|Focus||Changing Israeli policy in the Occupied Territories to protect human rights|
B'Tselem (Hebrew: בצלם, IPA: [beˈtselem], "in the image of [God]") is a Jerusalem-based independent non-profit organization whose stated goals are to document human rights violations in the Israeli-occupied territories, combat denial of the existence of such violations, and help to create a human rights culture in Israel. Its executive director is Hagai El-Ad. B'Tselem also maintains a presence in Washington, D.C., known as B'Tselem USA. B'Tselem has provoked sharp reactions within Israel, ranging from harsh criticism to strong praise.
B'Tselem was founded in 1989, during the First Intifada, by Israeli academics and activists of left-wing political parties. B'Tselem's funding comes from private individuals (both Israeli and foreign), governments, and European and North American foundations focusing on human rights.
B'Tselem has published over a hundred reports on various issues such as torture, fatal shootings by security forces, restrictions on movement, expropriation of land and discrimination in planning and building in East Jerusalem, administrative detention, house demolitions, violence by Israeli settlers and Palestinians, and Israeli operations in the occupied territories.
B'Tselem has been harshly criticized. In 2011, Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman charged the group with abetting terrorism and weakening Israel's defense forces. It has also faced criticsm from politicians on the left, specifically Zionist Union's Itzik Shmuli who said that B'tselem helps in the demonization of Israel.
In 2016, B'Tselem announced that it was cutting ties with the IDF over the alleged whitewashing of complaints raised by the NGO.
B'Tselem was founded on 3 February 1989. The name comes from Genesis 1:27, which states that all mankind was created "b'tselem elohim" (in the image of God), which the organization says is in line with the UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights that all humans are equal in dignity and so deserve the same fundamental rights.
Key founders were Daphna Golan-Agnon (academic and founding director of feminist peace group Bat Shalom), David Zucker (Knesset member for the Ratz party, one of the founders of the Peace Now movement), Haim Oron (Knesset member for the Mapam party, one of the founders of the Peace Now movement), Zehava Gal-On (Ratz party activist and future Knesset member for the Meretz party formed through the merger of Ratz and Mapam), Avigdor Feldman (civil liberties lawyer), and Edy Kaufman, a civil liberties activist). The Washington Post describes the line between human rights groups and political parties in Israel as "very blurry", noting that Gal-on has served as director, by turns, of both the Socialist Meretz Party and of B'Tselem.
B'Tselem states that it is devoted to "documenting human rights violations that come under Israel's purview as the occupying power".
Israel's land policies in Area C
In 2013, B'Tselem released a report called Acting the Landlord: Israeli Policy in Area C, the West Bank. It stated that Area C, comprising about 60% of the West Bank, is under full Israeli control, and stated:
Israel strictly limits Palestinian settlement, construction and development in Area C, while ignoring the needs of the Palestinian population. Palestinian residents are ... denied any legal avenue to build homes or develop their communities, so they face the constant fear that their homes might be demolished, and that they be expelled and lose their livelihood.
B'Tselem also stated that some parts of Area A and B only have available land in Area C for construction, which Israel forbids almost completely. Therefore, "Israel’s policy in Area C has ramifications for residents throughout the West Bank. The boundaries outlined for Areas A and B impose an artificial scarcity of land for some of the communities in these areas." B'Tselem accused Israel of violating international humanitarian law and international human rights law by its actions.
Notable B'Tselem board members include:
B'Tselem's executive director is Hagai El-Ad. In 2011 the group staff has 38 employees in a Research Department, a Data Coordination department, a communications department, and an administration department. Field data research in the West Bank and Gaza Strip for B'Tselem was, until the Second Intifada, performed by Israeli Arabs. Data analysis and dissemination was conducted at the Jerusalem office. Because of restriction on entry to these areas for Israeli citizens, the Israeli Arab field workers were replaced with similarly qualified Palestinian Arabs who transmit research data to the office via fax or phone, sometimes negotiating checkpoints to reach the Jerusalem office for debriefings.
