Australian head of state dispute
The Australian head of state dispute refers to ongoing debate as to who is considered to be the head of state of Australia—the Monarch or the Governor-General. Head of state is a description used in official sources for the monarch. The Australian constitution does not mention the term head of state. In discussion it has been used for describing the person who holds the highest rank among the officers of government. A number of writers, most notably David Smith, have argued that the term is better used to describe the governor-general. Some others and some publications in Australia have also referred to the governor-general as the head of state.
The difference of opinion has mainly been discussed in the context of Australia becoming a republic, and was prominently debated in the lead-up to the republic referendum in 1999.
The Australian constitution dates from 1901, when the Dominions of the British Empire were not sovereign states, and does not use the term head of state. In respect of the government of Australia, the monarch, currently Queen Elizabeth II, who has reigned since 6 February 1952, is represented in Australia by the governor-general, in accordance with the Constitution. Elizabeth II is also the sovereign of fifteen other countries, including the United Kingdom (UK), that are informally known, with Australia, as the Commonwealth realms, and as the sovereign the Queen is regarded as head of state. But in Australia the term "head of state" has been used in discussion as a convenient term for describing the person holding the highest rank among the officers of government.
In his 1993 book The Reluctant Republic, Malcolm Turnbull explained that, at Federation, the "Governor-General acted partly as head of state and partly as the local representative of the British Government", the latter being the Queen in her Privy Council of the United Kingdom. As with the other former Dominions, Australia gained legislative independence from the UK by virtue of the Statute of Westminster 1931, which was adopted in Australia in 1942 with retroactive effect from 3 September 1939. By the Royal Style and Titles Act 1953, the Australian parliament gave the Queen the title Queen of Australia and, in 1973, removed from the Queen's Australian style and titles any reference to her status as Queen of the United Kingdom and Defender of the Faith. Australia's full independence from the UK was achieved with the Australia Act 1986.
Section 61 of the constitution states that "The executive power of the Commonwealth is vested in the Queen and is exercisable by the Governor‑General as the Queen's representative, and extends to the execution and maintenance of this Constitution, and of the laws of the Commonwealth." Section 2 provides that a governor-general shall represent the Queen in Australia. The governor-general is appointed by the monarch on the advice of the prime minister of Australia. In practice, the governor-general carries out all the functions usually performed by a head of state, without reference to the Queen; though the governor-general is the Queen's representative, he or she is not the monarch's delegate or agent. Under the conventions of the Westminster system, the governor-general's powers are almost always exercised on the advice of the prime minister or other ministers of the Crown. The governor-general may use the reserve powers of the Crown as prescribed by the constitution, though these are rarely exercised. One notable example of their use was by Governor-General Sir John Kerr during the Australian constitutional crisis of 1975.
The question of whether the Queen or the governor-general is Australia's head of state became a political one in the years prior to the Australian republic referendum in 1999. Among arguments advanced in that campaign some were for retaining the office of governor-general as the monarch's (nominal) representative, and others were for a popularly elected head of state. Republicans included in their campaign the idea that the Queen is head of state and not Australian and, as such, should be replaced with an Australian citizen; this was summed up in their slogan "a mate for head of state". Opponents of the move to make Australia a republic claim in response that Australia already has an Australian as head of state in the governor-general, who, since 1965, has invariably been an Australian citizen. The governor-general in 2004, Major General Michael Jeffery, said at the time: "Her Majesty is Australia's head of state but I am her representative and to all intents and purposes I carry out the full role." However, the following year, he declined to name the Queen as head of state, instead saying in response to a direct question, "the Queen is the monarch and I represent her and I carry out all the functions of head of state." The governor-general normally represents Australia internationally, making and receiving state visits, but the Queen also carries out some official duties representing Australia outside Australia, such as in the United Kingdom.
