group of about 25 states, through their state attorneys general, are conducting their own probes, either individually or through a multistate review group.
The DOJ commonly uses the Herfindahl index (HHI) to measure market concentration, designating markets between 1,500 points and 2,500 points as "moderately concentrated" and those above 2,500 points as "highly concentrated". By some rough estimates, the merger would have increased the HHI of the US television industry from 1,815 to 2,454, or an increase in 639 points. The merger would have increased the national wired broadband HHI from roughly 1,455 to 2,130. However, the DOJ traditionally considers the effects of transactions on concentration in individual markets, in which Comcast and Time Warner do not compete, and ignores transactions' effects on the national market as a whole.
Positions on the merger
Comcast and its affiliates were among the strongest supporters of the deal. Comcast vice-president David Cohen stated that the deal was "all about increasing competition and creating more consumer benefit as a result of gaining additional scale." Carl Guardino, CEO of Silicon Valley Leadership Group, which represents Comcast among other companies, said that "there seems to be nothing but upside in this deal".
A coalition of libertarian groups, including Americans for Tax Reform, supported the merger in a letter calling on the FCC and DOJ to "allow the free market to function...without interference". Many of the groups which publicly supported the merger received political or charitable donations from Comcast or the National Cable & Telecommunications Association, leading some to doubt the impartiality of the statements of support. An investigation by The Verge found that some letters of support from state and local level officials were originally written by Comcast employees and forwarded to the FCC with only superficial changes.
The merger of Comcast and Time Warner Cable was widely opposed due to concerns over its impact on the overall market. It was argued that the sheer size of the combined company would reduce competition, would give Comcast an unprecedented level of control over the United States' internet and television industries. It was also argued that the merger would give Comcast increased leverage in the distribution of NBCUniversal content, hamper over-the-top services such as Netflix, and lead to higher prices for its services.
Prominent critics of the deal included technology expert Susan P. Crawford, U.S. senator Al Franken of Minnesota, the city of Lexington, Kentucky, the city of Worcester, Massachusetts, and U.S. representative John Conyers of Michigan. Some companies within the industry expressed opposition to the merger, including DirecTV, Netflix, and Cogent Communications. Prior to reaching a deal to acquire some subscribers of the merged company, Charter Communications also opposed the merger.
Public opinion on the merger was generally negative. A March 2014 Reuters/Ipsos poll found that 52% of Americans believed the deal was bad for consumers, while 22% thought it would be beneficial. An April 2014 poll conducted by Consumer Reports found that the merger was opposed by 56% of the public and supported by 11%, with 32% having no opinion, with 74% of respondents agreeing that a merger "will result in higher Internet and cable prices for everyone." Comcast vice president David Cohen has pointed to faults in the company's customer service as the reason behind much of the opposition from the general public, arguing such concerns are not relevant to the government's review of the deal.
A coalition of 56 consumer-advocacy and public interest groups expressed opposition to the merger, including both the Writers Guild of America, East and Writers Guild of America, West, the Media Alliance, Public Knowledge, and the Parents Television Council. Outside of this group, Consumer Watchdog also opposed the merger.
In April 2015, it was reported that the U.S. Department of Justice was preparing to file an antitrust lawsuit against Comcast and Time Warner in a bid to halt the merger, arguing that the merger would reduce the level of competition in the cable television and broadband internet industries. On April 24, 2015, Comcast officially announced that it had called off the merger.
Following the abandonment of the deal, it was reported that a TWC financial advisor had been in talks with representatives from Cox Communications regarding a merger; however, a Cox representative denied that they were exploring a sale, and that the company would "continue to explore any potential growth opportunities that align with our business objectives." On May 26, 2015, Charter Communications announced a $78.7 billion deal to acquire TWC, along with a $10.1 billion deal to acquire Bright House Networks.
- Rupert Neate, Dominic Rushe (13 Feb 2014). "Comcast announces $45.2bn takeover of Time Warner Cable". The Guardian. Retrieved 14 Apr 2014.
- Javier E. David (22 Nov 2013). "Comcast seeks advice on possible Time Warner Cable bid: Sources". CNBC. Retrieved 14 Apr 2014.