B'Tselem describes itself as an independent NGO, "funded by contributions from foundations in Europe and North America... and by private individuals in Israel and abroad", and by the governments of some EU countries and the European Commission.
According to B'Tselem's 2016 financial report, they had received NIS 9,549,286 in donations, of which NIS 4,665,144 was received from foreign governmental bodies.
This section may lend undue weight to certain ideas, incidents, or controversies. (June 2017)
Together with two other human rights organizations, B'Tselem was a nominee for the 2014 Václav Havel Human Rights Prize selected by a panel of six independent experts chaired by Anne Brasseur, President of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe.
Historian Mordechai Bar-On writes that B'Tselem's reports "frequently included ugly accounts of the behavior of Israeli security officials" and that Israelis "were often disturbed by these reports." At the same time, the Israeli media viewed the organization as "a reliable source of information" and their reports were in most cases proven to be accurate. Israeli military authorities also frequently turned to B'tselem to confirm the IDF's own information. Critics of B'tselem, including the Committee for Accuracy in Middle East Reporting in America, the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs, and Caroline B. Glick, have challenged the accuracy of its reports, arguing that B'tselem has at times classified Arab combatants and terrorists as civilian casualties. B'tselem has issued rebuttals to its critics.
Following the Oslo I Accord, Israeli prime minister Yitzhak Rabin assured television views that Yasser Arafat would be able to combat Islamic militant terrorists without being hampered by B'Tselem and or the Supreme Court of Israel.
In 2011, Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman called for a parliamentary investigation of B'Tselem and other human rights organizations. These groups, he said, "are clearly not concerned with human rights. They spread lies, they slander and incite against the state of Israel and against Israeli soldiers... Clearly these organizations are abetting terrorism and their only objective is to undermine Israel," he said in a speech to fellow members of his right-wing Yisrael Beiteinu ("Israel our home") party.
A response from the IDF from 1992 to a particular B'Tselem report on the activities of military undercover units remarked that "a large portion of the incidents cited are attributed to vague, anonymous sources - often rumors or stories gleaned from the press." The IDF letter added that B'Tselem's report "ignores the prevailing situation in the area, in which armed, hard-core terrorists, who do not adhere to any code of law, have engaged in terror attacks." At the same time, the IDF letter also acknowledged wrongdoing by military forces. In an incident that B'Tselem reported on at Idna, the IDF commented that a police investigation "found that an officer and several soldiers were apparently negligent in performing their duties and acted in an illegal manner." The IDF said it could not comment on some of the other cases from the B'Tselem report due to ongoing legal proceedings.
In 2010, Gerald Steinberg of NGO Monitor, a critic of the organization, expressed admiration for B'Tselem's research capability, saying that "B'Tselem really does have a credible research capability, and even among serious critics like me who disagree with B'Tselem's political agenda, their research ability is acknowledged." Steinberg cautioned that the reliability of B'Tselem's testimony had not been tested in court, and that he would withhold judgement until it was. In 2014, NGO Monitor criticized B'Tselem's presentation of casualties in 2014 Israel–Gaza conflict saing "B'Tselem presents what it terms 'initial' and 'preliminary' data, but these are inherently unverifiable and based solely on information from Palestinian sources in Hamas-controlled Gaza." In 2015, NGO Monitor said a B'Tselem report that accused Israel of violating international humanitarian law in the 2014 war against Hamas, contained "major omissions and distortions" and failed to "present definitive evidence that would justify the allegations". Later in 2015, Steinberg said that B'Tselem was waging "a very dangerous form of warfare" against Israel.[remove or clarification needed (did B'Tselem take up arms against Israel?)]
In an interview with Haaretz in 2009, Military Advocate General Brigadier General Avichai Mendelblit praised B'Tselem, saying that they help his office talk to witnesses and clarify complaints. He also said the organization "strives, like us, to investigate the truth". The following year, Mendelbit announced the indictment of several officers and soldiers for abuses during the 2008–2009 Gaza invasion. In the announcement, he "voiced his gratitude to the human rights organization B'Tselem, thanking the organization for testimonies its activists passed on to the IDF and for assisting in coordinating the questioning of Palestinian eyewitnesses at the Erez crossing."[undue weight? ]
In response to a speech given by El-Ad to the United Nations Security Council urging the international community to take action against Israeli settlements, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu announced that he will work to ban national service volunteers from working in B'Tselem. The United States government said it was "troubled" by attacks by government officials on B'Tselem with State Department spokesman John Kirby saying that the U.S. "believe(s) that a free and unfettered civil society is a critical component of democracy... it is important that governments protect the freedoms of expression, and create an atmosphere where all voices can be heard."