Within Australia, newspapers, ministers, constitutional scholars and the general public have not always been consistent in references to either the monarch or the governor-general as the head of state. Sir David Smith's lecture reviewing the state of opinion in Australia, published as Papers on Parliament No. 27, March 1996, ended by quoting some remarks made the year before by Sir Gerard Brennan, Chief Justice of Australia, on the oaths of allegiance and office:
- "The first promise is a commitment of loyalty to Her Majesty the Queen, her heirs and successors according to law. It is a commitment to the head of State under the Constitution. It is from the Constitution that the Oath of Allegiance, which has its origins in feudal England, takes its significance in the present day. As the Constitution can now be abrogated or amended only by the Australian people in whom, therefore, the ultimate sovereignty of the nation resides, the Oath of Allegiance and the undertaking to serve the head of State as Chief Justice are a promise of fidelity and service to the Australian people. The duties which the oath imposes sit lightly on a citizen of the nation which the Constitution summoned into being and which it sustains. Allegiance to a young, free and confident nation, governed by the rule of law, is not a burden but a privilege."(Spoken at a ceremonial sitting of the High Court on 21 April 1995.)
Reviewing the position in 2000, former Justice of the High Court of Australia, Michael Kirby concluded that the governor-general would increasingly take over as virtual head of state of Australia and the office would continue to evolve as an Australian peculiarity; and that while most Australians would continue to feel republican in their hearts, many would continue to have a vague lingering affection for the monarch, and some feel a measure of respect for the idea of the Crown as "a notion above the transient allegiances of party politics with its vital but often banal concerns."
When Quentin Bryce was Governor-General (2008–14) The Museum of Australian Democracy summed up the situation: "Because the Queen lives in the United Kingdom, she is represented in Australia by the Governor-General, who is in effect Australia's Head of State. Some authorities argue that the Governor-General is Australia's Head of State in every respect: others disagree."
The most authoritative sources published by the government of Australia have used the term "head of state" to refer to the monarch, with some providing explanatory statements. This includes Government House, Parliament House, Public Service Commission, and the Departments of the Attorney General, Immigration and Citizenship and Foreign Affairs. The Electoral Council of Australia in one document has used the term to describe the governor-general and state governors in their respective jurisdictions. Yet another calls the governor-general the "constitutional Head of State" and the Queen the "Head of State". Presently, the government website states: "Under the Constitution, the reigning British monarch is also the Australian monarch, and therefore Australia's Head of State". However, between 1992 and 1999, the Commonwealth Government Directory listed the governor-general in these terms: "Function: Under the Constitution the Governor-General is the Head of State in whom the Executive Power of the Commonwealth is vested."
Prime ministers of Australia have also used the term erratically: in 2009, a media release from Prime Minister Kevin Rudd referred to a tour by Quentin Bryce as a "visit to Africa of this scale by Australia’s Head of State" ; and the following year, his spokesperson told the press the Queen "held that position". In a press release issued that year by the Queen's private secretary to announce the Queen would make a speech to the United Nations, Elizabeth II was mentioned as head of state of Australia, amongst 15 other countries. In the Department of the Parliamentary Library's publication Research Note, Peter Ireland concluded that "the Constitution can be used to argue either proposition."
The issue has been occasionally raised in the High Court of Australia but never directly ruled on by that court. One ruling, cited first by Professor David Flint and later by Sir David Smith, is the 1907 decision of R v Governor of South Australia, wherein the court inter alia described the governor-general as the "Constitutional Head of the Commonwealth" (and the Governor of South Australia as the "Constitutional Head of the State").
A judgement of the Supreme Court of Victoria, confirming that new citizens must swear an oath to the Queen, said it is known "Australia is a constitutional monarchy with Her Majesty The Queen as its Head of State."
Internationally, for the purposes of protocol, the United Nations list of heads of state has for Australia "(Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth II)", in brackets, above the name and title of the Governor-General, "His Excellency Sir Peter Cosgrove"; this is the same as is done for other Commonwealth realms with a governor-general. The United States Department of State in 2010 listed the Queen as head of state and the CIA currently refers to the same person as "chief of state". Canada's Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade is less clear, listing the names of both the monarch and the governor-general as head of state. The Queen's Royal Household in the United Kingdom has updated the way the term head of state is used in relation to Australia: in 1999, the British monarchy website was altered to replace the description of Elizabeth II as head of state of Australia with one that mentioned her only as "sovereign". In 2010, the "head of state" description was restored, but, by 2014, this had again been changed, with the Queen described as "Sovereign" in the Commonwealth realms, of which Australia is one.
