An author mill is a publisher that relies on producing large numbers of small-run books by different authors, as opposed to a smaller number of works published in larger numbers. The term was coined by Victoria Strauss of Writer Beware, as a parallel formation from diploma mill, an unaccredited college or university that offers degrees without regard to academic achievement, and puppy mill, a breeding operation that produces large numbers of puppies for sale with little regard for breed purity, puppy placement, health, or socialization.
Predatory open access publishing is a closely related practice. However, the aims and the business model are rather different: predatory publishers will charge the author up front for publishing in a supposed scientific journal. Since academic evaluation is largely based on publication count or other bibliometrics, even well-meaning authors may be willing to pay to bolster their career prospects.
As described by Writer Beware, an author mill is:
... a company that publishes a very large number of authors in the expectation of selling a hundred books or so from each (as opposed to publishing a limited number of authors in hopes of selling thousands of books from each, as commercial publishers do). Author mills don't require authors to make any financial expenditures at all, hidden or otherwise. However, they do rely on their authors as their major source of income (through books purchased by the author for re-sale, or sold to "pocket" markets the author him/herself is responsible for identifying), and so can be defined as vanity publishers, despite the lack of upfront or other charges. Also, author mills tend to share a business model with vanity publishers: no editorial screening of submissions, no meaningful pre-publication editing, no meaningful post-publication marketing or distribution.
Victoria Strauss has used the examples of PublishAmerica and VDM Publishing to illustrate the concept of author mill. More precisely, she has characterized VDM as "an academic author mill".
Typically, an author mill does the cheapest possible job of production; it sets high cover prices and prints its books "on demand." The books are listed with online booksellers such as amazon.com and bn.com, and on the publisher's website. Any marketing, promotion, or physical bookstore placement is up to the authors themselves. While authors are not "required" to buy any of their own books, authors who wish to find readers discover that they need to buy their own books for resale.
- Minimal editorial gatekeeping
- Low production costs (acquiring/editing/designing the book)
- Low set-up charges for reproducing the book
- The power to set the cover price high enough to make a profit on a small number of average sales
- A relatively predictable number of sales to the author, the author's family, and the author's friends.
- Accreditation mill
- Diploma mill
- Ordination mill
- Contract cheating
- Essay mill
- Vanity publishing
- Nova Publishers
- Atlanta Nights
- Strauss, Victoria (21 October 2009). "Author Mills and a Request for Contact". sfwa.org. Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America. Archived from the original on 25 October 2009. Retrieved 14 December 2019.
Unlike vanity publishers or self-publishing services, author mills don't charge upfront fees–which is why they can convincingly present themselves as "real" publishers–but they often do their best to turn their authors into customers, heavily encouraging them to buy their own books, or incentivizing self-purchases with special offers and discounts.
- Strauss, Victoria (14 September 2009). "VDM Verlag Dr. Mueller". sfwa.org. Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America. Archived from the original on 28 July 2011. Retrieved 14 December 2019.
- Strauss, Victoria (2011-08-02). "Solicitation Alerts: JustFiction! Edition and DIP Publishing House". Sfwa.org. Writer Beware. Archived from the original on 2012-03-29. Retrieved 2011-08-14.
- Span, Paula (2005-01-23). "Making Books". The Washington Post. Archived from the original on 2016-04-01. Retrieved 2006-12-26.