In January 2016, Channel 2 (Israel) broadcast footage of Ta'ayush activist Ezra Nawi boasting that he has worked together with B'Tselem activist Nasser Nawaj'ah, posing as a prospective Jewish purchaser of land owned by Palestinians, then provided the Palestinian National Security Forces with the names and telephone numbers of Palestinian land brokers willing to sell land to him. Nawi is both Jewish and Israeli, and the Palestinian legal code regards sale of land to Israelis as a capital offense. Nawi said such people are beaten and executed. In the recording, Nawi says "The Authority catches them and kills them. But before they kill them they beat them up."
According to B'Tselem, its staff members have been both verbally and physically attacked by both Israeli settlers and Israeli military and police. B'Tselem says that on 19 January 2008, in an incident allegedly captured on film, a fieldworker was beaten by Israeli soldiers, then arrested for attacking them.[better source needed] According to B'Tselem, a worker was beaten in another incident on 20 June 2008 and his film was confiscated after he filmed IDF troops allegedly ignoring violent crimes by Israeli settlers. Following B'Tselem's complaint, Israeli military police allegedly opened an investigation.[better source needed]
- "About B'Tselem". B'Tselem. Archived from the original on 29 January 2010. Retrieved 2 February 2010.
- Staff, B'Tselem.
- Kessler, Glenn (20 March 2015). "Netanyahu's claim that 'tens of millions' in foreign money was aimed against him". Washington Post. Retrieved 10 August 2015.
- Fairbanks, Eve (12 March 2015). "The battle to be Israel's conscience". The Guardian UK. Retrieved 11 August 2015.
The group’s employees have always identified with the Israeli left
- "About B'Tselem".
- "A Peace Organization Making Peace Around The World - Carter Center". Archived from the original on 12 December 2010.
- "Carter-Menil Rights Award For Israeli and Arab Groups". The New York Times. Reuters. 16 November 1989.
- Bender, Arik (10 January 2011). "הוועדה הפרלמנטרית תחקור את בצלם, עדאלה ופרופיל חדש" [Parliamentary committee to investigate B'tselem, Adallah and New Profile] (in Hebrew). NRG (Maariv). Retrieved 15 June 2011.
ברור שהארגונים האלו לא עוסקים בזכויות אדם. הארגונים האלו מפיצים שקרים, מכפישים ומסיתים נגד מדינת ישראל ונגד חיילי צה"ל. מעולם, אף אחד מהארגונים האלו לא אמרו שישראל צדקה. ברור שמדובר בארגונים סייעני טרור נטו, שכל מטרתם להחליש את צה"ל." "שר החוץ אביגדור ליברמן יוצא במתקפה חריפה נגד ארגוני זכויות אדם ישראלים שיעמדו במרכז עבודתה של ועדת החקירה הפרלמנטרית שתקים הכנסת, וטען כי שורה של אי-סדרים כלכליים שלדבריו מאפיינים אותם עשויה להצביע על סיוע לפעילות טרור.
- "B'Tselem cuts ties with IDF over 'whitewashing'". Jerusalem Post. Retrieved 1 June 2016.
- "B'Tselem Brochure" (PDF). B'Tselem. Retrieved 16 April 2013.
- "Acting the Landlord: Israeli Policy in Area C, the West Bank" (PDF). B'Tselem. June 2013.
- "ANNEX 4 of the Commission Implementing Decision on the Annual Action Plan 2014 for Palestine" (PDF). European Commission. 2014.