Former governor-general and Liberal politician Paul Hasluck stated in 1979 that Australia's monarch is the country's head of state and the Governor-General is her or his representative. The same view has been expressed by former governor-general and legal scholar Zelman Cowen. This position has been supported by many constitutional scholars, including Harrison Moore, George Winterton, and George Williams. Furthermore, George Winterton argued that, because the Governor-General only functions on a federal level, with Governors playing corresponding parts in the States, the Governor-General could not be the head of state for the nation as a whole.
A founding member of the monarchist lobby group Australians for Constitutional Monarchy and former Justice of the High Court of Australia, Michael Kirby has long supported the view that the Queen is Australia's head of state. The same view was expressed by the former Chief Justice of the High Court, Anthony Mason.
However, Professor Colin Howard argued that, "It seems therefore that practice and law now coincide to support the proposition that, certain matters of ceremony and courtesy apart, the head of state in Australia is not the Queen but the Governor-General". Professor Owen E. Hughes commented that there was "ambiguity" on the issue, and described both the monarch and the governor-general as the head of state at different times in the same book.
Michael Kirby's opinion aside, Australians for Constitutional Monarchy has often argued that the governor-general is head of state. Sir David Smith, a former Official Secretary to five governors-general, holds that the governor-general is head of state, while the Queen is Australia's sovereign, since the constitution directs the governor-general, and not the monarch, to carry out the duties of head of state; and Professor David Flint, convenor of Australians for Constitutional Monarchy, feels the same way, believing the High Court's 1907 decision R v Governor of South Australia resolves the issue as a constitutional description. Professor Flint asserts that the term head of state is a diplomatic one and is governed by international law and notes that, as the governor-general is sent overseas and received as head of state, she is, under international law, a head of state. He says this has only become an issue because the republicans have been unable to raise other reasons to change the constitution, highlighting that it was argued nine times by the republicans in the official Yes/No booklet sent to voters in the referendum. However, in 1995, the one-time Director of Australians for Constitutional Monarchy, and later Liberal prime minister, Tony Abbott, described the Queen as the "titular Head of State" of Australia.
The Australian Monarchist League (AML) does not deviate from the official position. In an article titled "Monachists Affirm – Queen is Head of State", National Chairman Phillip Benwell says this "has been advised in writing to me on several occasions by the Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet"
The view of the Australian Republican Movement is also consistent with official position. Leading republican, and later prime minister, Malcolm Turnbull argued in 1993: "As long as we have the British Queen as our Head of State, other nations everywhere, not just in Asia, will regard us as somewhat less than independent."
Mainstream media sometimes uses the term head of state to describe the governor-general. A detailed editorial is from The Australian, prior to the Queen making a United Nations speech, saying:
[T]he Queen has reasserted her claim on the title "head of state" of Australia by using it in the announcement of her address to the UN in July ... In recent years, particularly after the debate and referendum on a republic in 1999, the local convention has been to recognise that the Governor-General is Australia's head of state and that Elizabeth II is our sovereign ... a spokesman for [Prime Minister] Rudd said: "Australia's head of state is HM Queen Elizabeth II, represented by the Governor-General HE Ms Quentin Bryce AC. The government is aware of the plan for the Queen to address the United Nations."
Comparison with other Commonwealth realms
In some of the sixteen Commonwealth realms, the monarch is explicitly defined as the head of state. For example, Section 2 of New Zealand's Constitution Act 1986 states: "The Sovereign in right of New Zealand is the head of State of New Zealand, and shall be known by the royal style and titles proclaimed from time to time." Likewise, in Part V of the Constitution of Papua New Guinea, the Queen is labelled Head of State of Papua New Guinea.
In Canada, some difference of opinion exists over whether the Queen of Canada or the Governor General of Canada should be considered the country's head of state; and there is some inconsistency among politicians, scholars, and the media in the application of the description to either individual. Canadian monarchists assert the Queen is head of state. The Canadian constitution makes no mention of a head of state.
The phrase "head of state" is not used in the constitution of:
- Antigua and Barbuda
- Saint Kitts and Nevis
- Saint Lucia
- Saint Vincent and the Grenadines
- The Bahamas
- United Kingdom
The phrase "head of state", referring to the Queen, is used in the constitution of:
- New Zealand
- Papua New Guinea
- Solomon Islands
- Constitutional history of Australia
- Republicanism in Australia
- Irish head of state from 1936 to 1949
- Ireland, Ian (28 August 1995). "Who is the Australian Head of State?" (PDF). Research Note. Canberra: Dept. of the Parliamentary Library (1): 1. ISSN 1323-5664. Archived from the original (PDF) on 17 January 2011. Retrieved 22 January 2011.