- Jacob Kastrenakes (13 Jan 2014). "Charter makes $37.4 billion offer to purchase Time Warner Cable". The Verge. Retrieved 14 Apr 2014.
- EDWARD WYATT (28 Mar 2014). "Charter Challenges Comcast-Time Warner Cable Deal". New York Times. Retrieved 14 Apr 2014.
- DAVID GELLES (27 Apr 2014). "Charter and Comcast to End Fight Over Time Warner Cable". New York Times. Retrieved 28 Apr 2014.
- "Time Warner Cable to Merge with Comcast Corporation to Create a World-Class Technology and Media Company". Comcast. 13 Feb 2014. Retrieved 28 Apr 2014.
- Liana B. Baker and Soham Chatterjee (28 Apr 2014). "Comcast in deal with Charter as it seeks approval for TWC". Reuters. Retrieved 28 Apr 2014.
- Scott Moritz (9 Oct 2014). "Time Warner Cable Shareholders Approve Sale to Comcast". Bloomberg. Retrieved 9 Oct 2014.
- JAMES B. STEWART (28 Mar 2014). "A Vision Beyond Cable for Comcast After Merger". New York Times. Retrieved 25 Apr 2014.
- Michael Hiltzik (23 Aug 2013). "Cable monopolies hurt consumers and the nation". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved 25 Apr 2014.
- Rick Karr (28 Jun 2011). "Why is European broadband faster and cheaper? Blame the government". Engadget. Retrieved 25 Apr 2014.
- "Franken: Comcast called Time Warner Cable a competitor until they wanted to merge".
- Associated Press (9 Jan 2014). "Comcast gains video subscribers in 4Q". Yahoo News. Retrieved 18 Apr 2014.
- Steve Donohue (9 Jan 2014). "Time Warner Cable drops 831,000 video subscribers in 2013". Fierce Cable. Retrieved 18 Apr 2014.
- Chris Meyer (15 Apr 2014). "I Want a Bigger Cable Company, Said No One Ever". Huffington Post. Retrieved 18 Apr 2014.
- "7521098038" (pdf). FCC. Retrieved 18 Apr 2014.
- Adi Robertson (9 Apr 2014). "Comcast has very bad reasons for wanting to buy Time Warner Cable". The Verge. Retrieved 18 Apr 2014.
- Cecilia Kang (8 Apr 2014). "Comcast the little guy? There's competition everywhere, the company argues". Washington Post. Retrieved 18 Apr 2014.
- Fran Berkman (8 Apr 2014). "Comcast invokes net neutrality in push for Time Warner merger". The Daily Dot. Retrieved 18 Apr 2014.
- Jon Brodkin (19 Mar 2014). "Al Franken: Don't let Comcast "manipulate Internet traffic"". Ars Technica. Retrieved 18 Apr 2014.
- Chris Morran (3 Mar 2014). "Franken: Comcast's Previous Behavior Doesn't Bode Well For Time Warner Cable Deal". Consumerist. Retrieved 18 Apr 2014.
- Steven Musil (12 Feb 2014). "Comcast said to be buying Time Warner Cable for $44.2B". Cnet. Retrieved 18 Apr 2014.
- Liana B. Baker (13 Feb 2014). "Comcast takeover of Time Warner Cable to reshape U.S. pay TV". Reuters. Retrieved 18 Apr 2014.
- Frank Ahrens (29 Aug 2009). "Comcast Wins Appeal of FCC Ownership Cap". Washington Post. Retrieved 18 Apr 2014.
- Maclean, Amy (2014-04-08). "Comcast and Time Warner Cable By the Numbers". Retrieved 2014-05-02.
- "Time Warner Cable Spinoff to Finish Next Month". The New York Times. February 27, 2009. Retrieved May 25, 2010.
- Don Reisinger (25 Feb 2014). "Senate hearing on Comcast, TWC merger set for March 26". Cnet. Retrieved 23 Mar 2014.
- John Eggerton (10 Mar 2014). "Sources: Senate Hearing On Comcast/TWC Moving To April 2". MultiChannelNews. Retrieved 23 Mar 2014.
- WASHINGTON (25 Mar 2014). "U.S. Senate panel delays hearing on Comcast merger". Reuters. Retrieved 27 Mar 2014.