- Crookston, Martin. "Echoes of Empire: British Mandate planning in Palestine and its influence in the West Bank today". Planning Perspectives. pp. 87–98. doi:10.1080/02665433.2016.1213183.
- Board members, B'Tselem.
- Hausman, Tamar (17 July 2001). "B'Tselem chooses its first Anglo director". Haaretz.
- "List of donors to B'Tselem". B'Tselem. Archived from the original on 29 January 2010. Retrieved 2 February 2010.
- "2016 B'Tselem Financial Report". Guidestar.
- "2016 New Israel Fund Financial Statement" (PDF). New Israel Fund.
- "B'Tselem Funding". NGO Monitor.
- Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe website, "Three Nominees for the Václav Havel Human Rights Prize 2014," 26 August 2014, http://www.assembly.coe.int/nw/xml/News/News-View-EN.asp?newsid=5163&lang=2&cat=37
- Bar-On, Mordechai. In Pursuit of Peace. USIP. pp. 243–245, 401. ISBN 1-878379-53-4.
- Sternthal, Tamar (24 September 2008). "Bending the truth". Ynetnews. Archived from the original on 25 September 2008. Retrieved 26 September 2008.
- "Researcher Slams B'Tselem - Defense/Middle East - News - Arutz Sheva". Arutz Sheva.
- Amos Harel, מחקר: "בצלם" מפרסם מידע שגוי ומשמיט פרטים חיוניים, Haaretz, 26 October 2008.
- Caroline B. Glick (7 January 2011). "Column One: Agents of influence". The Jerusalem Post - JPost.com. Retrieved 24 May 2017.
- B'Tselem Official written response to the CAMERA Organisation, Fax & Press Release, 22 August 2007
- Jessica Montell, B’Tselem chief: "Caroline Glick a hack who parrots any drivel", +972 Magazine, 21 January 2011
- "Explanation of statistics on fatalities" from the B'Tselem website.
- Killing a King: The Assassination of Yitzhak Rabin and the Remaking of Israel, page 111, Dan Ephron
- "IDF Activities Against Armed Terrorists in Judea, Samaria and the Gaza District". Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs. 1 May 1992. Archived from the original on 7 March 2016. Retrieved 11 January 2018.
- Jeffay, Nathan (14 July 2010). "IDF Recognizes Help From Israeli Human Rights Group". The Forward. Retrieved 17 January 2018.
- B’TSELEM’S GAZA WAR STATISTICS UNDER FIRE, JPost, 20 August 2014
- B’Tselem accuses IDF of violating laws of war in Gaza, 28 January 2015, Times of Israel, 28 January 2015]
- New legislation targets Israeli NGOs, YNET, 6 October 2015
- "הפרקליט הצבאי הראשי, תת אלוף אביחי מנדלבליט, מדבר על עופרת יצוקה, צ'יקו תמיר וגם על "בצלם (Military Advocate General, Brigadier General Avichai Mendelblit, Speaks on Cast Lead, Chico Tamir, and also on B'Tselem), Haaretz, 18 September 2009
- הפצ"ר לשעבר אביחי מנדלבליט מונה למזכיר הממשלה (Former Military Advocate General Avichai Mendelblit Appointed to Cabinet Secretary), Haaretz, 29 April 2013
- "B'Tselem head urges Security Council to act now on settlements". Times of Israel. Retrieved 27 October 2016.
- "Netanyahu supports end of national service volunteers working with B'Tselem". Jerusalem Post. Retrieved 27 October 2016.
- "Israeli Leftist Taped Trying to Set Up Palestinians Who Seek to Sell Land to Jews". Haaretz. 8 January 2015. Retrieved 14 January 2016.
- "Left-wing Israeli says he helps kill Palestinians who sell land to Jews".
- Kubovich, Yaniv (11 January 2015). "Police Make Airport Arrest of Left-wing Activist Who Turned Palestinians in to PA". Haaretz. Retrieved 14 January 2016.
- "Soldiers assault and arrest B'Tselem worker in Hebron".
- "22 June '08: Soldier assaults B'Tselem worker filming settler violence, takes the cassette".
Media related to B'Tselem at Wikimedia Commons