- Ireland, Ian; Magarey Kirsty. "Powers of the Head of State of Australia and South Africa". Law and Bills Digest Group. Parliamentary Library Web Manager. Archived from the original on 11 April 2011. Retrieved 10 March 2011.
- Turnbull, Malcolm (31 May 1994). The Reluctant Republic. London: William Heinemann Ltd. p. 33. ISBN 978-0-85561-372-3.
- Australian Government. "Governors-General". Digital Transformation Office. Retrieved 21 October 2015.
- Jupp, James (2001). The Australian People: An Encyclopedia of the Nation, Its People and Their Origins. Cambridge University Press. p. 331. ISBN 9780521807890. Retrieved 21 October 2015.
- Introducing the Law. CCH Australia Limited. 2011. p. 53. ISBN 9781921873478. Retrieved 21 October 2015.
- "The Queen's role in Australia". Royal Household. Archived from the original on 17 April 2015. Retrieved 21 October 2015.
- Office of the Governor-General of Australia. "About the Governor-General > Governor-General's role". Retrieved 16 March 2011.
- Downing, S. Law and Bills Digest Group Information and Research Services (23 January 1998). "The reserve powers of the Governor-General". Parliamentary Library. Retrieved 2 January 2013.
- Gerangelos, Peter A. (2009), Lee, H.P.; Gerangelos, Peter A., eds., "Constitutional Advancement in a Frozen Continent", Parliament, the Executive, the Governor-General and the Republic, Annandale: Federation Press, p. 213, ISBN 9781862877610
- Zines, Leslie (2008). The High Court and the Constitution. Sydney: Federation Press. p. 345. ISBN 9781862876910.
- Barwick, Garfield, A View of the External Affairs Power, The Samuel Griffith Society, retrieved 1 January 2013
- "Pillar 2- Parliamentary Democracy". Constitution Education Fund Australia. Retrieved 1 January 2013.
- "Solicitor-General explains opinion: did not deny Crown's power", Sydney Morning Herald, p. 10, 19 November 1975, retrieved 1 January 2013
- Squires, Nick (19 January 2006), "Republicans want 'a mate' to become Australia's head of state", The Telegraph, retrieved 9 March 2011
- Office of the Governor-General of Australia (29 May 2005), The Governor-General is Interviewed by Greg Turnbull on the Ten Network's Meet The Press, Queen's Printer for Australia, retrieved 18 January 2007
- Dusevic, Tom (12 February 2010), "Queen takes on Bryce in right royal title fight", The Australian, retrieved 22 January 2011
- Sir David Smith "An Australian Head of State: An Historical and Contemporary Perspective " Papers on Parliament No. 27, March 1996 
- Michael Kirby, The Australian Republican Referendum 1999 – Ten Lessons addressing the Faculty of Law, University of Buckingham, UK, 3 March 2000. 
- Governors-General of Australia (PDF), Museum of Australian Democracy, retrieved 27 February 2011
- House of Representatives, The Australian System of Government (PDF), Australian Government Publishing Service, p. 3, archived from the original (PDF) on 12 March 2011, retrieved 10 March 2011
- Parliamentary Education Office. "FAQ > 3. Historical firsts > 3.25 Who was Australia's first head of state?". Australian Government Publishing Service. Archived from the original on 6 April 2011. Retrieved 10 March 2011.
- Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade. "Protocol > Protocol guidelines > The Australian Government". Australian Government Publishing Service. Retrieved 14 March 2011.
- Australian Public Service Commission. "About the Commission > The Australian experience of public sector reform > The Constitutional and Government framework". Australian Government Publishing Service. Archived from the original on 13 March 2011. Retrieved 14 March 2011.
- "Australian Citizenship – Our Common Bond" (PDF). Department of Immigration and Citizenship. August 2012.
- Electoral Council of Australia. "Electoral Systems of Australia's Parliaments and Local Government" (PDF). Australian Government Publishing Service. Retrieved 10 March 2011.