- Bob Fernandez (11 Apr 2014). "A sometimes-tense hearing on Capitol Hill on proposed Comcast-Time Warner merger". The Philadelphia Inquirer. Retrieved 14 Apr 2014.
- Lauren Hammond (9 Apr 2014). "House Judiciary Committee Announces Comcast-Time Warner Cable Merger Hearing". house.gov. Retrieved 14 Apr 2014.
- Roger Yu (8 Apr 2014). "Comcast filing defends Time Warner Cable deal". USA Today. Retrieved 14 Apr 2014.
- "Obama to appoint cable industry lobbyist Tom Wheeler as FCC head". Th eGuardian. 1 May 2013.
- Steve Donohue (1 May 2013). "FCC chairman nominee Tom Wheeler welcomed by cable industry". Fierce Cable. Retrieved 15 Apr 2014.
- John Cassidy (13 Feb 2014). "We Need Real Competition, Not a Cable-Internet Monopoly". The New Yorker. Retrieved 15 Apr 2014.
- Hicks, Josh (August 13, 2014). "Comcast and Time Warner fund event for FCC regulator while seeking merger approval". Washington Post. Retrieved 2 February 2015.
- Joe Flint (10 Jul 2014). "FCC sets clock for Comcast's Time Warner Cable and Charter deals". LA Times. Retrieved 7 Apr 2015.
- Alina Selyukh (3 Oct 2014). "FCC pauses clock on Comcast-Time Warner Cable merger". Reuters. Retrieved 7 Apr 2015.
- Mario Trujillo (22 Dec 2014). "FCC pauses shot clock on Comcast-Time Warner Cable merger". The Hill. Retrieved 7 Apr 2015.
- Meg James (13 Mar 2015). "FCC delays review of Comcast-Time Warner Cable and AT&T-DirecTV mergers". LA Times. Retrieved 7 Apr 2015.
- Ira Teinowitz (6 Mar 2014). "Justice Department to Conduct Antitrust Review of Comcast-Time Warner Cable Deal". The Wrap via Yahoo News. Retrieved 15 Apr 2014.
- Diane Bartz (6 Mar 2014). "U.S. antitrust chief recused on Comcast, Time Warner Cable review". Chicago Tribune. Retrieved 15 Apr 2014.
- "U.S. antitrust chief recused on Comcast, Time Warner Cable review". Reuters. 6 Mar 2014. Retrieved 15 Apr 2014.
- Steve Donohue (7 Mar 2014). "DOJ taps Hesse to lead review of Comcast-Time Warner Cable deal". FierceCable. Retrieved 15 Apr 2014.
- Sam Gustin (19 Mar 2014). "Comcast-Time Warner Cable Deal Faces Scrutiny From States". Time. Retrieved 15 Apr 2014.
- "Herfindahl-Hirschman Index". justice.gov. Retrieved 25 Apr 2014.
- Kevin Roose (13 Feb 2014). "This Math Formula Shows Why the Comcast—Time Warner Cable Deal Should Be Blocked". New York Post. Retrieved 25 Apr 2014.
- Tim Fernholz (13 Feb 2014). "Why the Time Warner-Comcast merger isn't going to happen—at least the way it looks today". Quartz. Retrieved 25 Apr 2014.
- Christopher Matthews (13 Feb 2014). "Why the Feds won't be able to block a Comcast-Time Warner merger". CNN Money. Retrieved 25 Apr 2014.
- Sam Gustin (1 Apr 2014). "Comcast Exec Says Time Warner Cable Deal Will Be Great for America". Time. Retrieved 15 Apr 2014.
- Carl Guardino (15 Apr 2014). "Silicon Valley CEOs Support The Comcast-Time Warner Cable Merger". Forbes. Retrieved 15 Apr 2014.
- "RE: April 9th hearing on Comcast/Time Warner Cable transaction" (pdf). Taxpayers Protection Alliance. 7 Apr 2014. Retrieved 14 Apr 2014.
- Clyde Wayne Crews Jr. (9 Apr 2014). "Why Organized Conservative Opposition To The Comcast Time Warner Deal Misfires". Forbes. Retrieved 14 Apr 2014.