- Parliament of Australia. "The role of the Governor-General". Australian Government Publishing Service. Archived from the original on 12 March 2011. Retrieved 10 March 2011.
- Government of Australia. "About Australia > Our Government > Australia's Federation". Queen's Printer for Australia. Retrieved 10 March 2011.
- Commonwealth Government Directory. Australian Government Publishing Service. December 1995 – February 1996.
- "Commonwealth Government Directory". Australian Government Publishing Service. March 1997. Retrieved 22 January 2011.
- Smith, David (2005). Head of State. Sydney: Macleay. pp. 91–92.
- Office of the Prime Minister of Australia (6 March 2009). "Governor-General's Visit to Africa" (Press release). Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet. Archived from the original on 30 October 2009. Retrieved 27 December 2012.
- Dusevic, Tom (12 February 2010), "Queen takes on Bryce in right royal title fight", The Australian, retrieved 10 March 2011
- Smith 2005, p. 15.
- R v Governor of South Australia; Ex parte Vardon  HCA 31, (1907) 4 CLR 1497, High Court (Australia).
- Baxter v Commissioners of Taxation (NSW)  HCA 76, (1907) 4 CLR 1087, High Court (Australia).
- South Australia v Victoria  HCA 17, (1911) 12 CLR 667, High Court (Australia).
- R v Titles Registrar (Vic)  HCA 59, (1915) 20 CLR 379 at p. 380 per Griffith CJ, High Court (Australia).
- R v Kidman  HCA 58, (1915) 20 CLR 425 at p. 418–25 per Griffith CJ, High Court (Australia).
- R v Sutton  HCA 26, (1908) 5 CLR 789 at p. 797 per Griffith CJ and pp. 809–11 per Isaacs J, High Court (Australia).
- Thorpe v The Commonwealth of Australia  HCATrans 147 (21 May 1997), High Court (Australia).
- Moller v Board of Examiners  VSC 55 at  per Beach J (10 March 1999), Supreme Court (Vic, Australia).
- United Nations Protocol and Liaison Service (22 September 2015). "Heads of State, Heads of Government, Ministers for Foreign Affairs" (PDF). United Nations. Retrieved 19 October 2015.
- United States Department of State. "Under Secretary for Public Diplomacy and Public Affairs > Bureau of Public Affairs > Bureau of Public Affairs: Electronic Information and Publications > Background Notes > Australia". United States Government Printing Office. Archived from the original on 17 March 2011. Retrieved 14 March 2011.
- "Central Intelligence Agency World Factbook". Central Intelligence Agency. Archived from the original on 29 December 2010. Retrieved 22 January 2011.
- Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade, Australia (PDF), Queen's Printer for Canada, archived from the original (PDF) on 10 October 2012, retrieved 11 March 2011
- Marr, David (19 October 1999), "Queen's Hand a Royal Flush for Monarchists", Sydney Morning Herald, retrieved 10 March 2011
- Steketee, Mike (23 January 2010), "Prince charming won't stall the march to republicanism", The Australian, retrieved 25 January 2011
- Royal Household. "The Monarchy Today > Queen and Commonwealth > Commonwealth Members". Queen's Printer. Retrieved 24 January 2011.
- Hasluck, Paul (1979), The Office of Governor-General (PDF), Burwood: Brown Prior Anderson Pty Ltd, p. 8, retrieved 24 October 2015
- Markwell, Donald (2015). "The office of Governor-General". Melbourne University Law Review (Volume 38, No 3). pp. 1107–08.
- Smith, David, Why The Governor-General is Australia's Head of State, Australians for Constitutional Monarchy
- Williams, George; Brennan, Sean; Lynch, Andrew (2014). Blackshield and Williams Australian Constitutional Law and Theory (6 ed.). Leichhardt, NSW: Federation Press. p. 2. ISBN 978-1-86287-918-8.
- Winterton, George (2004). "Who is our head of state?". Quadrant (September 2004). p. 60.
- Moens, Gabriel; Trone, John; Lumb, R D (2007). Lumb & Moens' The Constitution of the Commonwealth of Australia Annotated (7 ed.). Chatswood, NSW: LexisNexis Butterworths. p. 47. ISBN 9780409323658.
- Omar, Imtiaz (2015). Constitutional Law (4 ed.). Chatswood, NSW: LexisNexis Butterworths. p. 11. ISBN 9780409339185.
- Hanks, Peter; Keyzer, Patrick; Clarke, Jennifer (2004). Australian Constitutional Law: Materials and Commentary (7 ed.). Sydney: LexisNexis Butterworths. p. 465. ISBN 0409319465.
- "10 questions – Michael Kirby". The Australian. 26 March 2011. Retrieved 8 January 2013.
- Michael Kirby (16 April 1994). "A Republic by Stealth (The Robert Harris Oration" (PDF). Michael Kirby.
- Williams 2014, p. 1351
- Howard, Colin (1985). Australian Federal Constitutional Law. Sydney: The Law Book Company. p. 112.
- Hughes, Owen (1998). Australian Politics. Melbourne: Macmillan Education. pp. 170–171, 205, 249–250. ISBN 0-7329-2796-X.
- Smith, David (19 March 2001), Our Australian Head of State, Sydney: Australians for Constitutional Monarchy, retrieved 24 January 2011
- Smith, David (January 2005). Head of State. Paddington: Macleay Press. ISBN 1-876492-15-5.
- Flint, David. "The Head of State debate resolved" (PDF). Australians for Constitutional Monarchy. Retrieved 24 January 2011.
- Abbott, Tony (1995). The Minimal Monarchy. Adelaide: Wakefield Press. p. 57.
- Benwell, Philip (2010). "Crowned Republic – No. Crowned Democracy – Yes". Australian Monarchist League. Retrieved 22 March 2016.
- Turnbull, Malcolm (1993). The Reluctant Republic. Port Melbourne: William Heinemann Ltd. p. 224. ISBN 978-0-85561-372-3.
- The Canberra Times, Editorial, 8 December 1977
- Naomi Levin, Insight into Sir Zelman Cowen, Australian Jewish News, 14 October 2009, accessed 27 February 2011
- Simon Kearney, $3 million bill for Australia's former governors-general, Sunday Herald-Sun, 24 October 2010, accessed 27 February 2011
- Australia Network News, Australian head of state bound for Kuwait, 21 February 2011, accessed 27 February 2011
- Hartcher, Peter (5 June 2010), "You've got to deliver goals and targets", Sydney Morning Herald, retrieved 22 January 2011
- Tom Dusevic (12 February 2010). "Queen takes on Bryce in right royal title fight". The Australian. Retrieved 29 February 2016.
- Associated Press (17 August 2010), "Australia's PM says Elizabeth II should be country's last British monarch", The Guardian, retrieved 14 March 2011
- "Australia's Gillard backs republic after Queen's death". BBC. 17 August 2010. Retrieved 14 March 2011.
- Thieberger, Victoria. "Australia gets first female governor-general". Reuters. Retrieved 24 January 2011.
- Associated Press (12 March 2006), "Queen Elizabeth II arrives in Australia on state visit", The Star, retrieved 14 March 2011
- Chua-Eoan, Howard (1 April 2009). "The Queen and Mrs. Obama: A Breach in Protocol". Time. New York: Time Inc. ISSN 0040-781X. Archived from the original on 12 February 2011. Retrieved 14 March 2011.
- Elizabeth II (1 January 1987). "Constitution Act 1986". 2.1. Wellington: Queen's Printer for New Zealand. Retrieved 13 March 2011.
- Boswell, Randy (7 October 2009), "Governor General calling herself 'head of state' riles monarchists", Ottawa Citizen, retrieved 21 February 2011
- Boswell, Randy (9 October 2009), "Queen is our head of state, Harper reminds Jean", National Post, retrieved 13 March 2011
- Boswell, Randy (9 October 2009), "Michaelle Jean retreats from 'head of state' debate", National Post, retrieved 13 March 2011
- Official website of the Government of Australia
- Australia PEO: The Constitution: The head of state
- Official website of the Governor-General, Sir Peter Cosgrove: "Governor-General's Role"
- Queen and Australia, from the official website of The British Monarchy. The Australian monarch is also the British monarch.
- Australian Republican Movement website
- Australians For Constitutional Monarchy website
- David Smith's description of the state of opinion as at March 1995