- ERIC LIPTON (5 Apr 2015). "Comcast Recruits Its Beneficiaries to Lobby for Time Warner Deal". The New York Times. Retrieved 7 Apr 2015.
- Jon Brodkin (22 Aug 2014). "Comcast donations help company secure support for Time Warner Cable merger". Ars Technica. Retrieved 7 Apr 2015.
- Spencer Woodman (26 Jan 2015). "Exclusive: politicians are supporting Comcast's TWC merger with letters ghostwritten by Comcast". The Verge. Vox Media. Retrieved 7 Apr 2015.
- "Netflix Says It Opposes Comcast's Merger Bid". The New York Times. 21 Apr 2014. Retrieved 25 Apr 2014.
- "More Than 50 Public Interest Groups Speak Out Against the Comcast-Time Warner Cable Merger". Freepress.net. 8 Apr 2014. Archived from the original on 2014-04-15. Retrieved 14 Apr 2014.
- Julian Hattem (24 Mar 2014). "Writers Guild protests Comcast-Time Warner deal". The Hill. Retrieved 14 Apr 2014.
- Ira Teinowitz (9 Apr 2014). "Consumer Group Slams Comcast, Time-Warner Deal at New Senate Hearing (Updated)". The Wrap. Retrieved 14 Apr 2014.
- "Why the government should provide internet access". Vox. 6 Apr 2014. Retrieved 14 Apr 2014.
- Susan Crawford (13 Feb 2014). "Comcast's Time Warner Deal Is Bad for America". Bloomberg. Retrieved 14 Apr 2014.
- ASHLEY PARKER (11 Apr 2014). "Franken's Campaign Against Comcast Is No Joke". New York Times. Retrieved 14 Apr 2014.
- Al Franken (13 Apr 2014). "Say NO to the Comcast takeover". CNN. Retrieved 14 Apr 2014.
- Diane Bartz, U.S. lawmakers air concerns over Comcast-Time Warner Cable deal, Reuters, May 8, 2014.
- Zach Epstein (21 Feb 2014). "DirecTV CEO says Comcast-TWC merger would be awful for consumers and competition". BGR. Retrieved 25 Apr 2014.
- MICHAEL J. de la MERCED (21 Apr 2014). "Netflix Says It Opposes Comcast's Merger Bid". New York Times. Retrieved 25 Apr 2014.
- Kaja Whitehouse (17 Apr 2014). "Cogent CEO bashes TWC deal to FCC". New York Post. Retrieved 25 Apr 2014.
- EDWARD WYATT (28 Mar 2014). "Charter Challenges Comcast-Time Warner Cable Deal". New York Times. Retrieved 25 Apr 2014.
- David Ingram (26 Mar 2014). "Americans take dim view of Comcast, Time Warner Cable deal". Reuters. Retrieved 14 Apr 2014.
- CR Poll: Most consumers oppose the Comcast / Time Warner cable merger (June 19, 2014), Consumers Union.
- Ted Johnson, Consumer Reports Poll: Majority Oppose Comcast-Time Warner Cable Merger (June 19, 2014), Variety.
- "More Than 50 Public Interest Groups Speak Out Against the Comcast-Time Warner Cable Merger". Free Press. 8 Apr 2014. Archived from the original on 2014-04-15. Retrieved 14 Apr 2014.
- Consumer Watchdog (24 Mar 2014). "Consumer Watchdog Calls on Dept. of Justice, FCC To Reject Comcast - Time Warner Deal". Yahoo News. Retrieved 14 Apr 2014.
- "Comcast/TWC merger may be blocked by Justice Department". Ars Technica. Retrieved 26 May 2015.
- "Comcast / Time Warner Cable / Charter Transactions Terminated - Comcast Press Statement". Comcast. Retrieved 24 April 2015.
- Linnane, Ciara (April 23, 2015). "Comcast to end Time Warner Cable deal: Bloomberg TV". MarketWatch. Retrieved April 24, 2015.
- "Time Warner Cable Adviser Contacted Cox Communications". The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved 26 May 2015.
- "Charter Communications Agrees to Acquire Time Warner Cable". The New York Times. Retrieved 26 May 2015.